← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/14378/2014dismissed

Sheo Ram Aggarwal v. Dharam Pal Aggarwal

2024-01-08Mr. Justice Harpreet Singh Brar13 pages

  

  !

    

 

        

     " #       

    ! ##  #  "      

     $ %& '  ' 

 #

$ % &    '

( )#*#+!,  )#*#+!- . +    )#*#+.. . # /%/%01  #/  % &   (((   ' )  &  2       

" )#*# + !, %!- .. .

 &&    

  3  4  "& 1%    "        )#*# +!, 

        "  )#*# +!,      

   ) )%    6          ,   '

7  * ( 

  "1         )  $   # % 0  "1        "1 

    1   "   &           "1          "1 

 

 1

"   )          1 "

           * 

  !

1 )#*#+.. . 6        . , '

7  *8(

 "1     )  $   # % 0  &         & "

    

%-,%-%,5 ) )  ) +    -

.   

  

  % -,% -% ,%  *9% ! 5 )      ) & :

%0      

   1

" ) 

            8  .'

7  * ("1 &        "1        " 

  "1      

$ %0   )#*#+!- .%    6     

     '

7  *,(

 "1    )  $   # % 0  &           "

  

%-,%-%,5 ) )  )  +.--*   -

.  

%-,%-%,% *95 )       ) &  :

% 0              

   1

" ) 

 

 )           8  .'

7  *("1  &         "1        " 

  "1      

$ %0  .  " %             *   &1  1; 1   "

 1    0&%        

   +%  

 "           

   "1&    &

 



  2   

%-,%-%,%.%.

-%  *95 )      

&  *

       88  888"1 

   2    "

.-'!() )           

    "1      )      *

    35 +   ! 

    

%-,%,%.% *9%.

-5 )    ) &  :

% 0                  35%  

         1        1 "     35  %     &   

"   )

%-,%-%,% *9 ! )       *

1 "  <    " 1  

 5   &   &    - 8

- '

7  *!(%       )  

        *

  

 

"

%-,%-%,% *9=!5 ) & 

  

     - 8

-%     *

1

  "   &    "  

$ %0 % &    - ,

%         1           

  "1       )    

   4   1        

%     "4"   )          - 2%      - ,



 "1    

 $ % 0 %       )     1       & "  % 

     &   6   *

  &        % &%

     

 

 %-,%-%,5 ) ,                  % 

   1   "   ) 35+   ! 

  

%-,%-%,%.% .

-% *95 )%   &    ! 

-

 "1    )  

 

   & "1       ! 

-%      &      "       

$ %0    &     ! 

8    "4

  2     ! 

8 

  "1         

 $     "1    )+- ,

8" ) %   

 &     ! !2      "   )        

         1    

  1" 1           8882%    

   &   1   

%      )  &          ,    &    

"  "1    1          1&    :   

          

   

       ,  %   )  1     >   1" 4 "1   )      &      "1    &        %     

 "

 "

   

    5

        %      ;

  

  "1  0 ?"   )     

  

     

   ;

 

 "1 )  !"#$ %#&'( 

  )3    "   ;

 

*   +,  -,#.  /00

 ()    &  "



)    

;

 %  

) ) "7   8 5            )#*# +.. . 1 "  <  & 1"    %     . ,  

  "1       )

       

   

"

  

%-,%- ,5 )        



 "3 %   * )#*# +!-   .   "

              %     

 "1   ) "1

  "

  

 

"

  

%-,%- ,5 )   ""  %4  &        1

 

     )   

  %    

     

"         )     1 

           ,  %  

&  "   5



       

   

    .- '!( ) ) "    ) % 35 +   ! 

     

  

%-,%,%.% 9%.

-5 )    ) & :

%0  

8

      -

.  

"

6 1%  1

             

 

    &

"   2         "

     &      

" 5      %       

   

"  "1   -

.     &"   "

  

 

"

-,%-%,% *9%!5 )    )  &          ! 

-   

   %     "

 1 &     "   %& )   1        "4 

  2%       & "    %     )    

       ,   &      

       " "    &    &   

 &     5&   

  

  "4  "

         2      "1   



   .-'!() )" )  "

 35+   ! 

   

%-,%,%.% 9%.

- )       ) &  :

% 0  5        35  

 "1    1     0&%"

"     "    )  "1      1%          

   "1   -

.   " 1 5   %   &"

    

 

"

%-,%-%,5 ) &                . , %   

";    )#*#+!- . .. .  &15          %   )#*#+..  .  %&%1  "

        

   

"

     

 ! 

 1       6  4    1         88            &    1         1  "         888    88  

% 

" "   "

   "1  *     

%    1          

2   

 "

";    1                

 1& 1"

";     "1    1"1#   5        



      =

    1 

" "

   " &  &       )

      5 



    

*  "1   1   $   9    0 ?"   )  ** 1,         / ) 

/ /% 4  $

 #@     

*

            



              !  " #   ! !  $  %&'  (  ) *          +    %   !'            ," -. /% '  (

 )

 0   (

 % ' 2  + +      

           " 3+           !   + +4 5-6  ( )% ' * "- !! (7178 * +!+ ! " -             5-6+$+          

   5-6!     (  )% '      ,+!  ( 1& *  

 " 77777 77777 )7" 5   +     5-6(71 *  : ;  *   ." 8&     <  * (     4!   4+!  ! 4" =       

!  

.")7))711          (  )%&' *  ,"- +            3         4 

." 8& < *(

(* %6"

"  '>        

3 "? . $  9 0 ?" ) 

'   2!   / 3

( 3

4  $

 ##    "

& 

1" #    6     !     ! !        

@  A  ("B * /A  ("B* +% CC1')(

 0 CC7(

% ' 2+          #"#"

!"(</#"#" !"(<+% CC'8 (

 & 0 CC (

 % ' C1&2 0 %A  ( /A 

 ("B* +% CC1')(

 0 CC7(

% ' 2+ (

" +  )'

)"D!+! #"#"

!/#"#" !"(<+% CC'8(

&0

CC(

% 'C1&2             $        +    + 4"# !

  ""      !         

!           !      4+4!              "#   "? #+A ( @  #"#" !            +  $ ! !" 7"=#"#"

!"3+  6  @"#4   !+!       ! 6  +    .

6."7& C E ! !++ $ .

6."8C  ." &) C        ," # 

 A  (  ! 6  + +   " 8" -+ A (    ! " -    4    4  !            +  !          

 A  (+      #"#"

!%A ((

"  $&+  '  "F -   +    !  !    !          + 4      +      !              +      (8  "? % 

' -        A  ( !!  "

"#  A  ( !   !   ! +    !  +         "#A (  +   

!    $   4!      

"G$+  ,+  +      " #+            !   !    4!," &"=          +   .

6."7& C ! 6      " 3+   

 !   A  (       !   !+     ! 

 !  +"=!    !  A  ( 

 "

 " #        !  

!    (" D-%(

") )+ ) ' ) "# !   +5-6            !     "-#"#" !/#"#" !"(<+ % CC' 8 (

 & 0 CC (

 % ' C1&2 +    !5-6% $'   "? % 

' C"

   ! !  ! " *  ! !  +   +           "  +       !   +4"      (+         *  !+ !"? - A  &              "1  0 ?"   )  #"#" ! % '   < H

% '% ) 

     "1

        '

(  

 1% 

     . ,  '

7  *8( 

  "1         )  $   # % 0  6       "  )    <     )#*# +.. .

     '

7  *,(

"1     )  $   # % 0  6        )#*# +!-   .   &1      )

6 1% )#*# + .. !- . 

 ,          )#*# +!,   %  )             

       

"   "1      1    &     

%-,%-%,%  .

-     *95 ) " 

 &       !

 "1 $   #    )

% 0    

     %   =       &      "  

) % 0   5  &      %  

& &   

  )#*#+!,  

  & "   

 

  0&%         "  "1      

 "1& ) 

 %       '    

*+,*-. )

4;B C 4 =   D =+ C" D =+