← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1122/1989dismissed

Jug Lal And ORS. v. Kalia @ Kalu And ORS.

2015-02-11Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal12 pages



    

 

  !!" 

    

 

    #   $%#   #  





 !

 #  !

  

$ %

  !

&

'

   !

  (((((

# & )*

   !   & "  

 ,) "

-. / !

 0  " 1  " & &   2



" !



.20% "

 /    

      

    &

 &



 "

,) "

-./ !



&2 ""

! 

 



  

 )33 " // '& !

  !   . 2&

" 

4

)33//

.  1 "&   

     



 )33 //   !  ! .

" .

/ 

 

 ! 5* 5!*"

)335)*// 5*

! .

!

2 & 

  

"&65.*

!  " 

 

 "&    

 "  " &  5!*  .  

  

!



 

/  .22

&

.

" & 2.2 !



!"

! 

 '&





 ! !2 .

  " .   1  " &    

 !

 

 !  .

 2 .

!

 

  !

2 &. &



  .   1 "& !

&



 



2 .   .! !2     

7   

    +



   &  " 2

 8   



4* 9

  

 .   1  " &

 .

"

+ 

 "

"& .  1 "&

  2"!   : ) ;

  !"! 

 " !

 ! .

"   "   "  "" &  "  

 

 &  

. 

"

)<5!*"

!"!  "!

)=<>?

>

4 ;

1

)< 5!* " !"!  "!

& 



""  &"









. !

"

!

 "!

? > ;

   

 "

 @, "

 !

& &

 

.

"

 ? , ;

 !!

 " " "!

&

  ! .

  .

   !    .  1 "&   

"

.  1 ""!

? @ ;

  .  "

  & .2

 / .

& ! .

 .

 .2 &2 "  .2

 /  ! ? >*

"" 

   !   

!!

 -

  

   .2

 /  .

& 

     "   !"! 

 " !

 

4334)=A@ ,*

""

"   !"!

"!



4334)=A@

 ",BC "  

 . " .  

  &   !

 " =3338: & "7  +

   !

 &  

 

 & !  &

 

2 "   '

 

 "



 "

   

 & "7  ""!

2

 "

 1 &

 2

"2

@*

 &!

.2 C

! 2 

 

4334)=A@& 

 &

"!

&

 ""  !



  "

  

 

 &

,



!

 

"" !

!

" 

+



"" 

 



!

 

" 9

&2

 

 &

""

 



!2

 

 &!

&

 !

 &

!

.

&

 .



!

&  !

<* "

 "

! 

 /  "

"& :                   

   

     

      

   !! "#     $ 

            

%  &        

            %  '     

    !! ("#               

       )           

  

 %  # * A* %

   &

 &      +  /   

   .2  ! 9  ') 

 "" $ !  9  '4  , &  



 & " .

.2  9  '> & 

  +  /   

  2 

 "

 

 9  ')

""

@

""&

 "

2&

 "!

B*  "" !!

"2 !

 

 -

 

 /  .

 9   

 /  &  



  -





4>3))=B= =*  ""  7       5!

.

*  ;:) 

""

;:4 $

 & 

 

    ;:>      .

  

 

 & 

 

    ;:, .

 .  

    :) !2 " - . "

 2  )=B3:B)  :4 !2 " 

    /    '<<3 " )=B,   D 

  E !   343B)=B,  :> !2 " C    &   :, !2"- ."

2 )=A@:A<:@ )3*



 7  0-  "

$;:) 7  & $;:4 .

 . $:)$:4! " 

 ))*  /   

 

""   & "  .

 &

 

   ! "     

 " 

 ,)   4A // &  "  +

     & 

 .

 !

   

    



 

  "   

 )=A@  )=B3 & 2 )><)>3  

 

 &""!

.

"

! 

 "!

.





 1

<

)4*

  !  &    .2

 &

 

 /  &   !

   

  ""

 " "

 /  

 9  ')

""

 ""&



2&

  " !

 '  !

 " 

   & !

!

" "" .



2&

   " !

!

  

 &

 "  





!





2"

 

  

 "

   2

!



&!

!

  "" !"!

!

 2

"

 



"

" !



 &  !

 .

  !

 "   +

 &

 

 

 

.



  )>*

 &

  

 /  

 " 

9 '4,

 .

! "



""& &

" !



+

2 &  

  !"! 

 " !

2

!

 &

" C

 ". 



"

& &

 &



 &

  @ +

 &   ),* 9

     !  "

    

!  " 

   

4334)=A@2

 "!

.



 &   F  $;:) 0-     

A



   F7:) .   ""

 !

  !

.



.

  

@2  ! "

.

     " "

 & 

     C !





.

 ! .

.

 +

 & 

  " !

  "7 "

 

 &   .

 !

    ! !  "

 2

 

""  ""



   &  

 "

 )<5!*"

!"!

"!

)@*



 ! "



 

"!

!

& 

" @2 &  & !

 .2 &2 " &  9  & "

 2

"

 

 .2

""

 ' 

"

 &

 

""&

 "

2&

  ". 9 .

.

   

 @, "

   !

  "2

 "!

 "

 !   

 > "

 !

! &

 .  

 ! 

""&&

    )<*  /  2G



!2  . "

 2  )=B3:B) 5F7:4*  &

   .

 $0G &

 & !:



 &



""   +   "

 &  &     ,  

C ! "

!

 ! 2

"  

B

&  0

 !

   "

"" & !

.

!2

   "

"" & !

.  "

 

 

 343B)=B,    !   &

   

 -!





 """

!



7 ! "

.2&2"

 2 !

!

 "

 " "

  "" 5

*   0G   

 

     &

&  



343B)=B,0





 "

""&&  F 

. 1



       &  5F7:,*

   "  "" &  !

  . "

 2  )=A@:A<  &    "

""   -  

 &

 

!  "    ,  9

" !  ""!

 &!! 

 

 "

 @>5* "

 + "

 

2!



 &

 ! " 

 &  )A* / !

 

!! 

)<5!*"

!"! "!

""

 & 

"

&



 !

  1

 "   

  

1 

!

   

  

 

 &     9

 .  "     !   .



""&

2&

 "!



=

)B*   

 )< 5!* "

!"!  "!

   &  

 

""   .

! 

.

!

" ""

  

! 

 & 

2!

"

"" 9

 . 

2

!.



 

.



  "!

 F  "        "!

/ 2 &2 "

     .

 &

 

.

!



B2 "





""

!



! .

!



.



! 2.







 !"#$

%&'

)=*  

     "   !"! 

   !"!& 

1

 

""&

2&

 ". 

&



 

"" "

   

 !. ! 

 

   &  9

   ! .

"

   !

! +

&

! "2  .



 ". +

!!

"" 



 

1

  

 "

! !

1 . !



"

43*

!"! 

   !

 2

" /    .   !

"

2

  &"  +

!

! .

!  .

2 

. 

  .

   

.  -!  !  &  

)3

.  !

    /     .

  

"

!

 2

"" !"!

2





"!

"  +

!

"



&

!

&  

 

&

2



!  " 

 H&

    "

 



    .

 .  

2  !!

 &

 " 

43" !"! "!

 4)* 9  & " '((' $#% ) '

   



  ** + , ! E 

 "

     .



!

"  "



"

" !

 

9  &"

43"

!"! "!

/  .  

"" !"!

!

    44*  " 

      .

 &"2

!



 !

""   .

 

!



 )< 5!* "

!"!  " !

 %

/

 " " "!

 9  !  

" " "!

&

  !  .

  .

 +

.   1  " &   .

  

 "

  .   1  " "!

 +

 .   1  " & 

 &



 

4>*  12

" &"



.    

 " ! ! 

  & C  .2

 &

 





  ! +  !  ! "&

H ! .



))

"

"9  

 

!!

 .2

&

 

"





"   !

2

 2

1

"&  ""

&

2

 29 1

2" "  2  &





" !



'((-$&%  $  %#.







+ 

,!  4,*

!

 "

""&" . 

 





  -

 !! 

""

   &  !!  " 

 

 "!

 &  

 .

.

 .2   +

   "    "  .2



2.

   !





 ""

 



 /   !  &

!

 +

"" 2

&

 

!

 4@* 9

 

"! ! .   1  ')  "



  &

   " 



""&



2&

 ". +

""



 !

 2

"" !"!

0 & 

1 '4&



 "" !



&

!

.

" ! "

 &



!





 "   !  .

 

" 2 / 1 2 1  '>    !  

 "" 

 . "  !  "

 1 

)4

!1 ',@!.



1 "&

&2 !

1 ""!



"

 & .2

.

&"!

! .



.

 !  



! "  H

/ ! .

"""!

.

&&

  

 . "



!  "     

 "

   

""

.

&!.



4<* / 1 2    -

  



.

& !" 2

+

   !

  



& !  ' ()#*( +*, - + !!"

/