Shamsher Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others

  


  

  

 

!"

# $%&%!'(  )) 



  

   
    

 

( *+ ) ,
 , +

  

 !"# $"  %&
  %

'''''

, +

- ) (

  # *  +    "    ,  $ *  ,%   "&   "$ "  (- (.

/./0 ,%  "*1")) "   % + ,% *"$ "$"*""*  % ""1"# )"%*3# (4--

,5#

%$"

*" "*$" 6+&" " ", "

/

8#"* ", *   9 **",% 
"$%  #"!

#   * "      "$  "*  $" /- %  $" ") # :/%$"*""& $ *  

*  *"!

* "*$"/-% * "    *  #"%  ##"#"$ ") #$* "

"  !#")) %!

"* ""$%"!

""$ 9 **  **  "* , ** **%#* ,%  "*1"))

 "

* $ ")

,#"!

# # "

(:0(;

./ /.(< 



"* #
 "1 % 
# "0;=2/323 0;=2/32 3 <.= "$ 1
# "-"$ 1
#,%  "*
 " 9    !

5 ).= .- /.(<   *

 #"!

# "# , ),1>>(:4:>?"$/.(< *,$"

1" + "./ (/ /.//

:

8#"* ",

,)  ",*""*$" +& "", "$"

"+! , 

,* " +

"% "$"& "* "

, ! ""$

 #* ) ,*#" #""$ # <

$ #* )"$ "$"*""*

,) ", 
"$% " *",*""*  $ *"

,  "*,%

)&

*""*

 ,)   
# "=203"$ ""

1"# )"%*3# /.// #"!

#+ " ",+  *%" ")$"* $ ** ** $ $#")* ""$<%"$

#2 #* )6 ))"$+"%  * "3  **, *"

*"* "+!  $ *")&"%#

* $#"$ #    "!

,% 

"** "#"*", !   ,)  + $"$ "    ) "    "* #      #     "  *""*   *" + #

*+"* ! " * $ "$ "  # +

,#"!

#+ "*" ,% )"*%  ,)    !

$# " "

0 , #") %  !* *%5# 7"$ $"*""*

=

 !  *#"*$","  

! " "

##"#$**%

;

*  "$     # *  +    "  $ *  ,%   " "+ "*#%) *""#)" #" "$   #  6# $"   " + ,%

7$""*+5#,%" "  ,#"$

  * "  &  "*  $ *  ,% 

)  ,$"    
   

1" #" "*%" * " ,  "*% +

*!* ) "$ #* )"$

="$ # *+  "  *" , " &*""*$" ""$ =+& $" ""$, *  "$"

"+!  "**%,**

  ,$"$% *7 *" "+

"&", "$"

) "

 # *+  "   @   "$  )  1"*"%    1 %      % A          "  5#     7  "$   "B*""*  ) " !

" # ",% #   "* #
 "1 %

"$"" !,  
 ** 

# ) ",% "+"!    

#*  $   ,  #"         "   ""

"# **  )"  "$% #"

"#)%) *    $$ , #"! *%) " # *+  " +

6> $#  #")* !

)  *,*%$ *""! ""$7 )$", *

"$"

)*$"% "** "

-

*"$
# "=203"$ ""1"#

)"%*3# /.//)& ,*%#* ), ,* "!

"$" ""#*

*""* "","+, *$

"$*"  

") " "*

* "  "$      "   ,  $"  $*  ,%   #")   %  $    ! "      "    )% #" " " "

",*""*

"+! +  " " ") " "5# "** ""$

 "* $ ,% + $"$ !"$

*  )%#" " " ,*) "$ + $"$

 #",) , "

$ 

"$ ""#* ) 

",*" "* ,5#"$*$ **)"$ )#" " 

""1"# )"%*3# /.//  

" !"# "% !

"

!"#"**#%

,*) *" $$# !"$ # "$" ,% + $"$

+ $ "$      "        "+   "+  #     !%" # * *



)    # !,%  ",+  "$# " ,% " +

# %" "$ " #**%) #

" !"*# %) *"#"  !*, * %"$ + $"  $) *%))," ## %" "$ ""# % )" ) $" # %"$

1"

(.

!

,"!$    # *+ "   #"7*%  %"$

*""* #*  "+!  )#*  *"$ +  "+"*"  %) #* "$")#*

)"%*$")

")*+  $ " , "$ $* ,  ! #"

 " )&

) *"

"$"*

, +

  "!),(: /./:

  & D" D "

 ",* D "