← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3819/1999disposed of

Chief Administrator Huda v. Presiding Officer, Inds. Tribunal Cum Labour Court Gurgaon And ANR.

2025-08-06Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari11 pages



               

  !"  #$%$!& ' ()*(*(+  

 

      

 

  !

" #

"$ $%#

&

   '

 '

,- * .

 /-





)  *

"(*

+    , +-"+   (  , . +    



-"+  

//// /-



0 *-

0 

- "



 "1123114 

!

   

-  54560776 

8

$9(

#: " !

" #

"-



 -

-  +

- "

" $

-  

: +  ""# ;-    11520775  - 

 ""

#: (



 1!# 2$&3% 4 "!1 5$% !61 1 

 

   +  07590777

: (  (

- 



"

   (

0777 

:

$- 

#"   

 9     "" 

(("  #

$1941$ 155<- "

, 04$. !

"

 07<4 

=! =- - ""-+  0951155<       -  (

   (

     (":  -   +

04$. "+

(

 8

 )$ >?      (

 (("      "

" $((" 

, * ", " "  

" $ ((" 

-



 (

  ( :  

((" 



, 04$. !

"

 !

 +

 ((" 

 "":   (":     

      

"    +

04$. !

"

 +- 

 

    (  (

- (

#:

  "   %#

 

""   

: 

# +

   ,  04$.      !

"  

  

":  

""  (":-  

- (   

 

 (:  +@ < .

8  

# 

 #:"

"     (

        +"

    " " :     (

-   ( + + " ( 

-   -

" 

(

   

  '

1  -  ((

    "    ":

- 50010762  +  - 

50500775   

    (

 

1$ - 

   ( :

""# ":- - ;  -  (":  50010762 50010767  -    A

 

  +    (  ; 

":  "":" #  - - -"" 50010767  "  #

"

" + "#: (

   "



 

: 

":   (" 1<5 :

:  



+     

 1B$C     !        (

  -   -  (

 -



- "

" 

-  

: +  # ;-

    11520775 .647$%%$!&% 7 2 !& 4 5 8" !" 9 $$!& 1%7 & 3 7 &* B %  

" (

# 

1D   (": 

-  

0775   "(   56:





  #"

 2 ,

# 

"  #

"

":  

 1B$C ! -  ":(  

""(    "  #

"

+-   (



.647$%%$!&% 7 2 !& 4 5 8" !" 1 %9!&2 & &!*:!1;7 &* 4  

# 

     #"      (

$

- (( #: "  

"

1D

,

# 

1- ; 1<5:

:  

 

-   (" - , 1B$C !

"

 - " (

 (

- ,

 ( +

: "" " :  (

- -

 #:

E" -

-

   0951155<   

#    (

$ 

   (" , 04$. !  #

 (" -   ": 1504 

1$ - (-    - , 04$. 6 ,"

# 

 "

" (("  $<297$E$151B ;

("   

 

 

#" - ""- 

+    (  

: 

  #:   

         - ;

"

1504   



$



 

""  

"  

  

1$  ( "( < = 1% & 8=%$% 7 .

 

(  

+  0051151B $ #  # (

 "  ( ++

 > -

;

- ( $

 ! - - +

04$.

( -:@ 05               (

$

" (  + #:,+ ,

 F8

+F

 

"

, &



# 

- (-

, 04$.

": ""1504  -

: 

(: 

-

((C

- 

$ "" + 

   +    

""- ;

- (

$ 

00 , + - 



#

  #:-:

8

'$1 '$<





#



# 

 #:"  

"

- ;

""

1504 01 

8

'$1 "

#

- #:  " ":

#: (

:  



A #

 +  ""  "  -

(   ("   0951155< #  -+

#(- "

 -

#:  "

- ""    "+

(

 8

  )$ >!

   - %#

:

04$.!  A #

 +  "" "

  E-+ ,*  + #( -

"

 - #:  "

E ""

    G     (" 



         =#"     

    0951155<  

":@ 09 

": #"

# 

 

#"

 

- ;

"



1504       0< 

 

 +-  "(  9B:



#"

(  "":- - - 

#"" "  1B$C!  ": 0B 

 +

# + 

  #:     =#"  ,    

   =.

- >%* 56167 8?0 (@ < . << "+

(

 8

 ) >99    "       

       

 :( ("

-  ""# ;- - 

#"" "

(("    "": ""  E"  :#

   -   +      

" 3(

 -

  "" "":   3  "     3  #:  -:   +  

 "#

  -+ -   

  ":$- - ; -

   

  "" "  # 

      (  

"  

 ": +" 1B$C !

"



 

;

+-

 

- # ;-

    

 "# +   :  (

- -""

  

  9<  

  :

"

  #+

!

"- -



#"" "# 

$(: 

 

 (

     (:      ":  A  

,  1B$C      !

"  

    +  

"-:

(  

+   (":#:(:

 

 

 (

,

- - ;

":$- # +  

 ;

" H , * ;+ +9H,  * ;+ +91552<,0)1552,%I, 4B9JJ

-  

 " 

" 

 

+ ":$- - ;

 "(



# +

-   #

+   :  (

#: 

"

          

    - "   + :   (

  ":        

 

 (

 (:!



+

" 

 "

(- " + :

 9B E- "-+ ";  +   :#  - ":$- - ; 

#"" "

-



 "#

  +" (""

  

+K -"

- ; ":- 

 -

   :"

#



 -

"

 (" :#

 

!

 

- ; "

# 

"

   - :



 (

 

  (

 

!

 

"#

"  ": 8 ( "   

#

-

 "  # @ 02 -

""-#:  =#",  

= &4$1 .$&35 >%* A #6$> &3****=+"(("?<<69

 1505  +  

    51571510  -     ""-

# +

-  8

  )$ 2 "

"-- - ;

-   

 

-  

 -  

((""

- ; 1<5  :

  ((""

L +   -   +"

 :( +

1BC  

:

+"+ ((

": ( #" 

:  

     ((""

- ":-

((""

- (

 (":!

"+

- 

-

!

?0- - -

((""

L + - 

   - -  

# ;- - 

"   -  

  

 "    ((""

  "    +

 +     

#"  

   

 - ;

  



(  

!

- ; ("-  

 #:

  -  

 '* 

- -+ 

- "#  (( (  ""-!

-

#

   

1BC#



#" 

#"  (

"# (( (   : 4

  

   

 

  ((""

-

 -  %#

1552 ((""

 ;

1557""-

 (

  "

;

 ((""

- """;" (": - "



 - "##

# +-  :

 (

 

(" '

1B5553$'

(

-

:C+

 "

  (

((""

# (  '

91B  ";  '

(     %;   -

:  C+ 

   (

;

 

 "

 ((""

"

:# ('

1B5553$'

(

-

:C+

   (

@ 04 

 + 

- -:# ;  50500775, 

"

"

":  (

   " "    

      (

$ 

 06 

"

 

  



+  

#(

 #

  9B:

+(

?- 

 

  - "# (   (

(:#"

( (

"  (

- 

 

 

 (   (

-  A   A ":

 (

 #:

+ :

( "

"

 (": 

 07  $ # 

,

, M



=.

 !"

1= & >%* .61B &2 &!5 1=E$005B4$ 1550       9554151B  

":  8    

  

 " #(  (

'

B55553$    (" :  "+

(



8

  )$ >2 

"( (""-

"#: + . 

%?0159$1510 "

, ;#  ,

  +   ,      :      

    

50591519  (": 

"   (

"  # 

+ '"+

(

(





)$ 





 

   

    

         

                        

    

     



     !

     

"! #  $

 

  



   



  !

%



     !             ! 

 

  !

%  

 

  

  

  &'   

 &'     

  





      

  

 

  

      ) * + , #

$ -! .

 + 

 / 0 1 2)3 (## ) 

  &'          -

 4 .

 #

 / 5#6  2)3 7 (## 8 8           ) &'  

 

   +  9

 %  .

 #

 :    / ;

 (  <8 2<3 (#

)7  

  

  









   =      

 

&'  

 ( 

   5

 $   5 *  "

 / ; ( <= 2<=3 (## =         

  &'  !



 > ?/+

 :

   / (

( -



  (

:

   < 23 (#* <      

         &'

  



  !

  @    

  

  

A 4# (

" #+ ( 

" -

    (" :



-

#(  (

'

B55553    (" : *(

+- 



?0$- - ; (  

52:

#   

"

'

9555553$

 

@ $& 8 !12 1 15 ;

 

 "



 - 

 

 " "

" (

+      -"" : "  " " 

" # ;





 (( ( 

 (

  %*0+(0(((C 69 % & - ;5 $"= 5!6% &2 !&8= 0

- - " +   

  A :

 

 10    (

""#(

1$ #:(

$ 

- ( 59 

 (  

 (: !

+

 : "

(: 

  (

(

$ 

""#"#" (:

7N(

# "

"   (

""

" " 11 $%9!% 2 !"- #+

/-



 636% ()0 (+  E (;

 ) G 3? E (

#" ) G 3?