Shamsher Singh v. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal And ANR




   
    

 !"#"$%& '( )#(*'"$+(  

,*#-#

*#" "$+ "!*.
$ -# /*"0-$ /. $ (

(*    #1$ $ #
 

  
 

 

   
  
       

          
! "!

"# $"% &       '

    ''      ()    

   '   )   *"  #  # 1* #  -1 02 *

"$* 3( 3 $ "4  -$"$"#   $  3 # )1/2  -$ * *#1$ $ 3 # "#)"## *)#*4"!$ &"$ *+

(1*4"#"$# (
$ -# /"#1- #!

. 5&6(*"$ ****  (!

893(*-1$(#*4  ) $ $ "!

 :-1$  $*-# / *"$#

"$*. "$* "$"

  !$!"/"

"$ 1*! "$+# 0* ( ##"#

 < 0-* ))"##"$*.#("

*1-*4"  ) $ $ "!$$=-* >4$ //2.

( )

* 3 # ***  *#" "$+ "!* < 0-* -* .  $ ( *
##-#3** ) "$ #$  "$!/- "$+ (*+

-# "$*0"$+ *?) $3"

($-# 1*4# " "##- 0"$+-1$ $(1 "$*!$!/-  ("#4" $!

+,+$"#-./ 01$2 $@3(* #*#1$ $ >;

!/# "

#4" $! $ : (* *. 3("/ # 3 # 1$ "$+ * #.

"$3 #)4 */ /4" $!$ (+*-$ 

$3 */"*0"$+*1*#$  02'(A'( *) 3((  "# ##!"

 (")#/*) #(* *. "$*( $+ +  (* (*"B  *1*#$

"4

+ 3($ # 3 "=  * 4" $!  ( ;

 ( ;

 ( /# !/#  4" $!0- $ #

( *"$+"

( !) (?$3/ +

(*"B *1*#$

"4

$4" $!$ *+ "$*0"$+!4* 3"

("$ ( "$"

"$7*?) $8 0$/  $ #"$! ("##-3 #4"

$ !-/ 0 !"  $/2$ #"#4" $!.1* 2*3 #*0"$+ /4" $! @ (

"$3 #11# 02 02"/"$+*1/2$

(+*-$ 

"$3 )

0/ #"

3 #"+$ 02

$. 0#" # //3"$+ ( # ) 3-/  )-$

//3"$+"//"$+-1/ ;*4*. "$*( $ )$ "$  "$

3(

/4" $!("$ $ "$

( $ !"*!-)#

$!# #."

3 #!/

"$3 )*/2  1*/$+ ( /"

"+

"$ ( / *$  *#" "$+ "!*.
$ -# *"0-$ /. $ ( *$!$#" *

$  (*#1!

"41 "#. "#)"## 

"$ 5 < *$  !-$#/ * "$* *"

( #-0)"##"$# ) 0* ( / *$  *"0-$ $  1* 2  * #

#"   ( ")1-+$  * * $ +* 11* -$"

2 /4" $! 
( 4( * / *$ !-$#/* $ ( 4+$ (*-+(

("/

+,+$"#-./ 0132   )"

 /2. ( **$! 3 # ) ( 2 * :
##-# 3* * )  "$ # $     ( */"* (*"B  *1*#$

"4 *1*#$ "$* 3 # *1/ !  02 ( #-0#C-$   (*"B  *1*#$

"4 "$ ( 2 *   (* *. ( #-0#C-$ /2 $+ + 

(*"B *1*#$

"4!$!/-  4" $!$0( / "$*$ @ *3("!( (*#1$ $ >;

!/# "

#4" $!$ :3(* *. ()

**) "$ 1$ "$+* # $-# 1*4 (*+

-# "$*0"$+3*?) $3 $ $(1 $!$!/-  ("#4" $!

* $+ +"$+  $3 (*"B  *1*#$

"4 "$ ( 2 *  $ @(1 "$*3 #*C-"*  4" $!"$ "*)

"4$

("##-(**.$!(!/# ("#4" $! $ 4$ (*#1$ $ >  !/#  "

# 4" $!. "$* !-/  $  !/ ")  0

 / /  4" $! 3"

(-  ) ?"$+ -

4" $!#-+( 0*/" -1$3 ("#?$3/ +*

 #1"

0# * #. )!-/ $ 01* -!  */"*4" $!3("!( "$*#-+( 023 2

/4" $!3 3//3"

("$("#?$3/ +*) (4*20+"$$"$+(1/ #1- * (02

(( !( $+  (*"B *1*#$

"43(!

) ?$3 0- (  "/-*  /  4" $! C- ( "##-  #

-#  #*?) $"#3"

(- $20 #"##"$! #( #0$$ 04.

(**$!"# (2 *:."##-#3** ) $  3("/ #-0#C-$ (*"B *1*#$

"43 #$+ + 02 "$*"$ *  3( /  4" $! $  !$!/-   ( # ) $ @ 3(* * (*#1$ $ >;

!/# "

#4" $!$:  ( #!/# "

#4" $!"

"#$ 1$

#?1*)"##"$ /4" $!3"

(- #

0/"#("$+

+,+$"#-./ 0142 4" $!3 ("#?$3/ + */"**

)!-/ $ 0/  - !"*!-)#

$!#02$ ("#!$ *///3"$+

 (  !$!/-   "

# 4" $! # 3 # "=  *

#3-/  )-$ //3"$+"//"$+-1/  & ( 1 /* 2 ( 4"$+ ?$3/ +  ( 4" $! 3("!( ( #-0#C-$ /2#-+( 023 2

/4" $!."

//3  3-/  )-$ //3"$+ "//"$+ -1  /  3("!( "# $ 1*)"##"0/  *$! "$ ("# !$ = $ 0 ) ( !"#"$  $80/ (/(""+(-* "$  

 !


  "# #$   % &

' 
 ()*

 ' 
 + ,- . "
   #"#  ''   /  "   . '  % "     

+! 

 3(*"$"

3 #(/ 

13*-$ *'!

"$* * *: -/ & ( 3 "$ 0-# *- "$/2 $ )*/2*

#?"$+.#!$ /2

"$#?"$+1*)"##"$ 4" $!3 #*C-"*  #

"#2 (-*

$$>1* -!

)

*/"*3 #*4 /"  $ #-"!"$ * #$#("* /2.

"

# -$   0 )"#!("4-#. * *"4/-#. *  !4* -1 $+/"+$! * . "

 3  0 *D!

  3"

( ( 42 !# # /4  =   !"#"$"$."
  &!

#6#-1* 9"#*1* -!  #-$ *% E9
$,/-# )26#-1* 94$ *!$#" *"$+ (1*"$!"1/# "  3$ "$ , "* D  ++  ,*$?

* 6#-1* 9

?"$+   '!

"$   . ("# -*  !$!/-  

*# #  D-# "!  1*4$ 0-#  ( 1*!##  .  "# *  !$#" * 3( (* "

 3 $!## *2 *1$ (4" $! $ "#."$3(

) $$*

3(

=  -* (*."

"#0#*4 

(4" $!#(-/  01*)"

 "$=*!"#"

#13*-$ *'!

"$   ( //3"$+ 1*"$!"1/# / "  3$ "$

* */4 %

+,+$"#-./ 01+2    ) 2  3*   !

"$ ( 13* -$ * '!

"$  * * * : -/ &  (   "# $ 0-# *- "$/2.)*/2* #?"$+
# -# ."

3"// 

(4*21-*1#4 *"-# )$ )$

(  =1 "

/#- 3(*

"$"# -$  00$ "  $ 3(* /4" $!. * / * !-)$

*2. 3"// ##"# ( !-*  !/ *"2 4" $!$ ("##-# $ 3"// ##"# "$*$ *"$+D-# "!.

(!-* "##

"#" 

$$1* -!

*/"*3 #* /"  $  #-"!"$  * #$#. ( !-*  ) 2 =*!"# "

"#!*  *!

// ( 3"

$### * 1*)"

( *#( 4" $!- ""

 ##."

#(-/ $#-*

(1*!## # $  0!)  1*

"! ( !-*  #(-/  "*# /2 11*1*"

 !# (  (* 1 2 !)1$#

* ( / 2'!$ /2. (!-* #(-/ 

? -1 $ !)1/ #3"

("$ "=  ")#!( -/#

( / 2"# 4"  ("* /2."

"$"#-$ 

0)"#!("4-#.**"4/-#.* !4*-1$+/"+$! */ ."

#(-/ 0*D!

 3"

(( 42!# # "

(#1*"$!"1/#./ -#!$#" * ()*"

# #"$ $  9(1*-# / ( )

/#1/ ! 02 (1/ "3("!(

*"$ 0) *?  #0"//#( 4 /* 20$)$ "$  02 (1/ ""$"

##

)$  !!-$ 0- (*"+"$ /0"//# 4$ 0$1/ ! $*!* 02 (1/ " "//

 "/"$+#-!(

"$
"#-* (*#$

 -*"$+ ($ "*

/. (# !-)$ #( 4*) "$ "$=!/-#"41####"$

(1/ "0- * (* #$#?$3$ "

.# "// (1/ "( 1/ !  (#0"//#$*!* 
$#-!(!"*!-)#

$!. #*"+( /2 0#*4  02

("# 0/

  #

+



( !$!/-#"$  ( 4" $! $  "$

* *#*4"$+ ()

**1*$-$!)$ D- +)$ .3

* (4"3

(1/ "!

$$ 01*)"

"/#-!(

"$# "// "$"

#1/ "$+# $ 4" $!/  02 (") # *"+( /2 0#*4  02 . (* "# $

!!1

0/ * #$ * !

-# 3("!( ( # 0$ #(3$ 02 1/ " 3(2 (# !-)$ #3*$ 1/ ! $*!*  02 (1/ " -*"$+ ($ "* / $* -$

/2. ("+(

?"$+$  (3* #E

$2#

+F!!-**"$+"$ * * G,


 -/ & !

#- //2 # #"  ( * *  .

(#

"$# $ 1*)"

(1/ " 1/ ! $*!* !*

"$0"//# /#+*  1*)"##"$ *!

// >

+,+$"#-./ 01,2  1*4 (#0"//#(-+(13*-$ *'!

"$!

$0 =*!"# "$ #D-# "!#3 ** 1*4$ 0-# 1*!##  ( !-* $  -* $ =*!"# "

# "#!* 1*)"

*1$"$+4" $!**!

//"$+3"

$##*-* (* = )"$

"$H!*##= )"$

*4" $!/ 02 "#. "$ (/"+(  ("$*)

##(3$"$ (* * . $ )/2. (# !-)$ # 3* 4*2 3// "/ 0/

(*-+(- /.3 * (4"3

4$02=*!"# '!

"$ . (1/ "!

$$ 01*)"

 F  :
$ (/"+(  (1#"

04.$!

#"#) - * **"$+ 3"

( ")1-+$  * * #"$! )"

 /2 $ #

"# *2 =1/

"$( #0$+"4$* */"*$$>1* -!

(4" $! $3#-+( 0/ .0#" #

"$0"$+ !4*

)1 "// -1 ( !"#"$"$."
  &!

#6#-1* 9 0"$+!

+*"!

1 2!

$$ 0 "/ $

"// -1 "$ (4" $!($-# ("##-"$*#1!

3("!(

/4" $!"##-+( 0/ 3 #$ "$* $/23 #

(4" $! "$*!$!/-  $@4$ (*#1$ $ > !$!/-  "

#4" $!$:3(* #3

##

+

3("!(1"$  ").

4" $!3 #)4 


$ ( /"+(   ( 1#"

# $ 04.
  $  "$  $2 !"*!-)#

$!#3 ** "$+"$ **$!3"

(3//* #$ * *1 ##  02 ( / *$   !!* "$+/2. "$ "$+ $ )*"

( *4"#"$ "$. )"# "#)"## "$/")"$



            * 5  65& ( (**1*

0/% #H