High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2023/1992dismissed

Om Parkash & ORS. v. Badri Nath Kohli Etc.

2015-02-25Mr Justice Jaswant Singh17 pages

!""#$%$&' "()* )+,-,

"#$ % &

'''

( )* +

&+ - ./ ( , -./

)"%"&!'

* 0& 1 23 4& 5%6!1 23 !!

7& 1 23 4& & & 1 23

000

8& 4 ! ,9

1 !!

; & *+ + )* +

,9!

!=& &3 0* +1.* + 0+ &1 &&& + !

+& )* +

> ?

! &*,0* +10+ &12& 4&3*&

% & A!&&

: !&

; & ,949 4 3 !2& + & , &4 3 8 3 4&3 & !+ *

% & A!&

*& & ,949 B* ! *& +>

B*9 ,*

3&, !&

1& *

4& & * &3& ! 0+ & 84 &

:*&

9;!

,9 !&

& 2*

* C 1 /2& +& !

@ 8 !&

2 9& & *&

3! *, &2,!

91*3 !& ,! 3* 2!

!3!& 9 !2

& 3 3

* ),

3 1

* ),3

; 4!!+ !&

9 & 3 *3

2 *& 9

+ !!!& +&!!& &

9! /6

&)& !!!& +6 !&!! !&

<& 3 9

? ,& +

& &#!& *&

9 !!& 2&!!+6&*

,* 4,

4& & * &3& !!&& 0+ &84 ,3* 4&3&

,3*, &2,! 93+ &E 3

843* 2!

!3!& 9 &

3 3

1 !& B* & ,!*

3 >

< * ),#

3 1

< :

< ;

8 *& 4 3

D 4&

,9 1 !&& 9 ,)3 4& + &

& ,&!& 9 *&

!3*

& !&

4& D

!& !

*& 9&& *

&!49 0+ &

,& + 3* 2!

2 &+ !& B* 89!!!+

3 &2 ,+&

14 &!& +

*& & 4 3

*3 !

&21& 4 !

3 *& !&

& 3 1 9

32 3+1+&

3+&

! &3

C 1 /D 4

& & *&

&!!9 & 9 !!&

6&*

,* & 3, 3!*

* &3& !!&&

0+ &

& *, &2,! 9!!+& + !&

4&2 &&+ 1 9 &&! *& 4 C !&

!&3 3

2 + ,)3 &

C ,9

3* 9 2&!&

!3!& 9& 4&3

9&& *

89 3 !

6*,F& +20+ & +4&34 3 C

4&3& 4!

*, !

4& & * &3& !!&&

0+ &4&3 2&!!+6&*

& ,!

3* D 4!!

3* F& & 3& 90+ &+ !!9!!% &4!4&34*!

9 3& 94 3* 2&! &2!3

&1 !!4& +&*4

( !&

2* &&+ - ( & 93* !3!& 94 !

&& *

-& 1 4

- ( !&

*& &4 3

*3 -= C ( !&

2 !3*

& &!

*& -= ? ( *& & &, -= < !& ? % & !

9 2&

3 *,

& &&2! ! + !&

% & (

&3!&

? G!

3 3 & )3

#F 1)* +

3& 3 !

H6*,F& +20+ & +H#F

#F 1 #FC1 3#F?

)* +

#F<

!F&

1=( 4&

* ,9 8

#F= 13 3 9

#F=

#F= < 5 & & + 2&

*3 ,9 &

*,&& &,!

&!5* 3 *& !&

3 & ,949 B*

! 9

? 1 @/& 3!* +< ?/ 3+1 ?

/+& 1? /&3!! *F

*3 +

4&34! 9 &

& 3*

, ? >

@ 1 &!& +4&3 *& 4 , ,

&& > I!& + ++&2 ,9 )* +

? >

@ ,9!

&! 5* 1

!4&34 && ,9!

=& &3 0* +1.* + 0+ &12& & *+

)* +

@ I!& + * & 1

8 *,&& ,9 * 0& 1 !

< 3* !

+ !!

7& 1!

& 3* !

2, 3 &

3 , *

4 3

&*&*

94 &!!9& *

2 * 2&!!+6&*

,* & 3 9

<< !!4& & * &3& !!&& 0+ &! *&

9,9 &+& ! 4 !&

& 2*

C 1 /4! &

3 8 !&

3!&

,& & *& 9& 3 3& 9

& 3 9

89!!+ 2& + !

9 &

3 *3 9&&

+ !!!& + &!!& 9! /6

&)& !!!& +6 !&!!&

? 8 * !&

,& +

*& 94

4&!1 !&

33 9 2&3 #F &!

+& ,9

G9 $, 5

#2&3 3 1

> &

3 ; )3

2! * *3 *

4&3! 2

8 !&

!!+

9 & H*,

&2,! 9H

3 3

,& +3* 2!

!3!& 9 &

> 3 3

< 14

9&& *

!& B* & ,!*

3 >

< & 3

< 8

*+ &

*& 9&H*,

&2,! 9H,*

&+ !&

4 3* 2!

9&& *

8 ,+& 4& 1 !

& 3* ! !!

G9 62

*,&

,92& * & &3 62 G9

3! &+ !!F& 3 ! !

!!& +& 9* &3& !& 9& G9 7

&3* !

9& &

!9!

!!& +&

* &3& !5&

10+ && G9 %92& * &3

@?1 &+ 3 ! !

!!& +& * &3& !& 93 F& 8!& B*

#F= 92 !3 ?

@ & &

&* 3 &3 ,* 3&

3*3, *& !&

3*!

, 3&

& > ?

@ D

,9G H,! F5* 1+ 2*&3") &3 &!1")4% 5*2 ) &3 &!1")- $4$67,81

&3* !*+ 3&

@ !&

! & &+ & 3 ! &

B* ,92& * &3

@?*3,

> ?

@ 4

! &*,0* +1 0+ &

8 3 F !&

,9!

&3* !3

1421& 93 & & 1 B* 4&33 *

& &4

94!

3&,

@?8

+&2 *

* ),!& 7

3 1

;&*

C 8

9 !!4& & ,&

+&2 3 3

,3*

4&3433* & & 9,*&!

4 2&!!+4 ,

D &

31 &

!91

&3 *3 F&

32 *& 9& 3

4&3 !!!& +&!!&,& +* & 3

? 8

9 :!

;4&3&33* & /!

* +&3*!

* * * *,2&

*& !9 ,

94 !

* +&3*!

*! * * *,2&

* 4,& +33* & *3 * 8 1,9 3 &+& 1

3*!

;

1 &3 43 & !9 !&3,!&

C %& ,21& !!,!2

< 4&3 9 3& *3 *

! "

% " &"

#$'(( )!!! $'((

#$ $'(* #

+ , ,

- , ,

# . "

/012 3 24#

, ,, ,

# # % " &"

#$'(( /)!! $'((1 7389 % " &"

#$'((

::%&;:((.<

5 #5 ; 5 ; 3

- % &; "

#$>>* )?!! $>>* #

1 H&2,! 9H !!& + 4& & !&& 4 1 +&3*!

*!!

1&3!!

H*,

&2,! 9H & 3

9 4 &

H+&3*!

*!!

H !!& +4& & * &3& !!&& 0+ &1& 4 H*, &2,! 9H

3 3

< D &

* &

& & 4&

! &

4& * 92

&:&2,! 9;8& && &

94:!

;

! &3 &

!&3,!

? G2& +!

9&H*, &2,!

9H1 B* 4&3

, , & 4 2&& 3 > 3

< !&3,!

93 > 3

< *

0 :

!&+ ,2 2&& 1 3!&& +&+ 3 !& B* 1& 4& 3*,

* !&

2 3* F&

3 3

< & & 4&3

9&& *

&3* !

9 !!& 2 * 2&!!+6& *

4& 9

<< &3 4& 3!*

! +4& 4& & * &3& ! 0+ & 4 #2

433

43* 2!

0+ & 4 1 3

, * , 2!

* &3& !5&

10+ &! 8* &+*

&3* !!& *

29")$ 6 $6- 9 &3 "&") 6 $66% 4% $%( 1:*3:$& &3 !1")%- / 1)";4& 4!& 4 *

7 # 5 @ # 5

A #

;B# #

&3* !!!& * 9 6$&<1 &3 &!1")4% 6 = &3!1")%- 8/ 1)",,74& 4 !

: C

2 7 C

$> D 5 5 2 <

# E

@ " <D

$ #F<D

"E + " @

A 74 - # !& 3 4 * !3 2 / 6 4 *&$#$9 6 22$!!""-1") - 887/ 1)">;4& &

!4!& 4 &*

:" < # #

$'((

< 8+*

&3* !

,9!

&3* ! !&

G*,&

3* 2&!& +& &3*! 4 4*!

3,!& F

9 4 !8

* 1 !& * $) & ?%14 1 22 3?) 251 &- 7 / 1)";7

%1"%1 ) !1 &3!1")%466 $+ &3!1")% >, *&= (

> G2& +3 & *,&& ,9!

& 3* ! &1 D

3 &

& +*&,! 3 29")$ 6 $6- 9 &3"&") 6 $66%.% 3* 19 6$&<1 &3 &!1").%3*

2/ 6.%3 * & &

3 , & !&

9 !!& 2 * 2&!!+6&*

<< 4& 3!*

* &3& !5&

!&&

0+ & 4 !&

% & ( G

9 9& 3 *3 2 !

? 9

+ !!!& +&!!& 9!

&)& !!!& +

6 !&!!

% &4!!! 0+ & 4 & & 3 J

! +

96&2& + 3 H!

H& *

6*,F& + &!

+& 0+ & + ! !

0+ & +8 H!

H4&34*,)3

& !4!& &!!9

2 * 2&!!+6&*

4! & 3!*

* &3& !5&

!&& 0+ &G3 +&3!!9

, 3* 2 * 2&!!+6& *

& 3 9

&!3*

0+ & 4 + !!9

% &4!!!& &3*!8* & 2& 1

3)* +

3 #F

3 !

,20

G0 ,

<>,9*,0* +D 5!10+ &8 !

3& 3 4&3&+ 43!&

!!% &4!4&34! 4 !!%, I &

)* +

,!& 2 9

<> F&

< 3* 0+ & 4 + !!9

!!% &4!&

&3*! & * 4 4&! =( 4!!

, &

% &4!!! & & 3 !9 / ! +

9D 4

& =( 4 3* ! H*, &2,! 9H& 0+ & 4

)& +G&2& 4 2

4 &+

93 ! , &!

G &

& 3 , * 0+ & +

94C 9 1,*

4 & 4!

+ *& + + !

)& + * 0+

& +4 &!

#F & &+ 3*

&& ,3*

4 !949 2& && 3 *! 3 8*1 !9

)* +

3#F

3,9 !&

,!& 1,* &! 2

=( 43* 2!

& 4&3

9&& *

*31& 3 ,&

3* F&

& B*

3 3

< D 9,

( % & &+ F&

! 9 2 * 2&!!+6&*

4&3 2&*!9

94& *

4 3!!

& &

> 3F& G4 2 *++

*33* F&

,9&D

1& & ,!& 3* 4 2!

2&!!+6& *

4&3 & &!!9

94& *

4! 2!

% &4!!! 0+ & 4 4&3& &

!9& *

@ 1

! & & *

*,*,4&3 +4 * *,B*

!9 F

& 0+ &3& 98&! & + 3 2 9*, &2&& & 0+ &3& 9 1 &

!9 *& 94!&& *

2 *

2&!!+6&*

,9( % & 1 3*

4 2!

& 3 9

94& 3!*

* &3& ! 0+ & 4

4! 3* + !

!!% &4! &3*!4

3,!& 2 & 3B*

3* 2!

&3*!3 , , 2 ,9 3& +& 34& , !!4 8*1 ,& + & !1& &,9 &&

"()* )+,-,