High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/534/2003allowed

Narinderpal Singh Etc. v. State Of Pb.Etc.

2018-12-20Mr. Justice Satpal,Mr. Justice Raj Mohan Singh12 pages

# $%&# %' ()* &% !!""

& ' #&&('

)* ! & # $+,# %' ()* +$ " ,$&# $% !!""

' #&&('

)* ! & -.

/01)- 2 3456-. /01)- 2- -5 76562 ( & # -# .&/ &% !

-.&-&%!!""

0 %" 12*-.&-&%!!"" &

)% %/)-# !'&5.&+ "-('

3456-.8 6% )'$2 &/ "" !&/.* $

34 -&%2 '& .22 )'$2 6% !!" & &'&$ &&%)'$2 & 3 - *5# ,'$- &% - #

4 -/%*5!!""

& $%-(2) & 7'-+$ " ,$&# +'2 &# $%/.%$/ &% & &% .'

#.& 88 9( 6%5/. .&

& .!& 3 6%.&%!.'& '&%"" &%& 3 - #9,$!# $%(" .#&& -&% -/! ""$' %"/ 7'"/ & )2- & ""$#2- &% .2!

5#!

.%% # $%-.2&% 2 :2&&2 & ;< ((&%&%/ $"= / &%%%" .= 2!

5 6%* .== "

/ &'&" $&% 3 &*'& ( -%/& $ &% := $% .% && # $%- & 7"

-/ .2 $2&% ""$ %"/ 0!#.& ( 7 >33 :/! '"5= /

&% 2 ://= $ &%('

)*#&&;".& . &5 :/ . !"# % % ""$%"/ :'& &% 2 ?' &"5 @% := $%.2!"""&&%* .== "

- ,!

" &5."'.22&% ""$+* !' 9&/

*5 # =%5'&%$*'&8 5 :/% $& 22*

/ $%$ /% &."' % % =%5'&% &%2. !& /" && $* % 2 ,!/ %

$" $ &2

,!/%$ &&%.& := ""/ :. 2'"& !" )' ,!"%"& 7'"/ & =&%..'!

&&%,!&%& . )' %* .''& &% .&-&% )'%'"* := $%/2 &% ,! :!&&%2&&&% # $%-#!

.% 6%&-

&% &&2 & ;< ((- A9- ;< ((8 / $ & 9 & $& /

.2!"& &%.%""

/!'&'!&.2!"& ""&% ."

2" & 6%!.'& <2 '2*/ & '!!& &. 6%&&2 &&%..'/".'

#.&

( 6%5 &%.&%!.'& 6%5/. .&

& .- & . &%& 3 &%" & "

'& : .-&%! &!!" 1 .'

"!! $ *%"&%!!""

&% %2 &"5$'&%&&%!.'& % "&! &.$ & &%!!""

& 1 .'

"!! $&%#&&'*2 &&&%&&% !.'& %! &.*5 *"'*& @%%" .'

"&%!& $ &%'$% &%)'$2 .5.'""5 > (@ : :.% # $% % " % . *5 "

$ &-;< ( 9 % .<2 & -%!&%&&%&&2 & 7'"/ & /. % ! .*5#9,$!# % /

% / & $ (@ 2 = $" % . '.& &% !&2&2 <2 & &%*5:= $% :'

&%""/ $ )' &%*5&%. 1.&/'

.2<.2<.2 "& % ".&/'

<<.2 ."! .2*

)'5

" $2 $%&/! &

*' < .2 & ! $%&%'"

'"& !"*' $%&2 3 ".&/'

< <.2 '2 $%&

% > #2 . .'"*' BB<CBB .%& *2

&& $2 $%& & < ""5"

2 &% * '

$&/2 "

- .2*"/ $%& !!"

&% . .'""5! $&%'$%! $& '2& ! .2"&&'2" " .' '"& !" *.&' 6 $%&"'

$ 1 '!&'22 5 :2! & '/! &

'"& !"*' & *2 "@""

4 1.& /'

< < .2 & "&"

!.&2 " $%&&% $% A.&'%&2'

2 " '"& !"*' *&%"/" 2* 2!'

.&'*&%* $%&"$ @'

/2' $3< < .2 2 "!.& $%& "$ ".& /'

>< < .2 2 "

!.& $%&& A.&' &2&&"

' 3< .2 '&!.&'!!&% "& 2 '"& !"*' *.= "/%" 6%.'&%- % !

-/%2%$ %.= '&2'"& !" )' 6% )' / &2&2 &' / ' . &&.'&% 5.'" 6%!**"& 2 *&/ )' &%/ 22 & &%!**"& 2*&/

&% !&2&2// &% %' :!!&2&2!&- ;< (:

(@>%2 +'!&/&%/ #.& ( 7

>33110! #%!&%&%"&%.&&"-/%

2% &22* #%"!&%&% &= /&%

2 &% ! - /% !'.% &% .& 2 &% " #%

<&% &-;< (7 #%.'" &&""&%! .&%.&

%.<2 & -*'& &.'"*-.. $&%-*&/

-& -8 (@ 7'"/ & &%2& "/ & .. $&% 2- 3 %/& $&&%* .== "

" $&% A/&% ! /"/ &%% 2&&%* .== "

.& &/.2 $ 2&% ""$%"/ #.&.% 2 : &= /- /%/&%.& & 6%&- .. &*&/ &%.& &% ,!&=!". :/ &&&%!"... & ,!// &%'& '2* !"& 6/! / && $ &%,!$*'& 5 6%5% & 22* 6%.& &/!'& &%,!*5&%..'!

&&% ,! : 2&%#!

.%&% ""$%"/ :2&% &&2 & & &% !" .- ;< (( ' $ <2 & .% - &% / & /."%& "*5&%('*" .(.'& .<2 :% &&&&%&:= $%/&%.& & : &= / := $% :/. &/ &%!& & ;< (( :

&&&&%&&%,!/ % $" $ &2

:/ . &/ &%!& & ;< (( .. $&% 2-..' +'2 &# $%/ &&%! -/%/&% ..'!

&&%,! (@ #' # $%" 7=&& &%&:= /% *&% : *5/'

2 2!'(%'"

3 : & &%*5:= &&&&%

?'&!&-;< (:

/!2 3 &%%'% .*&% "2$ #&& := /&%..'- /%/! &%'& 6%5%.2&&%

.2 5%

3 *&% 6% 2/ +'2 &# $% @ / % .*&%/&"= $&..' +'2 & # $%&%&&%5%= ""%%'* &%= $ 3 *5/5 .' $.. &,!/ &%.& #%." 2&%&%%'* / %'" % "" . &"& / &%&%2 := $%%" $

%*& $2 5& 2 ..'

&%<&2 &""& / &% &%2 (2) &7''&%&"&%&&%2&&* & ."& ! 6%5/ && $ &%2 &%$&&%%' :2 &%&&2 & 3 &&%!" . ,!/!'.*5 !"

# $%*&%!" . :%2 &&% &&2 &-;< -/% .%% %$&.' $ ?'&!. $ 6%&&2 &/&%&&% % *&%/.''&.. &*&/ &%,! #.& 6%5 &% 5'! . *'&&%2':= 0"'

&&%&&%5/!!"<

(@ ,"' # $% && &%& (2) & 7' / / := $%%2&% 2 3 % %' #%&"% 2&%& $%&& & $%%' :'& &%%'

&% * . % %'* #% % "! "" . & "& / &% $% :%'* %.2&= /*'&&% #%&" $%&%&%%'* %.2&= /*'&&% "" . & "& #%&" $%&%&%%'* / *&."

&% "& % * " 2 & 3 - !" # $%- +'2&# +$ .2&%%' %". & / &%.% &% & != $ &% .& % %'- &%5 &" % &%& := # $% * & &% .& 3 6% 22 & % %'* /'""&%%' &%.&!=*5&%..'-%

> %'" 2&%2 3 - +'2&# .22 &&&%2'%%'* #%?'&&%&% &% ..'*!'.*&%!" . 6%!" ./"= $&%2 9

% .<2 & -%2 &&&%&:= &"% 2&%& % / %<&2 &""& / &% $% :% &

..' $%&&%

.2 5.:=

(@3#'=%# $%!&%& 3 - !"

# $%.2&% 2&% .&2!' +'2&# $%-,$& # (2) &7'%".2&% %'&*'&> A &"5- $%2<&)' . ". &%&%% "" . & "& / &%(2) &7' := $%%.2&= /*'&&% "" . &"& % ! := $%%&&?'"

$/ &%% / 5(2) &7'&"% 2&%&%%'* /.& $%'" &% "& %%'"*" 2 & 6%5""%&.%. ! .5

3 (2) &7'2&"!% ..""&% 2&%&%%'* /'" $&# & ""$%"/ $&& $&%2 .

.&& *'&4 (2) &7''&%&"&%&%" $/ &%+'2& # $%%'"$ &%,! $%&"&%&% +'2& # $%/ &&/ ""$%"/ &%,! := $%/ .2 $2&% %"/ &* $ $2 .

@% %.% &%* .== "

""$%"/ - $%&'.=&%,!

$ &&%.& *5:= $% := $%.

)' : +'2&# $%!'&&%*5 &%,! &%/

&% *5 &% & 6%&- !" # $% 2 (2) &7'&%&&%5%2% . &% "& % ! ,$&

# $%-(2) &7' +'2&# $% &&&%. 2*5 $%*% 2 6%5?'&&%&&%5*!'.* &%!" . 9 % .<2 & -%2 &&&%& 7"

* $ ""$ 6% / #!

.% 2* ( .%5& &% ""$ (2) &7'/" $%&"5= / &% 2* $/ := $% 6% ..' &% %'! & 3 : &&% %'&%..' : && &%'

.& &%%'&% ..' :/ &/&%&(2) &7'% "" . &"& % !/ &% $%

(@>2 !7' &%'$%&&%. #% !&%& $%/.2 $&&% %' #2& 2-% '&.2&&%%' % ! . &%* .% &% $%%"! "" . &"& / &%%2&% @% % &%.2&= /*'&%"& -%/! & $%2&%2 $ 3 -+'2&# $%-,$&# .2&&% %' 6%5%.2 ,!2 " &5."' .& $ && '2*.&/( 78 >33 $ &&

'2*,!/( 9 >>> :2&%/! &%%'&&%& & 2 :&% *&%%$ '&&%%'22& .

/= 6%..'/ &.& $8&"= $&%2&% 6%5"&&% .& &% %' .&%2&%& %&%:=

# $% &% <&5 &%.&!=*5&%..' &% <& 5&*'&48 %&%%$ 2&%%' &% .& 3 - % % 2 &% &&2 & 9 % . <2 & -%!&%& &%&..' .-%/&' & 4&%"

4 3 (@ ()"%&%!.2!'& D.""& " ;< (68 > (@4#9 "/ &# $%& !&%&%%& ..'+'2&# $% :"&..',$&# $%

(@#9,$!# $%&& &%&7'"/ & -'

% * .== "

%%"2!

52&&2 &-;< ((-*% 2 A9/ $ & &%2 +'!&/'

&%"'$$$*< &%.& 9&/&= &! .522-;< ( : %.&%&&2 &#' # $%-;< 4 (@9 !.&7 !"# $%!&%& 3 % / !& #:- (" . #&& - &% 6 # $%- 2* ( .%5&-%"/ -%!'. ,! ( 9

>>>-*% 2 ,!/&= &! .522- ;< (E 3 -,"'# $%!'...'(2) &7' &% !" .&& *% 2 :&% @%&2$2&% . .'% * &%& &%!!""

&%%&.%. 2 ". ! .5&" 2 &:=

# $% 6%2& && *'&&&%!!""

& &%&(2) &7'% "! "" . & "& / &% ..' !" # $% !"

# $%* $ & $&2&&%%':= $%%!= .& &%%'&%. !!""

& $%- +'2&# +$ %&"(2) &7'&%&%/'" % %'* &%.&-/% .%/!=*5&%2 %%'-&* $ 2 .

&%2.&-:= $%/ &&$&2 .

@% %"&&%%'* $ $&%2 .

-(2) &7' 2 !" # $% +'2& # $% : / %'" &% "" . &

"& % !(2) &7' $% 6%5/ & ,!

,!/%$ &&%.& 6% . &/""$"5 *5 (@ 7'"/ & 6%*5/ &!&2&2<2 &

6%.'&%/%2%$ %.='&2'"& !" )' 6% )' / &2&2 &' /' . &&.'&%

5.'" (@ 7'"/ & "2% ! '&&2 & :/ ." %& " .. $ & % 2- !!""

& !" # $% +'2&# $%/ &&%..'!

&&%,!-&%'$%%2 &&% $ &' ;< (( (@ #' # $%" 7=/*&%&%. .. $&% 2-%%&%..'&"= $*'&&%. ! .5-&%5 %%&.%&" 2 &% *&%:= $% &%5

9& & *" *" &%& &% ..' /'" % .' *'& &% . ! .5 &% %' &"- 2 !& .'""5- /% &% " $ ' .2 5/$ $ 9 .%%%&%*. ! .5-% %'"% &%"2&% &%

(@ ,"'# $%!&%&(2) &7'%2<& )' . ". *% 2 #%&&&%&..'

+'2&# $%%!=&%.& &%%'&%. =%& %%'* $&& $&%2 .

&% .&

3 6%!= $&%.&*5&%..' &%%'&% ./'"% '! . 9 .-&%.&/!= &% %'&%.-%/'"% &"5 ?' 2&%2 "5 22*-/%%!=&%.& % %' (@ %"2 && &%&%% & &%

.2 5:=

# $% 6%'-&% . & .& &%&&2 &(@ #' # &%&%%% &%...'&"= $*'&&% 2'% *&%&&%& 2

(@3#'=%# $%!&%&""&%..'%2 <&)' . " . * % 2 : % 2 && % . <2 & &%&..'% &% 2! & 3 : !&%&%= /*'&&%..'" $%&"5 :% &&% %'&%..' %% "

$/ &%&%2 :%" 2 &&&%& 7"

* $ ""$ 6%/'"5".&#! .%

2*( .%5& 6% &*" *"/%5&%..'/'" 2<&)' . ". *! -/%% '&% &5 .2!"&& $&&%2 #&&2 &(@>2 !7'-'$%& &%.-" & ! . . 9& &*" *"&%&&% ..'/'"!=&%.& &""%2&%& %%'* *5 ' $&%2.&$&& $2 .

6% &.& !

$&%% ."!= % %'/'"*& ?' -/%% !=&%2 % %' (@>2 !7'/&5 $/ &%% '

."(@ #' # $%" 7= 6%<&)' . ". /= . 9& ?' &*.*&*5&% .

(@ 7'"/ & /."%& " % &!&% .&%!.'& :% "&.$ &%..'!

&&%,!

.. $ & % 2- !" # $% +'2 & # $% / & &% ..'!

&&%,! 6%#!

.%/%2&% 2/ &!'.*5&% !.'&

3 6% !.'& % " & ! &% . $ & &% !!""

&*5 *"'*& .. $"5-&%!!"""/

&%)'$2 & 3 & 6% & .&% !!""

&%"5* '! ' $&%! .5&%!!" 6% * "* .%$ ) #%2 ,'$

: # $%# %' ,'$ @%&%!= $8 F8 @%&%!&*" F8