Jatinder Singh Sarwara v. State Of Haryana And Another







     
  



 



 !"  #$ "%"  

 " &

"'  ! $" 

( !  
 

 
 
!


" ) *"



$+,%+-!. "$( "

*"

 ,/ $"0--"' *"

 "(,"-!. ""( !  10(+  1

 
!





$( $2 +!, !"  34"

  "5,$ #   

6 !!

6 "#"! , !"   768
  +  $$2!- " 9,",:$" + # %$ ++ ,25,  ("! #0  #$""0 !$0(,# !"!"!!

4 (! 2' $ "+ ," %$"2' $ ( " $ 2  !+"!  ("+0! !"

2"$"$$"! %"#"! 0 "( !  10(+ %$" %!$$ 0  %$$,!1( " $'"  +   2:

$$"$0(+ !!  6

7 ! $""-$( "#.0""#("(+0+'002"$ 0(+  !:!$" 0""' ' +$%,+! . 

 $"0+'002""0""# $( "%"! #2"! !  !%$ $0
!-$,!:$0(+ ", # ! !," # $ ("!- ($'+ "+  !.+(! 2%  $0   +"!+: #0$"$0(+  !("0!0""' 0(+ -2,".'""+ $(-$( "$!$% $"+, 0""'$"

," #$("!.'"-$".! 0 ' 0""#("(+2, $: #( "$",!$ 0 %%++%"2,$0(+ -2,",! 0""' $"   $ ("; $ $ ("  %,+!  ++%  "1 0""# $0(+ % /22, : #$( "-$ "# !


%,"$",20!$$( "%# #2: %<+ ! 7

6-$""- 2:  $0"$ $,+! (""0 ##0 "0""#%$ ' + *"

 

 $+,%+- +"

! , + " $ ( " $"   !$(",+ %,+!".+$++# +.+!%,+!

0:,  , !"  76=
 ("   - $ ( " 0     %$ $ 0(+  . 2:  ! %$ ." $ ( " .!
!- $' ,!  # "   , #  ! $"" ($'+ "+  !.+(! 2%  $0 
  ,"$" ,20!$"+ $(2% $0(+  !$( "%   ,+  !  %  +' %$  $ ( " ",!  0""' $"  , $$$(" !! #"" "10""#- $   $!2 "#"!


,(("$"#,0 -, + "$( "%,+!"+',( $/,!#0  >2+ ,("0," 
! 
 


    

   

%$" $ >2+ ,("0,"5,$! $ "#"! $++# 00 #"(2'#. #+ ("00""# =
  ,"$" "#,! $ !( $ "! ,+ ( - $ ( "  ! $ 0(+  $. %  "!    0("0 %$"  $ 0(+    !. ! $ $ !  % "#"!2'$" , " 0, !" ! # !!"  ! % $ $ "+.! ++ !(, %$ $ ( " 02+'  ! $""-$! % (,",$


%+!$$ $  2/    

6 !!

6 "#"!   $" 0 5,$!+ #%$$"("! #  ?"

! , + ((" #   2$+  "( !   0(+  !0  $ ,0  0("0  ! ,20 $ $ 0(+ $ 2/ $ "#"!# $( " 5,$!

*"

 ,/ $"0--"' %,+!,20$$( " $!2 !+"!("+0! !".!"!"!!

4(! 2' $ ,"  *- $$2!  ! $++  $ + 2  (" ! #  $0  $ ( " $ 00!  $ , "0  !   .# -  ?: , , "'  $! 2  ,! #  $ ( "

  (" "(+' +! 2' $ "( ! 1 - $ ,0  0("0 $ 2  ! ! " %   :

%+!#  !  $ 2 (+!!$%$+!0 #$  ( -( "2!"! (("2"$"+," !"+ 
$.$"!+"

!, +"$("

 @ $" /,!#0 $$!.+( #;,+ "+     + ("0  0""# %,+!  0,   "(  $  ++' 0  $   0    (". $ $   !!  0""' $ %0 2,$ #!$0 !+"-$ A "( 
A +' !"!"( A2+$!$$   %"  !"0$" $+% +!+! ("0$  (20(, !!2 # $ ,"0# '


$
 


 $2 $+! "#       "!  $    % & ! !'

 '

   '

 !' ()*+  !  !! # '&!'   '

 "!  $+"!  $  "'! ! '  !$' !  '

   &$
$,"$"2 $+!) "#   ' '&  '

 '  ,  '  ,'

-   ' '&     '

 '   !'.  ! .'

!  --'

% &&' +  '"'! ! ' !$ .''  /"!  $0   + !

   ' !

  '  & ' &' & '+ ,  '  &

.  '

 '  &'

- ' '-'.'

-'  "!  $ !' ()*'.''  -  "'! ! ' !$  !

'! ! '   '  !

'

- --'

 '!1 2 ,3 &'42 , 3 &'.5 +( )

)*6( (

 '

7 '   .6

 "8 '''

!'    !

 '+    &'&&'

-  & '  +   !    %'

    + & -& ''-

   !! 9       !   '

.&.  -'.    &&  '

-       ! :  !  % & '

 &- !  !   ! '%- . % &'

!  !!  &.  '  !! +   &&    !!   '  '    

   !! +  !!  !! !'!  ! '!

 ! &  . + '!

    '! &+ &  + ' .'

-. '

 '  !

! 

' &  ;;;;  ;;;;  ;;;;; ;5 !+''.'     : .' !   &. '' '

''&-'&+ !!  

'

 '  .+, '

- ' '  .'!'   +! + !'!  !+    .'

-    '

 '  ' &      .'!' '

-  .' 

.' &!'!  ! "'& ,  ''  !      !'

 +          . !&    .' ! .'& &+   &     '! ! ' !1 !' '

  '

-  "'! ! ' !$+ !  . ''&. !$ !' 1
!

 !&&'

''

 !

' ' +  !-'&'

 ' +  !''

&&' '&'    +



& ! '  !  . -'

'

-+  !!   .&& '

  $ 
"
#$%&'#&"()*
+ #$%&
%
,&,)

!&*"&,&(&
&"-
&",#)*
$"
*$.$"&/
&00)&/

1


-)2$-)-
"
  $2 $+! $!,+$+!$$"  "(%$ $"+ $(   ,!"."4'" 






"
3*
3#*4%&*&.
4*/$-#&*
"&*
%'
,&,)

&#&*&',*&

 
 


*$.$"&/
%$+!+ #%$$++# "(+.+!  +. "+ $( !$"%2"$("00""'-$+ $+!$$ "(%,+! 20!, "   +   '  !& ''

!'       !   & %   ! + '

  !

 !+   .  ! && %'

   ! &'

 ! &&     .'!' &''.  & ' ' ! & ' '& + &&&' '

  ' !

'

-  ! '    ' &  ''

!'   

!

 '   &'&&'

-& '1 !! 

     ' '    & '

 '    !   ! '%'

 &-'

% &!+ !

 ! &      !   ! '%- . % & '

!    !!    &.   '     !!   &&  !!  '! ! ' !

!! +  !! + !! !'!  ! '!

! &  .  '!

    '! &+

&  ' .'

-. '

 '  !

!

     ' &  1   ! &'

    & ' '

 '  '  !& '

'.+''!&!          

                

  
!"  !


$2:#", !$,"$+: $  $ "#"! !$!.+! ,"2'$0(+ %$!  % (,",$  !%,+!$. , $05,$!



      (+  "! # $   "#"!  $ (+  - " ("$$("%"   ,+"+ $(."$(= '"  $ (","; % #! 8 '"  $ 0  # #   $ "+ $(%$"$( "%3'" !%%": # % <+ ! 

("$." ,2'$(","; $ - $"" !$("!."2: $'"


!$$" $";("! 6

7 !"$$("(!$"%$+ #$ $%,+! . $"0+'002"++%$0#0""! 
 2 !$$( "2+ #! :$00, '-%$"$ "( ! %"0$2:%"!+ :$00, '

$'+"+  !.+(!2% $% !  ,!%$ ."$%,+!2 
! $( "%,+!+.$$0$(",";- !$!#.  ,"   $ 0$"  $ (","; $  0""# %,+! 2 +0 B!

 %."- " 2 # #$" " = '" $ ;("! $ "+, ! #$$'2+ #!!" - !$$ (" %" #" # " #$0""#%,+! :(+-$

(",";#$ "#"!$$,+! +."%<+ ! !$$,+! (""00""#+%$"

= $"+ $($!.+(!2% $("% 2! +("00""# $("0:

%$$"$",#$ 2:  " 2:  -  ! $""  ($'+ "+ $( + !.+(!2% $0+ $( "%,+!.$$0 $(",";%$ $%,+!."0%<+ !

$!. ,20!2'$(",";%+++"+'2+$$$"+ $(%   ,+%$$(",";2 #4'"$0- !$( " $" 8'" $"+ $(%$$!.+(!2% $("% %$!,  -2$2 #0/" !(2+: #" !!  " ($'+"+ $( 
+ $$(","; $$0(+ !,""! +' "$$$!2 ,2/!  ': !" $'%" "+ $(%$$$""5, 00 ! /'!$$"A0( '

C$ $0:

%$ $( "% # #0""'$"$+!#!$0(+  # "  (()+  ' -'

- !,  < =& +   , '& !'   !

 '-  &$
 $" $ $ 0(+  $ "2+' "(! $"   *"."- $  %,+! ,"$""+$$0""#% 2 #+0 B! , $ ("  #. #$"   
$(,+"2:#", !,+! 2 !$$$!0!+("00""#- +' $" $ !($'+"+ $( 

/,!#0 " !"!2'$ A2+ ,("0,"$"
&*$"-)*

$"6#
&"-
,#)*'
%'
,&,)

74"8&9
&"-
&",#)*:
  


-$

 A2+(;,"$+!!% " (" (+ !#,!+ %$$ $,+! 2 :(   0 ! %$+ 5,$ #   ("  #   0(, !2+  ""!'"" ("#"($ @  !@ =" "("!,!, !")1 "#    ' .!

 &     ' ''   :  '

-   !''

& !'

- ' '&+   - ''

- !'

 !

! & ! 6'

 > '!+''

 .    ! ! # '&%!''

-   5'-  '  '

'  '  '  >!'.$

6



;$")),
!4.&*
&"-
*'
%
,&,)
 ,,&*
7*&-)'#
&"-
"*
 5

*$.$"&/
5
$,"$2".!, !")
?1

  -'.  5'-   !' ; 
+ )(''      >!. ! > '!1 ! &  !    ' -     

   '  &': '.+         .    & @ '!'& ! '  &  !'

-  '!

!

 && ! .'

 '

   '   #   '&'

'! !''

& !'

-' '&  ' &'  !'

-' &'!' & '

' '   &''.+ 5'-  '&&

 ''

%!''> ''!' !' ; 
+ )(:    !'

-   ''!   5'-    -   . %!' ' > ''!'  !' ; 
+)( :   !''

& !'

-?

 5, +'-%$ $."' "(%,+! 22+$! "0  "! #  $   ! $ !. ,"

$!- $ ," $  $  5,$ #$ , !" 34"

   !++,25,  ("! #  +,! # $ "!" !!

4 !+" # $0  2  ("+0! !"" #, !"$0 - $  ,  $0%,+! 0, 2,$("+%

@ $( ++%!"! #+'

  
!



3< =)9*4&*>
:

 :/D C$$"(: #E" ! E C$$""("2+ E