High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1877/1992disposed of

Manohar Lal v. P.S.E.B. Etc.

2025-04-25Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja9 pages

!"#$%$%# $

! ""

#$%& '

$ ( '

&! '(&$) *)& ) * * + ,

# /!! ""

& , #

! ""

01 0 0 '

, # /!! ""

& ,

! ""

22222 *)& $+,

1 ++ 3+ , + , + 0

3 /!! ""

#$%&

, + 3+

, 3- ,+ /!!

#$%& 0 ,

'73

. 0 ,

,,3 3 3+

5/ ""5 73 9: 0

, 3

+ , 3 : ( 4;<" +

33 , ,

+ 0 , ,- 3

;

-3 8 "/< (

; (

,, + +( =86 < "/<+- , 03

)

" #$ %

&$'

% !!$ $('

"$( ) '

% $ "$( ) &*# !!) +& , $ -$"

$& "$ !$ &$.( !$ $( " #

!&&$/

9 + 0

,,0 8 "/<

8"5;0 !

"/<> 3 ,

?0 33 , + ,, 0 3

0 3 +

+ ( 4;<" 03 30 ,,- +

,,, , ,

+ +,

8"5;

, 0 + 0 3

; -3 8 "/< ;, 3A + ,

,,0 0

+ 0 , ,- + + +( =86 < "/< 0 1 ,+ ,

8"5 !

"/<

,, 0 + 0 + 3 0 +

0 + 0 0+

0 + , ,, 0 ,

3 -

3 , 03 0 ,+ :) 1""$ " ,!!

, $ )$ " & #& !$# " !2

1""$ " , !

" #$ !

" ,!!

-$ !. ,,( !

4 -" !! 2

0 ,!/ =

: 3+

8 5/ ""5

+ , ,

333

,,, ,

'73

. 3

, + , "6; , ,

3 ( 5 , B ) 6 )- !

$) !

" 6 7, $ '

4 -" "

$ &$4 " !

,$ &, !$ ,, -,, !&8 1"$ '

!!$ $ & $ -""$ '

#$ $!$$ &*

$$ 4 " #$ ",, * 4 & " , !

-"$ $'4 *'

7, $ , 6 $4 -"$ " #$ " " !

& "

6 $ * $$ 4 & "

6 $ ",, # " #& !

" $('

&, " &#$ $ " , $ , 9&'

" &,'

&$( & "

#4 : ( :

#"4 #$ ",, 4 " !

& "

6 $4 ") * $$ *& ) !$4 " $($ !

" #$ ",,4 " * !

!$&4 * ,&) $!

& "

#& $ 9&'8 6 " $#4 ", " ,, ,*, ,'

!$ &# !

, $ $('

!$ $ !

!) #" !$# " !

$)& !

" #$ -" - !& * $$ "

% 0%

-" ;,'( 9& " , !

#$ 9& * !. ,'

!$ &# !

, $ '

!$ " $ #,'

" ,, !&$"$ ,*, '

% & !

$ &$'

#$ "& , #& # % ,, " !, & !$ $ )$'

& !

" #& " ,*, '

% $!$$ *) "$!$4 $ $ ,*, '

" $!& !

% " ,, -" "

#& "

% * "$( !$# "# : 4 " " #& &, &,,'

* "$( &$ " $) !

7, $ '

&, "$&$/ <

3 33 3 3+

' 73

, : <

+3 0

,,, , ,; , "6;

: 3 +

,, 0 C "/<

3 ,, +

"/< 0 + 0 , ,- 0 B 'D 4

:0 030 3

"/6#B 'D ;

& +,

, 0 3,

, ,

"6;

+ 3+

:0 ,

1 :0

9 , 3 3

- 9, ++ ,,

, 0

+ ( 4;<" + ,

,,0

B+ '

+ <

"/6 + 0, 3

B 'D ;

A 8 "/< ,

A 0 ;4 3A 0 + 0 , ,- , 0 , + < "/<, ,

+ ,

8"5; !

"/< ++++ A , , ,

9 +

+ ( 4;<"

B+ '

+ 0, <

"/6> +, <#<&, 9 " 5

,, , 0 ,

0 -3 ,

,+ <

"/6 , , -3 8 "/< 3 3

,0 ,3 4

: 0 +,

, ,; , "6;,,

4 +

,,+, "6;03 ,

0 0 3 , + , 3+

:+, , 0 8=, : ,:

"5/

,, , E<F

, +, "6;,+ ,

, +

3 +

!! "#

3 ( 6 / , B ) %. As indicated hereinbefore, apart from the provisions of the Interest Act, 1978 Section 34 of the Civil Procedure Code also empowers the Court to order interest on a decree for payment of money in the following manner:

"34. Interest.-(1) Where and in so far as a decree is for the payment of money, the Court may, in the decree, order interest at such rate as the Court deems reasonable to be paid on the principal sum adjudged, from the date of the suit to the date of the decree, in addition to any interest adjudged on such principal sum for any period prior to the institution of the suit, 2[with further interest at such rate not exceeding six per cent, per annum as the Court deems reasonable on such principal sum from] the date of the decree to the date of payment, or to such earlier date as the Court thinks fit: Provided that where the liability in relation to the sum so adjudged had arisen out of a commercial transaction, the rate of such further interest may exceed six per cent, per annum, but shall not exceed the contractual rate of interest or where there is no contractual rate, the rate at which moneys are lent or advanced by nationalised banks in relation to commercial transactions.

Explanation I.-In this sub-section, "nationalised bank" means a corresponding new bank as defined in the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings) Act 1970 (5 of 1970). Explanation II.-For the purposes of this section, a transaction is a commercial transaction, if it is connected with the industry, trade or business of the party incurring the liability. (2) Where such a decree is silent with respect to the payment of further interest 3[on such principal sum from the date of the decree to the date of payment or other earlier date, the Court shall be deemed to have refused such interest, and a separate suit therefore shall not lie." 16.

It is, therefore, clear that the Court, while making a decree for payment of money is entitled to grant interest at the current rate of

interest or contractual rate as it deems reasonable to be paid on the principal sum adjudged to be payable and/or awarded, from the date of claim or from the date of the order or decree for recovery of the outstanding dues. There is also hardly any room for doubt that interest may be claimed on any amount decreed or awarded for the period during which the money was due and yet remained unpaid to the claimants.

17.

The Courts are consistent in their view that normally when a money decree is passed, it is most essential that interest be granted for the period during which the money was due, but could not be utilized by the person in whose favour an order of recovery of money was passed. As has been frequently explained by this Court and various High Courts, interest is essentially a compensation payable on account of denial of the right to utilise the money due, which has been, in fact, utilized by the person withholding the same. Accordingly, payment of interest follows as a matter of course when a money decree is passed. The only question to be decided is since when is such interest payable on such a decree.

Though, there are two divergent views, one indicating that interest is payable from the date when claim for the principal sum is made, namely, the date of institution of the proceedings till the recovery of the amount, the other view is that such interest is payable only when a determination is made and order is passed for recovery of the dues. However, the more consistent view has been the former and in rare cases interest has been awarded for periods even prior to the institution of proceedings for recovery of the dues, where the same is provided for by the terms of the agreement entered into between the parties or where the same is permissible by statute."

Accordingly, we are unable to sustain the order of the Railway Claims Tribunal directing payment of interest on default of the payment of the principal sum within a period of 45 days. As we have indicated hereinbefore, when there is no specific provision for grant of interest on any amount due, the Court and even Tribunals have been held to be entitled to award interest in their discretion, under the provisions of Section 3 of the Interest Act and Section 34 of the Civil Procedure Code."

9 0, 3

3 ( /!! ""

, ,

#+ & 0 0

(

! ""

, , #'

+ & + '

, ,

*)&

- D

-3; ) ;( D

) ;(