Raj Kumar v. Jagir Lal And ORS
!
August 26, 2022
"#$%&
'& $ ( &)*!+ ,& -
./ 0).
1- 1)1)) 0).
- 1 1
!"
%%%%
)1))2-
& "'( ) *( +,*'
- -
"( 0,* * 1
2
(3 " "4,( "$ *
"( 6
(# #" "
+,("( '
87 2
- 9 :
"( 6
"( -
*(
("
( '
( (" * '
"'( & +
<- 3$
,(* ; / $
"'( $ ,*$ 3$'
3
( '(= ,*$
+( 5
"
( "",
( ,
>(,
(
(,
,##("(
$( ""(/
*(! ('
(* ., (3 "'(= ,*$
3 ,$/
*(! ) ,(* "'(= ,*$ "/"
*(! ('
(* '
, #
3 '$
#,
'/ "$
( , 3$("$ ?
@ "$
( "'( $ (3 (
"", ,$*3( * ) .
(* .(*
# (*
# '
( (3 '/ 2,
$,*$
' "", #, ("
, (* (!(*( "
*( *(! *
(*
., $ ,$/
$ *(! * ('
(* '(= ,*$
"'( "",
((* 3(# A( " '( 9 :
"(! $("
" # '
"",
., -
"'(* (") , "'( ( "",
4,
"'( (" $( #" / ., -
' "",
*3($ $( ('
* "'(
"$
,,
$) B$( ;$ 3(# " '(
"$
" ; 7 ;$ '( "
$, $( $
(3 $), () ( #
"$(* ; 7 ;$ -
' # '
3$ *3($ $), ()$ ( B ( 5,$,
,"
$), () ( " $,
3$ $/ 3
"'(= ,*$
$*(* "((* #
'
, (
,
") '(= (3 $), () ( ", ,
)(#
, "'(= ,*$
. #, $ (
* "'(= ,*$
"''( ,("( ,
"",
,$*3( 0*(
B 2, (
$,. '$ (3 #$ (3 ( (3
"(!/
" '( (# ' '
(" .( $(
' 87
C1 <:@5
*( ,*$ (
C1 <:@8
' '
"," !("
("
1'((
' "" 3( 3
" #
"'(
(!(*( #(
"( :- *( $
"", "''( ( - 6 : $ *
"( 6 3 # ' *( "",
,$*3( 0*(
B
",( 1'( (*$
3( ,.( ( "
7"
('((* !(" "( ",'" 3 , "", 3$ (
*( ("" '
"( --
3
"
"",
$,. " (
*(
' ' >
(!(* $(/ $( 3(# $/ * ( ( 7 #"
(3 #'(/ "",
((* #( #
$ 3 $(
3$("$ <)# 5 3$ 3 ,.(* (',"$
$/ 3 '(* "$ # '
$('
, "$ 3 $, 3$
1 $( (.((/ !" $,* ',
)$ 3$("$ .(*
' $( (3 ,(* $( 3(#
" , 3$("$ $
," # 4,"/
!((
$' D
/ (
"",
" *3($
*
$' /
/ "$( ,''
!"( ., ! $(
/ $ $ "", $,. ) $('
)
.")
' ('( $' "", $( 3(# ! ( #
"'(*
.") #(* $'
#'(/ , 3$("$ $
"''( ,("(
"", 0*(
B ,$*3(
2 3$(
(* ("" $/ $(* ' ('( (#
" $/ 3 (!(* / $!(*
( " * ""( *(
' '
3 ( $/
3 ('(" #/ / ,
($( " '/
(*$ 3( 3 1'( #"
B ( #
1'((* !("
" #"
"( ",'" " "", ",( #( ! ( "
*( (3 3$ 3 "" (*/ "4,(
"$ * # ' *( $' "", &
$,.
" $3!
$ *,(/ "!("
##"
,($.
"( 6 " "" (*/
** (! # '
"4,( (3
$ #( "'(
B ",
!$'/ *, (#
"'(= ,*$
,## , 3($( ! /
(*
,##("( !("
" ((" $ ,.+"
' ' , $
2
"(#("
*( ! *( (
B ", #,
*, $!(*
(" (
3 " !(
('
/ (
(" 3/ # '
("
$,. #
"
", !(" ( # " ' ('( (#
.(* ' ,
"", / #,
" ' "( -5 7( C!(" "
!("
" #" ' "4,(
2
$, / $( 3 "4,(
2
( (3 ( $/ $ *,(/
"$ *
"( 6 " "" (*/
> ",
* $ ,*$
#( 3 $"/ !(" 3$("$ ," $('
/
, ,#,
#
!(( "(
"( -5 7( C!(" " 3$("$
E1 !
!
" ! !
# $ % &
'(#)'( #
! !
!
."
1 !3
,'( $F<$ 4,(
3$$
$ "''( $ 3'
$3 .#
$ ,"$ 3' ,.+"
,"$ "
,/
""( /
$ ,' ,"$ ",
$
C1(F8
, $( "( E3 $G $
' '(* "( 5 7(
G
7 #! "4& $ 1
$!"567819 $
,'( $ 3 (",'. ,
",( #( .($ #3(*
$ 3' ", .,
.(/ (+,
"",
$ 3( $
' "( ",'"H
. ,"$ $ $, "",
3($( :
/
(*H
" ,.+" "
,/
$,.
/
(!
$,.H
,"$ "
,/
$,
""(
/H
,"$ "
,/
$,
,.+" .#
$
$, "
,'(
"( -5 7(
C!(" " 3$("$ ,'( 3 " 3 " ",(
#( .($ (* ( .!
>=. , ' , * %4& $ 1
$!"5 637:1 $ $ $ 3( (# ! ,")
(! *3($ $,. "( ."
"(#("
*( ." ",( !(* (* (
"( " ., " , $!(* ("$ *
,'(
"( -5 C!(" " " "
>=. , ' & , #$%& 4& $ 1
&;! !+ ,& 8 67 1 6& -7 9<9 $ $
4,( '
*( *(
(! $,. '/
' "(#("
'/ ' ",(, (* ,"$
*( $( .") '
$ 1'(
$ "'(= ,*$
'(/ ) " 3($( !
/
(* $ ( 9 :
(* $!(*
'(A
<?
7 !
(*$
3 )(* ("
##("
(!( >( * (" 5 6 9 :
"(, *3($ , + 5
","(*
'
+( 5 . ! "$ #, "* ', .
'(1 $ /( !
( (
+,"(! $'
$* .( / ' ( .
#,
1'(( #, (
") "(,,
1" ")
,(* .(4,/ .")3 "'
('
"'
('
!
(*$ '( " .! ! $/ ( " (*
$/( . (" , $ #
*(* $ ,*$
$'(" C1'(
C1 I $/1(
, "' (
") "$ "'(= ,*$
( ,,
$ 3($( ( ! /
(* J,( '(
3$$
",( . ! (3 ,.+"
"
,/
""(
.#
$
B ",
,. / *(
! *( (3 * !*, ,
'
.(*
# (*
'
2
,$*3(
'$ (3 ' .# ( "'(
(*
<- #$ (3 ' * )
.* '( "'(
<- (3 (!(*
/ # '
$,. "",
" ," $( $, /
(!(* *3($ $( 3(#
" "$( (" $ $ !
" (3
( " 3$(
$( 3(# $( "$(
!("
" $3 !
"'( ( '
2
("
(*
(
,# , '(
9 : 8, ' . , # '
" ,'
:
@
(
2 0*(
B #!,
+(
5 $ 8
C1<@ /
8
1 (
6 '
"
"! 3$!
##" # '
2
< , ' "'(
<- $( 3(#
2'
(
< $,) () (
<9 ., ",
,. (( / #(( !("
* (* ( '
' ,
2
""(
.#
$
",( $ ( #( ! (
" ./
. ,. *(
2
(( * "'(* ,.(
( "4,( "", ('/ .", $
!(3 '/ (.
" * ,
! (* +,*' "4,( >=. , '
&$*4*$4-1&=& !+5;, $5* & $ &<671:
$
K4,(./ $ 3
!(3
"( ( !("
" ",
3, +,(#(
! (* +,*' "4,( / (#
,.( "'(*
3$
+,*' ( ", #, ! +,*'
7 # (*
,( '
3$ $
!(3 (.
"
*
((
"
/(A
# '( +,*' $( "", ,'
(" ,( ! *,(/ "", $(
,'( 3$ .# ( ", ( ", =
"4,( . ,'( (" D$(
#,' ("( ', ) !(3 3$( (*
+,*' "4,( ( ", G
# " $(
* " '
+,*' >=.
, ' & % !* ==* - <
61
" ,! 4& $ #
& %7 "( :
3$ ( $
'((. ( # #((* "4,( , #, !(3 )
('(.
!
;(* !(3 #" "( ",'" .! 3
#( / * , 3$!
( # +,*' - -
"( 0,* *
(* ( "4,(
2
>3!
" (#( . !( $( "((
1 ( (( / '
' ( '
* (* "",
3$ "
('( ( ?
5
$
"( ( 3 ' ( "" " 3
"" (*/ ('(
(LISA GILL) JUDGE August 26, 2022 (HARSH BUNGER) Rts JUDGE <$$
)(*@ L@2
<$$
. L@2