Narinder Kumar And Another v. Vikram Singh And Another
!"
# $% & '
'
(
!"
$!)!*)+ , ) & '
'
( -.!
/ / !)& 0'
'
(
& 12
3'
3 3
3
!
""""
3
3
'
#
$ % & '( ') !'#*%+ , $% #-- #.**/
0 $% 12 3 450 5
34/ #!
(!
(''34
# 5'
'''34 !2&6)7
8 %+ #) '( !'#(
!
&%+$% %+
3
2 323 3
$ 3 &%+$% & % $ +%& &3 % &
(
!4: , + & + & %+$% +% 3 $ +
;
: & &%
32 26
3
-
1% , & & %+ $ <, 8*, $ 9#'
7 :
8*, $
)/ )! ; $
3*-$ , !*$ # # 4
! " # $" "! %#"& ! !'" & !
#$ !(!
( (! "! " (! & ! # !
'" #
"#" !
(#$& !%"! ! &" & "( $" " ! #& !'" # & # ! & $"&#"
"! "" $"&
# ! #& ! " #&$& "! $&!#" $" ! #& " "! "!
!
)* + )"# ,&
+" " - ,.
/0)" *"1/2.
4 ( ! *,!
5!
)**
!6 7"( #&/0*82/
!"! !! $"& (9
:% ( ; ! " (! ! "%!" 5 ( ! ( $"! "!
! ! #$"! (9 5 (!"( ! < # 5"" ( " ! #& ="" ! % ->" & !
( ? ( 3 ( "( ! "
'" $" 5 !@ (
5% ( (&
," $"& # !!& "! ! !
,&" $"&
! !# ( ! #( !"! &
! # ! ("" ( " ! #&"" ! %
!@ ( ! % %%% %%% %%% %%% !"
#
$% $" ! # ( $" ! " ( &
( ! #&
#!& # "
!# ( ( & "!& ( ( & ( ! #&% #" # !"! ( ( & ( ! #&
! ! $"!> % !
"#'"& % ! #& (!&( ! % ! #&
( & ( # !#& #" !&
! #& &"! ( ( &!!!(" "" $# (!" ! &'"( )
$ # # # * +,+ 9
$"! (!10& !
(. 1000@> ! 3 ! ! #& # '" $"& 20A ! '" ! #& '" ! 10A
( &
!#& #" A # ! # " "! & #" ( ! * " # 9 " # !9. 12000@> # 5"" ( "
A " 9 . 800@> " # (9/ !
5"" (9 800%/ 9 . 00@>
* +-+9
$"! ! (!10& (.
1000@>
4 ! " ! ! ! #& ! 20A 4 ! $# "!(! 4 (( & & # ! ( &$# & &#
#" ! "" ( & / * " # 9
" !9. 12000@> # 5"" ( "
/ A " 9. B/000@> " # (9/ !
5"" (9B/000%/ 9. 8 000@> * +.+ 9
$"! B & ! & :(("! " ! ( ! " ! ! !
! # ! /0A $"! !"" ! '"! "( " "" ( & ! /0A
" # 9
"
" "!
( !# &! :( 9. 20000@> # 5"" ( "
/0A %! " 9. 8B000@> " #B & 9 !
5"" (98B000% 9. / 2000@> C- 9
(" !! " ! 6
&
("," * # ! " !!+"
"
( )
1% , * .
/"0"
12"< 0
( 3 (= > & #-- #-54 #-* #.** & 4 / = <
> /?2
> /,2
% +
> /=2 % +
< & > /@2 & 8%> 4 + <+ $ 8 4
&% #"
, " #(" ! & "
!" % "!#. 000. 80000 !. 000&
( ! ! # 6" "!# >'" "
> 7 "!#!( " '" ! "!# ! (# & & ! "!# 0A & 7 !! ! # " #( &
! *
1% , 3
0" 3) ( ". "/"&'&',.4& 5!6 4 F/
'"!#% !#&"9
+ 7+ + 8+<
! ""( # ( B1& &( $"!( - ," * &5 ! &) !G B0/*H B/00)*
, 82 !$"!( *"6 & ! " !#"! ! # ) ) !G 3
* ! B00*HB)* , ( (" >B & " # ( ( %! #&
! &!"!#& !" !) * ! " " " # ! # ! /
$ /
# $
9 " : , ! !
!# !" H (! IG B0*H 0)* !) ! + "$ "3 !I B0/*H/)*
7% # " H (! " 9 J , ( & # !
!## !
" &! #& !#& ! ! !
! " ( ( 9
"( ! "
"( !<
5 "!("" <
#& ! ( <
! %"!( &# '"!"! ""< !
5% J C "!D
! # ;! $"!( ) !+ "$ " (
" ! ( &"! !( & # ! '" & " ! ! #&"! ! , " " % ! #& !
@ ; ""
#! &K& "(" B0H " &B01
"$" !#" "!9
= J 9
"! " "
"
"# #
"! "# #(
"1!8 I ( !
"# "( "
" "
"# #( 7 "! ( %! ( " & "( !#& !" !) * ! "
6 & !
"$" % =" #! 1) !+ "$ "
&( " ! "" ! ! # ! 7 ""'" &
! !
( !"" " # !
( ! #& 1 A
'" # $"!( - ," * 5!
" & 2 !( ( "!# 0A " &
(
&: , ! !
! !"( " (A $"! " "!( H (! L "
G ( " !" !#& !" !
!A !#& *"
.2./;
*2
" ! &( !
" #& " & "! # !! 9 < ,# 5 ( . 828%B%1 @00 . /@> ="" 0 !!
. 80@> ! % "!( ( "
. 8228@> 5 .
00000@> 5
! (& . 0000@> !"( . B00000@>
. 821@>
"! "#! . 821@> ! ( A "
! ! &
3(3=>*,(*22?.2>3 ,(*2*=3 3.(2?,3//,( 2" @,=* 3=A;>,= .
& #&% (#+
& $% + 8 (# +
#(
#'
&$% #%+ :$/@<.
##2 & $% %+
:$ $ +8 1% , =
A
> " * .
/"6&'&9,.49&7 & 1% , + : $< % +
, $% $< FB 4 ! ! " ! "!
"# ! - !! ! "!1 0/ B002
! ! (!
#"1B& ! "! ( "(
* ( ! ! #! ! ! # ! > %" & B002>B00/
! ! . 2/ B@>
4 ( ! *
!! "
. 1 11 @>
4( *" !"( !
" ! ! " "!#$"! ! ( & ! !"!
"( !
" !," * & !
4( *" ( !!!
#& *" ! " " &" "#& 4( *" $"!
! ! ! ! !( > %" !
! !B008>B00 !! ! ! "
. 28@>! ! & B008>B00 ! # # !!
,
#"! &!
!"! !" !! & !!& '"!#! !
##
$ % %+ 1% , > B "= A 6/ #?
*C&57'DD&6 &%
+ % $ 8 FB , ! "! 0 B08 !! (
* ( ! ! ! "( + ! (! #" 8B & # !
4 * ( !"
:% #>= ! !! , %."
!#!#& ! ! & B00B0 ( & " " (
+ #!!
, ( . 00@> ! ! ! "( !! !1 0 B0
4( *" "( ! !" , %." !#!"!
#" . 0000@>
, ( ! '"!
!" " $"!( * " ( ! ( B $"!( #& , %." !"! ! ! ," ! (! ! %" " ! " #!"! " " ,
%."! ! #&
! ! #& % !
4 !"
!"!
! ! !
"
! !#$"! ! ! ! "( , %." & # ! #!
: # : $< C!'##4#!!'#(D#;
:$ + & :
+ %+$% % + #
#5
+ , & + #%% : $< C
+ @< 4#5
E + # #'
86'''E@"
#( &$% %+ 4 #+ ('7&%+ $ + $ %+ <% @< ( + 4 #&< %+= F3G4;
& 4 # );7 %+ & & $ %+ ('7&+9 8
+ %+ = 8 4 #% % ++
& & $ %+ + +
#;
: &&
%+ 1 +
% & + %+ : 8 1% , =
$ " * ." /"
&'&9 ! !7'
& <, & %+ + + + %+
% + +% $ 8 F8
$" " & " & & "( ! #& A
" # "( ( ! " # !! " #"& # !#( "& &!
*!( "! #& "
!#00A ! 0A !#& 4( *" #- $ 8 %+ 4 #%04?
% +
#)
&$% + & 8 3 #
4?%
#*
& %+$% <
#.
$ & % # 4 3$'
!'
/# !,- )# @!) A $/ / # : #*'''34 !
H /!;72 (;''34/!;7 #*'''342
: !
)'
'''34/ !!;''34I#!2 ( H );7%+ !
'!
;''34/ !)''''34I);72 ;
#( !* 5;
'''34/ !'!;''I#(2 ) * ''
'''34 *
, !
''
'''34 .
$, ;'
'''34 #'
< ## H !
''
'''34 #!
= *'
'''34 !
.
+!,- )# @!)
$/ /& #'5(45
B /*+ @!)&
&%+$% #' 5 5
B );
)+ /
,!*) !"
+!,- )# @!) #' 5 5(
B 5(45
5 5
4
3(3=>*,(*22?.2>3 ,(*2*=3 3.(2?,3//,( 2"&@ ,(2 <A;>,=* !'
& !& % $$% & $ , !
!#
$, ?,2@ &!&@&''D6 F4 $
0"
G6 &&"'9"&' 8& & 4 F,=G- BB08 >! 6 *"
&(" !! / #
" - &''
H =.= .
D79 ! (# 9> F5 !" ("!
( ! B0B % & . 000@> #" (& ! ! ! . 000@> !# !!" !# ! %
("
!
,5 7 !
!
) 6 ! ! B008 .*.
* 2/1 ! !
4 #)" *" " ! #" " . 1000@>
! B1& , &!!
( " ! !! $" " "
( +( B1& # ! 5 7 !
! ! ! &" " ( ! "! # " # #"
( ! ! ( (" G
, !"( '" "
J / ,!" $"!( =G-
BB08 " & , ! ) 5 )5 ! ( ! #! !#& 4 #)" *" ) & )5! !#& *'"& ! ! & (" !"( !( #!( "
, !( " !
" 4#"%!#&!
" # ( " !
( ! " ! " #&
"( "(;!
& " # "( ! > #( " !
, ( "
" ! ##" "!
! #%!"""!
, #$" ! #!
& ! !* $+ " " . 000@> !'" #& *" !!
: %
, !#'5
B - $ ,!) ;'
!5
&$% !
& ?
%
!(
&$% %+ 4 !+
0 !'7&%+ $ + $ %+ <% @< ; + 4 !&< %+= F3G4;
& 4 ! ;'7 %+ %+ $ %+ !'7 &+ 9 8 + %+ = 8 4 !% % ++ & & $ %+ + +
!;
: &&
%+ 1 +
% & + %+ : 8 1% , =
$ " * ." /"
&'&9 ! !7'
& <, & %+ + + + %+
% + +% $ 8 F8
$" " & " & & "( ! #& A
" # "( ( ! " # !! " #"&
= # !#( "& &!
*!( "! #& "
!#00A ! 0A !#& 4( *" !- $ 8 %+ 4 !%4 ?
% +
!)
& %+$% <
!*
$ & % ! 4 3$'
!' /# !,- )# @!) A $/ / # : .'''34 !
H /('72 5-''34/('7 .'''342
: # ;# !''34/ #!-''34I#!2 ( H ;'7%+ );
-''34/ #;#!''34I;'72 ;
#;
## 5( '''34/ );-''I#;2 ) ;
''
'''34 *
, ;'
'''34 .
$, ;'
'''34 #'
< ## H # ''
'''34 #!
= *'
'''34 !
.
+!,- )# @!)
$/ /& #'
55
B /*+ @!)&
&%+$% #'5
B );
)+ /
,!*) !"
+!,- )# @!) #'(5=5
B 55
5 5
!.
:& % && '( ') !'#* + 4 %4 5'
%+ 1% ,
I - 0"
0
&' !,.49 7D ="0
20 "( ( . &'&& 5
..
'7
+6.7
J
5#
!4: , + &&$% & &
+ 8 $$% % & 4 $ % $% 5!
/2 +
3
3
'
'
( K G34 C3 G% C