Gurmail Singh v. Sukhdev Singh And Others
!"# $%&
'!
(! $ )&* $%& &!
+
'!
!
$ ' , $!
-* .&
# / !, -* ! & +!
!
'
$ 0!!, -* ! !+ 1
!
$ $ $& , -* ! !+ 1
!
3& !* + # ! -!# 4 & 5 ! % & !!
-6 ! ' + 78 & -# *# 9 % $! *, :!), .&!78 ++# # 78 1
;!+ 1 ! !)% ++! 1 ;+! .## .! " # 78 1 ;+! & 7 ##.
!
<! $! # ! & +! & 7" & & +! , & +! 1 & !+ 1 $ )&* $%& & # ! + 78 .8
+ +!!" %!" ##
5 7" & & +! % !+ 1 ! 1 , .& +! &! , & # 4 &! * ! !" & +! +!
5 7" & ## & &! .! +! % 6+!, & , 6+! = %" ! > . + 5 !&!
7" & &!!, 1 ;!+ 1
# ++# !
!! ? # ' ! % & 6+! = %" !, .&& . " 78 & !# ! 7 & ++# # &!!" . ##. . +##8 7!* +! & !! 4 4 4 & & = %" ! > . & . !" & !# !, .&! 7& & +! .! ! ++!
5 7" & & ! = %" ! > . , & , & +! ++! & . +!" = & +!% ?
5 !&! 7" & & +! ++! ?
. % +! % 6+! 7 ""#8 &!!, ?
, & +!
++! &! %& & # & . % ##. = & +!% 6+! +!% @ & +! .! & +! . +!" # .! " ?
-6 ! '4, .&& . #8 # 78 & +! .! !" 5 !% & & !!, "! , !! ?
.## !! ?
.! &##% 78
8 & +! & , & " &* #8
5 7" & & +! & !6" & . & +# & * ! & * A6 B;- .& & ++# . # 78 !+ 1 !) & +! & +!, .## & .! ", & !6" 'B & * A6 B;- 5 7" & & ++# & 7 ##%##8 ##. * "+ % !!
5 !% & "! # #. & & +!+# != ;! * != * ++# !! + & " +!% & +! . +!" = & +!% # & .! " & !! & #8, # & " & 1 7@ #8 # & ++#
5 # 7" & = %" ! , & *!8 +!8, "! , .& ! , . # &* !%& +!+ & +!% 5 7" & & ++# # 78 1 # ! 8 +!* #. "+##8 "* +% & "+ % !! & ++# & ! "# , & ! .& !+ + +!!" &# 7 7% + 1 , 7 1 , .& ! & + !&! !"
1 5 7" & +! & !#! ! >, 1 . !@ ! 6 & # + ! & %!" ## * ! & +#
& ! @ & +! +!" , &, 1 .& . # # 7 +!= & ! . # # 7 7% 1
5 !% & & +# # 8 & ++# & , & ++# # 78 % 1 "7#
!
<! # ! !+ 1 , .& ! & % !+, & 7" & & +! !+ 1 &* ## .& & &! ! ##% & +!+!8 1 * !%! # 4 , &8 &* + !+#8 !% 7! & %!"
5 7" & & & 7 +##8 ) +! & +!#"!8 7= & .! " # 78 1
5 7" & & , , & "+ % !! 7 & 1 7 +!" ! & !% & ! !#, ) & .! "
<! # ! !+ 1 +# & 7" & & !8 +!8 ! & + !+ = +! !* + & & # 8 ++# 7! & !# ! ! !)% & .! ", * & +!
!
>
3& ! & &! #! # ! & +! & +! & ++! 7) & & "+ % !! !* 7 & +! !* +
C !* 7 ##. ! & ! &!!
?
5 + & C, !+ 1 $ )&* $%& & # & ! + 3& & & !+! &!7#.
! "
#
!
#$$
% &
'
($
) *$
+
%
,- -
&
". * "./ *
).) )..
"''"0'1.&".2 "''"0"13&42
"''"0"1.&".2 "''"0'13&42
$, - "333&'///
-
5 '6///0& $
'4'///0& - ,-
,- - - '. ) '//'
(
!
" ( - 5 ' 8////0&
9 - +! # & 7* . # &. & & +! . "+# 1 !+ 1 &! .! "+# 1 & . # & 7 %!" ##
.&& +! & & +#;!+ 1 . 6 78 1 * ! & +# &##% . " & # 4
.&& 1 & 6 * ! 1
$ ## & &! .! +! % 6 +!, & !# ! * = %" ! > & ! & & +# & ##.% !" 6 #
"
"
" "
:
;
- - &
,
- ,
4
'
( '//69
1 ;+! #% .& 1
.! ! 6 & # * ! & +# .& +! . "& 1 ;!+ 1
&!! # ++# !
!! ? # ' ! % & = %" ! >, .&& . " 78 & !# ! * = %"
-++# # 78 1 ;!+ 1 % & !! . ##. 4 4 4 .& & ##.% 7!* "4
,
,-
& ($
*$
,- ') "' '/"4
<
& $!
%
&'
( )" * $ ,
/6 /6 '/"8 (
&
/6 /6 '/"8 , = - - +
-
& =
> "8 ; ; ,
= , ,
& -
,
5 5
?
> "8 /8 '/"89 - +! # & 7* . # &. & #& %& & !!
, .&& . !! "% & ++# !
!! ? # ', . @ 1 , & !! . + #8 + ! & ++# # 78 1 , 7 @ #8 & ++#, & = %" ! > . & "! . !" & !# ! 9 %" ! > . #8 % 1 7 . !#8
$ 7@ & +% & !! 4 4 4, & +!, .& . 1 , # ++! & +!% & . ##. = & +!% !" & % D" !!
?
& !%! !+! &!7#.
?
+ (
* * # (
' @ ) "
+ , " % * * # ( - , ' @ )
$ /4 /3 '/')
/" /3 '/') 1= + 2 (;A120 1B7? /)/329
?
3&!!, & +! . % +! % 6 +! * !! ?
7 ""#8 & 6 &!% , ?
, & +! ++! &! %& & # & . % +!" = & +!% 6+! +!% % &" .!
!! ?
!+! &!7#.
?& + (
* * # (
' @ ) "
(
"C" ; ; , "
+ -- .
"
+ " %
+ !
" % / "
? "' /3 '/') 1= + 2 (;A120 1B7? /)/329
3& +! &!! # .! " ?
.&& & 7 6 -6 ! '4 .& & +! !* + & .! !" ! !% & +#% ## & +!
?
3& +! * ! 6" . & +# !&! ! & *
A6 B;- .& 1 & +# # ++# ! !)% & +! & +!; 1 , & .! ", !6" 78 &" 'B # & * ! A6 B;-, .&& ++# . ##. * "+ % !! + & & & ++# . !!7# 8 +!* #. 5 . # 7 !#* & !! ?
.## !!
?
* !&! !! * .&& & +! & !6" & . & +#, .! *! &##% 78 8 +!8, " & #, 1 & , &8 &* #8 5 "! # #. & +!+# != ;! * != # ++# *! % +!% & , ## & !! 7 ## 78 *! "*% ++# 7@ #8 .& &*% +##8 &##%% & !! 5 . # # 7 !#* & & +# & # 8 & ++# 1
.& &* # & ++# % 1 ! !"*% & .! "
C
E! & ! +!* !! ? # ', & ! # 6+! = %" ! % ##, "! , .& & ! & ! & 7 % #8 5 & +! , . # 7 !#* & = %" ! > &# 7 7% # @ 1 , &, . # ! "#
& " . # ! #8 +!= & !%& * 1
1 ! #"% !%! # !" 1 5 , ! %* & !#! ! & & 1 6 & # + ! %!" ##
* ! & +# , & 6 +!%, . # 7 & 8 1 6 & # * ! & +# & , 1 . # 7 7# *#8 +!8 !
"# &
3& !# ! & "" %!* !!! !% & 7* ! " .&# 7!*% & & 6+! ! % 1 . .&# ##.% & ++# # 78 1 ! !)% & +! & +!, .## & .! ", & !6" 'B # & *A6 B;-
#8 & +! ## & +!, * = 7 3& , & +! !* + ##. & "+ % !! & ++# # 78 1 "
4
-## & +% "## ++#, 8, &## + *. & 7* !!
""#
$%&'%&()*&+,-./0(&+)1.&2!
&)01 $%&'%&((&*1('+34&!
&)01