High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/1825/2019disposed of

Punjab State Co-Operative Supply And Marketing Federation Ltd (Markfed) v. Subhash Chander Kawatra

2025-07-17Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel3 pages

!"#$%$ &'() ()

' *+), ,+ !"# $!%&'()*+," -*"& ,.. //,!",../$+,!" 00000 ,+ -)./ 1 & ",!"$) .,4 5,( $!"& .

!",.. ,/ ,( '"&2 #

! "#

% &

' (

)

- /*!%6$"&,!,.. ,/',!,../$+,"$*!-*%,!"*-/ ,) &, * 3 !. - (2!( +"$*!789: '1;87 < &,) & ,(/ ,! (+*2!

/-*"& ,.. //,!",../$+,!",!( &,) . 2 ("& .,.

3**= 7 -* .*+ ($!%"*( +$( "& ,../$+,"$*!-*%,!"*- . +$,/ / ,) "*,.. ,/,.. ,/'$"6*2/(3 ,..* $" "* - & $!"*,>2(%5 !"

( 34 "&$ *2" $! "$"/ ( ,

6& $!'"&$ *2"'6&$/ /4$!%2.*!"& ($+",*-"& *!?3/ 2. 5 *2"$! ! "! #!

$ % & #

'()

*+, *!! , -&,

& /("&,",!,.. ,/,%,$!

",!*( *-,+@2$"",/$!,.*+ ($!%2!(

+"$*! 179 *- "& %*"$,3/ !

"25 !"

+"' 1991 . - ( 34 "& +*5./,$!,!"'-,// @2, /46$"&$!"& .2)$ 6*-.*)$ *"* +"$*!78<*-

:17*-'<A<7 &$ >2($+$,/ !2!+$,"$*!6, . ($+," (2.*!

"& $!" . ","$) 2!( ",!($!%"&,"'-*"& .2.*

*-,+*5./,$!"2!( +"$*!179*-"& %*"$,3/ !

"25 !"

+"'1991'"& +*5./,$!,!"$

!+*5.,

(6$"&$!"& B.,!

$) ( -$!$"$*!*-C ?, ( /$! ," ($!"&

' 1;87' <A<7 *!

@2 !"/4' "& +*5./,$!,!" $ !*"

+*!

",$! ("*.2 2 "& 5* "$!% !".*+ (2 *- =$!% . +$,// ,) "*,.. ,/2!( +"$*!789:*- '1;87:1;:*-'<A<7 &$ *2"2!( +* ("&,""& +*. ,!(,53$"*-.*)$ *"* +"$*!78<

:17, $!& !"/43*,( ,!(5* ,++*55*(,"$!%6& ! >2B",.* (6$"&"& +*5.,,"$) /4!,*6 +*!-$!

*- +"$*!789:*-

'1;87:1;:*-'<A<7'6&$+&5,!(,"

"& .*+2 5 !"*-

. +$,// ,) -*5"& $%& *2"-*,!,.. ,/,%,$!

",!,+@2$"",/$!, +*5./,$!"+,

*6 ) ' ( 5*!

","$!% , .*-*2!( +*55$"5 !" "* "& *) ,+&$!% .$!+$./ *- >2 "$+ ,!( , ( " 5$!,"$*! "* . +/2( 5 .*+ (2,/" +&!$+,/$"$ -*5 +/$.

$!%"& ",!"$) ,(>2($+,"$*!*-"& +, '"&$ *2"'$!

" ,(*- 255,$/4($ 5$

$!%"& ,.. ,/*!"&$ " +&!$+,/ $!-$5$"4'>2($+$*2 /4*." ("* / %," "& ,.. ,/',/*!%6$"&,++*5.,!4$!% ,../$+,"$*! '"*"& +*!+ ! (

$*!

*2" : . /$!)$ 6*-"& ($+",*-"& *!?3/ 2. 5 *2"$! ! "! #!

2.,, *"& .*!*2!+ 5 !"*-"&$ *2"$!

2.,D"& .

!",.. ,/',/*!%6$"&,++*5.,!4$!%,../$+,"$*! '

$ ($ .* (*-, & 2!( # $ & .

!",.. ,/',/*!%6$"&,++*5.,!4$!%,../$+,"$*! '$

5$"" ("*"& / ,! (

$*!

2(% ' *E .26$"&,($ +"$*!"*" ,"

"& ,5 , &,)$!%3 !-$/ (2!( +"$*!78<*- '1;87 +"$*!

:17*-'<A<7 & ,$(/ ,! (

$*!

2(% 5,4 !"2 ""& ,.. ,/ "*&$5 /-*,

$%!$""*,!*"& *2"*-+*5. " !">2$ ($+"$*!-*$"

($ .* ,/', . /,6 $$ (/

"*+/,$-4"&,""&$ *2"&, !*"( /) ($!"*"& 5 $"

*-"& ,.. ,/, *,/*!%6$"&,++*5.,!4$!%,../$+,"$*! D,!("& ,5 $ / -"*. !-*+*!

$( ,"$*!*-"& +*!+ ! (/ ,! (

$*!

*2"'6&$+&

&,//$!(23$",3/4,(>2($+," "& ,5 6$"&*2"% ""$!%$!-/2 !+ (34,!4 *3 ),"$*!5,( & $!,3*) $$$ & %$ "4$ ($ +" ("* !(' B. ($"$*2 /4'"& +*5./ "

+*( *-"& .

!",.. ,/$!+/2($!%"& .,.

3**="*"& ,$(/ ,! (

$*!

2(% .,+1 2/418'<A<F +

& "& . ,=$!% , *! (# *

& "& .*",3/ # *