Meena Kainth v. National Highways Authority Of India And Others
"#$
"#"&#'
"#$
($ )* (
+ ++ ,
)* (+
+ +
+( ! "#$ %&'( )*&
+ , &-.&/, ,&#( )*&
0
& !,( ( 1&"
& &&( )*&
& &, 2,( )*&
0 3
&,&.&( )*&
0 &.&,&.&( )*&
0 4 ++ ,
-
,!, 0'! 0 +
*'
778977:0 0 &(
, &# 0 ,
- &*
' 0
! "
# $ %& '($ &( )% *+, -
,,
($ / #0 ## 1,,
*2 / / !#/
"#"0.
3% 4.
, 6, ,
$
+
+, + , 3 !& .
7".
8 ,
+
$ ( 9 +
$
# %, , 6,
9 $
+,
,
+
+& ! )
,
0:
&
$$ $
.
( $
( 8
& & %+ .
$
(
, 6, ,
$ & ;
#/
0# /1
2 0/ /0/0"#
&)
( &!
' .
+&&''
( '*#0 ) 0 &0 '0 0 + &;
0 *
#( , "# %,&&
'
./ &
<,
0, *&''
&= % /=>
,!, '
&
?:
?@ 7?6: < A6> & &''
( +&.
0 &"'!
&'
, (& &") & '*& (= % /=+''
'
& +'' ) &.
+ &0&*'
& .
, 0 &"',! &0 &
' ** +& &;
'
"#= % /=)
!
'
&
77 ?C 7??? < A7>( 0.
0(, & ;,!,& )!, @
,& & &'
, +&! &* 0''#( ''
00*&'0 & &' !,+&# , #0 &<,
0 , *&''
&= =>*' #& - &
& &*, 00* 0 B & @& *&.
;+ 4??D& .
& &0,
(,& "
&*D ,!, . ! .& "# ( "
( & 1! '& ,&) &' "
&*D (0 0+ !& .&
&* & &'
!,+&# 6 "#/ #/0"#
"4 /1
6 # '"&#
4"
/1
/0/0"#
& * '0
". ( ,!, * 0 &*D 0 '& +& ) '
9+ , & ;,!,& )!,(+, - *
( 0&)0 4A% /(,+ ( * +& )
% /A 4 +,+& !
& )& .
:
4A% /+&&'& &# & #
&*D
!& +& &,& *.
' 0 &*D 0
'& "
0'0" +&&''&"'
"
& 0 (
&*D +& " ! ,
( , ". .'&'# &
&'
A
' . - ! ,) #& &' !,+&#(,&)
) '
&
&
,(0
! & ! !&
( +' *& &#' &!
&#
"#
4"
'/0#8 /1
&9.0
0"#
"4 /1
6 # '"&#
4"
/1
:
/0/0"#
.&# &0 ! ".0
& * '0
"
&;
0. 0&* .
"
! + 0 &*D '& (,&, . 0'
) (, &' &
)
'& ( "# (,& , .& &
6?
(& &'0 && B0 '#0'
"# 73 ( &' 0'
"1 &!& '&*,! 0 &*D *
! # )
. *.
' 0 <>0 '& '#( "# , , !
.&;
&#'&+0'*,&''
'&*,!0 &*D
!& &*
) (* &'' (+&.&
?:
?@ 7?6:("# 4A% /(+, &(
BA = * =(+& 6E ?:
7?6?(0''+ "#&&+& &
78 ?:
7?6B( ,( &0
.&;!0 < &>( 4A% /(,& & , #+,& ,!,.&;!0 <
A6>& ?:
?@ 7?6:( ,&'' &
*. &! &*D '& &"
! '&*,!0 &*D
!( ) "
*&.
)
0&#!,
) &*D '& (+, &(*. '
) 0!, &
) &*D '& (& *&.
, *0 ( ( &*D!& , # "#
;
< 4A% />,& !, &
A6 * ( "# &'' ) &
(
'#( ( )&' ,
.&;
&# '&+0' *,&''
'&*,! 0
!<>(+,*,,&+
.&
,!,.&;!0 &#&+& 78 ?:
7?6B("
+,
. *.
&. ,&"
) "#
6B
( & BA <@> 0 = * =( )+, 0& - &*
,
( & #"& &!& &#*,&''
!.& &&*D &.&
BA <6>0 & *
<= >
%2
% <=
( ($ & !
$
!
($ & ,,!
%2
% <= .
($ & ,,.
(& %(
$ ,&
,
+
(
$
$ .
,
+
( ,, ,
%& 6,
, ,
$ $
$ $ ( % <=
<= 6
$%,
,
% <=.
, ,, + %, ,
+
(
( ,,
(%
< = >
$ & ,.
$%,
% <=
% ,
% <=
$%, !
( $%, .
,, + &
:
+ ($
! &
9 $
% <= & %&
,,
,
<0= ! "#$%&!
'( $"
# "##$ $#)
6@
"# *,&''
,!
. (& & !0 && E(0 '#( &00 &) ( &'( " &* 0&*D BA0 = * =(+& "', + &'# + & + '# **'& ! '*&' #( &.*, &( &.
"
*&.
"', =, & .
</,& !&, > &
?E ?B 7?6?& &;2&!&&< 1&" > &
6?
?B 7?6?
* ( & "'*& 0 < &> BA( ,("1 BA/+
) 0. '& ' ** ( & 9 0. '
** (& (+, &0
*'&& BA
& * +&
/ *'#( "#+ & +;!&!& ( &!&
** ( "
&' & ' +; &!&
6:
/ '#( * '
& .& '
** (+& ,.& # &7???(& 0 +& "', # &7?6?
'
'# "#&
,& &
0*.
(" +, '&+0'. ( 0
. *.
&. ("
!&'
%
& "
*&.
) '&
"
0 # & , # **
0 ( +&;
&") ("
+,
& + **'& ( "
! .& "'*& 0 &*D < &>( "# +, '
&' ,& &*D
;+'
0 & "'*& ( #
.&;! &# .
'&*,!0 &*D
! '#( +, & )& &!
(&'&+0'
.&#"
& +&&.
&"'
"
"'#& "#
** (#
+, .& A &
, 0 ( ,!, '
,& " , &
&. .&#,&) &, *,&''
'&*,!0 &*D
!(" +, '&+0'*,&''
,&"
.& "# "#
6C &0
.& ,(
'#
+, *&.
&''
( **'0 &*D *
!(" & &''#(,&'&+0' , . .&;
&# '&+0'*,&''
&.
6E ) ( +, &*D < &> *&.
+ '# "', + & < &> 0
+&**&0 * '0
&!!( ) &' * &*D < &>("
*&.
)
!
(& )& 0
.
43% /<'
>(& &.
0
&") &(+& D (& )& &
,"
!
&''# ) ( (
(&& &!
< &>( &'' ,!, A6(+&.& 0&)0
"# 43% / +&;
0+ "'*& "
!
.& &*D &' * +& D
) % /
7?
. 7A '# &00 &) ( 0.'# *
+ '& <>( + &*D 0 0 ! D
"'* (&
'& (&
&
!&'*. '&# '& '& ! *. '
0
)& "'*
'#(* .&* ( "
&! "'* ,& ) &'
0
,'
0 ( !( ,/ 0& &''+
=*'&.0 &*D '& "
*.! 0.
+ ( " &'1 *
& &"'
, .&;
&&"'
0
' . ( 7A
(00 &"'
'
&
' . ( ,"
( .&
0 (& "
.& &)&'&"'
* .
&)&'! )* &
' .
0
* +
&0
.& ,( ,/ 0 .
( & (+ , &") " )& ( &.
.
7B . ! & *
&+& .& & & &00.
<++ ,= <+
+(=
;&)
!, ,
&;!9 &
9 ,
&"'
9