The Narwana Rajendra Coop. L And C Society Limited v. State Of Haryana And Others















 

  



   !!"

 



 #  

      

  

 

  !"       $

%
 $!   $ %
 $! & &$ $ # $ % 

& !

  '''''   $

#

!


"



 (               ) (+  

,-.//./, (0 !

 0   !00& (*

0! *1(&* 

   !!&  & +  !!& 0    ( 

 ( & !+ /  

  0!!!

*0+ 

 4 ** !*0  &+ * 0%*    *(  ! * !0&  (

&0 5!#43



#33
 !! 5



0%*   & 5 -, -/

/6.7/.,-8 1*#4, #4/9+*  (
::7  
:27  &  ;    0  !  &*    &      (    .,,//.,2!

!< ,6    %*              *     *  ,2/    ,27      + (  &      5   1  +(& 
- 
,= !! 53 ** !  * 

 41*

+  5!&0 5 #3

#33*  *& !*   (  %*    ( ! %*     !&! !+*+  0*  ( 

 *0+ !  0

+*  (
,>2,=2-)4 
,=.-.6.)4 ++  +  0 *    (   !  %*       ;  7.,,/.,-   !%*    *0 &  ;!!8 9 !5 ( + && !+ * ++  & * ! 5 + 
,.  + !+*

++  * ) !?& + !" 

 0   0!!!*

++   0%*    &   ,2,//./,- ,,.7/.,2"&  & 

 4   &

    .2.=/.,2  8 1*  #4,,9 
!  &  <



# /::,>!/.,28
    9 *(#   !"  9 ! 0 

   !0*&  />,,/.,2 1*#4,/9  (+ *  

  5          !+ !+ !!! 
  (! /6.//.,68 1*#4/.9 01*&;!!%*       +!

 0   5

 *

 0 !  & 5  0 * 0%*   *@ (

  *1 5 !*  + && 0  0* ++  + *  ) * !?& + !" 
      /6.//.,6  8 1*  #4/.9    0 

 (

   ! 00!

  (  * (   (    (! +*( 

,-.//./, 7  

 +*( 

 ) (+     0      (   * (  !  (  !+ 1 ( *   * 0   (!      0     0   " A0   *+  *    &*

(+  * 0+0! * " A0 *+ *   

 (    *+  ! (*!  * 0 (  +  0  + 0*+ B* !!!

    0(* !*   
" A0 *+ *!*( 

 & & (  B*  !!+  + +  0  ! +*(  (+ )  (  * 0  &04  +  ( * (!   + : <&   *0+ + 0

!

   &( *(+*( 

(+  (

 !  0*  !  

 + - * (*! (

 0 0 *  *+ *

  +  *0    5 0 



0+ * 5      (    1  5        

       0  !  

*+ &  0 0 0    )& ! + * 0 & )1 5
+  B* !! & &

            (    !*+ !      5 (  

&! !  & * !5 * 0

 +     +   (   +*+ 05
  (!!*  

* +*(  /6.//.,68 1*#4/.9 +   &  )  .7.,/.,6* 01*& ;!!%*   

 

*  !+  +!*  ( 

%*   ( * 

'

*& 51*

 4!  * !  +!!!0+5  89)*   !* 

 
  *  & +*+ 05& 0 !  * 0

 !* (! + !& ( *

( & 50  & 0 %*   

* 

   0 0 0       *+ ) * ) *

( & )  !* ++  B* ! 

 !50 +* !
,.  2

*(    +   0      ++   *   +   !!0 + 0

  + +*  !5 

 4

( &0  *00**!!5

! +* ! 
::7  
:27 &0 *(01

*& !+ *!+* *

0     0 
-     
,=      *

  

 
,>2,=2-)4 
,=.-.6.)4&  +

 ! !5

   01   0 

  !  (  ( (

 & !  &+  0  0 *  41! ! *  *  6  *0  0" A0 *+ *   0  50*  *  !



"( **               B*   !  !    !     0(   + !    (  *  !     *  0 (  (           *+  !  B*  !!+   +"& (& ! *+ ! * +!*1*         *

 & * > 3  (!0&  ! *+ !

  (( +  * *

 0! *1(&  *(  ( 

  !!&  &+ & +*(   0 0 

 * 0 =
 0 ( & !+  + 

  $ "

  ()(*+ #  

& &$ $ "

,-(./0   <5 ()  $ C) < 0 $ C)