Pala Singh & ORS. v. State Of Haryana
!" #
$% &' '( )))))**$$ +( %(, )))) *
(
-().) )%)+(/!0 ('**$$ ) -()+0/% !!(, )
( **$'2 *(((2,'**$$ 3
$ % &' &(4 % &' '$$ & & '( 0 2,'$( &!%*$ (!.( $05* & &5 ((##) 6)" 7 # ) 6)" 7(*0$,) ''**$$ '02 0(' *
'2$
( % # 89 ' ( ( & ,'(* % 2 8( '( : % :9! #6;
(&(&( 5*( 5 ( ,(2*, #! ! <= $'(
(&(&( 5*( 5 ( ,() (('( (5 >(02,
?@% &'!%<% ! $% (( "#) @)" #'
2''**$$ $ &>' $0 (% &' $% &'
>(5 &(5'0$$& ( >(0$$& ((($$,$>'***,'
/) ((> $2(0 2, &(4% &') $% &' $> ( % &'>( & '($$,)% &'!%$ &>''(*$ $>& &>(2(& $ '5
>'*($$ &'/ & /2 )
(*' (5 !%% &'('' 2(& $0$$& (2(()(5 52 @) *)5)((($$,> 5 &(5' 0$$&( >('2(&)((($$,>** >'& $(')((>(0 2, &(4% &'!>'> $, 2, % % &') ' 2&! $ % &' $0 (% &'>(
&) $% &'>/ > % % &'($() &'*$*(,!$$''(5& '(*'( &'*,$>''>( $$>()'((!
'$(% '$.
5(! ?A>$$)%$ >&'>( (( &)( 5 '>(B*$ ''$( >' 5 ' * ' ( *(*(, > '/) **,'
/>
#"2&8## $$ 2&>'
$(C ,9)#"5*$" &(5'!B) # #"!>( / (5'2&)76/&***,'
/>
##2&
' $ 2& "D /& > *( ) $$ D 7 /& ***, '
/ > (0()%5*$>( 0( *(*($ $ >'$:%: :%.: >(/ * 055B)
$ &>'((($$,)%5*$$>*(*( *
$')
//!B) !> '( &' 2$.(5% &'
'2>''(5$ )6"#D) @)" #!B) !> (&(2,%$0% &') 2$% (% &'8 ?"9 $0(*$(*($$C-&(>$$ (*$ ()>(0$2,%'5% &' % 4% &' % &'!%''*( >'( >,>' $% &' &(4 % &'>$0 (% &' $0 ( &') $ % &' &(4 % &' >( (( 2, % % &'
# ) @)" #) %5*$ >( ( $, ( % E2((,!-'
2 >(
2***,(>0(*( B) ) $$, (*(
(% #@7 () )) > *( & $% &' &(4% &' $,$0 (% &' $
2 (() $0 ( % &' > 2C $, ((
7 )##)" #2,%'>(% &' 2C $,(*(>$ & '5$()'(&>(5& $$'
A) )" ">''',*$
$5($)
( B5 5 ,0 > *(0) >'$ , & (5 &5($* '5 *$
$ 5*$ '( 5
(% 7#7() ))>0(! 0 >$ ) E( ($ ( ( & ' ( 5 ' $ ' ' *( ' $$, *(0 2, ( 2$ 2 & $% &' &(4% &'2 '$5/ & ' $0 (% &'!>'>C &0 & 2 2)
!
E(
$ ( ' **$$ 25 ' 0 '**$$ 2$ ,5
() ( (5 , ' **$$ ' 2 B) 25'>*'(/ &' '$&''(( > $2$ '*$*(,)'( , ,2, '$&' (')'( ' & && '>' **$$ >(/ > %% &'! ?@)
('(5(!'(
5*$ '5 (,*(0 % D"' %) ('(*$''($,#",
&'5*$('5$ $,))(0(,>$$&$, #D) @)" # >'( 5*$ ( '5$ B5 "A) @)" #) E(
$('**$$ 25'(0(, ' 2 '*( , * > * '( '0 & 2 *(( (5 $$& 2, ' *( ) $ *$ ' * ' 0( ' (2 *(0 ,5
() ( &$, (&' C (&( & * > * ' !'((!', $ 2 0 ' )
('(5(!$ /0 0((25 &5*$ ' 2 / (5$$'2&)(>52,' *( /'*(> ('*'((($$,) $ 25' $,>'2&>(>&' $$!
'(2,0 &'*( && ' )'((! 25 ' 0 ' **$$ $$&$
2$! *$$, 0> ' ' ' 5
"
0 = $0 ( &''2 ('2 2)
( ($(
$('%>'$ , & 20*$ 25''( & 0 ((*(0' $*2$,' )0,C , (2 '2 (0((5' *( ) ' ',5 &$(5'*
5*(0'()'( ( ($5*$ ' )!'
!*(,(
*'$ &' 0 5* * '**$$ ) '0'($(
$('*( & '( &''((>''(2$ ) *$$, 2, % % &' ' 2' ' **$$ >(/ > '5($()'' )) $ % &' ' &(4% &'(( 0$$& /' >''$$>' *$% (($)'( ' &
(( 2'5 , ?@%% &' '(*( * '(2$,'> )2 ' ((($$,(0 2, &(4% &'> (*2 @*)5) #D) @)" #)5(55 / >$&'
$, '5'2 @*)5) $ 2*'(/) '((! 2 2(0(5(( '( B5 ?@!%% &''>*'(/)'
! ' '!
2' ,' *(0 '(()
0(,> '*( '$(% '$ .
5(! ?A! >' ' ((2( ' *( 0( )
# (& 5 $(
$('**$$ '$$'2&>(
>&'2,((( &'(B5 % '$.
5(!
?A ' ' $, > ( '( 2& >( 5*$$, 5* ' (5 & 2& >( /* 2$ $, 5 0)5*$ *(*(( &'5 '
?A% '$.
5(>$$''(> '*(0$ '>&'5 $$'2&> !'>0(!>>( '( $,>''>(5*$$,5* '((>&')
5 &2&>( 5*5*$$,2 '$$$ '5>(
2$,>&')'
,5
(5
' >&'5 $$ ' 2& > 4 2 $$2&>( 5*) '' **$$ ''2& ,'( 2 ) *(0 (('#"5*$>(/ (5 '2&!>''(B) # #")%5*$ $>(
)*( %E(*(B) !#"$*($>'>$ :%: :%.:>((0) ('(* B) '$>( ',$$>'*5 $*(' $(>( &$()'((! $(
$( '**$$ '*(5*$>( / 2( (5'(() E(
$('**$$ '0'5 $, (& '( (5 '> ( >( &
*,> ''&'($'(2,0 &'($) 5(((''( (5 >(02,% % &'2 A)7 *)5) '5 (, '(&( '
$ (F 5') (( ($$, > (* 2 @) *)5) '((! 5 > ''$(55$,!>' ((0'*)
//> >$$ (5 ' '&'($ 0,) ' ( 5 '!
2''( =5*$ % D"' %'B '> $0'*( &'(2, $ &' C $) %5$($, ' ( 5 '$, &'5*$( $,
5*(0'**$$ :
)'(& *(*(0 (('$
'5*$(0( (2 >(
2 5 20)*(*(,$ &>'5*$>(' 0(2,% &'!% ?D!$*% &'!>'>*- #D) @)" #)'*$$,*' "A) @)" #!' '/ >$08#"95*$*($(* &'5 >' %E ', >( ' 0( ' 2$ '(5*$$ &>'5*$$)*' 5*( & >2,'5($$>2>''*(*(, ('5*$$) ? !'(5*$*''*' 5*$' 0('5 "A) @)" # '((!
%E '5,$ ' 0('(*'- "A) @)" #) 0(5*(>''5*$ ( $$> , ' 5 $$ ' 5 (5 ' * )
($(02,' %E>(
2 ) %$>( $$ >' ' *5 $) '((! $, & ' 5*$2,$
2$'*( '2
% '$2,' :2$% *(5 (
) %5$($, $(
$('**$$ ''( 0 (('>''((($$, 2$ &' (4) ?@!%% &''* ' $*% &'(&(> ('(()'(( (((' % &')$*% &''$'(( $% &')'(0*(*,5 2 '(( > ( (( ' 5 $% &' (* '5*$*,5 )
$'**$$ ' '2 * > '*( &(0 4 ) *((5 2 ,0 ((!'( 0 >'*('' $> '$ ,5$>(' *( ( ','0 ,B&( & '5)'( ( ($ 5*$ ' 2, ' $ > ) ?A 5$, '$( *$ $) 0(, > '*( )'((!> $2 (( && ' ''0,(0(,'2 *$ ' ' $> (0(,> $20 '2 * > )$* '5 , '$>
2(
$
$'( ,5$ '(*() '2 * > '(5 ,> $!'>0(!2 24$(( ,2,' () '*( !'( ' & 2'0(, '$> (( '*( 0( )
'((! * > '
$'*( ) (& 5 $(
$('**$$ ' ( (5 &5($' 2 * ' >'$(( &'(5
(% 7#7() ))$ 2( '(() '0& '( &''5 '
( % 7#7() )) ,((& $(,'( ) ( (5 &5($'2 * ' ',( $C $ '&(
)'2 '$2,' :2$ % *(5 (
! '!
G)))))))*((($!% 7#7' (5 $ ( ( (C ( &0 & **(
, ' &0 ' B*$ (&( & ' ( 5 **( & & '5 ' 0 2,'*( )'* (*2' 2$ ' B*$ ' ( 5 ) (, * ( *( 0 $ >( 2 $, ' ( 5 >''(0(' ' B*$ > $ '$* ' ( 0$ & ' 0 *(*($,)'( 5 (2*
' $ ) $ (5$, &5 2( ' (5 $$&2$ ' ) $$>'5 >$$
($,0'($)'($> $20
' ( $, >'
' ' $ (4 )H '
!($ 0 '()
%5$($,! 25 'C $'=
'2'50 > $ $'*( '52
2$)$* $>'$ 2,' :2$% *(5 ( " # $##% !
'C $ '= > $ $(4 ' (0 C ''( >$$) '( 2 0 '2'50
(2$C '5) 0> ' 20! (5, ( $$&$, ' 0 5* * '**$$ (' *
'2$
(% # 89' %) C $,!'**$5) &'( &)) *+,-
!" # (