Dharminder Singh v. Financial Commissioner (Appeals) And Others
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
!.#/0*,(%/ ------ %$*$*&,%/
3%/+4+
66%#5+7 4,8#9 &$.%/+ ------
%+6&,(%,$+ : ;
1 1
/%+%,$ /- 1.%//< =- 1*,25#7
(>&)#$% 6%$*$*&,%/-
/- */0#58*$ !*?#,#7 1%,*&/ ! 4,8#9-
/- !*56/%%$ #,(.*7 (>&)#$% - - - 1
- %$*$*&,%/
!.#/0*,(%/ 1*,2. '*5%( )*>*5 4,(%/ /$*)5%+ @ &,+$*$4$*&, ,(*#7 *,$%/ #5*#7 +%%A*,2 ,#$4/% )%/$*&/#/* +%$$*,2
7
66%#5+7 4,8#9
+.&/$ :
&00*++*&,%/: ?.%/%9<
7 1/* 4A$+#/ 1#.*9
+.&/$ :&55%)$&/:
7
%/&C%64/ !*>*+*&,7
%/&C%64/
+.&/$ :!*>*+*&,#5 &00*++*&,%/: )#+% 9%%, (%)*(*,2 #'/%+.-
/*%'5<7 &, (%0*+% 1./* 80%/ 1*,2.7 6/%>*&4+ ;#09#/(#/ >*55#2% 4/4+#/7 %.+*5 *((#/9#.#7 !*+$/*)$ 1/* 4A$+#/ 1#.*9D 6/&)%%(*,2+ ?%/% *,*$*#$%( '*55*,2 >#)#,)<-
, 64/+4#,)% 6/&)5#0#$*&,
04+$/* 04,#(* )#55*,2 46&, #665*)#$*&,+ '*55*,2 +#*( >#)#,)<7 $?%5>% #665*)#$*&,+
*,)54(*,2 &,% +490*$$%( #/8*$ 1*,2.7 ?%/% /%)%*>%(-
#,$%)%(%,$+ )#,(*(#$%+7 ?.& /%0#*,%( '/#<7 ?%/% 2&$ >%/*'*%( '/&0 5&)#5 6&5*)%-
$/#,+6*/%+ %.+*5(#/ #2*+$/#$%7 *((#/9#.# /%)&00%,(%( ,#0% 6/%+%,$ #'&/%+#*( >#)#,)< '&/?#/(%( &55%)$&/-
- 46&, #66/%)*#$*,2 /%5#$*>% 0%/*$+(%0%/*$+ )#,(*(#$%+7 #66&*,$%( ;#09#/(#/ >*55#2% 4/4+#/7 >*(%
-
%+6&,(%,$ #/8*$ ).#55%,2%( &55%)$&/:+
'*5*,2 #, #66%#5 9%'&/% .&?%>%/7 +#0% (*+0*++%(7 >*(%
-
%*,2 #22/*%>%( #2#*,+$ #'&/%+#*( &/(%/+
7 6/%'%//%( /%>*+*&,
9%'&/%
?.*).
)#0% #55&?%(7 >*(%
?.%/%9< &/(%/+
?%/% (%)*(*,2 #'/%+.
#'$%/ %>#54#$*,2 0%/*$+ #55 )#,(*(#$%+-
, #'&/%0%,$*&,%( )*/)40+$#,)%+7 '*5%( )*>*5 /%5*%'
+7 ,&$*)%( #9&>%-
- ;%#/,%( )&4,+%5 +490*$+
%//%( 5#?
'#)$+ #55&?*,2 /%>*+*&, 6/%'%//%( $.%/%9< +%$$*,2 /%#+&,%( &/(%/+
-
+490*$$%( *0642,%(
7
#2#*,+$ +%$$5%( 5#?
;#09#/(#/7 ).&*)% 5*2.$5< *,$%/'%/%( ?*$.7 %>%, $?& >*%?+ 6&++*95% 4,5%++ $.%/% 6#$%,$ *55%2#5*$< &/ 6%/>%/+*$< $.%/%*,-
'4/$.%/ +490*$$%(
'#*5%( 6&*,$ &4$ *55%2#5*$< &/ 6%/>%/+*$< &/(%/+ &00*++*&,%/-
,%B$ +490*$$%( 0%/*$&/*&4+ *,#+04).
,#0% /%)&00%,(%( %.+*5(#/ #2*+$/#$%7 *((#/9#.# <&4,2%/ #2% - +490*$$%( +4''*)*%,$5< %(4)#$%(
$.
6#++ )#, 9%$$%/ 5*#+&, 9%$?%%, >*55#2%/+ #(0*,*+$/#$*&,- + /%2#/(+ 5#,(.&5(*,2 )&,)%/,%(7 *$ +490*$$%( +4''*)*%,$ 5#,(.&5(*,2 .*+ ,#0%- ))&/(*,25<7 6/#<%/ 9%%, 0#(% +%$$*,2 *0642,%(
9%*,2 4,+4+$#*,#95% %<%+ 5#?
/%+$&/*,2 &55%)$&/:+ &/(%/7 #66&*,$*,2 - %/ )&,$/#7 )&4,+%5 #/8*$ &66&+%( +490*++*&,+ 0#(% &, 9%.#5'
+490*$$*,2 *0642,%(
/%#+&,%( 84+$*'*%( (&%+
)#55 *,$%/'%/%,)% $.*+ &4/$-
+490*$$%( %(4)#$%( 5#,(.&5(*,27 .&?%>%/7 +#*( #+6%)$ *2,&/%( &00*++*&,%/D #))&/(*,25<7
.#( /*2.$5< &/(%/+
/*2.$5< '/%+.
(%)*+*&,- *$.
#'&/%+#*( +490*++*&,+7 )&4,+%5 6/#<%( (*+0*++#5 )*>*5 6%$*$*&,-
.#>% .%#/( )&4,+%5 /%+6%)$*>% 6#/$*%+ .#>% 6%/4+%( 6#6%/9&&A ?*$.
$.%*/ #95% #++*+$#,)%-
@- %/%7 *$ ?&45( #66&+*$% +$#$% /%5#$*>% 0%/*$+ )#,(*(#$%+
,&$*)%( *$+
7 ?.*).
4,(%/ #/$*)45#/+ %$*$*&,%/
!.#/0*,(%/
%+6&,(%,$
#/8*$ 2% (4)#$*&,#5 E4#5*'*)#$*&, $.
- - ;#,( .&5(*,2 + )/% )/%
%)&00%,(%( %.+*5(#/ 1!7 *((%/9#.#- @-
6%/4+#5 #9&>% %B$/#)$%( )&06#/*+&, )#,(*(#$%+ ?&45( +.&?
<&4,2%/ #2% +4''*)*%,$5< %(4)#$%( +4''*)*%,$ 5#,(.&5(*,2-
4/$.%/7 ,#0% /%)&00%,(%( 5&?%/ /%>%,4% &''*)%/+ '&4,( 0&+$ +4*$#95% )#,(*(#$% 6&+$
@-
,
*>*5 @@7 &,:95% 146/%0% &4/$ .%5( ?*$.
/%2#/( ;#09#/(#/ 1$#$% 4,8#97 #2% )#,(*(#$% /%5%>#,$ '#)$&/- + '#/ /%)&00%,(#$*&,+ 5&?%/
%>%,4% ''*)%/ )&,)%/,%(7 #5$.&42.7 9&4,( /%)&00%,(#$*&, 0#(%
%>%,4% 4$.&/*$*%+ '#>&4/ )#,(*(#$%D .&?%>%/7 (4% )&,+*(%/#$*&, #))&/(%( +4).
/%)&00%,(#$*&,+ $.%< 6&+*$*&, #++%++ +4*$#9*5*$< )#,(*(#$% +4).
/%)&00%,(#$*&, ?&45( .#>% +&0% 6%/+4#+*>% >#54%- , $.*+ /%2#/(7 /%'%/%,)% )#, 0#(% &9+%/>#$*&,+ 0#(% )#+%
!7
*>*5
$0# >+
%>%,4%7 4,8#97
;
-
@-
5$.&42.7 &?,+ 5#,( 6%$*$*&,%/D .&?%>%/7 *$ &9+%/>%( '#/ .&5(*,2 5#,( )&,)%/,%(7 +#0% $#A%, *,$& )&,+*(%/#$*&, &,5< 64/6&+% +%)4/*$< $&?#/(+ 2&>%/,0%,$ /%>%,4% )&55%)$%( %$*$*&,%/ #9&4$ #)/% 5#,(7 ?.*).
+4''*)*%,$ $#A%, *,$& )&,+*(%/#$*&, 64/6&+% +%)4/*$< /%>%,4%7 )&55%)$%( &/%&>%/7 )#+% "#
!
@
*>*5
$.*+ &4/$ &9+%/>%( 5#,( /%>%,4% +$&&( #9&5*+.%( 9&$.
1$#$% 4,8#9 #/<#,#7 5&,2 9#)A7 $.4+ &?,*,2 5#,( )#,(*(#$%+ 6&+$ ;#09#/(#/ ?&45( 04).
+*2,*'*)#,)% '4/$.%/-
@-
4/$.%/0&/%7 )#+% #
$## %&& !7
*>*5 @ *$ .%5( !*>*+*&, %,).
$.*+ &4/$ ).&*)% !*+$/*)$
)#,,&$ 5*2.$5< #+*(%7 %>%, $?& >*%?+ 6&++*95%7 4,5%++ $.%/% 6#$%,$ *55%2#5*$< &/ 6%/>%/+*$< $.%/%*,- %+$#95*+.%( 0#*, #4$.&/*$< ?.& &,5< #66/%)*#$%+ #,$%)%(%,$+ #55 )#,(*(#$%+ '/#< 94$ 6%/+&,#55< *,$%/#)$+ ?*$.
$.%0-
?.*5% *,$%/#)$*,2 ?*$.
)#,(*(#$%+7 &9+%/>%( #/8*$ *,)#6#95% $%55*,2 #,<$.*,2 #9&4$ .*0+%5'
&, #))&4,$7 )&,+*(%/%( +4*$#95% )#,(*(#$%-
?.*5% (*+0*++*,2 #66%#5 '*5%( 7 >*(%
7 &9+%/>%( 4,(%/
!
"
#$
%%&
'
($
"
&)
)
* "
&
'
($
#
+, - )
!
"
.
"
'
% $
*
"
$!
"
'
$
/' ,
)
)
)
,
*
0
' & &
@
$ -
' &
- 1
,
&
' & *
0
*
0
*
0
&
!
2
- *
*
"
-
&)
-
)
) *
" 32 " ) '
&*
0
4 - %+*(%+7 .#>% 2&,% $./&42.
?.%/%9< 9%%, '/%+.
(%)*+*&,-
>*(%,$5<7
)#+% ,&$*)*,2 )5#*0 %(4)#$%( .&5(+ 5#,( ?.%/%#+ &$.%/ /%5%>#,$ #+6%)$+ .#>% 9%%, $#A%, *,$& )&,+*(%/#$*&,-
;%#/,%(
'#*5%( 6&*,$ &4$ *55%2#5*$< &/ 6%/>%/+*$< &55%)$&/:+ #,(&/ &00*++*&,%/:+ &/(%/-
9%%, ?*$.&4$ )&,+*(%/*,2 +%$$5%( 6&+*$*&, 5#?
).&*)% 5*2.$5< *,$%/'%/%( ?*$.7 %>%, $?& >*%?+ 6&++*95%-
, #'&/%0%,$*&,%( '#)$+ )*/)40+$#,)%+7 #0 )&,+*(%/%( >*%?
4,+4+$#*,#95% +#0%
#))&/(*,25< #+*(%-
%+45$#,$5<7 #55&?%(
#66&*,$*,2 ;#09#/(#/ >*55#2% 4/4+#/7 %.+*5 *((#/9#.#7 !*+$/*)$ 1/* 4A$+#/ 1#.*97 46.%5(-
- %,(*,2 #665*)#$*&,
+7 #,<7 +.#55 +$#,( )5&+%(-
1
!
+8A+ .%$.%/ +6%#A*,2/%#+&,%(
"%+
& .%$.%/ /%6&/$#95% "%+
&