High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/353/1993allowed

Jagir Singh v. Markfed Chandigarh And Others

2026-02-05Mr. Justice Namit Kumar11 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()**+

) ,-

* .

! " !

#### .

/*

-

$ %

&

!

(!

$) $$ $**++, $, $**, %-

"

.

&"

&

! & &"

& %

,

/& 0 1 2 ,, $, $*33 .

&"

. . ! ". !

.

! ( ! " " !

" & !

, , % & " ( 2 "

$*43 ! . ." 2

&. 5"

. .

. . ! .

"

" &"

!. . " 65"7 &!

.

. "

" & 5"

.

!

& ( ! .

& "

.

/ &

" ." 8 & .

.

)9 '.

5 . ! / &

&" !

,, $, $*33 &

! ."&" ! +:

+* $*3* ;

. $3 +$ $**+ !"&( 4* (&

$*:$ &

&

2

& & ! & !&

< ( " & & 3, (&2

$*:$ / . .

!

2

!

" #$

% &

'

( ) $* +

&

%

,

-

* . )

/ = $ 9 .

.

/ = )>.

!

.

?.

/ = ,. & / = $9&" %

5 "

.! & $ < @ (!

$) $$ $**+ . .

&" -

& -

% -

/ = $ 9

. &

!

&" " " .

& ( ?.

. / = ) .

"

"

. (&

$*:$0

0 A$*:$ A1 . & 4* $*:$ B

/ = > &

"

"

. 990$10 1 $*:$ & .

"

"

5 & ( &

( "& 3, $*:$

>

B = $ "

&

" 2&(

B = )>

&! "

.A(&

"

0!! $*:4A .

!

"

$**>

8 "&" $*:$ 4* $*:$

2 /

01

2

2

.

)

) )

!

)

3 :

&

. & ".

A & "A

<

990$10 13, $*:$ & ( ! !

"

/ &! & "

& & 990$10 1 %

(!

%-

& &

<

"

2

"

$*:$ /&! .

990$10 13, $*:$ & .

2

" "

5 & ( &"

& ( " & /

!" 4* $*:$

.!& 5 "

( %-

! *

/

$+

% ! ! $$ $$ $**) $, +3 $**) .

!!"

" "

"

+

$$

! "

,, $, $*33

.

&"

. . ! ". !&"

"

%

" "

!

"!

&

"

$,

% 5 A.

"

& & 99 $*:$

A !

& C

D

!

"

#$$%&'( %)*+

(!

$$ (!

.

"

&" . A & "A 99 $*:$

% ! ?A& .

&" C

.

&" ?A&

8D !

#$$,&%( ))*&(+ / 99 $*:$ "

& & -

. 8 ( <& /C &

& &" -

1 ( -

.

/

011

2 "

34*,&%("#))-52

6

52 17

34%&#( %4$+ %

!

"& 5" "

$*3:

.

% &"& ( '%& &

( "( !

$)

-

!& & 4* $*:$ &

8! &"C

8

6

9

34%&4( :"&/ ;

2(')% . &

2 /4

/

/

3

/

3 )

)

6

2

2

.

( ) )

0

!

) !

!

-

#$

(

5

)

-

4 .

!

6

!

( 7

!

!

)

)

2 #$

.

& '

% 4 8

.

!

!

4 !

.

6

%

2

!

5

2

! )

3 $>

%

.

4* $*:$ .! $9

&" &"

. & & & &"

3, $*:$

990$10 13, $*:$ 2 /)).

< 2 2 0

9 !

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

*#6 1; 1 0 9 '

( )

%

9

0!

0!:

9

:

-

,,

. :

!

9

)

!

) -

) 2

.

%

'

(

)

!

(

-

! $:

990$10 1 $*:$ . . !"& & &

.

& .

" !!

" !!

" "

" "

!

"

"

"

% .

& ( % " . & &. & " . .

"

!"

3, $*:$ . " . "

& ( &

"

. . ! "&

&"

!

"

=

& ( $4

. & !& 4* 990$10 13, $*:$ . &

."

!

!

-

. / = $9

"&

2

5"

.

.

2

!

2

.

" E.&

! " "

"

/ . &

"& . ,, $, $*33 0!

1 &" (

/ = $9.

" &

. .

.

2 / = $9 2

!

7 & / = $9 / = ,.

$3

&

" & &!

"

& 2

&! 5"

-

! / = $ ,9 . ! & 2&"

5"

5 & &

" 5

.

&

. !

!" "

5 .

(

/

$*

- . .. & (!

&"

& ,, $, $*33 .

&"

. . ! . ".!

.!& 8&

&"

,+

/ . ! . A&" & ! A

.

% !

(!

% -

&" &"

"

5 "

!

,, $, $*33 &"5 C

&

"

,$

"

**+ 0 .

"'!

' '=

& '=