High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2840/1993dismissed

Joginder Singh v. Agya Ram And ORS.

2026-01-15Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger11 pages

" !

!#$% (%)*+*&,

- - &.*,(%/ *,.0 ------ 11%22#,$ 3%/+4+ #6 &$0%/+ ------ %+1&,(%,$+ 7 8 -

/%+%,$ /- 3*9#+ *,.0:

%,*&/ (;&)#$% <*$0

+- ,#6*9# 0%&/#,:

(;&)#$%:

#11%22#,$-

/- #/* 6 0#/6#:

(;&)#$%

/%+1&,(%,$+-

- -

&/ )&,;%,*%,)%:

1#/$*%+ 0%/%*, #/% =%*,.

#((/%++%( 1%/ $0%*/ +$#$4+ &/*.*,#2 +4*$- - 0*+ *+ 12#*,$*''7+ %.42#/ %)&,( 11%#2:

)0#22%,.*,.

>4(.6%,$ (%)/%% (#$%( - -

1#++%( 2%#/,%( ((*$*&,#2 %,*&/ 4= 4(.%:

#.#(0/* >4(.6%,$ (%)/%% (#$%(

1#++%( 2%#/,%( ((*$*&,#2 !*+$/*)$ 4(.%:

#.#(0/*:

%?$%,$ /%2*%'

+1%)*'*) 1%/'&/6#,)% (%,*%( 12#*,$*''-

/*%'25:

#11%22#,$12#*,$*''

&.*,(%/ *,.0 '*2%( # +4*$ +1%)*'*) 1%/'&/6#,)% #, (#$%( - @

/%+1%)$ +0&1+12&$+

#,&$0%/ $<& +0&1+ @:

+*$4#$%(

#$ #0#=*/ #/9%$:

#*2<#5 A&/9+0&1 &#(:

"#64,# #.#/-

, #2$%/,#$*;%:

1/#5%/ 6#(% /%)&;%/5 +- :

$ *+ 12%#(%( )#+% /%+1&,(%,$

%,$%/%( *,$& #, (#$%( - - @ +#2% $<& +0&1+ @:

+*$4#$%( #$ #0#=*/ #/9%$:

"#64,# #.#/:

&=$#*,*,.

+- : %#/,%+$ 6&,%5 +#2% (%%( =% %?%)4$%( &/ =%'&/%

- @ :

1#56%,$ =#2#,)% )&,+*(%/#$*&, +- :- $ #;%//%( #$ $*6% %?%)4$*&, +#*( #./%%6%,$:

14$ *,$& 105+*)#2 1&++%++*&, $0%+% $<& +0&1+ 0% 4+*,.

+#6% /%+*(%,$*#2 14/1&+%+- $ *+ '4/$0%/ #;%//%( /%#(5 <*22*,.

1%/'&/6 0*+ 1#/$ )&,$/#)$ .%$$*,.

+#2% (%%( %?%)4$%( 0*+ '#;&4/ &/ =%'&/%

- @ 0&<%;%/:

'#*2%( (& +& 0% #.#*, %,$%/%( *,$& #,&$0%/ +#2% +%;%, +0&1+

*,)24(*,.

$<& #'&/%+#*( +0&1+- 0% +#*( *+ +$#$%( 0#;% =%%, /%(4)%( *,$& </*$*,.

- @

#$ $*6%:

)2#*6%( 0#;% 1#*( +- :

1/*)% +0&1+ #(;#,)%- $ )#$%.&/*)#225 +$#$%( +#2% (%%(+ <%/% =% %?%)4$%( &/*.*,#2 &<,%/+:

,#6%25:

490(%;

*,.0

!#2=*/ *,.0 #2*#+ #2=*/ *,.0

B <0& <%/% +$#$%( =% 6*,&/ #$ $*6%-

- ))&/(*,.

12#*,$*'':

0#( #++4/%( 0*6 +#2% (%%( <&42( =% %?%)4$%(

41&, $0%*/ #$$#*,*,.

#.% 6#>&/*$5- 0% 1&++%++*&, +0&1+ )2#*6%( =% 12#*,$*''-

2#*,$*''

'4/$0%/ )2#*6%( 6&,$0 #5

/%)%*;%( =#2#,)% )&,+*(%/#$*&, +- : '/&6 1/%$%?$

0#( =%)&6% 6#>&/ $0%5 <%/% <*22*,.

%?%)4$% +#2% (%%( '#;&4/ 12#*,$*''- ))&/(*,.25:

*$ #++%/$%(

&=$#*,%( '422 )&,+*(%/#$*&, /%+1%)$ +0&1+B 0&<%;%/:

- - :

C#4+0#25# !%;* <*'% 0/* +%/;%( # /%.*+$%/%( ,&$*)% 41&, 12#*,$*'':

)2#*6*,.

0%/+%2'

=% &<,%/ +0&1+ )2#*6*,.

+0% 0#( 14/)0#+%( +#6% '/&6

;*(% +#2% (%%( (#$%( @-- -

- 2#*,$*''

)2#*6%( #'&/%+#*( +#2% (%%( (#$%( @-- /%+42$ '/#4( 6*+/%1/%+%,$#$*&, #,(:

$0%/%'&/%:

,&$ =*,(*,.

41&, /*.0$ :

<%/% =&4,( $%/6+ )&,(*$*&,+ (#$%( - @-

A*$0 #'&/%+#*( #;%/6%,$+:

1/#5%/ 6#(% (%)/%%*,.

+4*$ +1%)*'*) 1%/'&/6#,)% (#$%( - @-

- , &$0%/ 0#,(:

#11%#/%( +4*$ +4=6*$$%( 0*+ </*$$%, +$#$%6%,$B <0%/%*, 0% (%,*%( %,$%/*,.

*,$& #,5 +#2% <*$0 /%+1%)$ +4*$ 1/&1%/$5 .%$$*,.

#,5 +#2% )&,+*(%/#$*&,- % (%,*%( 0% 0#( %;%/ 0#,(%( &;%/ 1&++%++*&, (*+14$%( +0&1+ 12#*,$*''- ))&/(*,.25:

1/#5%/ (*+6*++#2 +4*$ 6#(%-

- !%'%,(#,$

C#4+0#25# !%;* (%,*%( )2#*6 12#*,$*''-

0% +$#$%( *,'#)$ $<& +0&1+ <%/% 1&++%++*&,

# $%,#,$ #'$%/ 14/)0#+*,.

+0&1+ '/&6

+0% 0#( =%)&6% &<,%/ 2#,(2#(5 +0&1+-

-@ $ #11%#/+ 41&, (%6*+% :

0%/ 2%.#2 0%*/+ <%/% =/&4.0$ /%)&/(B <0& )&,$/&;%/$%( +$#,( '*2*,.

$0%*/ /%+1%)$*;% </*$$%, +$#$%6%,$+B <0%/%*, $0%5 )2#*6%( $0%6+%2;%+ =% #=+&24$% &<,%/+ +4*$ 1/&1%/$5-

- ;%,

)&,$%+$%( )2#*6 '*2*,.

$0%*/ +%1#/#$% </*$$%, +$#$%6%,$+B <0%/%*, *$ )#$%.&/*)#225 +$#$%(

,%*$0%/ &<,%/B ,&/ 1&++%++*&, (*+14$%( 1/&1%/$5:

$0%/%'&/%:

0% 0#( ,& #4$0&/*$5 %,$%/ *,$& #, /%+1%)$ +4*$ 1/&1%/$5- $ +$#$%( $0%*/ '#$0%/ #/=#,+ *,.0 &<,%/ +4*$ 1/&1%/$5 #'$%/ 0*+ (%6*+%:

*,0%/*$%( +#6% $0%5 +&2( +#*( 1/&1%/$5

C#4+02#5# !%;* =%*,.

#=+&24$% &<,%/ $0%/%&'-

A*$0 #'&/%+#*( 12%#+:

$0%5 1/#5%( (*+6*++#2 +4*$-

0% )&,$/&;%/$%( +$#,( $#9%, '*2*,.

# /%12*)#$*&,-

/&6 12%#(*,.+ 1#/$*%+:

'&22&<*,.

*++4%+ <%/% '/#6%(

$ %

& ' ((

$ ) *

" !

" $ ,

+,*+

,*+!

$ ' . /

, &/(%/ 1/&;% 0*+ 12%#(%( )#+%:

%?#6*,%( A #> C46#/:

A #;*$/* <*'% 12#*,$*'':

&.*,(%/ *,.0 A 0#,(# *,.0 '4/$0%/ $%,(%/%( (&)46%,$+ *-%- (%%( ?- :

)&15 &/(%/ )&612#*,$ )#+% 10&$&+$#$ )&15 ?- -

- , &$0%/ 0#,(:

0#( %?#6*,%( !A

-C- #*,:

#,(</*$*,.

%?1%/$:

!A #6:

&0*,(%/ C46#/:

!A &0#, 8#2 #6 !A- 0%5 0#( $%,(%/%( (&)46%,$+ *-%- ?- !A +#2% (%%(:

?- !A +*$% 12#,:

?- !A %?1%/$ /%1&/$:

)&,$%+$%( )&1*%+ +#2% (%%(+ %$)-

0% $/*#2 &4/$:

#'$%/ )&,+*(%/*,.

12%#(%( )#+% /%+1%)$*;% 1#/$*%+ %;*(%,)%6#$%/*#2 #;#*2#=2% /%)&/(:

(*+6*++%( +4*$:

'*2%( #11%22#,$12#*,$*'':

;*(% >4(.6%,$ (%)/%% (#$%( - -

- %*,.

(*++#$*+'*%(:

1/%'%//%( #, #11%#2 =%'&/% 2%#/,%( ((*$*&,#2 !*+$/*)$ 4(.%:

#.#(0/*:

<0*)0 1#/$25 #22&<%(:

;*(% >4(.6%,$ (%)/%% (#$%(

<0%/%=5 $/*#2 )&4/$ >4(.6%,$ (%)/%% (#$%( - -

+%$ #+*(% (%)/%% /%)&;%/5 +- :

<*$0 1/&1&/$*&,#$% )&+$+ 1#++%(- - , #'&/%6%,$*&,%( )*/)46+$#,)%+:

*,+$#,$ %.42#/ %)&,( 11%#2 0#+ =%%, '*2%( =%'&/% $0*+ &4/$-

- 0#;% 0%#/( 2%#/,%( )&4,+%2 /%+1%)$*;% 1#/$*%+ 1%/4+%( /%)&/(+ <*$0 $0%*/ #=2% #++*+$#,)%-

- 11#/%,$25:

'*2%( # +4*$ +1%)*'*) 1%/'&/6#,)% (#$%( - @

12%# +#*( %?%)4$%(

=%0#2'

<0& <%/% &/*.*,#2 &<,%/+ +4*$ 1/&1%/$5- ;*(%,$25:

+4*$ '*2%( (*+6*++%( $/*#2 &4/$:

0&<%;%/:

2%#/,%( '*/+$ #11%22#$% &4/$ 1#/$25 #22&<%( #11%#2 1#++%( # (%)/%% /%)&;%/5 +- :

<*$0 1/&1&/$*&,#$% )&+$+ $0/&4.0&4$ '#;&4/ #.#*,+$ #6

0&2(*,.

4,(%/ 0 1

2 .

4 5 6 7

2 .

9 !

9 $

4 5 !

3 3 :3 9

2 .

9 !

3 :3

-3

4 5 !

2 .

! $

# 0 9 9 #5 8 :3 $!

2 .

*,!

:3 $&

1 ;

2 :3

2 .

;

2 9 < 8 9 ,+)- =. "*+! >

(

< 9 < 2 . ,+! 2

! %"!

64 < ? .

! 2 . ,+ 2

! 7 ?

3 9 #5 8

3! $

2 .

3 $ %!

4 5

2 .

# 3 $%!

# !

,*+!

:3 *, ?

9 < 9 $

8 ! ,+*- @=.A , 0

3 2

. )%'&- @3

2 .

$% $

. )%'&- :3 8

9 !

. %'&- $ 2 .

3 :3

. "!'''&-

. )%'&- ?

4 5 %

$ . "'''&-

2 .

:3!

. %'&- 2 .

. !'''&- ,*+

:3 4

. )%'&- 2 .

- !

. )%'&- 2 .

97 9

$ 9 !

0 2 .

0! :3

:3 3

2 .

2 !

(

1 & + B

2 ! 0!

2 4

9 . ! ,) " 0 2 !

2 .

/ @- %'&/% $0*+ &4/$:

2%#/,%( +%,*&/ )&4,+%2 #11%#/*,.

#11%22#,$ 0#+ =%%, 4,#=2% (*+14$% '#)$ #$ /%2%;#,$ $*6% <0%, %?%)4$%(

'#;&4/ 12#*,$*'':

<%/% 6*,&/

0#( ,& #4$0&/*$5 %,$%/ *,$& #, +#2% /%+1%)$ 1/&1%/$5

,&/ #,5 +4)0 1%/6*++*&, ./#,$%( #,5 &4/$- $ *+ '4/$0%/ ,&$ (*+14$%(

,&$ %;%, .4#/(*#,

@- , $%/6+ %)$*&,

*,(4 *,&/*$5

4#/(*#,+0*1 )$:

+0&/$ )$7:

,& 1%/+&, *+ %,$*$2%( (*+1&+% 1/&1%/$5 6*,&/ <*$0&4$ 1%/6*++*&, &4/$- %)$*&,

)$ /%#(+ 4,(%/

2 !

! !

/ @- &,)%(%(25:

+*,)%

,%*$0%/ .4#/(*#,

,&/ #,5 1%/6*++*&, +#2% 1/&1%/$5 6*,&/+

0%/%*, $0%/%B $0%/%'&/%:

#$$%,(*,.

)*/)46+$#,)%+:

,& '#42$ )#, =% '&4,( <*$0 '*,(*,.+

/%$4/,%( '*/+$ #11%22#$% &4/$:

<0%/%*, +1%)*'*) 1%/'&/6#,)% (%)2*,%(-

*6*2#/25:

)#,,&$ =% %?$%,(%( =%,%'*$ 1/&;*+*&,+ %)$*&,

1%)*'*) %2*%'

)$:

&/ %)$*&,

/#,+'%/ /&1%/$5 )$:

@ '/&6 ;%/5 *,)%1$*&,:

D4%+$*&, # ;&*( (&)46%,$ /%.#/(+ 1/&1%/$5 6*,&/+

*+ )&,)%/,%( =%)#4+%

,%*$0%/ #4$0&/*E%( ,&/ )&61%$%,$ %,$%/ *,$& #,5 =%0#2'

6*,&/+:

#,5 6#,,%/ <0#$+&%;%/-

- &,+*(%/*,.

$&$#2*$5 )*/)46+$#,)%+:

#6 )&,+*(%/%( ;*%< '*,(*,.+ '*/+$ #11%22#$% &4/$ #/% =#+%( 41&, #11/%)*#$*&, '#)$+12%#(*,.+ <%22 %;*(%,)% /%)&/( +%% ,& *22%.#2*$5 &/ 1%/;%/+*$5 '*,(*,.+ /%$4/,%( 2&<%/ #11%22#$% &4/$-

4/$0%/6&/%:

,& D4%+$*&, 2#<:

64)0 2%++ # +4=+$#,$*#2 D4%+$*&, 2#<:

*+ *,;&2;%( 0%/%*,:

+& %?%/)*+% #11%22#$% >4/*+(*)$*&, 4,(%/ %)$*&, *;*2 /&)%(4/% &(%:

%+42$#,$25:

*,+$#,$ %.42#/ %)&,( 11%#2 *+ (*+6*++%(:

=%*,.

=%/%'$ #,5 6%/*$- - %,(*,.

#112*)#$*&,

#,5:

+0#22 +$#,( )2&+%(-

- -

+>9+ A0%$0%/ +1%#9*,./%#+&,%(

"%+

& A0%$0%/ /%1&/$#=2% "%+