Seimens Limited v. State Of Haryana And Another
!"#"$% & "' $#("'" ) " "$ * +# & *, $ $) $ - * #.$) $ # %
####
$%& ' ( (
*)'
( +
'
))(
''
( (
'
*)(
))(
,) $"& - )'
) ./) % 01 (
*)'
( +
'
))( ./) 2 %"1 (
'
*)(
))( ( '(
3) ')
*)'
( +
' '
*)(
$4& +''( (
*)'
( +
'
))(5
! !) (
(
%
6 ,
'
789%0:9";%<
'
' =9
4:;
%>4 . %>%1 9
%2% 8
". 1 %<."1
8) ' *8
))(
"
6 ? '
789";29";%<
'
' =9
4:;
%>4. %>%1 %>> %2% 8
)9 %<."1 ". 1
)9 ".1.1 ".1.1 @ @ *8
))(
6
)'
)
! %;4
'
' =9
4:;
%2% %>4 %>A %>> :%0 :%2 :"; :;A 8
4:9%;>9%";5 8
@) *8
))(
:
6
,
! 2:
";%4
'
%>4 9 %>A 9 ";;
9 :;A 8
%;> 9 %";5 9 4:
9 <%% 8 8) ' *8
))(
<
6
-
7894"49";%<
'
%>4
%>%9%>"
9 %>A 9 %>> 9 ";;
9 %2% 8 )
4:
9 %;> 9 %";5 9 <%% 8 8) ' *8
))(
6 +B C'
78 %<<
'
%>4
%>%9%>"
9 %>A 9 %>> 9 ";;
9 %2% 8 )
4:
9 %;> 9 %";5 9 <%% 8
8) ' *8
))(
( 6 6
%9";%:
(
%% %"
%>0% ! *8
))(
)'
)' ) :
'
! % :
< (
'
4:;
'
( )
'
! 0 '
$:&
''
''( (
'
*)(
))(5
! !) (
(
%
6 9
C(( .1 -
! %%A ";%<
'
' =9
4:;
%2" %>4 .
%>%9%>"1 %>A %>> ";> 8 )9 %<."1 ". 1
)9 ".1.1 ".1.1
@ *
))( "
6
)'
)
! "4"
'
' =9
4:;
%2" %>4 %>A %>> ";; :A< :A2 :0% :%> :";
8
4:9%;>9%";5 8
@ *
))(
6 9
C(( .1 -
! A24 ";%4
B( 3)( %A ;4 ";%4 (
! 0< ";%"
@ *
))(
:
6
,
! "A> ";%<
B( 3)( "" ;0 ";%< (
! %A% ";%"
@ *
))( <
6
,
! <:2 ";%0
B( 3)( 4; ;% ";%< (
! %";
";%:
*
))(
)'
' )' '
! % :
'
7'
'
! < '
D ' %0 ;2 ";%0
! %A02 ";%0
$<& -
)'
(
(
) ,) ''
'
''
- ''
'
'( ,)( )
'
$A& -
)'
('( ) ''( '( '
)' 9
)( ' -
)'
) ) )' '( ' ( 9
''
) B ( 9
'( )'' ' ') '
$0& -
)'
' )
!"#$ % &'"$()* %+ , %- % .
% /0 ,% 1 #23! % #'!&
(
:;0
-
9
D / E
E ' ') '
' ) D / )
:;0."1
D ) ' ) ) ) B( (F
-
)'
) ) ,)
:24
,)) )' ' ' D )
(
/ ) )
'
:24
) /) '
( D ' )' '
( '(
'
' -
)'
' ) )'
' 3) )
)
'
'
)9- ''
$2& ) ' '
(
% % 4 1 0 )
%
(#2'3+!5!5 ) )
. )(1
(
D ''
5)( (
) ''( D ' (
)( ) ' ' )' ' '
''
' 5)( ( ) )
'
' ! 2:
";%4
! % ";%:
8
789%0:9";%<
789";29";%<
7894"49";%<
! %;4
789%<<9";%A '
)
B
5)( (
) ) ' '
' ";.41
) 8
! %;4 ''
''
' ' ";.41
) 8 /'
''( '
' ' ) 6 ,7 1 8 %8 *9.
#2$##3"3 :
4 (#22#+# #230 4* 9
;
9* % .
< #2$! 09 :
7 =
#"#
:
*
#22! $"5 9 %;%4 *
%
6 )* %
, 8%
.%
#23& $'
)
% . 0 -
#2$5(#+
$&2, .
%< ** .
8
:
*.% #2'$#25'
* 0
4* * % *
(!""5+'&&3
$>& () ) (
' $%;& '
,)
'
)9''
D
'
' ' (
*)'
( +
'
))( ' (
'
*)(
))( 7) 9' *)'
( +
' ) ' (
' '
! 0 '
! % ";%:
( D '
(
4:;
''
' 9' ( '
*)(
))( ) ) '
7'
'
! <
'
! <:2 ";%0 (
D '
'
, '
D ' ''
5(F ( 8
789%0:9";%<
789";29";%<
7894"49";%<
! %;4
789%<<9";%A ) $%%& D '('
( ) ()
(
'(
:;0
:24
5(F ( )' /
$%"& ( B(
' )'
'
! " ''
' 5)( ( D
B )' ' ) '
' ' ' ' '
' ! < .1 .(1
5 (F ( ) )'
'
( )' ) ) ) '( '
' '
)' ' )'
' )' ) ) '
'
D '
! 0 '
'
'
! %;4 ''
'
D '
' () 5'(
4:;
$%4& DB( )
' () '
,) '
( )' '
3) '
' '
$%:& !( / )' ) )'
%: ";%2
/&0
G B(9
?9! G ' ?9!