Kamal Nain Etc. v. Inder Singh Etc.
!!"#$#%& '() *+) ,-.#% *!/$ 00!..% $ 1!/$2$ %3!/#%4*$#%"!3!"!$!3 */24*5 $ *!/$ !$0%3!% $
!"#$%& '( $(')#
/!$!% &
/.#.4/+!%#/36" !7# *
/%8.04/+36" !+ / *!00!..% $
/ #$*95*%+36" !+ / *!/!$0%3!% $ ::::: (')#*% 00!..% ;3!!%3% $/!#% !42./!"%300!.4#%$ *!
"%"2//!% #%3#%4$" +7*!/!9' *!$2# *!/!$0%3!% ;0.#% #$ $!!8#%40/!;!-0 /'/#4* 9'"*..!%4#%4 *!$.!3!!33 !3)<)= !>!"2 !39'3!!%3% /*-+";$*/!/+#%62/00!..% ; 3!!%3% $ (+*$9!!%3!"/!!39' *! /#.2/ %3#/-!3#% 00!. 7$..!4!3 * 3!!%3% ;/*-*3?(/3$*/!#% *! ..%3-!$2/#%48%.$-/.$$# 2 !3#% *!/!6!%2!!$ ! 1#..4!@7%"-0/#$#%4,*!7 ( 7$ 3!! *!/#4* *!0.#% #$9!#%4";$*/!/$#% *!!% #/!8*!7 !# *!/%'% #"!7$ 4#6!% !!%3% 3#3 % 00!/ 3!$0# ! $!/6#"! %3 7$
0/"!!3!3!>;0/ ! 00!..% ;3!!%3% $ (00!/!3%3"% !$ !3 *!$2# ..!4#%4 * *!$.!7$% 0/!;!-0 #9.!$3!!%3% *3%.'$.3 $0!"##"8#..%2-9!/ *!6!%3!!$+#%7*#"*0.#% #$7!/!% *!"; $*/!/$$2-+A=)?;7$0#39' *!00!..% $ *!6!%3/$ !/%!$ -%!'%3% *!/$2-=+(?; *! #-! *!$.!3!!3 % *!9$#$ *!0.!3#%4$ *!0/ #!$+ *! /#.2/ /-!3 *!..7#%4#$$2!$&;
B
!
"
!
#
! $ % & ' ! (
)
%
"
* !
! $ +
,
$ - !
$ .
.#% #$+ #% $200/ *! /!-!% #%!3 0.!3#%4$+ !>-#%!30.#% #%3!/#%4*$ C;%39/24* %/!"/3$.!
3!!3> %3@-9%3#> +7*!/!$ *!3!!%3% $!>-#%!3C; - /8$*%3.$0."!3%/!"/3/!6!%2!/!"/3
/.#.4/+.!/%!3!%#/2%$!.$$#$ !39' /%8.0 4/36" !+/!0/!$!% #%4 *!00!..% ;3!!%3% $$29-# !3 * 9 * *!"2/ $9!.7*6!-#$/!3 *!"% !% $ *!$.!3!!3$ *!0.#% #$
+
*3"D2#/!3 *!7%!/$*#0#% *!$2# 0/0!/ '9'6#/ 2! *!$.!3!!3 3 !3)=)=(+7*#"*#$,*!7 )+7*!/!$ *!$29@!" - !/ *!$2# .%37$,*!7 (+#% *#$/!4/3*3.$/!32 *! /%$. !3"0' *!$.!3!!33 !3)=)=(%3$7!..$ *! #-024%!3$.!3!!33 !3)<)=%$200/ *!/!-!% #%!3 "% !% #%+/!.#!320% *!..7#%4@234-!% $&; & ,
(
,
-./0//0/1,
-,1
/,
,-2 #,3,-
-./* 4 3
- //5 "% !%3 * *!/!6!%2!/!"/33!$% "%!/ %' # .! % *!/ 7/3$+ *! @-9%3# 7$ % $2#"#!% /!D2#/!-!% .7 /!6!/+# 3#3% ..'7# * *!"% !% $ *!$.!3!!3E -- &--6.
-.0//
, , #73 , ..8*49 3
- //:9 "% !%3 * *!0.!#$.$7# */!4/3 ,*!7 ) %3% (%3+ *!/!/!+$0!/ *!0/6#$#%$ /3!/A
2.! +$2# 7$.#9.! 9!3#$-#$$!3E (
2..!%"*@234-!% *#$2/ #% 3 .
0//".,3 , .
-./*44;+<#99 "% !%3 * *! /!" %4.! %2-9!/$ %3 8#.. %2-9!/$ /! /!6!%2! -!$2/!$+ 2$!3 9' /!6!%2! 2 */# #!$ / !$ 9.#$*#%4 *! 3!$"/#9!3#!.3$ * "%$ # 2 ! *!7%!/$*#0.%37%!/+ *2$+ *! 0.#% #$ -#$!/9.' #.!3 0."! % /!"/3 *! !6#3!%"! % *! "% //'+ / #$*9 5*%+ .!/%!3 "2%$!.
/!0/!$!% #%4 *!/!$0%3!% ;0.#% #$$29-# !3 * *!@-9%3#/!.!" !3 *!$ 2$ *!/!$0%3!% ;0.#% #$%3 *!6!%3/;/!$0%3!% $ ";$*/!/$+92 *! !" == *!$2# 0/0!/ '#$#3!% #".%3+ *2$+ 0/'!3/3#$-#$$. *!00!. *6!*!/3 *!.!/%!3"2%$!./ *!0/ #!$%300/#$!3
*!00!/98 %3 .
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
7# */!4/3 !" == #%3#%4$" +#%$2"*"#/"2-$ %"!$+"%% 9!$#3 9!$2!/#%4/-#..!4.# '/0!/6!/$# ' /-3#!/!% 0#%#% * *!0/0!/ '7$3#!/!% %3+ *!/!/!+0/!;!-0 !3 4/2%3/#% !/!/!%"!#$-3!2 +-2"*.!$$#%6.6!-!% %'$29$ % #.D2!$ #%.7 !$2. % .'+ *!00!.#$3#$-#$$!3 2+4-.*4 (')# 3/.
%&=>$ ).-./6, ?/
@/?
).-. -A @/?