← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/737/1993dismissed

Block Development Panchayat Officer v. Sadhu Ram

2024-03-20Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj15 pages



     

 







 ! "#$# %& '(('(') *

+ ,*      -- 





    

 

 &  .*    ,   /



   





! "#



&  ,   /0 

*

'$( % $  ) *+

 ) ")( +  , - 

* & . - /  *  *# 1) % 

2 #3 ( 

 &, 

. - 4,. --

 ")( +  

 --

   + 1) % 

6 $0 (( 7 $+  + 

$$

 +

 (

"+

 '$ $( 8 0 + #

'

 +  

 -  /  -   7  (

   -   $( $$ )%

#   +



9 % # 

 $$

2 *+% !( +%0 52  2  %

%  +%) % $$ +  * (

(# +%0

52

 + +%0   (  (

/ /   2  !( +%0 $  2% +% 

(   .    2 0   % #8 :%

( ( 

.,

  2  '

 $$   ( +



)   

(  ,,.

   % 2 +8

 #

( :% # $+ ;  *+% 2%(

+%) % # %  + 4+(  -  -.

 + $$

 ;  :%

( % 0  6 ( 2% ) + 

%

)

2  -  -. ;+ #$ 6+8

5( +%0 <$$ + 9 2  

$$ % + )  6 ( % 

 % (   ) 6 ( # ( 2)0

"+

+  2 %$  % ( 2% +% 2

++ + 6 ( *+% 2   9 2

+ $$ 2 +  + *+%

) 52 ++ %$ 6 ( 2

( +

$$ 

  +  +(



(  

 +%0 +

 %$

( +  # $+   (

+

!( +%0 =% $$ 2 '+

*+% % ) " # (  % (

  -./

:%  ( + % + 4+( 2 (



/-

  :% 2  #"+   (  (

:% $$ (  *+% 

  -.

%$

/  -.

+%) 2 #  $( % ( 65<

 2 +%0 +  %   -.

2% 1

(  6 ( #+( *+% $$

2 + ((# !( +%0

 + 2

%$ (

3 0 ) *+% 1

(

$$ ) % % ((# !( +%0

) +

)  (   +((  % ( :%

  + 2  +( 82 # (

  + +# 1

( *+% ( 

 +    -  ) $$ #$

65< % 

3 

 $  (

% ( 2%  + 

  -

2 

'$



2  34 $( 2  '

 $$   + +  # )   +% ( 

3 0

++ 50 + +%0 1%

 (

:%   $$ 65< 2% $ # 0

$$ + $$+ +0    -  

)

  ( 

.,

 2  + 



 -  /  - 

/

9 2 $%    +

)

% 7 % "  +   *+

/ >?

"# !( +%0

+

-/  )

(  % 9 2 $%    + ( 2 (

# $$ +  # ( ++#

(8 ) 0  $    0 +++ ( 

$    0 2% % + # *+%  ((#

!( +%0 :% 

3      

,

 -.

 + 2 ( 1

( *+% 0

  - 

 $  ( % - 0 :% $$

+ # *+%

/  -.

+ )

+0

0 + % #

  # 0 

/  - 

* + + )

 #0 + # ( 

"# !( +%0

+

-/ %+ ( 2 #

(  

,

=  ( 2  '$ 

  #"+ 

+ (  # 0 + ) <

(  $+   # $$ %

# *+% % #  ) 

(   $ 9 2  + '

$ 2

+++ %   "# !( +%0

+

-/ 2 

%( 9 2 )  %)%

$$ )  + + +  %2

1

(  $ % +%) 2 %   +(

% %

 )

2 +% #8 2  *+0

!( +%0

. -.

 0 2 ( % %2

 ) $$  

.,  

$ $$ ) '+ *+% % ( 

0

 ++ +%0 " ( 9 2 



3 0 2 ++ ) $$ 

 +   " + $  0 #  ( 2

$ # 

 

  -  2 %$ 

+0    -   ( + # + 

  9 2   $$ 2 ( 

$( $$ + +%

   -  -  50

+ +%0 % )% ++ (  

+((  % (   $$ )%

# ( 

.

< +(  ) $2



$('

=%%

 $$

 

"+

0 @<

=%%  + +0 (

)

@ <

 =%% 

 % ( @ <5

  $

2

    + +  + 

( *  *# 1) %   ) % +



&

+ '

   

           



 

     



        

  

   !



    "#



   

     $%&'() 



   "#

  $%&'*

  

 

  

   

       



    "#

 

 "



 "# 

 

 

  





 

+  

  

" 

  

  %       



  "#,

  #  $%&'-*



 





  "# 

.

 % 

  





  

   /  "#    !



 

 

+    $%&'-*

  

 

    !



 

$%&'- *







+  

  

          

         "





     !



  

   

   

   

    !







  #  

     

 

  $%&'* 

   !





 

 





  

 

$%0)-1

   !



 

   (-&-'0    

  

  -2

  !3-1 4

 !



  

 





    

  $%0)1 

    

  !





 

  "  

"   

 



          

+     

 "  



   !







        



  !



   

  

  

      



 

  62 !0      

  (()'0    "  

 

+   



    "#     

 

   62 !*      

   2 

  "

  

   



  !



   "$%&'-*

!

    $(**'

  #



+     $%0)-1



 "#7

62!* .

 $  



         2  62!'  

"



 

    )'

         2    

 "

   62!(    "#

 (&)'0

  $%0)1

 " 

+  

 "#      

    

   

      

   

 6  

$ %    

   

 "# "  "



"62!0   

    .

$  



 



      

 

" 



4

$ 83-

 .

$  







 



   83- 8   62-!)

 62-!&   .

$   



  .

$   83-

 -2

  

3

      





 )'( "

 

  #   

             

  

 62-8-         8  8  

  

    





4

$  .

$ 





 !



        *-0-)(



  

 4

$ % 

   #    #    

   "

  

 

           62-$-   

 



 

 #  



    

   



    "    

 ,  

    

  

  

+   *-*-)(     **( 

  

  "            

 #  

.

      

     

      

      !



% %  9

        

       - "

   *0)(   



   





   .

   



         

   " /"  "





     #  

     



   "#"

  

   



  

    

2 

 

  

628           "

# 

62-8- 





 8

 0    

 2     "

 $ 8 8 



 "   %  



+     (-&-)'0 

 "

 

    

" # 



"

 

 " 

+  

      

 -2

  !3-1 4

 !



          

     

 



2

"

   

    .8  !:      

 

 



  " 

 .

!3-1 4

!





 2

-

-       

 



   

 

    

 

     

    

 ,   

   

  

 $ 

 

 

  

      

      ,   "   

   ,      #   

        ;%       

 

       "  

        "   



  



 

 



"  

2 %



 "

 

  "     



      ".8 !:  "

  

8  8 

       %



 %



 

 83- 

 

  %    .8!:     

   -2

       

  

   

  

    2   

   

  

   

  

     

 $ 

"  

2 % 

       2 



     " 



  %  

 

     

   



     

+

   "    



  



 

 

<

(

-

9 2 % % *  *# 1) % 

% 2  + 

++ %

3 0 ++

'$ (    +

 '65< #

3 0

% #

) ) 2   

#+ 0 +%

+(( + 4 + 

3 0 + ) 2 (  5=

*%) * )%   6+8 5( +%0 <$$ +

%

+';(   9 2 % %  + +0 (

%+

)

"+ )% # )

$

$$



:%   $$ 2 ++ )0

+ % +

))  %$ '$ $  

#$  + 1) %    ")(  

 --

   + 1) %  (   

+ '

& 7     "  

 

      #  

   

 "+  

 "  

  "

 

  

    

    2

 "#   

  $0)1



   2



"  "#  !

  -      



$0)1

   -

 

 



  "#6

 %



   

   

     "#      

 "

 

   

      !



 



 

   

 

 

    

$%0)1



   

 "  "



 "# % %   







   "

  

 

    

"   



     



     "!



, 

 

    

        

          -     "

    

       #  

 

 

  





       

  "       



  

 

    

 

  

 

   "  



  

 





 :



% 

   







   

   



  

    "# 

+   

 

 

 %  



        



 

 

   # 

   

    "#%   

    

   =   





 

 

  

    "#    "

   2    

  "  

% 

+   

  

  % "   

    "#       "      

   

   

      

  $%0)1 



  (-&-'0 

 

  "# 

'

13  

 

  





 

   628>   



%  

 

  " "

 



"

<

+   2 



A * +  #%$ '

$ %   % )( 0  + $$+

#%  $  8

 +  + %

2 (#77(  $$ :% + )

$$+ +0  )%0

 5( 9 2

)  % $  +  +



+ 

3 0 2 ++  2 $ $$

 0 $+ 2  (   "# !(

+%0

+

-/ + + 

(

(   $ !( +%0 + # 8

 %  % "  +  +%   )

4+  8 +( % 0  

+



& % )( % #  

/

% %  +  

%  ")(   #2 2% +% % #

#"+ ( +%) #$ % 

,

6%  % ++0 % '

$ % $  + 0 + + # 2%$

'$ + #  % +   0

3 0

% (  +# ( $( $$ 9



2   +

   + 1) %  %

+ $(  

 .

 --  2 )%

$( % *  *# 1) %  + 2 +

  

  2  :% + +

 

 *  *# 1) 2  +   )

+  (  9 2 0 + $( 

   + % # +



 +% 2% +%  + 9 2  +

$$ % (  

2 +% #8 +

 #+ ) % (  +%) !( +%0

2 + 9 2  + # 0 '$

 $$ % %2 (



/-

   + ( 2% +% +% + +  #

# % '$ < ++ % %%

+ + + ( % + ( ( $$ 



$+

3  # 2 )  9 2 

 + $$ % + + )

((# !( +%0 %  #(  % ++ + +

#    ) % % (    0

( #  ) % (

# + ( 2 

4++ + + 2  % #

 '

 $$ :% +( ++ '$ 2

 + ++

+  4++ + +

'$ 2 #  $(  + ( +0

9 2  + $$ % (0 (  0

)

+% #8 " (  ) % ( $ +

 + +  ++ *+% % $  (8 

0

+% #8 C 

3 0 % # ( )

0

+% #8 # +  +

$$  ( + % # ( +0 +

+% #8 + % 2  $+

+ % %

+0 %2 #  ( + (

2

0  0 ( # % ++4+  

$+

+% ) !( +%0

.

6 



 $$  7

#  $$ + # + )

 ( % 2

0 %$ &% % # %2 %2 +0 + #

 + (0

8 20 2

9

  

2 2%  + )) 

% # 

 2  + + # %

 % % "  + +  +% + (

-

9 #+ 0 + + '

$ % ++  ) +  

)     # # + 

")( +   #   0

$ %



:%





++ )0

( 

:% ")( +  , -   * 

*# 1) %  2 ")( + 



 -- 

   + 1) %  

$$ (

1

 ( +  + >?

0 %  >?

 ++ )0

4"5 '(0 '(') >,   / 4 4

 3 #

/   ?@/   3 "   ?@/