Navneet Malhotra And ANR. v. M/S Bibby Financial Services India Pvt. Ltd.
!"##$#
!"!!#$"
" " "
" %&
' (
$# %& %" &'% ((
() *
) * +,-+.&/0++& #+1
2+ 3+.&/0+ 4 2%
5220+ + 1 2+ 3+.6.+ 7++ (
() *
+, '- 0522% 4 3+0332
&+& '
.%+
&572,+ &9 &0+,+: +$
,+
.
:+.-2 572%
- &0,+ &+ 0,+3&%
.
+&.0 2 .
- & &.4 2 : +4+ $". 0'42".+,0 +
2+<.
06
:
+3.2 %.522% +3+5,4 033 5: & &2 !22+5/+ % +7& 5;
2&.+&. + &
2,+ &0 ,+%%+ :4 2%
53 .
2+2 :2 3+,3%,+5+ : ='4
(,&+
> !557$+0+, /0 "&+/& + 2!?
$+0 7 /+3&+&2
@.0 :2 +440
0( 42 :+5,"
3 0.2+ 03%,,7 3+&.+ + 403% 2+ 5 &&.+02 .4 + ,33+&+3:
200 &.+&.%
+0-2 .
2 +00
& +& +0;
& 0%7 4 2 +5/ &+&
4,&&+72
.+&. +< &.+&.
% & 0&2 +4 >& ?7 ,4 03%,++
53 2+2 3+ 2+ 5 ,&5-522%+
+& 2 03%,++ 2+ 0/& 2 ,3 +3 2 3+ ,4 03%,++2+ +& 2+ 22+
0 4 3203%,++-2& +- 2% 3+ +344 03%,++5 && 2 440 +344 03%,++ && "/-42 +344 03%,++.2 3+ +& 03% && +& & % & 4 00
& +& +0;
& 4 2 440
( " 0@ ( /2 :2+4 3+4203%,+.2 -+
34+7%
+,+%%+ +0.205:3+&572 +00
&54 2,+ &:00 &-/ . 02 ,+ & +, +: + 00 &. &
: 2 %&07 4 2 03%,+.2+&3+&+ 03% &?
.&0,+ :2 %
0,+3&44& B.2 244042 +5/ :3+0 ,,
// 2 :2.2+%% % +0
4
2+00
&-+ .+2342+5/ 4+0;
+,5:
(
&&.3+<+354 2,+ &:00 &.
0+,,2+5/ .+ 203%,+ &03%,,7 3+& -/ .2+5/3-+ 23+& 2 + 4 3+<:2+5/3. +7
5: & &2 .+%%+
5034 && %24+0 2+%
+042 &&?
.2 -+ & 03+&2 00 &. +$" 0 ' 4 2 ". +:+ 2 +00
& 2 . ,7 % 2 00,
4 +,. %2+5/440.+&. %+/ &04 +0;
+,503: &&. 2 :3+0+,,:+ 0+& 2 - ,&503 & = 2 + % + +5/ +&. < ;
?
-/ .54 % 0&:;
22+5/ . ,/+5+ 3&.2+% 2 .2,+ &:.+
/+,& 57 ?
C. 2+& /& % 0
2 %
+, +%%+ +054 23.42+00
&.2 :223&4
+0 +&. ?0 4 5+,+5, -+
+ . % 23. 5 2 5+,+5, -+
+ 3+& ?0 & 2 . 2 -+ ,& 00, & 2+ 2 +00
& 5
33& 2 :2
+0 4 + 0,+3+0 C -/ . 7 00, && 2+ 0 2 +00
&.
&:+4+ 4, :+ +.-202 &21
&0 42
.2 . 0- ,&5&440 , /. %23.2 0,+3+0+ &+ 73+ ,7.2,+ & &:% 0&&%,+0 ,+0. %. 0
BAB42 . +&. +
02 % 0&& 4 2 % : 4 2
0,+3+0+&+,7- %+% B ' 2 +5/ 50+3 03%,& -2. +&. 2 0,+3+050+3% &&+,7- %+% B.+&.:/ 2 +00
&. 0 ( &+7 ,+% : 4 3 2 % : 4 2 0,+3+ 0 + &+,7 - %+% . 0+
: 2
+%%+ +0.54 2,+ &:.2 %.2% 0&& &0,+ 2% %
0,+3&%
/ .2+, & 0&2++$"+:+ 2+00
&.4 2
033:+ 440. 0'".5 : &.+2%,0 + 00 &
2 +5/
& 3& 57 2 ,+ & 9 &0+, +: +.2+
,&+:
5 +025:0+
&2 ,/+ 3+&+ 03% & 0
A BAB 4 2 . % /
-2 4503? +0&2 +4
!
!"
#!
$
$
%
$
=
& '
% !
()
%
&*!
&*( &+( &+, &-!
&.!
&.& &.( &./
&.+ &., &.- &..
(** (*!
(&+ ((.
(/.
(+* 0
(/ -+*
/"
% !&
% (
% 1
5 0A B4 0
.0330 -2+ 3+&+ 7 / . +&. 2 1 2+ +,, 2 0
35&& 0,+
AB 2 4. 503 01,7 03%,& -2 -/ .+%%+ ,703%,+0 3+&23+&+35&& 0,+
AB4 5 0A B4 0
.5 72 ,+ +,+: +% 0&&%,+0 ,+0. %.0,+
AB4
5 0 4 0
2+5/%,+0& ,+0 %0,+
AB4
5 0 B4 0
.- ,&5++% ,+0.,742,+ & +,+: +00 &.2+&+, 3&2+%% % 3% 03%,+0. /D+/D. 2 3+&+ 35&& 0,+
AB 4 0 A B 4 0
4 2 " 2 - & . ,7 4 03%,+0;
+
5 0.A BAB.4 0
42 .-+
+, 3+&.2 %.
5 0A B0,+
AB.+.+&&+,2
C / .4 2 %
% .3+72+/5 3 ,+
,7
2 +,:-2.205030+%+,D&572,+ &: 00 &.2 - 0. 2 ,+ & +, +: + 00 &. -2 3:23% +/03%,+02% 3% 73+&+0+
&
5 0 AB4 0
42 . 0&&
+:2-+7& +- ,+0 %0,+
AB4 5 0A B4 0
42 .2 .2 +:
5 +020+
&2 3+&+4
5 0A BAB4 0
42 .-2 + .
03%,+0-+ 0
7.+&.+, 2 :203%,+040,+
AB4
5 0A B0 ,&2+/53+&.5 +&,7.03%,+0 2 -+ 53+&.,7+&& 3 ,+
,7+,:-2 03%,+05:3&2% 3% 73+&+ &
0 A BAB 4 0
. 2 - . +& &%&,72 4 3 -/ .2,7 + -2022+ 53&572 ,+ & +: +. &%&,7 3 03%,+0 0
BAB42 35&&24+0 3.2+2%
&:+4+ 4, :+ +. &21
&042
.5 7-22%
- +4 :,+&.2 %.
-22 :22+: 42% 0
/:+:0742
.
-2-2 1
&0.2%
- +2 ,/+3.
20 &:.202 ,/+ /02 :2 &+ 73&0 ,& 2+/ 5 0+
& % 23 " ,. -2 2 ,+ & +, +: +0 ,&2+/7% 0&&.% ,7: %0,+
AB 0+
&
5 0A B4 0
.303%,+0
' 0,+
AB4
5 0A B4 0
. %0+,,7-2 :/2-& % 5,072% 5,0+0. %. 503:
&&+,7- %+%
.- ,&5 :-22<-,&:4+ ,+ : -+24%% ,+. & :%25+4+,3. %23.
4 2 ,, 0 0 4 33 3+ 5: 0+
& 2
% +42%
2 .
-+ 5+/&&.
2+5: +:2-+7+&%&.+&.+
022+&%42
A
+B2 :223+<:423% :& 3+< .
&&-2+/04+ 5
( 2/ 7%
% 40,+
AB4
5 0A B? :
%+ +,74 30,+
AB4
5 0A B. 2+.,7-22 3 &440 , +.-22 - 2 :2+7
5:3+&0,+
AB4
5 0A B4
.2 ,/+
% - ,&503 /&.2 %.2+&%42+5/ 3+&
- ,&5/+,&.+&.2+-23+&+3 2 :24 ,. +&. 1 &0
3+ . %0+,,7 +/ + 33 &+3+:5:0+
&2 % +42+00
&00 &.:/ 2% :42 % 5,0+0+&+,7- %+% $ 2 +5/5 +025:0+
&2% 3% 73+&+5 0,+
AB4
5 0A B4 0
.2 & 0:2 : 4 2 % 5,0+ 0. 2 &+,7 - %+% . 20 503 0
+5,53+&.-2+:
+%%,0+43&.
+&.+, +1 &0+,,7 - 3+ $ 2+5/ +& + .23% :& 0+
& ?
;
2&.+&. + &.+&.20 2 -2 & 0 3+&2 .4 : +4+$"+:+ 2%
%
. 0'".+ +, ;
2&.+&. + &.
-220 440.2+2$"A
+B0+:+440
0'".+, 503 +3+5,4 5:;
2&.+&.
;
2&+00 &:,7 ,(
() *
- ##$# <+/ :2 ) 2 # 324
)
# 324