← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/136/2021allowed

Sumit v. State Of Haryana

2023-02-21Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra16 pages

 

     



       

       !       !    """

! "# 

$"%#  " 

& '

" %'

 (((    )" " *  

$

"+$   # ,  -   

  ./0 





  !

" &" * "  %' #"*  -  " " $ $

"

&"  "   "*

 -  " $   1,23*& "$  #   

 

"*   ,,  3%4,5 " 62367   ,   

  3"

 89  %5 " 6939% 67  : ; 

%"  "*



 6"  6"

   )"*   

"  *

"

  " /4%"

86 65 & ""7 &"





$"

*1 

%   *  " "& 

$

0" 

9 ,4*4  % "& $

$" " " "%&" ""     ' # "& )" & "#

$  ' " 

"  

$"" & " "

")"

8"* "  *

 

$"

" "%" ;"  &" "   )< )"

8 - ' # "  " *

$""" & ; "  %"& " % ;"  "#"



$  &" "

#  "  & "    

;  6

6  )"      "  "  

& " "" "    ' #  $" "  &"     * 

* ;

"  &" "

8&



$ " &"

"



$"  "

" %  "         "  *  ;

$    "   )"

8 

$ & "   #"

 &# %""

 ;

"  "

 *"



 )"  %*"" "  "

""  $  "" " "& 

 *"



 " "  = "*

"

 %    

>% ,%/,23   =939 &

 $

 $   

&

  $8

 "

8&     "

8&       ,=  3    3

    %  0/ 5 " 367)"    /"939 &  $

  ' #  &

)" &

$  

    

$"

##

"

*+  

         

$     % "    /3 3&  

"3  

"   1 3 " " &  "    )"  &   "  

9

$       

 

"*  

>%,, & "  > 1,522723   , 939 %*""  "*  " $ " 

$ )"

 $  " " $   

 , ) *    %" 8

 

/&

%*



$    

  )" &

& ?6 6

8%?66" "

8% ?66  "    "  

8%  ?=

 

$"  "

   %

3 3 %&%&""  

  

%  ?12

   !  # %       &

%  ?,2

#  "%2 $ 9 %?/3>% ;"  "

&"    "    & 

* "2 $

9 %?43

* %&""

"     :@ "* %?03"*"% &"  " $  ;" "

%  "       

$           "  *



%  ?    %  A>)  2 " $%  '#

  



 "% $

%&"   $

$

& " &"

8 " "%?3

*@8 % &"&  &

%? ; "3" % $

& "   *

$.  ,0/ "    %?%  

!

"

&""    $8

"

8 /4%?=3& &""

      :@  >"

%  ?13

*  !#   &"  "   

    :@>"

%?,3

* @&" "+

$ =0 ?/  " "" % &""    $8

"   

=0 / )"    &     3>""    " # *

      2  # %"   8

& &

 %? # ?+ 4   

$ "  #          "

$" 

* *""

%"



3  - "  ' #" " $ $

"



$ &# %"   & "$    

 

"*   ,,23 &  $

$  

  

/ 

&    

 

%B

" &  $

 

  , "

&  "$  

   ,    939        &      $ 

$ 



  

 

&  



@ 

  

%"&  

   $

 

  & 

)"

8& 

 *&  

" 

1@ 

@$ # "

 0 :

$  $$

#     "      "

  # %  "

" *  

* "   %   @

 

 "  %&"





$"

$ 



3 #"  $"" $ +$   #  -  

$

"  &  ** 

 "

$





3 & 

" 



   + .

8 "  "  "#

" ." 

 

$# "   $

"  )"# "$"

8&     #

$   #" " "$ 

% "& *&"$4 

)"  #  #" 8



+

 " &

   "

"

8@



3 "  "

$$ "    "*

.  "  "".  *"   "& "" ." 



   C8 9B"$" &

 #""     * $"

8 ?

"" *  $ % & * "" # *& "    #* - " " $  &"

"""* "$    #     % & $* 

 

""

$ 



3 *

$&   &

 )"# "$"

8&

$  #" "& *&"$4 

"  

)" "".  "* 

 &"

"& ; "   "    "  "

8 "& " "" %& 



     #  "  "      " 

"  "  

8  

$ % & * ""*

$# 

%&

 **

  ?"#$ "$" 

" 

* *""

"#    " *





<)" " & $

 

"

  "*

  C8% *

8* "   /42 "

 % ""$""    $& "  ' #"" &"

 "& "&

% " " ,4   ' #"  "

" "

"  &"

"" & "#

$& """"  "

 

$" " "%" "; "  ) <%&"

"&

"* "   2 "

 %C8% "" " $*1 

@

3 "* #""

8&  #**&" $    4  

     "       

   )   #  "  "

8& 

,4%" "



  " 

?%   %A>)2 " $ '#





 "% $

)"

&

"* $" "  

    C8,     

    & " &  $



* "

"% # 8  &"

"

C81  #C8/%  

* "

& " $ "*

"

"

8 

" "

  %" *

""

8& =,= "&  

" *#  " 11 ""  1 ?     

$ 

8

 "   

 *

"

   

  #   "  *  $  *  "      "

8" " 

"*# "  .&  "  -  "  

   

    &"" "*#   * 

* 

 

"$"

8)"&  

&

"

" $"" 

  # 

$

  $"+#

%"  ;  *&* "3 

&

$"$"

8 &  ""$"

8

*

  #

A#

A 53   3"

 7 %15 " 6 %17 &  "  )"    

$"$

&   0=" %1%   &"

"%"$ "

B+#

 

    & "  &    *  

  * ;

# * *

$ 5 7"*

"   " "%

"  

    - #         "  

8

> % # *D

"* " D5

7"*

"

$    

"

 " D

7

"* " %*    

$

 

"  $

 E * % 

 # &    "

#

%"$ "

  *

 "*

 *

"  

 " "&# %

 &  ""*

"

" $

" #

# 

"

&""

&"$#"*

"

8

)"

 

"

 

"

$

 * "& * "*

"

  $

* " 

"#

$  ;

&$*" *

""

 

2"

" $

$

*

"

 "*



  $ " % &"##

# " &

& "#2 "

%? " *

"    # & $

" "

8" " 

"

'  2  C8,#* " 

11 %" *

"&  : %#

" "

8 ? ?   "

   "    & "  $     "      *

"  *

=,= 

C81 C8/ " *""

  

$ 

8

 "  "  

8  &  *

 

C#

8    = .# "

%"

8 & "   " "" #  

"

# $





& " " "

8"  $  2  0" 

)"  %" 

#

" C81 / 

$"*

""

8 

*  

 

  " "  &  *

   =,=

 # &  "  

 *

8 "  " "

""* *

  "%    *  * *""

8& *&"$4 

,4&" " 

"$ ;  @



 3  "  

 "

    "  "  % " * #

* 



3 ""

8&  # *

%"#*  ** #

 1 )"  8  -  "  

   

    &""

8&  #"#* * 

" * "   $* )"  "*

" $ "   ,,23)*

$""$ "

    "

  % &  

  # ""  "

 "

8 " "

 $ 

 D"  "

  &   

"  ";



$ *  ; & ""

""

8 $"*   



B ""  ;

& * ; " " $"*   



%

" *  ;



$: % #" " $

  ,"939  $

"  %  &

-

* #* ""

8"*

*+  $$ #  # 8

* "   &# %

8%&"& &

" 

 "  

  &

  "    ?     ?%

 "#

" "

" "

 &

"

"

  #  * 



  "

8" * * B;



"& *

)"   "  "

*  ;

"

8" "

&

" *   "  & *+ 

-



 8



*   )" &   & ""

  $  $    *  "  *   "     )"

8& #   & ""  C8     ,=3 3* " $

&# %" ; $

"   "  "# * *

"  *   

 

  )"  %  *  8

$  "   



 &

%"  8  

$# &" # $

"    

 "& " " $

$

" , )" "     "#  

$

   * "   #  C81

?,2 "%2 $

$9 ?,3

* @&"

""    

* "  # C8?/)"$"*"" &

 "  " 

$""   " "



    "  "   

&# %

 

%# "

 * #* 

 % "  

* 

* # #

# &  "  "



   " 

 

 *

$  * " 

"   " *

$  



 %& 

*

#

# & "*  

  1"2 C#  %4/5:

" 6C#  67. & 

 &"

"&* 

*

*

# &"8    #

  /" C#    * "#* 

#



 "

       C81%  #  *      "       

&   ;

& " ?,"  $"

 C8"  /4  )"  %"

  #

 

 % ""

 #

$   $

"   "





  3

 

"& $ "

  / :

# " %

#"

$ "  %



3 "

   "

 #         

 "       :@  

C8F C8F  #

%" &

"# "    

$"  8

"*

;

   ? 

!

"

 """ #

" " 2 " &



%? "  C8 9B.&   C8F%"  &

  "  C8 9B:   %C8F%.  

$& *

 "C8 9B* 8  

$.

    "*   & "".  

$* "   " 

*"

". " " 4 @

 

   $""

 &   

# " ""  &"

"&

  " "

8%& "   ""   $$ #  # 8

B  " # @



3 "* #"

.    ""

8 * "  

 ""  %" & *;

 

#""  "

""

8&# %&



"""  "

$ 

.

   "  C8 9B "* "

   &

  

 

 "  & ""   

82 "

$  * "%

& ".#

 

#  #

$   =1"2 C#    ;

" # %  * ###

    2

"( !

" 





") !* +!

 57 

7==/ " 6*83 &"



$& ""

 .  

$"$  "    #  .# "* #".  & $  " *  %

" $     #  # &   & ""  *

    "

; #  "   & " " & "

 * *

"2& * #" "    #

.#

     %  % ;$ #%" &  "$

-

 



* 

  &   %

      ,

 , * ") -"

))  " %2 31,,%"  6*83 "* #"&"

""

" .  &  #

# &" ""  ;



$

";"   $  &    #""  "

-  .  

$&  *  * "8 %" # "    *"* 

* 0 "

  %" "& ""*  "    "  .  

$& ; 10*

# " " 

" ;"  =0 "  % & 

& ":@.# "   # &" "C8 9B #$

 &*  "

& 



" ;" %"$"?" " "" " #   /4 ?=3

* & "

C8 9B 04 :@>"

2

"



%" & 

* 

$  :@ "



8

)" 

*  

$& "" 

 

$"

$

  *   8"

* C8F F   #"  "

  

 %&"

8 "

  "#

" "" C8 9B * $"  "

"

  # &



%"

""

8" " # "  $ 

"

$" : %# 

* #"C8 9B&

; * ? " 

"    

$ $8

"

8*  & "

""

& &"

" "& &

$"  &" ""* $

"  "%"  * "    "    $       "

  * #   

 "  :@     "#     

&" # "  %# 

""C8 9B * $"

8 " 



  "

& "  %   

** #"C8 9B&

$ &

8"  

%   *   "  ""

8 & "  # 

"  " *

$

"@



3 " ;  

 

  "

  



%"

$ 



3   

* " *  # ""  "

 "

8

" "  $ 

 * & 

   

& "

  "  



 "";

& * ; " " $"*   



%   " *  ;



$ """

"" : %# " *  #* *" "& *&"$4 

" " 

  )" % # 

 " 





$     "  #   # *   %    



"

*# $" % 

&

* 

"" "  

$""$  "     

 

"*

  ,,23   ,939   "%* #

"

$ 



3 %" $ +$  #  -  

%"

& "   %

 - " " $ 

&"

"""* "$  *   "& "   -

"   

 



   7% 

% 

        

    !! +

        G B. .  /"0,

#$%&