Dalip Singh v. Baljit & ORS.
!
#$ %&% &
'(
#) #$#*$+ , $(&-%% &
.
/0 %
1 20
!" # $ # $%& 1 20
% ( ## " ) ##* +, -%# .
/" %0%1
"
/ 3'
2 # #
"
4 5/ 4 "4 )5, 6 " 3 # 2 # 2" # ! " ! "" "
3
! / 7"#" !
8 9 6#" " ! " " # # ## # "
"! # '/'
2#"#2
# "
# #2" #
#3 *'
## #2 "
3#3 # " %# '
!! 2
" "2 7"! 5 ## :
#
# "
'
# $% 8
" # $& ! 2 #3 "# ; #
"2
## "
+ & < " # # 3
2 # $ % 8 ##= "2 # 3
#2#
#"22 ! # " " " # ! "
"3 3 ## ! " 3 /!/"6" 3
###2 # " ## # $&
3 2 3
3
- < "# " #
! / #2 #3
#2 #" "2 ! ##"!" 3 % > /!/ " " ! !! ?. 8 # @ 3##2 "! " # "!"2 # < " # ! " #
4 5/ 4 !
"# "
2
" 2 ! " 2 ! *
! "+
!
" 3# # "4 )5, 6 3 32
!
* !
"
# $ %
!
&
'
! ($%$(% #" )
! "* A # "
"
/ 3
+ 3 2#
< 2 "3 B 3! $% & # " 3 $83"
2!
" #
!# $8 "
2
2 / ; " "
# /322 # /="
"2 2 C 5 ! # "
"" 2 7#
! " #
# /
3'
" " 72 ! ! " ,
!
'
&?
1 > "#" 33 #3 . D "
-%# . /" %0%1
%EE# /#/!."5 " 7 " 2 " # 2 /
'$4'5'4 67
'" (6 #*86 0 '$"
(6
!% 6'$" 74'
'$"
(6
&9 #3
-7 #"7
7$+
+ " (6 #*86 0 !% ', ' 4' 6 '$"
(6
& -3 '$"
'( $"
'$"
(6
!% ' #5 '$"
(6 &
+':
5 !3#
" ; #3
"#2
. 0 ! #" # / *
! ( /!0
1 $2 %# ) # # F #&,+? / 3 ! " /!/7 !3# ! " " 0% # 3!
/ 3 ! "22 2 #
"
"
#
5 # " "
"
/ 6'8 * ', !% '8'$ '$"
(6 && ; 0 9&B ', ' '<'$ '$"
$#(6
!%
6'$'4 #,,*$7(< '$"
(6 &
7!7: &B ' ,7
7$86 '$"
(6
!%
':7= 7$86 '$"
$#(6 & ; 0 & G " # " ; #" 27;
#3 #" 3 "
"2 5 / 3 3
#"
2 %E " "
#/!/=" 2# " %&# """
3#2 2
'
""
F6'8 7$86 !% 7$863 ;
- 0 = 2"
" ; #" ;" ! " " ! #"/ ! 2 #
3 " #2
2!"#" #2 !2 2 3 2 # ! " " #2 %E% ##=" ##
"# 2 "
# #2 #
!
2# 3
# %% < " $&(# H2. ##=
3
"
!#"22 ! 53# " ## !2 # 3
"# / 3 # " " " /!/ %&# " %8 # # 2 " !!" #3
2 3 "
" %& #6'8 * ',> ") *= ',! 2!# ""
#2 " 3
', ' '<'$> ") *= ', ! 32!
##
"23 # 53 ! " %&#
4 "" 3 ; # 5
%-#', ' '<'$> "), / (+" # (
!
)
!
/ "5 4
#
6
!
!
/
!
!
7 / )
!
"* %- " ##" "2 #"#2 " #3 ! 3 # ! ;!" = '
#
" " ; #3 #; 2 #2 / ;
2 " "#2 "
7"!
"2 ! %&# "'
""
"
" #"27#
8 '
#
# / 3
/! /!#" "
""2 " # #2
! " ""
# "3
!# " 2 2 %@ " " 2 " #
#
2" " ), #
3 " " 2 "
# ""
$ ;
1 20
&-%% & '* '!
# #( Whether reasoned / speaking?
Yes / No Whether reportable?
Yes / No