Abhay Bhatnagar v. Ut Of Chandigarh And ANR





   
  

 !" "#$%$&'

 



        

 

  

' ()  *
*+*
 

 ! " #$  %&     '( 

( !(& &!

  

  

)* ++++ *+*
,- . /0 

!

,
   -!

 ./

)0,
*,**
1* !

 12 3,4 /    (&    

 5&&"12." 6 

 !-!

   &7 7
0*

1* 5&&"12." 36 %

 #

   ((

 ./  &7 (

8#49 "

5

)
6 

 # 

 

   

 7( 77  

#  &(  &(!

     1010
1*0  !

&

 ( /((-  8 ( !

 

   

 &7 7 

!! &  #&    8(

 ) :5:964(4
1*08
,0
1;
1*0   &%

7  ( :!

&(    * ( 

 #&  " &

  .4 /  

  

 &7 (

 % 7 #  &&!  # !

!8&& 



< =( !

7 ! -

30*5,*%6$ !6".%7% *! !"  .8 & &!6". 7   > (& ( &( 

 *0    $!

7

 <  ! >&   

# & -! &7 (

 ./  &7 (


1     (7  &

# !

,
     .!(( &   ! 92/:$&;".*$&<6 &;!6".%=*! !"

2&> ? &; &!6".

5-30 -.$@$& /0

 (

 !  

   & #( >&

# !

,
 7 -! 

./

&(

 &77 !

(  &  (%

> &   !

4   (  % ( & &(! 7  % &!

 

  !

  !

   #& & &

  

#   ! !

,
 .!   7 &

 (7

 7 7 ( & (  

 !   # #  -!

 %

4&7 !

(  & 

  !


1      %

 !  (# 

 &!  

  $! & B < =(  > !  &  

-C0*C ,$46$/ ".#6 &!7%"&!. /2." 2 
&="%!$< !$&&!6". #( (

!

& *%6$(%# %"-%2D. 0  ( (

%#   &7 7 %  #

 & &(  !(

 ((#

 

# 

 -!

 &7 (

 

 &

! &   7   7  #

 #!(   !

( >& 7( %# # >   < =(   > !  ; & 6 &?!=*! !" 2&> ?,

-0*   (%

> &  #&   !

4 ? 

 7     %(

!

 #

 -! %(%    !(  ( !  &! !(  ( &&

7   &7 7 % &7 (

  "

7

 (% # (    !( %!  &!

  (!>! #&  &!  ( %!    &



7  % &  !

(

&

7 & % 

7

!( (     &77   

&  7

 

!

 (  





3 & &(    (# @

%#  % 

( ( ( 

"

 &&!

 &

  % 

 (% 

& 

7  

& 

 (% # !

 (( #((   &!  (%

  & 



  7   %

   & #  

 7 7

 #   !

 >&  

# !

,
  -!

 ./

 

  $! & &&

( 

 ((#

./ )0,

*,**
1* !

 12 3,4 /    (&    

 5&&"12." 6 

(( !-!

 

7  -!  2<2%!

,

-*+*
0 '