High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4165/2023dismissed

The Managing Director, Haryana Financial Corporation And Another v. Rakesh Gupta And Others

2023-10-03Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger13 pages

"#$ '$()*)%+

, ,

-$ "+".)+.

)/$(#%/0 "/1"+"

)+"+()"2 %/3%/"#)%+ "+%#-$/ ,,,,,, $#)#)%+$/* 4$/*5* "6$*- 758"/ 53#"

%#-$/*

,,,,,, $*3%+'$+#* 9: ,

; ; /$*$+# /, "'"8 7"+# <)=$')0

'=%("#$ 3$#)#)%+$/,

, , ; 0

, -$ )+*#"+# </)# 3$#)#)%+ >$$+ &)2$'

3$#)#)%+$/

/#)(2$* %+*#)#5#)%+ +')"

*$$6)+.

</)# +"#5/$ ($/#)%/"/) ?5"*-)+.

%/'$/ '"#$'

@, ,

++$A5/$ 0 3"**$'

/$*3%+'$+# %,

%+#/%22)+.

"18$+# /"#5)#1

(#0 @ 0 <-$/$>1 "332)("#)%+ &)2$'

/$*3%+'$+# %,

"6$*- 758"/ 53#" "18$+# /"#5)#1

(#0 @

*-%/# 9#-$ @

(#9 *$$6)+.

&/%8 3$#)#)%+$/* >$$+ "22%<$',

$#)#)%+$/ &5/#-$/ 2"1* (-"22$+.$ %/'$/ '"#$'

B, B,

++$A5/$ 0 3"**$'

33$22"#$

"18$+# /"#5)#1

(#0 @

/$*3%+'$+# %,

-$/$)+0 ')*8)**)+.

"33$"2 &)2$'

3$#)#)%+$/* ".")+*# %/'$/ '"#$'

@, ,

++$A5/$ , , /)$&210 /$*3%+'$+# %,

"6$*- 758"/ 53#" &)2$'

"332)("#)%+ @

>$&%/$

%+ 32$"

-$ C%)+$'

*$/=)($* 3$#)#)%+$/"/1"+"

)+"+()"2 %/3%/"#)%+

-$/$)+"&#$/ /$&$//$'

93$#)#)%+$/%/3%/"#)%+9 %+ , B,@@ %+ /$.52"/

>"*)* -$ /$#)/$'

;$+)%/ "+".$/ %+

,, "&#$/ /$+'$/)+.

8%/$ #-"+

1$"/* *$/=)($,

$*3%+'$+# %, (2")8$'

-$ -"'

>$$+ 3")'

"8%5+# *, B00B0 <-$/$"* -)* #%#"2 "8%5+# (%8$* *, 0 0@B0 -%<$=$/ #$/8* 3/%=)*)%+* @

(#0 *")'

"8%5+# <"* /$*#/)(#$'

# "33$"/* "+%#-$/ "8%5+# *, 0 8%/$ <"* 3")'

/$*3%+'$+# %, %+ , , @ "((%/')+.210 /$*3%+'$+# %, (2")8$'

-$ >$$+ 3")'

#%#"2 "8%5+# *, @00

0 <-)2$ #%#"2 3"1">2$ "8%5+# <"* *,

"+'0 #-$/$&%/$0 "8%5+# *, 0@B *#)22 %5#*#"+')+.

".")+*# 3$#)#)%+$/%/3%/"#)%+ -$ 3/"1$'

')/$(#)%+* 3$#)#)%+$/%/3%/"#)%+ 3"1 -)* '5$* )+#$/$*#,

, -$ "&%/$*")'

(2")8 /$*3%+'$+# %, <"* (%+#$*#$'

3$#)#)%+$/%/3%/"#)%+ %+ 32$"

/$*3%+'$+# %, /$($)=$'

3$/ 5+C">

)+"+()"2 %/3%/"#)%+

"18$+# /"#5)#1 832%1$$* $.52"#)%+*0 @ (2")8 "332)("#)%+ @

+%# 8")+#")+">2$0 #-$/$&%/$0

/$*3%+'$+# %, <"* +%# $+#)#2$'

"+1 &5/#-$/ "8%5+#,

, + >"*)* 32$"')+.

3"/#)$*0 &%22%<)+.

)**5$* <$/$ &/"8$'

, -$ 3"/#)$* 2$'

#-$)/ /$*3$(#)=$ $=)'$+($ *533%/# #-$)/ (2")8,

, -$/$"&#$/0

/$*3%+'$+# %,

-$/$)+0 =)'$ %/'$/ '"#$'

@, ,

++$A5/$ 0 -$2'

# $! % & ' $ ()

% ' !

* (+

, $!

% ' $ () % %

% !

./ 0

. &1 2

4 * %

2 (56) 5 $ 07& * %

2 8)5 5

5 90*: # -; 0 *

<= & ' $ () 0 =$ % !

=0 0 % % $ % >= =% >

% %

-; 0 *

% & ' $ () !

! 88(+6?= # $!

% $

% % % 0 ) $

5@ 558 85 5( ! (?= 85 5( ! 88(+6?=

! +6)85?= #

" , $)+.

')**"#)*&)$'

"&%/$*")'

%/'$/0 3$#)#)%+$/ %/3%/"#)%+ &)2$'

*#"#5#%/1 "33$"2 ;$(#)%+

(#0 <-)(- <"* ')*8)**$'

33$22"#$

5#-%/)#10 =)'$ )#* %/'$/ '"#$'

B, B,

++$A5/$ , B, "&%/$8$+#)%+$'

()/(58*#"+($*0 )+*#"+# </)# 3$#)#)%+ >$$+ &)2$'

>$&%/$ #-)* %5/#,

@, -"=$ -$"/'

2$"/+$'

(%5+*$2 3$#)#)%+$/ 3$/5*$'

3"3$/>%%6 -)* ">2$ "**)*#"+($, , $

3 4 % $

3 4 ! A $0

; 0 %+9>2$ ;53/$8$ %5/#0 <-)2$ (%+*)'$/)+.

3/%=)*)%+* "18$+# /"#5)#1

(#0 @ D -$2'

5+'$/

" -$/$ +% $*("3$ &/%8 3/%=)*)%+*

5+2$** $*#">2)*-8$+# ./"+#$'

$A$83#)%+ &/%8 %3$/"#)%+ 3/%=)*)%+*

"33/%3/)"#$ %=$/+8$+#,

> /"#5)#1 3"1">2$ $832%1$$ %+ #$/8)+"#)%+ -)* $832%18$+# "&#$/ /$+'$/)+.

(%+#)+5%5* *$/=)($ +%# 2$** #-"+ 1$"/* %+ *53$/"++5"#)%+ %/ /$#)/$8$+# %/ /$*).+"#)%+ $#(, >$)+.

*#"#5#%/1 /).-# ("++%# >$ #"6$+ "<"1 $A($3# "((%/'"+($ 3/%=)*)%+*

<-$/$5+'$/ $A$83#)%+ &/%8 *5(- 8"1 >$ ./"+#$'

%+21 "33/%3/)"#$ %=$/+8$+# ;$(#)%+

<-)(- )#*$2& "

(%+')#)%+"2 3%<$/, % $A$83#)%+ (%52'

>$ ./"+#$'

"+1 %=$/+8$+# 5+2$** )# $*#">2)*-$'

$832%1$$* "/$ /$($)3# %/ 3$+*)%+ >$+$&)#* <-)(- "/$ 8%/$ &"=%5/">2$ #-"+ >$+$&)#* (%+&$//$'

(#,

( =)$< %=$//)')+.

3/%=)*)%+* (%+#")+$'

;$(#)%+ "18$+# /"#5)#1

(#0 3/%=)*)%+ $+*)%+ 52$* <)22 -"=$ +% $&&$(#, %**)>21 #-)* /$"*%+0 ;$(#)%+ "18$+# /"#5)#1

(%+&$//$'

"5#-%/)#1 %+ "33/%3/)"#$ %=$/+8$+# $A$83# "+1 $*#">2)*-8$+# &/%8 %3$/"#)%+ 3/%=)*)%+*

(#0 )& )#* %3)+)%+ $832%1$$* *5(- $*#">2)*-8$+# "/$ /$($)3# %/ 3$+*)%+"/1 >$+$&)#* +%# 2$** &"=%5/">2$ #-"+ >$+$&)#* (%+&$//$'

#-)*

(#, EB

* C % C & 0

,0 @@@

; @F

+ $*#">2)*-8$+# *#"#5#%/1 %>2)."#)%+ 3"1 3/%=)'$'

;$(#)%+

<-)(- /$?5)/$'

>$ /$"'

"2%+.

;$(#)%+

<-)(- *"1* 3/%=)*)%+*

*-"22 -"=$ $&&$(# +%#<)#-*#"+')+.

"+1#-)+.

)+(%+*)*#$+# #-$/$)+ (%+#")+$'

"+1 $+"(#8$+# %/ "+1 )+*#/58$+# %/ (%+#/"(# -"=)+.

$&&$(# =)/#5$ "+1 $+"(#8$+# %#-$/ #-"+ #-)*

(#,

$ -$ 3/%=)*)%+*

3/$=")2 %=$/ "22 %#-$/ $+"(#8$+# %/ )+*#/58$+# %/ (%+#/"(# *% &"/ (%+($/+$', -$ /).-# /$($)=$ 3/%=)*)%+*

("++%# >$ '$&$"#$'

"+1 )+*#/58$+# %/ (%+#/"(#,

& - 7% $ % 0 B

@ ; /$21)+.

53%+ '$()*)%+ & - D % .3 & 0

;

)# <"* -$2'

<%/'

9)+*#/58$+#9 <%52'

)+(25'$ "<"/'

8"'$ +'5*#/)"2 /)>5+"2,

. ;$(#)%+

'$&)+$*

"5#-%/)#1 "33%)+#$'

"33/%3/)"#$ %=$/+8$+# ;$(#)%+

(#, +'$/ ;$(#)%+

8"'$ /$*3%+*)>2$ "'8)+)*#/"#)%+

)# &5/#-$/ 3/%=)'$* "33%)+#8$+# ')&&$/$+# "5#-%/)#)$* ')&&$/$+# "/$"*, ;$(#)%+ '$"2*

'$#$/8)+"#)%+ "8%5+# ./"#5)#1, =$/1 3$/*%+ <-% $2).)>2$

/$?5)/$'

*$+'

</)##$+ "332)("#)%+ $832%1$/ 3/$*(/)>$'

&%/8 *5(- ./"#5)#1, ;5>*$(#)%+

;$(#)%+ 3/%=)'$* %+($ >$(%8$* 3"1">2$0 $832%1$/ *-"220 <-$#-$/ "332)("#)%+ >$$+ 8"'$ %/ +%#0 '$#$/8)+$ "8%5+# .)=$ +%#)($ </)#)+.

3$/*%+ <-%8 3"1">2$ "2*%

*3$()&1)+.

"8%5+# *% '$#$/8)+$'

"//"+.$ 3"1 "8%5+# 3$/*%+ <-%8 3"1">2$, -$ ;(-$8$ $+=)*".$'

;$(#)%+

(#0 ("*$ "+1 ')*35#$ "8%5+# 3"1">2$ $832%1$$

%/ "'8)**)>)2)#1 "+1 (2")8 %&0 %/ /$2"#)%+ #%0 $832%1$$ 3"1">2$ $#(, $832%1$/ /$?5)/$'

'$3%*)#

"'8)##$'

"8%5+# 3"1">2$ ./"#5)#1, ("*$ "+1 ')*35#$ 3"/#)$* 8"1 8"6$ "332)("#)%+

'$()')+.

')*35#$ <-% "&#$/ '5$ )+?5)/1 "&#$/ .)=)+.

3"/#)$* ')*35#$0 "

/$"*%+">2$ %33%/#5+)#1 >$)+.

-$"/'0 '$#$/8)+$ 8"##$/ %/ 8"##$/* ')*35#$ )&0 /$*52# *5(- )+?5)/1 "+1 "8%5+# &%5+'

>$ 3"1">2$ $832%1$$0

*-"22 ')/$(# $832%1$/ 3"1 *5(- "8%5+# $832%1$$,

;5>*$(#)%+

;$(#)%+ 0 3/%=)'$* "33$"2 ".")+*# %/'$/

5#-%/)#1, -$

(#0 +%<-$/$ (%+&$/* "+1 C5/)*')(#)%+ 53%+

'$"2 "+1 )**5$ *5>*$(#)%+

;$(#)%+ <-$#-$/ #$/8* 3"1">2$ "+1

<"/'

%/ "./$$8$+# %/ (%+#/"(# 8%/$ >$+$&)()"2 $832%1$$* #-"+ %+$ 3/%=)'$'

(#, -)* %5/#9* %/'$/ (%52'

+%# -"=$ (%+&$//$'

"+1 *5(- C5/)*')(#)%+ 53%+

'$()'$ "+1 8"##$/ *5>*$(#)%+

;$(#)%+ 0 *)+($ "/2)"8$+# )#* <)*'%8 -"'

(-%*$+ (%+&$/ *5(- C5/)*')(#)%+ %+21 53%+ "33/%3/)"#$ %=$/+8$+# #%% 35/3%*$* (%+*)'$/)+.

./"+# $A$83#)%+ &/%8 %3$/"#)%+ 3/%=)*)%+*

(#,

3$/5*"2 "&%/$*")'

C5')()"2 3/%+%5+($8$+# <%52'

8"+)&$*# 3/%=)*)%+* @

%=$//)')+.

$&&$(# "8%5+# 3"1">2$ $832%1$$ #$/8* 3/%=)*)%+* @

*#"#5#%/1 /).-# $A$83#)%+ &/%8 8"1 >$ ./"+#$'

%+21 "33/%3/)"#$ %=$/+8$+# ;$(#)%+ @

5+2$** )# $*#">2)*-$'

$832%1$$* "/$ /$($)3# 3$+*)%+ >$+$&)#*0 <-)(- "/$ 8%/$ &"=%5/">2$ #-"+ >$+$&)#* @

(#,

)+*#"+# ("*$0 3$#)#)%+$/ &")2$'

*-%< "+1 $A$83#)%+ >$$+ ./"+#$'

3$#)#)%+$/%/3%/"#)%+ #$/8* ;$(#)%+ @

(#0 #-$/$&%/$0 )# ("++%# >$ ')*35#$'

3/%=)*)%+* @

"/$ "332)(">2$ (2")8

/$*3%+'$+# %, ,

* &"/ (2")8 >"2"+($ "8%5+# (%+($/+$'0 #-$/$ +% ')*35#$ ">%5# &"(# /$*3%+'$+# %, /$#)/$'

&/%8 *$/=)($ %+

,, "# /$2$="+# #)8$0 8"A)858 2)8)# 3"1">2$ @

<"* *,

'8)##$'210 /$*3%+'$+# %, -"'

>$$+ 3")'

"8%5+# *, @00

-)* (2")8 >"2"+($ "8%5+# ),$, *, 0@B >$$+ /).-#21 "22%<$'

(#, ,

* /$."/'* ./"+# )+#$/$*# "# /"#$ %+ '$2"1$'

(%+($/+$'0 $+#/"2 %=$/+8$+# )**5$'

%#)&)("#)%+ '"#$'

, ,@B0 /$2$="+# $A#/"(# <-)(- /$"'* H0, 6) 9A: E

= 9 $: 0 ) & ' $ () 9 ( (): *

3$/5*"2 ">%=$ $A#/"(#$'

<%52'

8"+)&$*# $+#/"2 %=$/+8$+# -"'

*3$()&)$'

/"#$ *)832$ )+#$/$*# 3$/ "++58 $832%1$/ $832%1$$ <-$/$ +%# 3")'

<)#-)+ *3$()&)$'

3$/)%',

- '

' . / $ * 7 55 9: 0*# ( )0 )# >$$+ -$2'

%+9>2$ ;53/$8$ %5/# )+#$/$*# %+ '$2"1$'

>$1%+'

3/$*(/)>$'

3$/)%'

),$,

'"1* *#"#5#%/1 )+#$/$*# 8"+'"#%/1D #-$/$ +% ')*(/$#)%+ "=")2">2$ %5/# %/ "5#-%/)#10 $A($3# ("*$ $832%1$$ <"* -)8*$2& /$*3%+*)>2$ '$2"1 $832%1$/ %>#")+$'

3$/8)**)%+ </)#)+.

&/%8

'$2"1$'

%+ ./%5+',

%+9>2$ ;53/$8$ %5/# -$2'

)

% 0 )9:

F 0 )9 :

F = 9$: 0 )

= 9 :

'% G %

H % 0 )

- % % 0 )9 $:

F 0 6 % % $

# *

% $

0 ( = &

A % %

% 4 0 /

$ , % B & 2 I(68 985: H7! 8J A

0= 9 $:

0 )

, (6)

* 0 % B? 3

$ I(66 98): H7! 8 0*J

% $

L *

$ *

$ (6) = 9$:

0 ) # % %

K (

% 0 D

L %

% % L # 0 D %

% 0 )9 $: $

$ %

% 0 )

% %

0 6 $ 0 L %

0 )9 $:

F C % 3 - * %

0 D

% 0 D

0 ) $ # C % 3

0 D

, =)$< ">%=$ ')*(5**)%+0 '% +%# &)+'

"+1 8$/)# )+*#"+# </)# 3$#)#)%+ *"8$ "((%/')+.21 ')*8)**$', ,

3$+')+.

"332)("#)%+ *0 )& "+10 *-"22 *#"+'

(2%*$',

;

, ,

*C6* -$#-$/ *3$"6)+./$"*%+$'

!$*

% -$#-$/ /$3%/#">2$ !$*