Suraj Bhan And ORS v. Niadri & ORS.
!"# $% & &'
() $* !$%$+%,-%) & &.
/0$(## $%1& &.
1 2 3 &
4 53 !" #
$ % &' # ( )% &
#( % & * ## % &' #+) % & *
#
%$%+" 4 53
, - & ))
.
% / ** &
** 0 1)
)
&
23,2,445%
!"
&6
%
% '
& **) % "% *
& !" - .
- -.
%!"
)
& 75,,,447%
!" !6
%
% & !"
/ **% 8
& " *
)
7
% 9&
/ ** & -.
' &)*
* )
% )
&
)
!
"
#$% # " & "
'
() "
*+!
, - -.
***/0 '
) " (
!
# &
# # 0 "
"#
()& &
, !.
***/0 "#&#
# ") " # 0 &
1 5 :
!
" ' ))
%
&
!) ' )
&)% '
" * '
&
& # # " #
) #) , - -.
***/0
#) &
$ ( 2# "
&
"
3 #" 4 ( # # ) & #
# ( # &
(# #) " "
# " #()
# # )&#
& )# 1 +
8 & "
!)
% .
*
&) &
"
% *&&
&
&
%*) * '
* &
5 # " 0 6# 7899 - 5
( 2 "
( #) 3
7899 5 " #()
#73
789 :
5 # 73
7 89 .
5 # ( )&# #
# $#
73
789 5 & 0 # 2
" 73
# 789 0; 5 6# 789
!
, ;
< '8 *)
*
* '
!
) "
& &% - .
& *
/ **- * !"
/ *
' ) !" = .
.
&
& *
% !* .
>
% & .
%)
&
& *
& * .
! '* & "% ' ) *
%'
& "
.
! *
9 %
.
*+" - )' * & ) "%
? !)
& !" & * & >, - *&
' * ) )
@
% & .
! '
'@
) ! .
* & "
&
%
** & * *
"
.
%
?
)& ?)
% &%
&
& *
& ! '%<
8 & ) & " & & B #" $# " # $#
"#) & ) &
# $# ) $#
9C
D & * &
%
'
*' ( !
+" %&
* !
&
3, ( !.
&%,4,D
&
,22.(. * & & !)
) ).
& *
!
"
## !!
$%%* ' !"
) & * & ' '
(
"
!!
%
"
'
)
"
'
'
*
) %
@
*'@ !*)
&" % *
.#& &
7;27. *727;%8
.
&
& ) *: 3,% 7A .
*.( & % ' &
,;,.(.- &
' * * *&
& !@ ) %
!
&
&) )8
? ,
7% '
& & ) ? &
&"
&
% ?& * &% !
& 4, - !) 2A2A,447
!" = &.
))
&
E?7
! &
.F(
,5,3, *,447!"
8%
'
' *!" +
.
7,23,445%&* & " *'
&
?
? ,- )'!@ ")
= &.
))
%'
%!"
72,7,44;% & )
&
.
& %<<
$ %
%&* & " *'
& )8
? 7 47
&
!"!
!' & '
! & ) ",44;
-
&) *
") &
% " )
&
!& "
%&&
"%
&))
- !) &
*
&)
& &"* &
&&
&& !" *& & & )
? & ,2 - &
' ) " !"
% '
* ' ""
* )<'&
''' ? & * &
!
%
&
'!
* ) '
& *
% !"
!
! !&
,2, = %'!)
! *
!"
&
&
G
< &
@ &%' &
&) ''
" * * &
% * %
! )
& ,, < )"
*
&*&
!)
& !" & * <
&)
!!
& &&
& ) ? &
&" &
& % " )!
&% "! ") & &
&
*& && )
&
"
,,, 7,23,445
? ,
!" .
.F(
,5,3, *,447 )
) ' )
= & .
))
% +" % * &
?)
9
)
* * &'
-
'
' 8% )
%
*) %'
"'
"'
/&
! & ' &
& )
*
,,7 - !@ 72,7,44;E? 7 !" = &.
))
&" & )')
.
& %<<
$ %
%* ) %&"
* &
9&)-
* = & .
))
9 % '
& ! & & &
%
&
0- & *
8)
%
! & && *
H
! )F ! ) H'
) '
)&
+% * %@ )
!
H'
& ' *&" *H
( .
*
*& &'
!
& +
I!+
.
- )
'
+
.
' ** * ) &* & " )
'
& &"
'
8 ! H'
& ! "
) %+%
'% )
H
! )
< &*"&
) *!
& %.* & " ) &"
' H
! )
8- H
( ) H "
-
* )"
! & !"
) %
% * % ! 8
* H' *&" *(
H <'
'
" .
& % <<
$
8 @ )
''
*
< &&) &% &)
.
& %<<
$ %
'
)"&
) *H
@
)
& &
)
& )
I'* " & ,7 &*?)
* )
&
'
" % )')
"* ) * )
*
8 .
@ "% &
% ")
%**&
G) %
/ ** ,7, < &&) &% @
!
) & )
* &
% "
)
!'
/ *
% )"
-8.
8+
&
) "% &
8
!
&)
& *
!
*)
%&&
"% )
,5
& * !)
=.
& )) ) *
&
<'
*& '
! !
* ) *
<
''
&
&
"
* !" .
&
!@
8 "B 9 ,5,
& * &
= .
* &
/ **
& " & !
* @
&
&
,4 &<
% ) J
%!
&" &
% ! ) !" **% !"
! ! )
*
* &"- * =.
&
&&& &
! *)"%
& !
! '
,3 .
"% & *
/ ** &
*
& !" .
! '*** ) "
"<'!) = .
& &"&
& !
*& ? !' **
& *
*& '
"&
** ) ) *
%
! &
" !" .
' & ,3, <'
! *
/ **
) .
! '*
&
&%
&
&
& '
"
&& & ' '
&
&
* '
,;
- =.
%*&
% &%
!)
& !" % &
*
,2 K,, )
) %'
&
0,2 ????
F, )
'* !* = &.
))
E *
&
*
&!" **'
!"+
I! +
.
&''
& "' *
& & ! *- +
I! +
.
"
& &
& "& *
" &
& & "
#
'
'!
!* )
**&
"' *
&
! *
&
& !" **
"' )
& ) *
<
& * & ! * ) "
& !
"
& ) *
* "!& ** '
&&! & * -
" * &
& ! '
*
L) *
!
'
& * * .
& - !
&
&
' ) !"
& " ) *
" &
' " ) *
'
,,< ' **
&
%<
**)
*
&
, **& ** '& 8 ' ) *% ) *
) &
*
*)
,>
& *
/ ** & &
' ' & !" .
*
+, - )
"
%'
'
& *&
**& * ) ) *
! '
)''? !"
& .
+,
(
"
/ 0%'
'
"& ) ! & * "?& ) *
= % (
+,
2"
/ % .
**) ?&
*
) @
* )
&
,>, :
! *
&) % ' &
.
! '
" !
/ **&
"&
& ) '* )"?& %
&
*&
&
!) )"
) " * )
)
,A
& * M *
%
%!) &
!' '
&%
&
)"! ) & )% ) ) * ) !" :**&- !@
* ) *
%&
)
&
,7, ( !
&%' !") ) &%
8 " * )**& &
"
&
,A,
!
"#$% & ' (() # % * %
% # # %
* % + 052 <*
"
&
( !
&
(
%'
'
&
8 !" :**&
&
,,D
@
" ! &
)
*
%
&
) & ) %&
&
@ ! N &N- &
@ &
*
) *
&
)
&
<<<
'
!
") ) & !& & )"
&
!* :**&+ &%
& &
" !
)
*
8 !"
:**&
&
,,D% '
*& &
%!&
&
* "* !" "- &
@ &
* '
) *
'
* ' * + &%)"!& ) *
'
'
% &
!
'
& ) '
5, - * *&
,7,
& N'
& ) N#
!"%'
' !
)
*)8
&
) !"
:**&% *&
,7,*
) *
&
*
'
& ) "& &
@ !8 &
*&
,7,%'
!
" ?& "'
8 ) & !& * & )"
& !" "!* :**& & * & &% &
&
&"
&
* ' )
&
"%
' &'
!) "'
* &
!8 !* & !& )"
*< )'"%'
&
8 !"
:**&
&
,,D%
'
& ) % '
'
)
) %*
*)
&!
&- * &
' ) *
'
!
" ?& " ) '
8 ! & & )"
& 57 * *& &&
& % .
& % &
& :**&
7;2;,4D7 & !&
!" **6
' )
*
&
*) )
*
&&
" :
"% N8 N' "
? *
&'
5,2;,4D7*
!&
N8 N:
5,2A,4D7% .
&
'
H
' %
"
?
!
%
N8 !%
'&& -
)! *8 !
!!
*
' )
-
! &&
N8 N%
:* & % 5,2A,4>7' &
!" **6
!"'" * !* .
& '
,7,2,4D7 ) )-
*.
& '* &
!" 6
!"*
&
!* .
))
-
% .
))
" "
5,2A,4D7 ,>,,,4D7% ) " "
'
* ?
*O
&&) &% & )
5,2A,4D7%'
.
&
'
)' &
*) !" .
&
,4,2,4D7- &
& %
&&) &%
"
**6
*&
* &%
2,,7,4D7%
*)
*
& <
% +
.
" )
*( !()
&
*
&%
)
& !" &
& 1 ,D < &*" !)
) % +
9!?.
@ &" *&
'
B8 9< &% *
' !" .
& %<<
$ %
522,,4D>-
* !* .
& %&
'
&& &' &! )
- ' ) !" .
&
7;2>,4DA - *% '
*
!* .
))
% '
& ' ) % * '
'
&
' "
& 6)!
* ",4DA/DD%& " *'
& )8 E?(D#
&
' &
7A,2,44A%!@ '
& '?& !"-8.
8 * ,D, " ) @
8&%
! .
))
% )
&
! &
& %
)
! & 6)!
* ",4DA/DD<% * % &
% & !' ' " ) &
'
!" +
9!?.
/ ** +, /
3 .
@ "%) & !& '
'
,D7 - .
! '%
'% * & &&*&
"
/ ** &
"& '
'
) *?&
%*
%
* &< '% &)
*)
% * ) ! '& '
% **
%
*
&- & ! &
" !" .
4 (
+, + !
2"
$0
%
' !@ " 5 )
2 +, / 3
2"
$6 77!6 % < ,2 *
) %
! && &"& * ' *
##( # 4 (
+, + !
"
1,$0 8
# "
-* ; # # <0 = > # #" # "
0 ;
# # ""
&
0 0 " 0
" #
"
- 0 " 0
# & #" # #(
" #3
" & & " 6# ( &" ( $# # # 0 #
& # & #
" &
" ) : 3 # ; &
# 0 (
# -* ; & &
"2
" "
) = ,4 -
& !" .
4 (
+, + !
2 3 ! &
"
* ' !@ &
% &
(, ! 9) + ' ' +, :
)
2"
% &
23,,7273-
)
P ,& ? +--*
- @ #
" #" $# "
()@
; #
#( @
; # )
"
(
6# " ) () ) 6# " () )
@ # # #( ( )
"
(
6# > # &
& "( # " #
*!+!
(
" # # # & (
3
# A(( "& A" "-*- ;3,-*!:
& > B +9@A *
# & " "+!9@A.+ >,& #( +9@A::.
, & (!-,@,++ > # #( 0 & ) # ( " " & #
-* 9# $( 9 ; #
& (
C # ( &
() # # A(( "D #E 9 > ;"" # "
/0 #( @
; #
") # ()0 F&
*-*+!
# # & %) ) *-*+!
),$ , %" ( ( " & #
**!+! $# " **+!
()%" 89 / & , #" & &
" C
$ () " 6# ) # & "
# " C
#
() # , &
,, +9@A!* B( "& C " !9@A- G#% # B( "& C " !9@A.!+ :>;"" # #( & &
# -+0; 90 ; # ( "
*!/+! *-*+! "
(
( "
#
# 0 ) #"2 C # -+0; ; ()# # 9D @, & # " -** D E:
() # >)&& , -9@A.!C# #
() # 9& # " 9@A.
#( & & # () & # )
# " ) 0 # "
" ) ( "
" (
# (
#"()#2
. 3& # &#)"
#"
# (#
( &<0
F& **!+ 2# () & # & ,$ , 8 9 %" DF20E - *-*+! , " # " . .
() & # ,$ ,
- %"
.DF20E *!+! &#
* +! ()
**!+DF2E :
**+! %" 0
.
89 / &
,
#" &0
: . --+!
& #( "
*: +!
()
*-*+!DF20E !
#
( # <DE5
*-*+! $# "
**+! # & # ()0 *!+!7 DE 5 0 / 2
#7 + * -; -+; 9 ; # <0 *9) 0 3
()$ 0
) # ( " -; ; ) & #"
#
# & # # 0 " # # 0,
3( 8 ' 8 3(3 ' '
03 ) # 0 )
( " &
"##
&( ) # )
( ( () " 0 # # #" 0
2 # D )E # ) # " &( ) ' 0 # " 0
# # 3 &
" 0 & " "6# () )
#" ( #
-+;
#
/ -; & # & #" #
# # 0 3 & # & #
# (#
#
( -0; ) & # () 0 3 & (# , #" &
:( # # *!+! , 0
:
& 6# # () ) *-*+!
(# () ) $# " **+! # " ) # *!+!> "()
" & #
* +!*+!
,
" ) 6# #
)"6# () (#() ) #
" # & & " # # () 0 > " () # ; ,
" # ) **+! & # ; "
& "
# $ "
" # "
(
()G#% # B( "4 #E " # <0 ;
(
( & # -0; # )"
" &
" 0 () "
&
()& # ) & # " " %) # " &
& # &
# ( # # #
2 & # & #
& (#(# #
# 0& 3@,:-@ .. 3@,:-@ * :! &
0 H "() & " # )# $# #() # 6# ($
"; ::
<0 = -0; ( "
9# $(9 ; # 6# 0 #
&
&
() & # )6# " ) # #= -* #
&
-0; 9# $(90 ;#
, & " ;3,. 9# $-+ C " A ) "# # $ ,&9#
# & #
& # # 0
" 0 #3
2& " 6#
& " 0 6# 0 # ( & # () & #() & # " ) #3 "( &
C " A # -0 ; 9# $(90 ;; )&
& ( ()C( "AD)@ A# ) C "&
9@,:.
#
" " # 0 & # !0; 9# $(#)
@ # ; )(# 2 "
( "" "(
"
0 # # " &
@ C" # ;> C) % 4 A ,$A# 4 #> "4
# # ;3,.++ +
# & () @
< = #
#"
-0; 9# $(90 ; ) ( ) & # & # " ) #
H # H)& "
2 (#3 2
" H
# ()& H3 #
& # (# (" # ( C )( ( & ) " "& #= - 3 " ) # ) " " # " )
# "
" () # " # ) C " A
, & "
D #E & % $# " $,&9#
( #" @
H %)$# " $ ,4 @ 9 %
,
A $, &9# --3 ( # (# 9# $( 90 ;() # -0;
#
( # & () & # ) 6# &
& #
# " "
-0; ) ( #& # ) & #
( #)
#
( ( #
; ( #" ( 0 ( #
-0 ; ()# " " H " B( "
) ) & # #
6#
"
# #
= & = # -0 ; 9# $(90 ;"# (
( 0 B( " &
( " #
#"()# " #0 )
#(6# "
) ) ) ) & #
&
3 # #
"#
& #() # & # 3
"
()H # H)@ A# C "4 ( & "
H
H3 #()# " H B( " ) & # #
&
(#
& 00& 0 ( ) & " 3
0 ()
# ) &
" 0 (
6#
# 3 & # &
#
& ( # " 0 "C B( " (
()" & # #) # & 0 H
()# " H
&"
() #
#
&
0 H 3 )
(
#(()" " "
&
-* #
# & & "( " # #
" 0 & # "
- "
# 0 / 2 &
# )
# ,;0-:.+0 > ", & &
3 "
-* ; # # <0 > # #" # "
0 ;
#
# ""
&
<0 0 " 0
" #
" - 0 " 0
# & #" #
#(
" #3
" & & "6#
( &" ( $#
# # 0 #
&
# & #
" &
" ) : 3 # ; & #
0 ( # -* ; & &
"
2
" "
) 1 - 3 & ( & & ) (
) (#
) ) #
&
2 ( " #9 6# &) &
# ; ( "
: & #
& )& #
-* ; #"
6# (
)) &
#" &2 & # ) & # @
#(
)"
## " ) " # ) 3 & #
# " " # & # # ; # #
-: ;
6# #
( &
# () (
&
"%&*"!) !
.
! '
& )) ) * *'< && &)% **'@ %) *'% !
&
* "
&
%)
&
,4 ( !()
&%,4,5.
) &'
*&
,4
72 ( !()
&%,4,5 &
*
*)
%
&
& ! '* "* &
&" ;
, 1' 3(3,05 )
) "## &" &( ) #( &( )
" )&" &( ) #( &( ) )
&" 0
)"& #
" # ) # # "" )( # ("& #" )0 #
$#
# ) )
# ( # )") ( ## #3 0 #( &3"
6
) # , 1' *< 3(3 +,0" 0 )
(2 "# #
#
0( #
#)"& ##
2 "
) # #)
# & &
""
" 0 # 0 # #
" "" # " ) 5 # ( #) &
&
"" "
( 7, &*
"
@ &"
)
&)!
) ! %
& %
* @
&&*"
& '
&
'
- !
& *&
&*
) &
* 8
* )
( ! ()
&% ,4,5%
&
!
'
7,, = & "!
&) * )
" !%
" & ! & * &
*&
! '<% * %!) .
! ' '!" &
'
@
** ! & ) &' "@) < &% **%) %
&
) ") !* .
&'
!"
& *
&
& *
& "
*
%
! &
! !" **- &
%
'%'
" *)<' & *' ! *
*
"'
&'
* ! & *&
*
77, < ) ?
*&
,4 ( !
()
&%,4,5% ) '
! !
& &'
&
''
"% '
& &
!& ) * )
- & !
" !" .
5 +, / ! "
:
#
* %'
.
3 )
() ) & (# ( " "
#
)
(" # " # )
# & ( " ()& "& ( & ( " " 3
#
)
( #( 00
&( # " #
! ( "& " # & ) ( &
( ( ()
# = 75 <% * %&*"!)
&% &%
&% *
&
&
,4 ( !()
&%,4,5%@"
**< &% ** &
& "* & !
& ! "
&%)
&
,4%'
!"
75, = %
'
"
&" %
' !"
&" !"
/ **- *)"%
' '
&
&" * )
- .
&
"
% &
(
2 +,
"
6
77!
% %%'
'
! * ' + 3 ( &0 "
2 ()C H( # # " 0 ()
)
( "
&) )
#( ; #" 3 ,#9 # ( ()
0$
0$
(# 6# # #
(
) $#
# & & #( # 3 ) () 00 &
0 < "& ) &
0 '>
( "& #() ;
# #( (
0$
)) ( &
# (&) ) < &%
'
!" !")
&" * = % **
&
& !
* @
&
&
,4 ( !()
&%,4,5.
@ "% ** ! *
* &"
% * % &"
! ' .
! ' *
8 &&& && 73, # %
*&
& % ) * &
!' )
"& '!* ?&
* <
% ) *
& ) &' )
"@)
&
,4
72 ( !()
&%,4,5- & )! **&
*& *)
'
" ! 737 < &&) &%
)
& !" .
! '&
! &&
"% * !"
' -
)
& - .
=.
!" - *
/ ** ) "%' & 7;
& &
'! * " &
*
)%&* &"% & "%
&
%* "%
& % %!" &"
)&
%
*< ' * &
&
&
%
@ & *&
&
% )
!& ) '
" & )&
*&
4 53
& &.
(+!("
$!$) Whether reasoned / speaking?
Yes / No Whether reportable?
Yes / No