Ashok Solomon v. Assistant Director, Directorate Of Enforcement
!
" #$% & & '( #) *+ +#$% &,& ' -' . / 0'1'$+ 2& (+(+#$
/ .
+ *(# '( #) $)# * $( (. #/5. + ('$( + *(# 2 6#$"
$(
.#- 7#8#4#$ 2& (+(+#$
/ + ('$( + *(# 9 + *(# '( #) $)# * $( 2 6#$"
$( % #$:08 &/ (+*
6'- 7+0'8
!""#$%&# $&$# '
( )
!""#$*+%"$&$# !
( ( ,
- ! .
'/ '
( 0! 1
1
6'- 7+0'89 & 2 ((
' !""#$%&#
$&$#3 '4 2) 1 !"
"#$*+%"$&$#3 ) )
1'
' ( (' ( ' -
,!5/,65$&#% $+ &# $&#%
7 *
08 $&&$9 38:
;,!- $%# #7 #$ $&#<
#& /0)( 1 ! (
6' #%=+9 3#%=+:
*$&,
> ) 1 > (0
7# &7 $&&= (,
8 9 3 (: #*% &%7 ( 1( ) 2
0( /09 3)2 : (
#%=+ (
( 0 2 $< &7 $&&< ( ?
!(0 108 9 3?
:
( 1 ' 9 3 ': (
( ('( '
(
( 1 ' )2 @
'(
(
$$ ## $&&< ( )2
1 ' ( ' - #%&5$&&<
$* ## $&&<
( (1
1 ( ' (A
$+B (
(( C-
- 8 C9 3--8:' , ' =+B
--8(
'(( (
9 A
: 1 $+B
'(( -
;
!
,
;
4D( ( ' '0 ( 0D( (( 1(( 'A (0A
'0 E ( 0 ( 0'0 ( (10(
9
(( 1
4 +B ( 1' --8( : 2 ( ' - +<5$ =%5$&#* 7 %*= #7 7=+ (0 ( (1 (( --8 ( ( ' '0 ( @ ( ' '0 ( (('
5 ( 11' ( ' ?
( ( #&F#&< #&% 1 ' (
( 0 1 C,
( 0C @#& #$ $&#<)2
/
@
((> ) 1
1 151 ( ( A
(( $*%--8( / '
(0<*--8( '((
<*( ++ '(( '0 ' 8 8 '
0 9 388:
'0 ' ( 2 '0(( --8( ((0 ( ' ( ?
(
( 1 ( 51 2 A (
( '?
88
#& #%=+
@' '
1( ;,!- $%#
*$&,
#& #%=+
> ) 1
;,! 1) 9 3 ):'(
( 1 0 ( ' $+ &# $&#% )
1 , 1
! -
,!5/,65$&#%9 3 ,!:
7 * 8
,
'0/0 ;,!
'01(
(0 '
1 15( '
0
*$&,
(0/0 (
#=7 (0
#& #%=+ ;,!(
'0/0 ( '
*$&, (0
( 8
(
)( /
G9 !8:
%=%"$&$&"5 (,
8 6
,
,!
&= &< $&$&
1 ,!0
(
81' ( / ( '0 ) ,! (10 5 1 0
' 0
( 9: 8
@$& &< $&$&/0 ( (10
#=79<:
"( (( A ( - +<5$ =%5$&#* ( ' 0 1
1 )2 ' 0 5
( 1 1
A
'
1
(( ' 1 ( (0
'( ( /0
(0
#& #%=+ (
'
*$&, @ 1 ( '0 '0)(
/
) ,! 11
(1 1(
** *+ 8 (?
) ?
( (0
7 * 8 ,
1( "( (( ( - #%&5$&&<$#$--8( '
'0)2 (0
('
' ( ?
(( (0%7 (
%7( ' (( +% 1 88 '0 ' 2 1
88'0 '
((0 --8( (
( '((
--8(
1 '0)2 '
(( +%( ((1
(( ( 0
( ?
0((
(( #< #F--8( (0
'
,
(( A (
(( ( 0 10 ! +& ! F& (0 G
(( 1 ( ?
1
1
(
15 '(( --8( 1 '0)2 5
((
' '1
19:
(5 0 (
1 '0 )2
(0 (
(( A
(
(( ( 0 )
'0 ) 1 ' ( ?
(
1 (( '
(
1 01
! $$& '0 ' (5?
(
! #$& 9 1(0: " '(
'0 ' (5?
' ( ,' '(
0 ' ((0 1( D
0 #F &$ $&$#D'
( 0'A
'0 )
A
0
(0
0D
1( (10
#=79<: 5 1(
** *+ 8'
<
(
'0
0 0
(
D
'
1 ( ' E
(
'0 ) 1 '
D '
! +& ! F& (0( 0' E '0
)D ,! ( ((( (0
( 8
,!
*$&, 1
' ((
( '
0
*$&, ' (( ' 1 15( ' ( )2 ' 4( (0
#& #%=+ D ( 1( ( '0)2 '1 ' (
;,!'0/0 (0((
' 1 15( 0'
#& #%=+D
#& #%=+ ' ('( ( 1 1 1 104 0 ( D (10 ( '0/0
'
*$&,
(0
A ( - +<5$ =%5$&#* ( '
1
1)2 ' 0
5
( 1 (( 1 1
'D (0 1
( '( 1
)2 &# &* $&#F( 0' '0 ( (( '0
0 5
= 0D 1( (
)2 5 ((
(0 0
D01 '0
) 1 ' (0 '02 (
0
(
1 15( (( --8( 1 '0)2 1
'(
79=: #%=+ 1 1(
0 2
'
E F# =+ 0 (0 ' ( 1
'
0
"#% 1 ,
!""#$*+%"$&$#( 1 ' (1 1 8
( ( ,
1 (
'1
' (
1
'
*+ 8
' (
(0
'(
'(
(0 (( ( ' (0 ( (0 0 D
*+9#: 8
' (
('0 1
'
'0 1
1 ' (
*+9#: '
( ' '08 (
- #7 $&#< 1
1 #% &* $&#<D - #7 $&#<
4
H '( 1 1 1 1
0
(I' ' H ID 1 1
'
*+9#: 8
D1
*+9#: 8 ' (( '0
(
'
'0
' D 1 ((
'0 1
! "
# $ %
& '
()* 1
'
((0(
((
'0 1
D + +
, -. +/ 0#
$ 1 - & )
2 1
(
((
0
((
'
D %, ," .3
)
*) 1
(( 1 0
((
'
( 1'
1
( 0 1 '
1
(D )( /
"
. !
4 5
4 5( 4
+
4 !
4
'(( ( #7 $&#<
' (
*+9#: 8 (( ' 1
'0)( /
'0
!
( '(
*$&, (
(10 ( '0
'
*$&, D '(( '0
D 0
(0
((0'0 '
'0 1 ' ( )2 0
--8( ((
D
(( --8(
((1
(( ( 0D 1 4
0
(('
( --8 (
1
1 (
1'(( --8( (( 1 ( ' ( '0 (
D 0
1 ( (
1 '0)2 --8(
(
( ( (
D ( '(
' (( 1 '1 --8 0D((
(
( D (
(0 ' 5 "
0( ' (0( (0 (
( G ( '
0
*$&, ( ( (( '
1
, . 1 %.
5(*
((("
7'
8,&
,
) 1
" , # 9,
# "
)() 1
" "
, :
# , , # &
&
, : " ,
; :
: , , $
" , # 9,
#
; ;
:,
; , ;
: , ,
& & # ;&
3,
& :
, ,
, 3, # "
,
, ; ;
8, :
"
#
,
" : " " #
;
: ;# ,
:
,
"
: "
: " " # :
,
:
#
, ;
<
:
9, ; ,
; ;
= 28 '0( 1 0$&&$
*+9#: "
7
> :
#
1 , & 5'* 5')&
"
,
", ;
"
# ,
1 % ,
;
;
:
;
,
> 1,;
1 , ;
"" , # "" ""
, ?
: 1,;
1 , "" ""
&
,
;
,
;
, # ,
# #
:
; @ 1
" & :& ,
<
# & :
& # ;
; & "
,
@
1
, "
,
A
#
", ;
,
) < " ,"
"
:
;#> 4 ?
#
,
:
; ;#
;#
"
; ;# = 2 A
1
' '
' '( 1
1 1 1 0
( 8 2
' ' ( '( A
' 0 ( ' ( '( (
( ' ( (0
'(
'( '(
(0 (
' ( ( (0 0 2
( (
0 A
1
' (A
' 1
B 9 : 1
'
( '
( (#* $#
,
(
*+9#: 8 4 '
( 2
1 1
(( "
72) .
;
;& :
)2 1
+ # -,
% & & " : ,
; & ; ,
,
%
)
;
,
%
; ,
: ;
;
& ; , "
:
)2& :
:
; "
, :
; %
, &
"
, ;
& :, ""
:
)2 %
"
,
3
"
; # &
;
,"
;# "
,
: "
""
"
#= >0#7 $&#<
*+9#: 8
' 1 #% &* $&#< 2
1 1 H '( 1 1 1 1 0
(I
*+9#:'
1 1
B 9 : ' H I ( 1 1 ' 1
(
*+9#: 8 '
( A (0
'
*+9#:
2 (
'0 1
B 9 :
'
*+9#: 8 ( ' ( '
D
'
0(( 1
D0 '(D1 0 ' 0 ' 2 '
' (
*+9#: 8
' '0 ) '
(0 '
H '( 1 1 1 1 0
(I H I ((0
' 01 1
'
((0' ( '
(( ' 0(
( 2
&F &F $&#< '0> 1'0 /
> ((
- $<F $&#<3 + 8,3;
% 4 4 !
(
'
'( )
((
(( '
"
75
;
&
)2 1+-% % : 7,
% =
,;
)2 1+-% % C: &
)2
;
,
;#
%
%
,
""
""
%
",
;,
,
, ;
&
5* ;#
)2 1+-% % : 5)&
;, " ""
; #
:
&
;#
%
;
" ; ,
&
,;D
)2
,
;# %
%
& #
:
,
,
)2 1+-% %
,
;
,
%
:
;& :
; :
)2 1+-% % & " ""
;
,
)*5
1 , : :,
+ 8,3; B
,"
(( '0> 1'0/
1 $+ &7 $&$& > ((
- #7$$ $&$&3)
) 1 2( '
(( "
* 9,
"
: :
,
;# %"<
,
,"
:
%
;
)2 %
,
8,3;
," ,
:
,;
"
; ,
E
% & : 5)
)2 1+-% ;#
: F,
% F
)2 %
:
&
,;D
)2 : "
:
,
#
, ;
)2 ;
<
, ;
#
""
;
;#
,
,
1+-% : , ,
;#
: F,
% F& G,
;# ,"
,
," ;
,
%"<
,
,"
)2 1+-%
" : ,
;
; ,
,
%
)
,
%
)2 1+-% : F,
% F
,;D
)2 1+-% C: &
)2
;
,
;# %
% !
5*
)2 1+-% :
,
5) ;, " ""
; # C
&
"
;
" 6
,;D
)2
,
;#
%
, :
% ,
&
;
; %"<
, &
;
#
= 1 (( '
'0)(
/
4 !
$&$# @( )( #&<# 7' :
)2 1+- %
, ; ,
:
;
,
,
:
3,
%"<
,
)2 ;# E
%
# : " ,;,
B
", ;
* # B : B
,
% B
:
# ,
:
;#
3,
:
;
)2 1+- % ;
,
:
;# C B;
,"
,
,
;# %
% & #
:
,
)2 1+- %
1
; "
)*5
1
:
# ""
#
1
; = 2 ( ' ( (1'0 0 /
+ *)/ 4 H
8
H % 4 & 4 !
$% &< $&#< /
( ((
< - *#*#7 $&#%3% # 4 8
$< &+ $&$& , '
(
1'0
/
'0 '0 1
' (
' '0( '( '
A
'
*7% 8
(
*$&, ( 80 ('
'1
'
' ( (
1 , (10 ( '0/0
;,!- $%# #7 #$ $&#<
#& #%=+
*$&,
> ) 1
' '
*$&, (
#& #%=+ 2 1( ( '0 )(
((
(0
(0 2 (('0
(10 ( '0/0 1(
( '0 ) 2 0( 15
( 1 '0 '
('
1 ( '( ( '
( '
0
*$&,
'( '
((
=
0 '1 '02 (
,
( 1 ( ( ((0
0
10
0C (
1
(
1(
#=7 ( (10
#=79<: '0 /0 1(
**5*+ 8'0 )( 0' ( D'
'
0 #F &$ $&$#D (( (
1 '
( 0 E
#F
'0
)
1
D
!""
#$%&#"$&$#
## 1
!""#$*+%"$&$#
#7
D '
4 (( 1 0 ( '01( 0 D'
E F# =+0 (0 (0' 1
0
"#%
!""#$*+%"$&$# ( ( 0$&&< ((
( ((
'
2 (
5,((A 5) 0 1 (( (
C 0( (
'( ('
, (
'
'
'1 (0
(
(' ( 1
' '4
1 0 '( ( &,&
6'- 7+0'8
/"5 G 5 J5-
G! '( J5-