Jagtar Singh v. State Of Punjab



   

  

  


 



!

" #  "$%& '( 


!  !

" #  "$%& '(

        "

)  $*!%+)(,+

!'


 "  $--+)(,+

!'


   +)).+"$%& " )!-$/-+)(,+

!0'-&!!
   2!    !  &  *  $'  !  !$ !

,( 

#(!00(+


-(3 !,  "$%&3(


 

 -(  3
!   !  ,      "$%&3    &

('( 4 &!!'!, 056+ ! +00 & ( 7 "  *       $-  &-  $(   748 
"
      &  56    ((  

 $( 4

6"
($(  9+

)0)

$( 7

+

:+7 +7 +7 + 46"
(((-( 

)0)(-( $&;$-<   (    "-    (  %'$+ "- 9 56/ (&< '  !  / !!-- !! ! /  !$( , , 0<,<0!,-- =* < '< &  

 +  !  ! 0'- /! (,-- !2!0'-- /0'-!/2!0'-(!

!  0(    !  .$(/    &$  >  !$  ( ! +!0'-( 
!( !! /!! !0(.$(/)&$"+! 0'-/ 0(&<0!! ! ! /-< !(!(%,('' &(    !  (   =  '-  '$0' 2! 0'-

4

- /!! ("6(  !$!(!'( /!! !/-< ((!(, ! (&-(/? $ 0!!((!-!/ 0(/!&-(2!0'<( / $(!   56  /   (     $*/  ' " !((!@%$(-  &  $%  !"A( /!!
!  !B
!$$(C*
!$!/ (&< !

!$ !  !  &!-/  /(   !    00

0$(  /  !
!  !B
!$$ ($' /  ! 

  - ! 0!/!!

/(,&<C*
!$!

D(  $-    !  '  0-<   !$&0(!!/0(- &/! '( /  !(!/0, ! '00! (

E'-(- $'  !  '   
!(  )$  -(  &<  ! 6,   

  -  /!  !--  (  $&0(  /!

 !6!-$0 &,+&*

!,&!/&/!(((!

0-</!!'!/ '<0  + +

F !'

7

D($- !' $! ( '<0    ((  9

7    !  0$  

+ +

F!0 /(  !/!&!

!((+<(( 9

 !$0 87+

F   ,$    /   !  (  -  -(  $'  $ 0 !'!/ !0$ 48 -('(&<!'!0'-'<$

-0$  + +

F2! ((!& $( !' 
!()$
 

-( $-($-<(/!

-($- !0'-''(!&-!

$(! !'F'/!!  $(C*
!$!( /(  !/! !,& ( $-&-&<!
$ D($- !0'-$&0(! !  '  F  !  0  $( 
!   !  B
!$$  !(  (    /   !     

   G0'< ( /,( 0! !((G0'< ( /5 D&<' ,< '-'$$ (-$0  $(
!  !B
!$$A!!'-/ 5 D @0+!' 5 D+/$-(!/!0'< ( / ( 0!0'-+!&<&-!

9

,-,0 
!  !B
!$$!'/!!(

( /  !  D(  $-    !  0'-  $! $&0(!''$-- +0$(

!!(!(!((!$ 0$(

!/!, ''!!(( / !/$-(,-,!00'( (! +! *(!&!-/ /(  !0* 0

  -0   /   ! 2!<!(  ! ,  

*--
!  !B
!$$(C*
!$! /!/-- (&!(, !,!-$(! 0
!   !  B 
!$$  !(  $

(  (-$ 0 9

 ' '-('$$ ! +! !0,( 0!!$"- & 5 D ,!0!   $     0'<( ,( 0! 4 D(  $-    !  0'-  $! $&0(! /  !/ !(,( !&-/'$2!&-/$((/! ((&(</'(+/ $(!!((!( ,( &$--! !( !!(+ + ! 0'-( !( !!2/0'<(  4



&/ $((,!0(0'< (  4 &/ $(!&* ! /(- (- /! (&$-- (&$--/

$(($(2!0'<(  4

&(/ (&$---(/,(2! '  $( 
!   !  B 
!$$  /  &(  2!

'/0'(/!! '&( 0 ! !(()'' 5 '@'+! 0/!, 0!   $ 0--<+
 ! 0&-,( 0!$(/&( 0! (0'(   !0!*( 0 !

  "+"-
<&
--+/ $( !! $('!( !(8

'$' 



 +!< !(!-(0*'-  4

 +&!-/ ! /( !(
!  !B
!$$/="(!   /'  (  !<  0  &*    7

  ( ! +!<0 !

 +!

&!(<  /(  !+--!$(/ ! (E$(,(<'!(< 0$(  

 +!$(/ ! 

 + '$ !+ !$(' *!0&-'!!'- $

 

7 D(  $-    !  0'-  $! $&0(!! ( ,  $( & $--</!@%$(-  !0 $( !0(&  $%  !"A 9 -$  0   
!   !  B 
!$$ !($-(,< '-/!/-,( G@ %$(-  !/$-(&(0&-;$! $!!0- $( 4 G,()(! &  (- -'+&(!@ %$(- /*<' ,(   !(  2!  --  (-+  &--  '+  5 D  '+ 5 '',(&<!'$/$-(!/! !  '-  !  ($(     ,   (  --  ! ,!,& $(&/!!@ %$(- 0(&< !   $%  !

"A )! +!
$/$-(-*00 $'- -< 0---(&<!'-!0 0<  $-    $  '%$(    !  '    !  - " $(&!0$(G@%$(-   !/$-(&(!!!-(

- -'0 G,()

 

 
!  !B
!$$!'/! 

($'(( /  !
0'-< !$( '! ! 0 0$((    ( 0-! /$-( -! !0 &-6,/ &,+!'< 0&-0(&!- 
!  !
 


 

-(0( 8 6,/  (+($- & (

,$ !'

 !  

      

 

 A!!'* F( HF

A!!'&- HF