High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1304/1992dismissed

M/S Harbans Lal Des Raj v. M/S Gian Chand Raj Kumar

2018-09-27Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages

!"##$%&%'(#)"#*+#, -. / 0&!,+!'&1!2#& !3.!'!!'4%. 5!67!,!"5,865!,+!'&1!2 )!,"'#,!'42#6!25#%,&#& !3)!,"'#, ))#22!'"& 9#,&8& 0&%!'5!'4 !3:8*!,.!'4%. 5!67!,! "5#,& #&)'4#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%

,#&#'"( #*"5#)!,"%#& ;;;;; *)+%,' ))#22!'"<)2!%'"%%&%' #682!,#$'4))#!2!6!%'&""5# 3846*#'" !'4 4#$,## 4!"#4 = "5# 17#, ))#22!"# 8,".

75#,#+>"5#&8%",,#$?#,> &..</ 4%&*%&&#4+>"5#",%!2 8,"?%4#3846*#'"!'44#$,##4!"#4-//+#%'6+!,,#4+>2!7 2%*%"!"%'. 5!& )!,"2> +##' 4#$,##4 , ! &8* 7%"5 ),),"%'!"#$&"&!'4%'"#,#&"@ A)#,!''8*,*"5#4!"#"5#&8%"

"%22,#!2%&!"%'

2!%'"%%'&"%"8"#4"5#&8%",,#$?#,> &..</ !& ),%'$%)!2 !'4%'"#,#&" "5#,#''"5#),#*%&#"5!""5#4##'4!'"&5!?# )8,$5!&#4"5#)!44>'$,#4%",*"5#)2!%'"%%,*!'4 &/=<-/ 7!& +,865",7!,4,*"5#>#!,#'4%'6-/75%$57!&48#,*"5# 4##'4!'"&7#?#,.%'"5#>#!,-/<-."5#4##'4!'"%,*)8,$5!&#4"5# )!44>'$,#4%"7,"5 &-..B< ?%4#4%#,#'"+%22&.4#"!%275%$5

7!&6%?#'%')!,!6,!)5"5#)2!%'"5#2!&"+%227!&4!"#4B - 5#!,#*#'"%'#464&7#,#)8,$5!&#4+>"5#4##'4!'"&7#?#,. "5#>)!%4!&8* &B../=</ +#%'6)!,")!>*#'"!&,#2#$"#4%')!,!

B"5#)2!%'"'?!,%8&4!"#&!'4"5#2!&"4!"#,)!>*#'"7!&&57' !&B-/ "7!&8,"5#,!?#,,#4"5!""5#)!>*#'"&*!4#+>"5#4##'4!'"& 7#,#!438&"#4%'"5#),#?%8&+%22&&)!''%'6,*-/"-/ 5#4##'4!'"&!$C'72#46#4"5#2%!+%2%">"7!,4&"5#8"&"!'4%'648#&!'4 %&&8#4!$5#D8#' / -/4,!7''#7!'C'4%!. 5!67!,!, !&8* &.=.0<"7!,4&"5#)!>*#'"),%$#64&.+8""5#&!*# 7!& 4%&5'8,#4 '"5#, $5#D8# 4,!7' ' "!"# !'C !"%!2!.

5!67!,!7!&%&&8#4'=/!$C'72#46%'6"5#2%!+%2%">!$$#)"%'6 "5!" "5# 4##'4!'"& 7#,# %' !,,#!,& !'4. "5#,#,#. $2!%*#4 "5# !,#*#'"%'#4!*8'" ##'4!'"&"$'"#&"#4"5#&8%"+>,!%&%'6)2#!"5!""5# &8%"7!&+!,,#4+>2!72%*%"!"%'!'47!&+!4,*%&<3%'4#,)!,"%#& '*#,%"&.%"7!&&"!"#4"5!""5#4##'4!'"&5!4*!4#)!>*#'"""5#"8'#

&B../=</ .+8""5#)2!%'"%7,'62>*%&!)),),%!"#4%',#&)#$""5# +%22&!&4#&$,%+#4%'"5#$,,#&)'4%'6)!,!6,!)5& ,%6%'!2+%22&7#,#'#?#, ,#"8,'#4""5#4##'4!'"&5#4##'4!'"&%,*4%4'"%&&8#$5#D8#&!& !22#6#47#?#,.%" %& 4#'%#4 % 6%'4#, !82 %&&8#4 !$5#D8#4!"#4 =/,!'4'+#5!24##'4!'"%,* ##'4!'"&=!'4B%2#4"5#%,&#)!,!"#7,%""#'&"!"#*#'" !'4$'"#&"#4"5#&8%"+>"!C%'6?!,%8&+3#$"%'& 5#",%!28,".'"5#+!&%&"5#)2#!4%'6&"5#)!,"%#&" "5#2%&.,!*#4"5#227%'6%&&8#&(<

E F5#"5#, "5# )2!%'"%<%,* %& ! ,#6%&"#,#4 )!,"'#,&5%) $'$#,'!'4#& !3%&'#%"&,#6%&"#,#4)!,"'#,&G

F5#"5#,!'!*8'" &/=<-/7#,#48#,*"5# 4##'4!'"&'-/G

F5#"5#, "5# 4##'4!'" )8,$5!&#4 )!44> 7,"5

&-..B< 48,%'6 "5#>#!,-/<-,*"5# )2!%'"%G

F5#"5#,"5#4##'4!'"*!4#)!>*#'" &B../=/ )!%&#""5#)2!%'"%&%"&##$"G

= F5#"5#, "5# 4##'4!'" %,* %&&8#4 $5#D8# ' F< -/4!"#4 / -/, &.=.<&%"&##$"G

F5#"5#, 6%'4#, !82 4##'4!'" ' %&&8#4 $5#D8# '= /4!"#4=/!'4!$C'72#46#4"5#2%!+%2%">"5# )2!%'"%G

- F5#"5#,"5#)2!%'"%%&#'"%"2#4""5#%'"#,#&"$2!%*#4 ,G

/ F5#"5#,"5#&8%"%&7%"5%'"%*#G

F5#"5#,"5#&8%"%&+!4,*%&<3%'4#,)!,"%#&G F5#"5#,"5#),?%&%'& ,4#, 82# 5!?#'"

+##'$*)2%#47%"5G F5#"5#,"5#&8%"%&$228&%?#+#"7##'"5#)2!%'"%!'4 4##'4!'"& #H$#)"=!'4B G = B F5#"5#,"5#4##'4!'" '- %& 2%!+2#" $2!%*"5# )2!%'"%G

#2%#

2!%'"%%,*#H!*%'#4 F<#& !3!'4!2&+,865"'

,#$,44$8*#'"&H "H B.%#.+%22&.&!2#&"!H,*&.$#,"%%#4 $)%#&2#&&#,!$$8'"+C&#"$ '"5#"5#,5!'4."5#4##'4!'"& #H!*%'#4 F< !3 :8*!, 4##'4!'" = . F< !7!' :8*!, !'!6#,"5#4##'4!'"%,*!'4?!,%8&"5#,7%"'#&&#& '"5#),#)'4#,!'$#"5##?%4#'$#+,865"',#$,4."5# ",%!28,"4%&*%&&#4"5#&8%"+>"!C%'6"5#2!&"4!"#,)!>*#'"$5#D8#

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

2>%'6 "5# ),?%&%'& #$"%' "5# 1%*%"!"%' $" 5# D8#&"%' 2%*%"!"%'),#&&#4%'"&#,?%$#!'4"5#$2!%*$!''"+#&!%4"+#+!,,#4+> 2!72%*%"!"%' 5!?#6'#"5,865"5#)!)#,+C.3846*#'"&!'44#$,##& "5#$8,"&+#27!'4!&7#22!&"5#,#$,4&"5#$8,"&+#27!'4"5# ?%#7"5!""5#,#%&',$#!'4*#,%"%'"5#)2#!&"5#!))#22!'" 5865"5#",%!28,"5!4"!C#'"5#!$C'72#46*#'"4#+" !&)#,"5#),?%&%'&#$"%'/"5#1%*%"!"%'$"!&=/ 75#'"5#$5#D8#7!&%&&8#4!'4+>$!2$82!"%'6"5#)#,%4"5,##>#!,&!& "5#&8%"7!&%2#4%'#)"#*+#,./.4%&*%&&#4"5#&8%"'"5#6,8'4 2%*%"!"%'.+8""5#17#,))#22!"

"5#),#*%&#"5!""5#4##'4!'"&5!4!$C'72#46#4"5##'"%,#8"&"!'4%'6 !*8'"48#!& ?%&<!<?%&"5#)!>*#'"4!"#4/-/5# 2%*%"!"%',8',*"5#4!"#75#'"5#$5#D8#7!&6%?#'!'4'",*"5#

- 4!"##'$!&5*#'".&%!"!22."5#$5#D8#75%$57!&6%?#''=/ 7!&#'$!&5#4%'#)"#*+#,./7824'"#H"#'4"5#)#,%42%*%"!"%'

F< #& !3&"!"#4"5!""5#)!>*#'"&*!4#+>"5#4##'4!'"& 7#,#!438&"#4%'"5#),#?%8&+%22&,*-/"-/!'4)!," )!>*#'"+%224!"#4/-/."5#,#,#.+!2!'$#2#"7!& 75%$5"5#4##'4!'"&7#,#2%!+2#")!>"5#,*!"#,%!25!&+##'+,865" ',#$,4"#&"!+2%&5"5#2%!+%2%">"5#4##'4!'"&!&$2!%*#4%'"5#&8%" &!'8)&5"*>!,#*#'"%'#4+&#,?!"%'&."5#%'4%'6& "5#17#,))#22!"#8,"4'"$!22,!'>%'"#,#,#'$#,$!''"+# &!%4"+#)#,?#,&#,!22!$%8&&8+&"!'"%!2D8#&"%'2!7!,%&#&, 4#"#,*%'!"%'+>"5%&8," #&82"!'"2>."5#!))#!2%&4%&*%&&#4 *)+%

'(./& 0123,4 156 +606578 95

:59

+606 02!

:59