High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/1720/2013disposed of

Madan Singh And ANR v. Ut Of Chandigarh And ORS

2015-09-16Mr. Justice Dr. Ravi Ranjan26 pages

"# $ %

&'

( ) *+ ,

,)

,

#-. / $ $

!

"

#$%%&'() ()&*+

, - .

!

"

./

!

"

012 !

"

#%%&3(4 ()&3+

5 (#%%&'() ()&6+ , ! , !

"

" %$

$ + / "

"" %

7 !

8 9 :$ 5 4;

&;6()&(

6() 643 64' 64< 6'& &()%/$

"

1! 5 * =

>&

2"

#"" :$ 5 &(3

&)4()&6+ 2

!

"

6)4 6() 6&; 643 64' 64< 6'&&()%/$

"

5 & 5

5

"

"

2 "

"

2!

:$ 5 4;

&;6()&(

6() 643 64' 64< 6'& &()%/ $

"

1! 5 *

=

" 2 ""

"

"

2

2"

!

" 2"

"

" "

%"

"

!

!

" "

!

"

8

!

"

2

2 > $

!"

!

?

#

@$@> 2+ "

&<4())& !

?

2

"

"

75 '4< */& " "

2

"

"

5 &%&(4$

" "

!

/%&)& A?B $$$$

$ "

@

#

+

2:"

2

3;())& ((6())(

!

"

522

$

"

"

"

2 $

.

"

8

8

-

,

=% - CA=%$ "

9

.

1 1

&3&&())3$

"

$

.

0

(64())&

8

"

%%.

"

$

.

1 1

8

2 2 - C5

"

"

"

!

28

-

,

.

1 1

2

"

"

"

" 22

=

%& &;6()&(

8

2

&&

"

2$

&&)()&)

(;;()&&1@

!

!

"

;)) )))>%

"

21

#

@B@+ "

"

1@

!

"

% 7 !

"

(*&()&(

1

1

1

2 "

,

=

"

"

8

"2

"

"

2

8

!

:

&%

"

" 2

8. $

7

""

2

"

2 "

2

"9 "

! :$5 4;

&;6()&( .

1

5B

2 *&*())38

2

63 )))>% 9 2

"

8

2

3)))>% 9 2

@ . $

" -

2

2"

"

2 8 2 5 /8

&' $$$/8

;71:/8

&'

!

9

:$

2

)

"

"

"

!

"

- C

"8 :$

!

2 "

"

""

2"

" 2

2

2

2

2

2

&;34-

! "

%

2

8

2- C

"

"

!

" "

2 !

2

:$" ! "

!

"

;&(()&*

- C

9 9

!

"

! " 2

"

2

2

2 ""

""

""

!

!

!

!

"

2""

"

!

2

8

"

2 C

!

8""

2

"

!

"

$!

"2

!

2 !

"

"

2

"

!

"

$!

"2

.

?

2

2

" A

" 2 / : 8

8

1

2

" ?

" -

2 " 2 2

=

2 "

"

!

!

"

"

2"

2"

2

!

%

"

"

"

! 2

!

2

- C

"

2 2

!

/$ "

="

2 !

"

9

"

29

22

! 2

2

!

!

2

%"

!

!

2 :$ " 2 "

"

:$ !

"

%

!"

# $%%

!

&% &

'

(

) )

!"

# $%%

!

* +

+,-

)

,

!.

) )

/

0 1

! 2

-.

+

!

.

"

# $%%

) )

.' $ # % &

# ! .

#% !

) )

# !

3

4

*

& ) )

5

0+

2

3

4

!&,6) =

:$ "

"

>"

2

2

2 "

!

"

!

2"

!

2!

"

!

2

2

" "

"

2 "

8 "

8

"

2

"

"

"8 2 "

!

"8

"

$!

" !

2

"

2

!

" !

"

"

D2

2 E 2 :

$ !

% &:

" !

?

#:?+ (:

!

?

#:?+ *:

7 !

?

#:7?+

- C -

, C

" "

1@

2 $

"

"

.

, - "

2

2

8

"

- C

2 ())3

8

7 !

(;;()&&

9

!

"

2 " " !

2 8

2 "

"

- C

2

8

5-

;3()&( =

>(

2

2

"

!

"

" 22 :

&%

(&3())&

22

"

22

"

8"

2 ())4

$!

"

2 8

F

"

2 )<"

29

"

"

2

"

"

2

2

$"

=

*6)

.$ !

2

, !28

" "

""

"

"

2

$

"

"

"

"

- C "

2

2

8 1

A

"1

?

? ('&)&;;; (<&)())&

" !

2 2

2 >

$?

=

"

1

;; 2 "

1

"

"

$

" "

" "

$

""

"

"

" "

B"

())&

" ()&& !

*&<()&* "

9 2

$ "

9

5 (6(6<

()&( 22 "$

?

!

- C !

2

:$ 5 ( ())6

"

"

/

%&

""

&**()&&

!

9 2 "

"

"

- C

"

"

"

1-

*)6()&( 1$- =

>3

"

!"

C

8 "

2

"

(<<()&(

!

2"

"

2 2!

('<()&(

"

2

0 "

!

2

"

&&(()&*

"

2 "

"

!

"

!

8

"

!

2 "

! 2 "

1

2

22

"

"

!

22 2"

"

!

"

"2 "

"

!

"

" "

"

8

"

"

2

!

&;34#

@

@+

&&)

&&( !

"

"

"

*3

!

2"

"

"

"!

&4

" "

*& ** 6)

, *;

"

B"

" " !

2

!

2

!

:$ "

! 2

2"

2 !

2

"

2 !

!

2 "2

2:$

" 9

2 ""

2

!

!

%

"

"

/C"D

" 9

2 C

2

3* 4

* (5 2

"

5

!

2 ! (*3 (*' (*;

!

-

2?/

!

2

!

8

"

"

A!

)

*;' *;<

"

9

2

*;;

F

!

1

$ " 5

#1$5+ ())4 "

! " "

"

!

!

2 " "

"

"

2

!

"

"

"

!

"

B"

"

$!

"2A!

;3()&( (63()&("8"

2 2

"

8

" "

!

"

!

"

2"

"

"

!

2

$

.

2 "

"

"

" "

2

" "

!

2

9

8

8

!

"

2 !

"

2 2

" "

!

"

" "

8 2

"

"

:

!

"

!

"

!

"

!

"

!

"

"

2!

!

"

"

%

"

!

!

!

"

= 2

%

"

"

"

2

"

" %

"

"

2"

!"!#$%&!

"

' (

!"!#)#%!

"

* + (

,-

.

!"!.)/%

1 0-"

# !"!.

. ( (*

&(0 $)$ ""#

"

!

2

" "2

=

"

"

"

!

"

:$ "

"

""

"

&34

!

2 C

2 "

"

"

( 1 2

!

- ,

$$)02! " $#

"" !

8

" !

"2

$

"

/ "

"

3

*"5&(

02! "

#/ &6 0

( ' '

# "" " $)

!

2

$!

"2

" "

2

$!

B"

"

2

2

2

"

"

!

!

$!

B"

"

"

" "

2 " "

"

2

"

"

$!

"2

=

"

" ((4(('

$

6<(

0

4 (

8

/ !"! " ( /$

=

"

="

"

2

"

"

"

!

"2

"

" " 2 28

="

"

"

"

"

"

"

=

" 2

"

9 1

( 5"

&

! 9 1

(

# ""/) / " 7 @

$

" ="

"

7

" ((4

$

"

=

%

2

7

=

" 2 " 2 ="

!

2"

!

" 2 !

" "

"

"

"

!

"

2

2

"

"

=

"

=

% "

" "

2

"

!

2 !

2

"

2

2 2"

8

" "

2 "

"8

2

>

2

5

2 0(3&6 # !"!" ( $) !

&34

"

!

%

"

" " "

"

!

"

!

"

"

"

"

"

"

2@?

"

!

"

"

"

1

-

!

"

8 "

28

! "

"

2

"

"

2

"

"

2

!

"

2

!

"

"

"

"

"

8

'

8

# : !"! " ( /

""" "

"

"

2

!

"

" 2"

"

2 !

! $!

B"

!

8

"

""

"

6(

( 0

(

,-

# !"! " ( /

"

- 2 :

# !"! " ( :$

!

@

$ &

,-

# !"!$" ( .$:

7 @ =

= !

!

"

!

"

=

"

"$!

!

"

"

"

" !

=

:

$!

B"

#:$B+ 2

-

$ A

1

2

$"

=1

"

= 2

/

$!

"

=

"

"

"

! 2 "

!

"

2"

$

$

"

%"

B

9

!

2

:$

2

2"

2

"

7 !

""

:$ 4;

&;6()&(?

"

0 !

!

2:$ "

2

!

2 "

"

2

(;;()&( "

"

2 !

!

"2

%"" ?

" "

"

"

"

!

"" 2 "

!

$!

"2

8

8

"1 - + ( $$ !"! " ( # #

@ =

% & F

: $

2

8

"

! ""

2

"

2

8

"

"" ( F

: $

2 ""

2

:$

" "

C

2!

2 "

"

&34#&+

="

! &33#(+

* F

"

:$

"

! "

"

2 "

"" 6 F

:$

"

C "

2 % C !

"

"

&33#(+

, 3 F

:$

2

"

"

" "

"

"" 4 F

=

2

!

#

" "

+

"

"

>

""

!

"

! ""

!"

2 ' F

"

2

>

" 2

!

8!

"

"" !

!

"

=

"

"

"

"9

"8

!

!

:$ 8

"

""

2

2

"

" :$

9

!

2

"

2 2 2

2

2

2"

*;'*;<

9

2"

"!

2

)

"

!

2"

"

:$5 4;

&;6()&(

6() 643 64' 64< 6'& &()%/ $

"

1! 5 * =

>& 9

29 "

9

2

"

9

6 $ 7 $ %

&'

( ) *+ ,