← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1256/1992allowed

P.S.E.B. v. M/S Sachdeva

2024-07-24Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl7 pages



   

  

  

 

 !  "#$%  &'( *(+ " ' ,,'' -(

.

/0 

 ''

1( / %

 , 

 

 !  "#$%  &'( *(+ " ' ,,'' -(

/2 3#4( /0

 ,

      "( 

( 5#((  1/ / 0

6 %/ ( 78 5#,+ 0

( 2 /4 /$+ 0 ,

6 %/

    "(  (( ''

, : 1#'(  ,,'

"#$%  &'( *(+ " '

 ;

# 8  <



;

# 8  <  7:

4()

$# ( 

,(  ,,''"#$%  &'( *( (  :(2 (( 8!

:(2 (( 8!

''

,(4

,'  

: ,'  

,

,(  

 .

/0



 ''( 1( / %+ 7/



(  4( ( /2 3#4( /0

;/4 =' */

  (  44  <  <!

(

0#( ,'   .( ,

,(  ,,''. :

(( ( :(2 (( ' 8!

! > 7:

%( ;

,,'

8<> ;

,,'

8< ,(  ,,'' "#$%  &'( *(+ " ' %(

 44    

,# /

%/

/#  ''

#

/

') , 

/ / "#$%  &'( *( @ 4,A

/( :

 '1'

0'

#/(

4 11( 0 1

4+ 

,(  : 1#'(  ,,'

 =( # '

%/

#%4  44  (0





/( ,  4(  (0

(4 %2

#%4 

/ 2



(

>

 "#$%  &'( *(

*#



 

( (((

@/   A :/(

/

+

/ (,'

"#$%  &'( *(

;# *#



( (((

@/ A /

(

#(/(

#%4  ('0

,(0 

,(#(

, ) 4, (''

#/( :/ :

(B# ( 0



 

 !

( C#(

* ,,

#(/(

#%4 

4#/ '

 !+ / 10( ,(#(

( ;#(

#%4  0  1' */

'    

     (,(



   !"#  $%% :/ / /

(  2



(  



0 (4')

( ('0

/ (  !

/#

#%4 

#() 1/

2 :)

#'

4( ;#(  =( # '

, ,'  

#%4  ( / ((') (

,'  

( 

4( ( #

#(/(

 0



'#  !

'1 C#(

*

(+ / 

%( :#' @ 4,A D:0(+  /

(  

#'

,# ! 7/

/( '( # '

,(

,(# ,,( %2 < 7/ /+ ' (') #, '(  1' E#1

 



#,( 4 ((  

/'

@ 4,A 1(#

/# ) '1'

0'

#/( ) 7/ ,( 0 ,( ,

(,(# %':

 







 



         !"#$ $%&

''(

) *+ , -  - . 

%

 '/ '0 +

    +

 





/  

/ /

+  2

   3 %    4+   

 

      "&'    ( )'  05& /  !

2 1 

 



     2 

        +  



  + 

/

 2

6  7 %  7 , 7+





7    

+  +

2 2

       +  



  + 

 /

  2 

 

 

 



#7

 1 , 7+

2

   +

/   3   

/ / * / 9





+   2 2    

 

1  7 7+

& *  



   & ! +   * ,+) ( ) &-

 

& & &   ( #'

#((

&##

  ,

 %  % *, 

&/ 

 -    - /

 / 

  :  6

 $% -  ;:( ; < 



 /1 + 1 

 



 



7 

 7

 1/ +

2   %



  &



  / 1  

  #   

    

 7     7

< +  / =

,#

,( 

)(  <

+

( '0 ,(

(,(# %':

&.>$#?<>?   '#    (     .$/ 0    12*

'  0   +  ( + + +'3) 



# +-( !

& &'  

  2

 %

 2

+ @3A 2  :  2



 @A#  ;!@$  2 ;!ABC  

 

/    7  +    4'3)    

 "&'  (5'

('  /6 

   7  2    D88888 "' .'

 +

2 2

   +22



 + 

E  !

'#

 ( 5+#5 & '



 7   2      # 8

F9 

 & /   "0 7   ' (8 9'

) ((



@A

   2



  %  

   

7  @A

 +

    %  

   E



 @1A

     2 + /    7 

  22     ( !

&  ((

         5+# 5 & '

+    &

 &:;

@A

 @A6 2/

 @A6 2#  22

@1A6 2#

@1A



//

@1A

 

  @1A8  1 /

 ":   # '

     !    <'

;= >    

&'      )  ( !    +   # *   "&'   1 888888=  

( C#(

* /

(  :/

' ,(#

:#'

/:

/) ,

#,(

('

( ((   ! (0(+ ,(#( / 10(

,( (



#

%/' *(

,(0 

 !

( C#(

* 7/

( 4#/ '

 !



,,( (4 ,( 0 ,( ;#(+ ('0 ,( /

(,(# %0 

(  ':

#() 1/ /#

#) $#  #,

!

1/

,(

( (#'')

( ('0 

': 6

 + #  '#(

( ('0 1/ /0 # $#  /

2 :) 7/

4,#1

#(

(4

''1'

,(0(

,

/# 2



( ('0  3,

:

%0 

(#4  %/ 1#'(  ,,'

( ,(') '': 44     ,





(4 %2 (

( 4(

( ':

  ;

,,'

<> < ( /

C, # ')

,

%' >

4 '(

,  4(

4  %

%(

:''

4(

:#' , %/ ,(

(

''

,'

( 0 '%' /4 %/

:#'

(  

( ':  ''

,

''#

,,'



)+

/''



,

:

%0 (( !"!

 %  

#$%&$%'()%*+,-./'%*(0-%12 %(/0 #$%&$%''%)0'&*34%2 %(/0