Prem Kaur v. Jasmer Singh And ANR.


    


  


   


!

"

#$
%%&%&%%'

()

#*  #$#+$, - $)%.&&%%/ 01#("

"

#$2 %.&&%%/ 
 

  
 

 
 







   
2 34 
& 

5
 

64  
!"
 #
$ ! % 
&
'  (

  #

#
)  &
'  (


  5
 

64

*






&

 
 


(
 + &

 , ((
 '
 


  
   
(

- .
 

% 

 
  /0 01 *112
(

 
 
 

&
   &
3 

(

(
(

 
 
+ 
4
 
+ &
'
 % 

 
 
** 05 *110&
 
!"

 

!


6 + &
7 ! &
 


 
(
!"

 , ((
8


   "
(
4
 
 

 
(
(
 + 
!3

!
 "
   !

(  "
 2








(


 &

 

 
  

 
4 
+ 
8

   "
 &
( 



(3

  

    

        

    

    

  !

"

#

$ "%&!"' 

"%!$' !

 !%$(' "

" "

"%!' %$ $'  !$"%(!

'  "!!%!('  "!"%!'  )   *  +,    

       !

 *

    -  .     /

  0      1



 

 

   "$(2!

, ,3  



4 4    -        ,  4 

 

!2!$   ,

       

 -    -

 





  

 3 0

0             4 4    !

(!

-    0  5%   

'   

4 4 6 

 ,7        

  

   

 ,  -      "$(2!

 8 -   4    !

!  


 

      ,   -       1         

     

-     

             1



 3    9   5   :

/





93
 
'


(
 &


   



(

3
 


 & 3
"
  

(3

'"
 



 





  ,3 

 -  3 , 3    4 4 6  

  "

(! $   -  ,3-



  

    

 

  

3  

 3   

 

      3        3:

:

(

( 

'
;  
(

  

 !
'  
!"

 &
+ 


 


" <

 

'"
&
(

 
(



 



% &
( 

(3
 
(
  ! ;   "$2!

   <=00 " ;          "$2!

     

 

<=00

;   "$2!

  1   <=00 ;   !2!$ "

!

 <=00


2 ;   4 4 6 -  

- 

4 5   

< =00 & ;   4 4 6 -    "

! $ -  

<=00 $ ;  



 1



 

 <=00

.  = 6

3 8
(

( 
(
 

(
3
!  

 "




' &

 
4 
+  

 
(

 , ((
4
 
(
!"
  , ((
3 


!"

 
9
 
+  + 

 
(&

 
 
 

  
!(

+  > 4
 

(



(

+ &
  
 '
(


 
 

 
( 
 
(

 
+ 
!3
4
 &

 
 "&
3  
(
  
 
3
 
'



 


 
(

&


 
3 
 (
 
 
"&


(

 
 !
'  
!"

  > * 6


(


3 

' % 
(

?





 &


 
(
 + 
!3
3 
?



 "
 
'  !


+ 
(  
;  

 " @ $ '
((

 

 "


 + 

(
! &
  
 "
(

 &
' & 
(
(

3
+ &
6
 '
 !% 

 

; '


;  


-    1

 

,31   

 3 

-

3   

-  .A 5



 

 
(
 
 &


3

 
(
 3
 

 % !

$ "  &
 
 
(
 
!
 

 

 
:*
(

 % !
+ 
 &
*1*5
 

 
*00
++
( 


 

!
 

 % 
(



+ 



(



             

  &
(3
!"


% 



(
! "

"



     #
     $

 % 

 

    

    

 "& $
"


 3
 
3

 ( 
% &

?


(
 3

?



!
(   

(

 
 
'  

 !  

 
9
 
+ 
( 

?

"

 
  


( ' 
(

,( 

"

   !&
!
"
 
 
 &

 





; 

 
3
(
'
6

( 


 

B

?


C;

*

 

 

  &

 

( 
(

 .
!
 "
  
 '
 '
3"



(
  

 
 
! 
(
  
 

 !
 
  
  
  
 '

!
&
& (&

 
+ 


 
  

C;

*
6

  




(



 

 '
!
  




  
3

 
(
   
  &
 
!
  


B
C;

*
*0  

(


 
 !&
3
  &
 

(
 
!"

 
+ 
!3

(
( "
 "&
("&

   
(
 3

( 
6

  

 
9
 
+ 
 
 "

 

 ,  ((

 

% 

 
 "
 ((
!"


&
   "
3



(
 
&
 
 (&
 

 &


3 
 '"
( 
 

  3 


 
(
"
  *0 * &


 !
 

B

?


C;

*
  "
'

 &


  
  
 !
 ' "
4
 , ((
 '
!
; "



B& 3

 
(




 "
( 

  "


(

 
6

3 !
 

 ((  "

?

"
( 
 .
 


 !% 

%  
 "&


B
! 
  "



  
(

(
"
D

 &
C;

*
 

 
(
 
; 
6
 



 




3

 
3

&
$ 
 &
 
(


&

 "
3 
   "

(


  
3

 *0 2 6

  &

B
 
!"

 ,  ((
 
'&


 
9
 
+ 
 
"


C;

*
+?

"&

 
'

!
&

 % 

 
(

 
9
 
+ 

(  (( 

 
** 6

 '!
 

B
 
!"

 ,  ((
 

!
'


  
3

?


(
 3&


?

"&

 .
 
 



B
;  !"




( ' 
(
!

 
 
!
"
%  ** * B
 


 
 "
 ((
!"


 
2@ 0= *155&

 
9
 
+ 
 
 "


 "
 
 &

  
3

 '   
(

+ 

'(&  )  *+ #
  ) 7  . 4  %&
E 8  , 7



,     6    

    



>   , 7

 ,

  3       

    -

   4
(
(

 
9
 
+ &
(&
 
 "

 &


( 

3   ** 2 6

 (
 

 
9
 
+ 
 &
3


"&

 

 

?



"
!
 
 
 
(
( &
 &

 



 '' (
' 

(3


(

 


&

"


 

(&
 

 

"



 
#'& 


!

!
' 

 

 !
 
  
 ((
!"



3 
 
!"
( 

  6
?

 &

 
 


' 

!
%  

 
!
"

!"

 
9
  +  ** / B
 


B
C;

*&

 
!
 




 


 
3
  
  &

 "

 
(

( 
 

(

 .
 
3 
;


(   
B
B 
&


3&

"
 
 "&



3


 !
3

;  4
 
9
 
+ 
 
  "

  

' "
(

B&


(


 
   

   
**

*2
(

 
% &
3 
 


 
(
 "
(  !!
; ?6/! "

 $ 

 6 ,34   -  

  

 @

A 

     0 +  4 4 6

3 -

    0       , 6   A , 

 

4 4    5 

5   0

 

 0 -

  A

 

   4 4   A 7

           

  4   4      ,

  6   - 5

0  



   /;



     6       ,3  4   4   -  

 

  

!" 8

  

      ,3

    



  





-  0    A   

 0 4 /;

3 

  - /

4 ,

       3

0 5

  4 4  0 4       /  4  3    -   



 -     

 
 ,  

   3 6     0   8

      

      

  3  !(%!',
- .  (  %$ #
 + /.

+ + 0 # +/+.)B?/5+5?

0.?4?8+4?;+4CBA?4A*AD+.=5?8+4?#?E=.? 5?48            

 A

   

 ,  5 @, 48 7 



 6

 1

 35   6  3,   



A -   @

 



 

3 

     ?6  /       

     3      

 

 3   3 0   ,    3 

-  6  



:

*2 6

3

 3
 

 

(
(
B

'
!"

!
 
(
 
>/
(

6 


 &
*12=&

 
>5
(

6 
C' 
 &
*5@2

 
>/
  
 

B
 
!

!"
3
3&
3

 
>5
 !
 &
3

 
?


 &

  !


 "
 


; 

 

 3

'

; 

%
 
(

'
 8 
!

 "
 
 

 3


 

;  
(
 
3


 !

 !
 
; 
(

B *2 * 6


&

,( 
 
;   
&

(


3&

'

B
4
! 
( ' 
(



3


 !

(
 "

  



' 

(
(
; 
9 &

;

 



' 
' 

 
 
 



 3&
&


! 
(



  &

; 
(

B
  "
 !

  */  

(

 
 
 

"

  
(

+ 
D 
(

+ 

! !

"



     *+ 1-2 

"



      3&  3+ 4
''$4

&
3

B  
3 
( 

!
  
!"
  
  
6
 

&

 .
  
3 
 "
 

 
 !
 G


3
 

 '
!


 !?

"&
 '

' "
3


< "G
 
B
( 

 

 
(


 
 
 
3

  */ * D"
 &



 &




 

  


B
C;

*


 "

 
;  
( ' 
(

&
3


  
 
(







 



"
3
 &



 
( 
 


3




&
3
3  
 
6



   
  &

 .
( 
3  


"
  !
#'&

B
; "

 
 (( 
 
(


 


"&
 B
 
 "
'

 &
(
(
"
 

 
(
  & 

(
 
!"

 
9
 
+ 


  !
4
 
&
(&
&


% 
  
(

 
9
 
+ 

((


 


*:

+?




( 
% 
(

  
 & 

   
 &
(
"&

 
(

  3


 &
 
 

(
!"
  "

 
6

(

 
 
&

  
 


?



 
(



 &

  
 
! 
3"
(

 



5
 

64 %.&&%%/   (+ (!

# #) Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No