Harpartap Rai Puri &ORS v. State Of Punjab


  

 
  
 




  

  !!"#$#%&'



  

              

        



  &
 ()*  + *++ 
,)









   ! "  

 "##!  "   

 $%!"! %





 ++ 
,)- ./  &'(
)"        " !  * "   +   , "  -.-/'//-   * " !

  01"  2     '3/1"" $ $   "     "   2   4!   )!"  5" !  67 )" + "# " $  " !  " " " $  
'

8.

13-9:*# "  $   2  *" $ &;(
)" ## * #"  " <'   #" =>' !      " #  " " !  5 $ +  =#  #!""" #"< &<'( !" ! " 5   6  $ "  "  ! " #  7$ $! $*!7!! "$  $"! #$ * "  " !   " !  $*  %  "  #" & <;(   %$  !"""!" # $>!" " !$ $++$! "# ""





!   !     "  $ !   # "    =""#"&=>.8(! $ "    "   $6:+)"       & <0(  #    $  *  " "5 &=>' ;(!# #
'3--9:!  7      *    !   "  <'" #"< !"""  "$  -'-;'/38 ""!++"!  7 " ""!""! "

!! " #! """*! 7!" "$"" ! """"*""# $ * # """$ " " ""!  " 7"    &.(
   "" "" "  !  
 "# ! 7     "!    " $  ?  "

  $  "   "     
'3--9:" 7    "" $ !     # !" " "     * "   +     " " " "     " !  * "   +    $  " "   +       $  #"    &1(
)"  !  2         '/9;-';'/3. !"*.8 07'$ #5" !17/ $ #  67 .@ '7'-$ ! 2 "    # 4!  )!" 





)" ! "  $   $ 
1 0- ---9:  "     
;7"  #"  #)"   $   "  *        " ! A4''1;'/3/ 

 

 &0(
?"     '3"  2      '3/1  !"  #!  " ," 4'8;9;   #  '- "     1 $  7  "  " "!" "!   *"   "  #""    " " '# #"5" !"" !$'   7 ! " $$! "  " " " 7  ""!$++  #  *  "  " # ++   #         "  7  " " !      "     )"     # !   ! "   *   > ""%?""

 '-B>/B#"! ! " *      7  ?   $ "  " !     $"*   "   
'3--9: )"  7     " "   !  " "  *  

            "!# " )"$"*  $! 
;;0-9: *$""   $$""" "  "  2     " +  "  7   ! "              * "  +   !  * "  $ + !"  > #"$7 9 "   





&8(
)""!""   ""! 6:+!$$ $"!  7)"  $ !"" " <5$" "" " $ "#   #  &@(
  #" <'  " "   $ " <5 5$  C   =#   " .- * >      5 $ +  =#  # '/0."  >    "     $    "   #  "   " $   # "   =>' )"  "! " "  !      #  !

   $  # 8 "     $  #  1 "  )" $    #    '- "  1 $'7  "" ?  "!!   $ $ * $ 6 #  "   #  " "  )"       #       ! *  #*  $
0 0@ --.9:!     )""#""!""!!  * 7*$ $"   $ 6:+)"-.

8.

13-9:

 # "$"  $ &3(
?      "   $  "  <; %  "  #"""  $$"   "" "* '/@1! "   ! "" $ <1  #"6"  $ " "#"&=>.0(!7*" $ &/(
)" !    " $  $  " "   ""!  "*'/@;""!





#        
'3--9: =>3  '' ! "       "    )"   " " !   !" "" =>';'@""" 
10---
18---"   "" "*'/@;    " "    " " ! 6:+ "  !$  ! &'-(
?  " #"< <'5 6  " "   #     !  ! 6 + 2  *     $$  !# "!"  #       ! $  $ $  $   $  #++ !" " $ ":    4 !

""  $" $    "   !! " D 7?!"! ++!$6!" "$ 7 "!  7 "? "!""!"" ! !" #!

!" # 7 "!$* #"  #"  * ""   * "#"  #!'-9'0*)"!    "  7  "        " $  # " "#" "  *  ! $$  =>;.  ! #"!" 6 7"  "   "           $  " !" "     ""#"=>.=>0 &''(
$  <'' 5   #" "     "   # !" "      =>;1   * "   " " !





  " "   $ *  $  <'. +"$  " "  =>;0 &';(
 "  ! "!"" +  !    "        # "  $  " !  " $ $    !"  " # " =>'  *)" :  



          
 
           



  

  !

"

  # !# $
    

  
   

 %& #  '
 %()*"

%%++', --

!

-

 .

 


  

 / 
 
   -
  

. .# 


 0 1 .

 "

      2 "  

#  .
    %+ 
 3 

. %

 
56  - 67 

.7  7

 84

7  7

   " 

"# 
 5'

 
5 

 

  91 :;1 ! 

 "

 

 #  "   .



"#

 -

 


 % 9.  -: 
 
   '.

4 < / 1   #: -
7 5 

0 =  :

 >2 - ? ;@  -

>0  -  9  ;@  AAAAA

 3 '  "

 : 9-


; $
;%

B
 0&C$*3B>/B+*& ;%/#   

;7 
8*

%+
 0&C$3+C>%3++ 8%&#  7

:   

87 

.<4

 0&C$3+C !)//%/ & 



 "

 : 11'82@?'9

D-

61   B .   "

 : %++#  '  


 "

 $ 

 

 
 "

        !




 1 .#"  
   ! 


  *'  


  "

 $ 

 

 
 
 -"# 

-  

 #1  
  
 

     

E

   2      


  

  %?    . .



   #. 
  /

=@  6  





07

8
56  -
 !

-

.   

-

" D

 

 

. 37  7

8@  EE=

6 E. 

   

. &? 

#8 .
 B

#8 # *   

#8
 !

 )

#8
%

B
 !

-



 

 

*

%+-

 -



' 
-

 #    (7   8E.   -

-

- %+'8

 %%3C0F$0&C)F>3+(%(3 9-
0&C)C$B*CBF

-%

B   *

%+   
0&C)C$3BC(F %%,D !    : 1 " 

  .   

  . 2 -      !#            

 -  .D 



"       

    

  " 

 ,   - " & $

 

 

 9   /C

 /C&F / 

-               0* 

61 "

         " !    /++++5;
 . 

 





  ..  !  .
  %/1

 !    :G 

 -

 



2

E  2' ' %06 

:9-


%%3C0F$0&C)F>3+(%C(3F-
0&C)F$B*CBF  


: >/3/+C+)F 
0&C)F$3BC$(F >%B*(C+/F E17E91GE196G927@

  

3+(%C(3F  %/&5;> &%%3(/;&+ 9-


0&C)F$B*CBF>/3/+  %/&5;>  0+/&%+++  


0&C)F$3BC(F>%B*(+/ %/&5;> /+()**++

'  6 7

 &%/0)*++ E17E91GE19717@ 9-


 B*CBB$%0F$%(F$/>/(&3F >  3&%C3F 0&C)F$%0F$%(F$/>%&B    


0&C)F$3BC(F >)&& > )&&C+F 9- 



   717@ %++5;3&%3   3&%3+;++   



   717@ %++5;)&& )&&++;++

=  %0+B3+++

  E   

6 7

<7  7



E >  'H=>1

   B30+/*++





2
 

%I
#  

%&# !  /(&0**;%&I1

   330+B++ 2
 

%I
#9- 

%/# !  03*B&+%/I

  3%*%);++

 2
 

)B+/3;++

 9

!   

2
 

B30+/*++8)B+/3++H

&&*++0++

E 

2 



 AA


 $%BF$%0F >0B*&F 30C$%BF$%0F >&+*(C++>&33BC&C   %)+5;
%++ &33B++ 

 ?

2

 
9 %

B &(F$*BF $

  0B++++  #9      
%

%+ %+C$)0F1
 )0++++

 E  &&*++0++ 'H=HEH2H H7H6H

 

 
 2 . 

 

< /


5

'1''96'22' F &'.(
)" + "

 $$ # #   "    2  $         "    ! !#*    "  !  * !"   " $  $ "  "   "  7   "  $          %  "          " #  !     
'

8.

13-9: 
0 0@ --.9:!7 "$7 "    "   #$
 

    

 !" " ! !   !    "




    #$$#   #?"    !"#$   " ! !  !7   
.

8- ;1'9:  "  !      "   
'

/8 @8' !" " !      "$





  #*  "   !    " " "    " $
'

/8 @8'9:#! " *   ' !!

  ++%012/#

304!