High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1165/1989dismissed

Abdul Gaffar v. Gurcharan Singh

2016-02-02Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal8 pages

"# $$"" % # &'&!& $! ( )*+& !, &$$"" )- !, &$!

./ ("!

"#!$$"'& !'1!!!!2

$! !!"

* !' # !$ 3& $$""! !! !'&0 !'1!!!! 4

$! * !' 56" # !$ 3$! ./ (""! $"!1 ' -" -" )" &

"7 !&( 089+!!!4 ("""'!&"!:

33! ( 089 +!! 3!&, $

-" )""!"

!'& "!! 9"$&"!!$93'&& $"3,&"! !89+! 2!3$ ''

.4/ 3! &!!"" "

!'' !1" " !! 0! $!0 !&6,"6 .;/ &&$"!'&$ ""3' 31! <= 8&&&"!!$ 3!

( 089+!>(( <= 8&& & $" " & ( 089+!>(( <4= 8&&&$"&" ! "&$ >( <;= 8&& #1 (& ) !$ ,""'3& "!>( < = 8&& & $" $$! 1 "'&$ &$, !

4 < = 8&&& &0 ! &$ >( <2= 8&&& !0! $>( < = 8&& & 3& "1> (( < = 8&&& "!&1"!&!

!! ",'$ &1$& >5 >( < = 8&& !! & 1 3& "! !,$> ( <= 8&& & $" "! & $& "!>(( <= " .

+& & $ "! ,! ! & " 6 !! & ,! 0 !'1 ! ! !!

2 . / !"''',!'&0 !'1 !!&"6 "!$$"&"3 $$""6 !

!,! &"3 $$""6 $!&$$",!0 !'1!!

; !!2

!& &3 &$$$"1 "! .2/ ?& '& " :

"3 & 1!&$$" "! "&$$""& '

!&3&&&$$ ""

!$!&, !

$$"1! 1!89$$ , !

!!$,! ,!> .

5&,!!&'

1"! "

&&!3&! .

?&,":

&&$$$"

8&& "!89$$ > . &$""1$& "!

'" !&( 089+! & " "

'!&$"&"&'&& $$ , ( 0 89 +! ?& " , ( 089+!:

&$""& &&3!

!" &( 089+!! "!&$"!1&!!5& , !,@*1!&

ABCD #1(& !!&3&"! 1 ' -" )" 5 6"

1 & 01! &&3$

-" )""!!&1'"! -" )"&&3 ?&"!

&3 &!&$

./ E! "&$$""!!&& 3&$&"!1 ' -" )" 3!1&#1(& ( 089+!

,3"!!

2 ! &E!

! ./ $$"

&"&&"'&&!

! "!"&!3&"'" & & 3!) "! " ( 089+!"1!"&BC(4A( (3D ! !! 4

2 ABC(D !

! & 89

; %! & !

"!1 ' -" )"3! 89 ' ', ! ( " & &3&&!89$ "

3&!&89!& $ "" 1'1!" ,$ 89$$ ?&:

$!&$$$"

3&&&$$ &3 &1

$ 1!&,,!89+!3&

$!!! &1(" "!"!

,!& & "' ! "!

$ & !! &! & ?& " ! $$ ! ,' "! & !,,&$3&! &89!& $ ",'89 $$ .4/ 5

!"#$%&'()%*%+ ,-./01 /23&"!& ! AD&89 "!"

&+!!1 3""& +!! &$!& &3,&! $ ! &$ ""

3& &!$ 3 &&!$ ,'& $$ 89$$ .;/ 1""

-3$%&$# (4+5!"#

(*-

'( &-)+(- &$*-3%( ./1/60/3&"!

&&'!!!! $,!

$,' & $$ 89 $$ 5 & !! &$$ ""'!89$$

&"! 1"

&' !!

1!&, ! &,! !$,$1!!&$$ $$'5"1 &$ $1!

2 &,' & &'! &,'

1'"'& . 1""

!"# $%& '( *5 -%5 $7( +,-3% 38$ &%7 8-$$4 (+ ./0144 &+ &9( 3:$%*3%1.63&"!&1 1'&*1!3""19 & 1 89 $$ ?& $" & "! &, !!

!,! !!! &$$ &$ $'@! ) "1"3$ "' !

&" . / 1""

!"#$%&5 4 **'( *-+ ,-./00 .; &,+&&6 !' "3 & 0 1 &"! & & ! AD&" !&$&&&$!&89 !!A&D5& &: $!

!!&"'&$!!& 01 "

!!&& ,! !!!& $ "' !&"$ $ &$"'& "!3&&1

&,',!

( 089+!&'&1& , !!&"

.2/ 5&"'&! &$"&"! !!

",,! &!

"' '! & $" & $" & ! & '&&3!&9

""'!39&&!!?&!$ $ ,' ,' & $$ 89 ($ :

!&!1&6,"6 1 6(6 & &:

"1!

&$"!&$$" . ""

&$$"""

!!,! 1!&1!'"

!1!

3 % %7;66;.<