← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2403/1993allowed

Suraj Bhan And ORS v. Niadri & ORS.

2026-01-21Mr. Justice Virinder Aggarwal31 pages

    

 



 

   

 !"# $% & &'



() $* !$%$+%,-%) & &.

/0$(## $%1& &.

 

      



 

 1  2 3 & 

4  53   !" # 

$ %  &' # ( )%  &

#(   %  & *    ##  %   &' #+)  %  & * 

 # 

%$%+"  4  53

 , - & ))

   

.

%  / **               &

   ** 0 1)



) 

& 

23,2,445%

 !"  



&6

%

% '

& **) %  "% *

& !"  - .

- -.

%!"

) 

&  75,,,447%

!"   !6

%

% &   !"

   

/ **%  8

& "  *  

      





)

7     

%  9& 

/ ** &  -.

' &)*  

 

  

 * )

% )

   &

 

 ) 

 

 

  



     

    



     

 !

   "

  #$% # "  &  "

    ' 

 ()    "     

*+!

 

  , - -.

***/0 '

 

   )   "  ( 

 

 ! 

  # &



 

 #  # 0         "  

 

   "#

   ()&  &

,  !.

***/0  "#&#

  #   ")  "  # 0  & 

1 5 :

!

" ' ))

% 



& 

!) ' ) 

&)% '

 "  *  '

&

 

  &      #  # " #  

          )      #)  , - -.

***/0



#) &

 $    (    2#  "    

&  

 "     

3 #"  4   ( # # )  & #

    

    #    (   #     &   

(#     #) "  "





       # " #() 

#     #  )&# 

&   )#   1 +



8   & " 



!)

 % .

*

    &) &

 "

% *&&  

&

 &

%*) *  '

* &

 

  5   #  "  0    6#  7899 - 5 

   ( 2  "

 

( #) 3 

7899 5       "   #()

 

#73

789 :

5  #   73

7 89 .

5 # (  )&#  #

 #  $#

 73

789 5  & 0      #  2   

"  73



# 789 0; 5      6#  789

 !

, ;

< '8 *)

*

* '

!

  )    "    

&   &%       -  .

 

  & *  

/ **- * !"

   / *

  '  )  !"       =  .

.



&

& *

%       !*  .

 >   

 %    & .



 %)

&

& *



& *  .

! '* & "% ' ) *   

%'

& " 



   .



! * 

9  %

 .

   *+" - )' *  & ) "% 

  ? !)

  & !"  & *  & >, - *&



' * ) ) 

@



 %  &  .

! '

'@



) ! .

*   & "

&

 

  % 

**  & *  *

  "    

     .

%  

 

  ?   

 )&  ?) 



% &%

&

& *

 & ! '%< 

8 & ) & " & &  B     #"   $# "     #    $#

   "#)      & )     &  

# $# )   $#

 9C

 D    &  * &

 %

'

  

*'  ( !

+" %&

*  ! 

&

3, ( !.

&%,4,D



&

,22.(. * &   & !)  

)  ).

 & *

     



    ! 

 "

 ## !!

$%%*  ' !"



)  & * & ' '  



  (

 

 "

 

!!

 %

  

     

 "

  '

)

 "



'

'

 *  

) %

@

*'@ !*)





&"  %  *

.#& &

 7;27. *727;%8

  .

  

&



 & ) *: 3,% 7A .

 *.( & % ' &

,;,.(.- &

' * *    *&

& !@   ) %

!

  & 

&) )8 

? ,

7% '

& & ) ? & 



&" 

&

%  ?& *   &% ! 

&  4, -  !)    2A2A,447

!" = &.

))

 

 &

E?7

! & 

 .F(

 ,5,3, *,447!"

 8%

 '

'   *!" +

.

   

7,23,445%&* & " *'

& 

? 

? ,- )'!@ ")

= &.

))

%'

%!"

  72,7,44;% & )

 &

 

 .

& %<<

$ %

%&* & " *'

& )8 

? 7 47

  &

 !"! 

!' & '



! & )   ",44;

- 

&)  * 

")   &

% " )

  &

  !&     "

%&&

"%  

 &))

-    !)         &

*    

&)     



  & &"*    &



  

 &&

&&   !" *& &    & )

 ? & ,2 - &

' ) "   !" 

% '

*   ' ""

*  )<'&



 ''' ? &  *  &

 !

%

&

'!

* )  '

& * 

  % !"



!

! !&

,2, = %'!)

! * 



 

!"      



&

& 

 

G 

   < &

@ &%'  &

&) ''

" *    *  &

 

% * %

! ) 



 & ,, <   )"

*

&*&

 

!)

  & !" & *  <   

&) 

 !!



&  &&   

 & ) ? & 



&"   &

& % " )!



 &%  "! ")  &  &

 &

  *& &&  ) 

&

 "

,,,     7,23,445

? ,

!" .

 .F(

 ,5,3, *,447 )

 )  '  )

      = &  .

))

%  +" %  *    &

  ?) 



9

)

*    * &'

- 

  '

' 8% )

%

*)  %'

   "'

"' 

/& 

!  &   ' &

& ) 

 *   

,,7 - !@    72,7,44;E? 7 !" = &.

))

&" & )')

 .

& %<<

$ %

%* )  %&"

* &

 



9&)-   

   *     = &  .

))

9  %  '

&  !  &  &   &

%

& 

 0- & *  

  8)

% 

 ! &  && *

 H 

!   )F  !   ) H'  

)  '

 )& 

+% * %@ )



! 

H'

& '  *&" *H 

( .

*  

 *& &'

!

 

& +

I!+

.

- )

'

+

.

' ** * ) &* & " )

  '

& &"

'  

8  !   H'

& !  "  







)  %+%

'% ) 

H

!   )

< &*"&

   )  *!







& %.* & " ) &"

' H 

!   )

 8- H 

(    )  H   " 



 - 

 *   )"

! & !"  

) %

% * %  ! 8

* H' *&" *( 

H <'

'

"  .

& % <<

$ 

8 @ )

 ''

 * 



< &&) &% &)

 .

& %<<

$ %

'

)"&

   )  *H 

@  

)  

&     & 

)  

   &   )

     

I'*  " & ,7 &*?) 

* ) 

  

 &

'

   "  % )')

 "*  )   * )





       *       

8  .

@ "%     &



%  ")

%**&  

 



 G) % 

/ ** ,7, < &&) &%    @

!

 )  &     ) 

*       &

% "

 )



 

  !'  



  / *

% )"

  -8.



 8+

&

  )  "% &

8

!



&) 

& *

!

 *)

%&&

"% )

,5

 & *   !) 

=.

 & )) ) *

  &

<' 

*&  '

! !



* )  *

<

''

& 

 &

"



*    !" .

& 

!@ 

8 "B 9 ,5,

  &   *   &



         = .

* & 

/ **

&  " & ! 

  

*  @

&

&

,4 &< 



%  ) J 

%!

&"  &

% ! ) !"  **% !"



 ! ! )



*



 * &"- *  =.

 &

  &&& &

    !       *)"%  

      &  !

 ! '

,3 .

"%    &   *      

/ ** &



*

& !" .

! '*** )    "

"<'!)  = .

 & &"&

& !



  *&   ? !'  **



   

& *  

  *&  '

"&



 



** ) )  *

%  



! &

 "  !" .

 '  & ,3, <' 

! * 

/ ** 

)  .

! '*



 &





 &%

&

&

&  '

"

 && &  '     ' 



 &    

   

  &

*  '

  ,;

-  =.

%*&

 



% &%

!)

  & !" % &

*

    ,2 K,,  )



) %'

&

 

 0,2 ????

F,  )  



 '* !* = &.

))

E *

&

*



 &!"  **'

 !"+

I! +

.

 &''

&    "'   *

 

&  & !  *- +

I! +

.

 "  

  &  &



&   "&  *





" &



& &  "



#

'

'!

  !* ) 

**&

  "'   *

    &

!  *  



   &  

&  !"      **  

  "'  ) 

& )  *

< 

 & *    & !   *    )  "  

       &  !    

  " 

& )  *

* "!& ** '

&&! & *  - 

" * &



 & ! '

  *

 L)  *

!

'

  & *  * .

& -   !  

  &  

 

 &

 '  )   !"     

& " )  *

 " & 

'  " )  *

'

,,< ' ** 

&

%< 



 **)

*

& 

 , **&  ** '&    8 ' ) *% ) * 



 ) & 

 

* 

 *)

,>

 & *  

/ ** &  & 

' ' & !" .

  *  

  +, -  ) 

 "

  %'

 ' 

 &  *&  

**&   * ) )  *

! '

)''? !"



  &  .



 +,

 ( 

 "

/ 0%'

 '  



 "& ) ! & * "?&  )  *

= % (  

  +,   

 2"

/ %     .

 **) ?&

*

 )  @

* ) 

&  

  ,>, :

    !  *     

  

&) %    ' &



.

! ' 

" !  



/ **&

   "&  

   &  ) '* )"?& %

&

*&  

 &

!) )"

) "  * ) 

) 



  ,A

  &   *       M *

% 

    

%!) &  

 !' '

&%



 &

)"! ) & )% ) )  * )  !"   :**&- !@ 

*  )  *

%&

) 

&

,7, ( !

 &%'  !")   )  &%

8  " * )**&  &

 "  

 &

 ,A,    

    

               

  

              !

      "#$% &  ' (()     # %     *   %



    



    

% #   #  % 

     * %      + 052 <*   

"  

&

  ( !

 &

(

%'



'

 &

8 !"   :**&

 &

,,D

@

  " ! & 

)

 *

% 



 

&



 ) & )   %&

&

@ !  N &N- &

@  &

*

 )  *

&

) 

&

<<< 

'

!

")   )  & !&  & )"   

&

   !*    :**&+ &%

&  &

 " !  

)

 *

8 !"

  :**&

&

,,D%    '





  *& &

%!&

&

 * "* !" "- &

@  &

* '

  )  *

'

*  ' * + &%)"!&  )  *

'

 '

% &

! 

'

& )   '



5, - * *&

,7, 

 &  N'



& ) N#

!"%'

 '     !  

)

 *)8





& 



 

) !"

  :**&%  *&

,7,* 

)  *



&

  *

'

& ) "& &

@ !8 &

   *&

,7,%'

!

" ?& "'

8 ) & !& * & )"  



&  !" "!*    :**&  & * & &%   &

&

&"

&      

  *       '          )  

&

 "%

'  &'

!) "'

*   &

  !8 !*  & !& )"

  *< )'"%'

 &

8 !"

   :**&  

  &

 ,,D%     

 '

 

& ) %   '



 

'

)

)  %* 

*)

&!

 &- *  &

'  )  *

  

'

!

" ?& " ) '

8 ! &  & )"   

& 57  * *&  &&

& %  .

&   %  &

&    :**&          

7;2;,4D7 &  !&

 !"  **6  



'   )

 *



&

*)     )

  *  

 &&

"  :

    "%   N8  N' "

? *

&'

5,2;,4D7*  

 !&

 N8  N:

5,2A,4D7%  .

&   

   ' 

H

' %

"

? 

  

!

  %

N8 !% 

'&& -

  )! *8   !

  !!





* 

' ) 

 - 



! &&  

N8  N%    

 :* & %    5,2A,4>7' & 

!"  **6 

!"'" * !*  .

& '

     ,7,2,4D7 ) )- 

 *.

& '* & 

!"  6 

!"*



&

!*  .

))

-

% .

))

  "   "    

  5,2A,4D7 ,>,,,4D7% ) "  "

'

* ?

*O

 &&) &%   & )  

5,2A,4D7%'

 .

&   

'

)' &

*) !" .

& 

,4,2,4D7- & 

& %

 &&) &% 

" 

   **6 

   *&  

 * &%

2,,7,4D7%

 

 *)

    *

 & <

 

% +

.

 "  ) 

 

 *( !()

&

*

 &%

 

  

) 

& !"  & 

& 1 ,D <    &*"  !)            

) %   +

9!?.

  @ &"    *&

'

 



B8  9<  &%   *

' !"  .

& %<<

$ %

522,,4D>- 

  *  !*  .

& %&





'

 && &' &! )

- ' ) !" .

& 

7;2>,4DA - *% '

* 

!*  .

))

% '

&  '   ) %  *  '

 '

&     

 '  "

&    6)!

*  ",4DA/DD%& " *'

&  )8 E?(D#

 & 

' &

7A,2,44A%!@  '

&   '?& !"-8.

 8 *    ,D, " )  @

8&% 



!     .

))

% )

 &



!  &

  & %

)

!  &    6)!

*  ",4DA/DD<% * % & 





%  &   !' ' "  )  &

'

  !" +

9!?.

 / **   +, /

    3  .

@ "%) & !& '



' 

   ,D7 -  .

! '%

'% * & &&*&



"  

/ ** &

   "& '

 ' 

    ) *?&

  %*

%



*  &< '%  &) 

 *)

%  *  )  !  '& '



  %   **

%

  *

 &-   & ! &

 "  !" .

 4  (

  +, + ! 

 2"

$0

%  

 ' !@ "   5 ) 

 2 +, / 3 

 2"

$6 77!6 %  <        ,2  *      

) %      

! && &"&  *  ' *  

##(   #   4  (



 +, + ! 

 "

 1,$0 8

  #   "

 -*  ;  #  # <0 = > #    #" #  "

0 ;

      #   #    "" 

 &

0  0  " 0  

    "  #   

 "  

  - 0   " 0

    #  & #"   # #(  

 "      #3 

" &   &  " 6#  ( &"     (  $#   #  # 0 #     

  

 & #   & # 

 " &

  "   ) : 3   #    ; &

#  0      (

#  -*  ; &   &

 "2

 "  " 

 ) = ,4 -   

 & !" .

 4  (

  +, + ! 

 2  3    !  &

 "

*  '    !@   &

%   &

(, ! 9) + ' '  +, :

)

 2"

  

%  &

23,,7273-   



)  

P ,&   ?    +--*  



- @       #            

 "   #"  $# "  

()@

; #

#( @

; # )

    "  

  (     

 6# "        ) ()  )             6# "  ()  ) 

    @     # # #(   ( )

  "

  (  

6#  >  #   & 

& "(    #    "  #

*!+!

   (

 " #    #    # & (  

3       

 # A(( "& A"  "-*- ;3,-*!:

 & >  B +9@A *

#  & "  "+!9@A.+ >,& #(  +9@A::.

,   & (!-,@,++ >     #  #(     0  &      )     #  (     " " &     # 

  -*      9# $( 9 ;          #

&    (   

  C    # ( &

    () # #   A(( "D #E    9     >  ;""        #    "       

  /0 #(    @

  ;   #  

")   # ()0 F&   

 *-*+! 

 

 

#  #  &  %) )     *-*+!

 ),$ , %" (  (  " & #

 **!+!     $# "        **+!

()%"       89  /  &  ,  #"  & &

    "         C  

       

 

   

         $    ()   "   6#   )  #   &   "

  # "     C

 #   

()  # ,   &



 ,,   +9@A!* B( "& C  "     !9@A-  G#%    # B( "& C  "   !9@A.!+ :>;"" # #(  &  &     

#     -+0;   90 ;      #  ( "

*!/+!     *-*+!   "

    (

 ( "

 # 

# 0   )         #"2 C  #  -+0;  ;   ()# #   9D @, & # "     -** D E:

  

()  # >)&& ,     -9@A.!C# #  

()   # 9& # "    9@A.

#( &  &  # () & # ) 

# "    )    0 #             "  

      "   )  (      "    

  "    (

#   (

#"()#2  

. 3&  #    &#)"

 #" 

       #    (# 

( &<0 

 F&   **!+    2#  ()    & #       &  ,$  ,  8 9  %" DF20E - *-*+! ,  "     # "  .     .



 ()   & # ,$  ,  

-    %"

  

.DF20E *!+! &#

 * +!  ()           

**!+DF2E :

**+! %" 0 

.  

     89  /  &     

       , 

#"  &0 

: . --+! 

& #( "

*: +!

 ()   

   *-*+!DF20E !

#   

  (   # <DE5

     *-*+!    $# "      

**+!   # &        # ()0 *!+!7 DE  5          0  / 2 

   #7 + * -; -+; 9 ;    # <0 *9)    0 3   

()$  0



) #  (  "  -;  ; )   &         #"     

#



       #     &           #  # 0  "      # # 0,

3( 8 ' 8 3(3    '  '

 03  ) # 0  )

(    "  &  

  "##

 &( )   #  )

( (  ()    " 0      #     #          #" 0

 2   #   D )E #      ) # " &(  )  ' 0   #   "  0 

#  # 3  &     

   " 0   &     " "6# () )

 

  

#" ( #

 -+;

 #   

  /   -;   &    # &      #"    #



 #  # 0 3      &   # &    # 

# (#   

# 

(     -0;    ) &     # () 0 3    &  (#  ,  #"  & 

:(    #  # *!+! , 0 

:

& 6# #   () )     *-*+!

(# () ) $# "    **+!  # "   )   # *!+!>  "() 

  " & #

 * +!*+!

 , 

 "  ) 6#  #

 )"6# () (#() )     #

  "  #  &    & " #    # () 0   >  "  ()  #     ;     ,    

 "  # )    **+! & # ;    "

&     "

# $   "

  "  #       " 

 ( 

 ()G#%    # B( "4  #E   " # <0 ;

(     

 ( &      #  -0;  # )"

 "      &  

    "    0  ()   "

 &   

 ()& # ) &    #   " " %)  # "    &    

  & #  & 

# ( #    #  # 

 2  &   # &   #

   &  (#(#      #

 

 

 # 0&   3@,:-@  .. 3@,:-@ * :! &   

0 H "() & " #  )#  $#   #() #  6#       ($  

  "; ::

   <0 = -0; ( "

9# $(9 ;     # 6#    0 #

 & 

  & 

 () & # )6#  "  )  #  #= -*    #   

  & 

 -0; 9# $(90 ;# 

   

,  & "   ;3,. 9# $-+  C  " A ) "#       # $ ,&9# 

#  &    #

 &   #  # 0

 " 0   #3  

 2&    "  6#  

 

&   " 0 6#   0  # (  & # ()   & #() &  # "  )  #3   "( &  

C  " A #  -0 ; 9# $(90 ;; )& 



& (  ()C(  "AD)@ A#     ) C "&  

9@,:.

 

#    

 " "      # 0   & #  !0; 9# $(#)

@  # ; )(#  2     " 

 (    ""    "( 

 "

   0 # # " & 

  

@ C" # ;>  C) % 4  A ,$A#  4   #>  "4 

# #    ;3,.++ + 

 

  #  &  () @

  < =   #   

  #" 

-0; 9# $(90 ; ) (  )  &   # &  # "  )  #

H # H)&    "

  2 (#3  2   

  " H

 # ()& H3      #    

    

 &     #   (#     ("      # (   C )( (  &    )  "  "&   #= - 3               " )  #    ) "   " # "  ) 

#  "

        "  ()  #  "         # )          C    "  A  

,  & " 

D #E &  % $# "  $,&9# 

( #"  @

H %)$# "  $ ,4  @ 9 %     

,

A $,  &9# --3 (  # (#     9# $( 90 ;()  #  -0;

# 

        (  #      &   ()  & # ) 6#    & 

 &  #

   #      "  "

      -0; )  ( #& # ) &   #   

(        #) 

#    

  (    ( #

; ( #" ( 0    ( #

      -0 ; ()#  "      "    H    " B( "

  ) ) &  # #



  6# 

 

  "

#  #    

= & = #   -0 ; 9# $(90 ;"#   ( 

( 0 B( "       &

( " # 

 #"()#  "      #0  )

#(6# " 

     ) )   ) ) &  #

     &

3  # #  

 "#

   & #()    #   &   # 3 

  "

  ()H # H)@ A#  C  "4   ( &    "

H

 H3 #()#  " H   B(  "   ) & #  #  

  &

(# 

 & 00& 0      (  )         & "  3      

0  ()     

        # )    &  

       "     0 (  

6#



# 3       & #  & 

  # 

 &   (    #     " 0   "C B( " (  

  ()"  & # #) # &    0 H 

()#  " H

 &"

   ()  #

#    

 &



  0 H 3 )  

  (

#(()" "   "

  & 

 -* #



#   &  & "(        "  # #  

   " 0     & #       "    

-  " 

#  0  / 2  &

  #  )  

# ,;0-:.+0    > ",  & & 

 3  "

 -*  ;   #  # <0  > #    #" #  "

0 ;

      #  

#   "" 

 &

<0  0  " 0    

   "  #   

 "   - 0   " 0 

   #  & #"  #

#(  

 "     #3

  

" &  &  "6#

( &"  (  $# 

#  # 0 #     

    &

#   & #  

 "  &

  "  ) : 3   #    ; & #

 0      ( #   -*  ; &  &

 "

2

 "  " 

) 1 - 3 & ( & &   ) ( 

) (#

) )    #

&

 2     ( "  #9   6#  &)     &

#  ; (   "

  :          & #

   &   )&     #       

     -*      ;        #"

  6# (   

))  &   

  #" &2     & # )   & # @

 #(

 )"

      

        ##  " )   "  # ) 3 &    #

  #  " " #  &  #   #   ;   #     #

-: ;

 6#   #

   ( &    

 

# ()    (  

 &

"%&*"!) !

.

! '

& )) ) *  *'<  &&  &)%  **'@ %) *'% !

& 

 *   "

&

%)

 

 &

,4 ( !()

&%,4,5.

) &'  

 *&

,4

72 ( !()

&%,4,5 &



* 



 *)

%

 &

 

& ! '*  "* &

&" ;

, 1'  3(3,05   )  

  

     ) "## &" &( ) #(  &(  )   

"   )&" &(  )    #(   &(   )            ) 

&" 0

)"&   # 

   "  #  )   #  #    ""   )( #  ("&  #" )0 #   

  $#

 #      )     )       

#  (  # )") ( ##  #3 0 #( &3"

   6

 ) # , 1' *< 3(3  +,0" 0  ) 

(2 "#  # 

#

        0(   # 

  #)"&     ##

2  "

)  #    #)

    #    & &

  ""    

     " 0 #     0    #  # 

 "   ""         #  " ) 5  #      (  #) &

&

  ""    "

( 7, &*

 " 

 @ &"

)

  &)! 

)  ! %

& % 

 *  @

&&*"

& '

& 

'

 

-  ! 

  

& *&

&*

) &



*   8



 * )

 

     ( !  ()

&%  ,4,5%  

 &

  !

  '

7,, = &    "! 

 &) * )

 "  !%

 " &  ! & * & 

*&

!  '<% * %!) .

! '   '!" &

 '

 @

   ** ! & ) &'   "@) <  &%   **%)  % 

 &



)  ") !*  .





&' 

!" 

 

& *  

&





  & *

& "

 *

%

!  &

!  !"  **- &

 

%

'%'

"  *)<'   & *' ! *

*

"'

 &'

* ! & *& 

*

  77, < ) ? 

 *&

,4 ( !

()

&%,4,5% ) '

 ! !   

& &'

& 

''

  "%  '

&  &

    !& )  *   )

 -   & ! 

" !" .

 5  +, /  ! "

:

 #

 * %'

 .

  

 3 )

() ) &    (#   ( " "   

   #

       )

 

("  #   " #   )

# & (  " ()&  "& (  &      (  "    "     3 

#

      )

 

( #(   00 

 &(     #   "    #  

   !      ( "& "  # &    )   (    &  

   ( (  ()

#   = 75 <% * %&*"!) 

   &%   &%

&% *

&

&

,4 ( !()

&%,4,5%@" 

 **<  &%  ** &

& "* &   !



 & !  "

&%)

 

 &

,4%'

 

!" 

 75, = %

'

 "  



&" % 

  '  !"        

&"    !"  

  

/ **-    *)"%

' '



&

 &" * )

- .

 &

 "   

% &

  ( 

 2 +,  

 "

6

77!

% %%'

 '

! *  ' + 3  ( &0  "

 2  ()C H( # #  " 0   ()      

 )   

(   "

          &)     )

   #(   ; #"   3 ,#9 # (  ()

 0$  

0$   

(# 6#   #  # 

(     

    

)     $#   

#  & &   #(  #  3     ) () 00     &

0    < "&  )   &

0   '> 

( "& #() ;

#  #(  ( 

0$    

))   (   &

 # (&)  )  <        &%               

  '

!"  !")  



&" * = %  ** 

 &

& !  

*  @

&

&

,4 ( !()

&%,4,5.

@ "%   ** !  *  



  *  &"    

 %   * %  &"

   ! ' .

! '  *

8  &&& && 73, #  % 

  

 *&

& % ) * &  

 !' ) 



    "& '!*  ?&

   *   < 



% )  *

 & ) &' )

 "@) 

&

,4

72 ( !()

&%,4,5- & )! **&  

*& *)

 '

"  ! 737 < &&) &% 

) 

& !"  .

! '&

! &&

"% * !"

  ' - 

) 

&  - .



 =.

 !" -  * 

/ ** )   "%' &  7;

 &  & 

'! * "  & 

  *

)%&*  &"%  & "% 

&

%* "%

 & %  %!" &"

)&

%

  *< '  * &

&

&

 %

 



 @  & *&

&

%       ) 

  !& )  '

"  & )&  

*&  

4  53

 & &.

  (+!("

$!$) Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No