Vinod Patel v. State Of Punjab

 

    




!"#"

$%&' &'  ("$



) ''''** ))$

(+#'

, 

-$./

'''' #* $ $

% 012 ,'

,
2   012 ,'

,
2 
 
 

   

  

 

  

"

- 34"5 '

 "



 "  #$ #% %#%&   

 

('

 )*+ , -.

 &/ #0 %#&1

  /#% *
 2 

   ""

 + &####45



 '"  

 +*  " 

  &/ #0 %#&1

'

 '   

* + 

  '  (  

 7 '

  



 "

   8   

  ! +  

   * + 

5 9% & ! "    

  

( 

! ' &/ 0 %#&1

&###

" "   (8 + 

7 "   :

  

  "

' ' '

8 ( 

   

  



  "  "'

    ' ' 

 ( " '

' '

 /#5/- '     (  8  !



  

;  

"

 '   = 

3  " '

  8   

"

8(  ( '



 ' 8

8  '

     8 > ;







"  ?



  ( "

)*+

  /#%

%#& *
2 



8( 

*



  "8 


 '

 '

 

   ;  " )6



 (      











 '

 "

'

2 :  + 

; &- #0 %#&1 '



  

 



%0 '  



3(  
  + 

 + 

! 



""

'



 



"



2"

=@ " <



(

"

"



  

 

   

  



  )6   " 





'

6    " , .A&10.A%-% "

 

 "     

3



 
"

  

: 

  &0& 2
2

   

 8 ?



(

   8 "  

"  "

, $A%1%/A%%0   "

; %# #0 %#&1 ( *

 ;

  ' 

 " 





  "   



 ! + 

    + 

<    


   !

 

  ,

 B
 ( 

  :

   <   

 ! + 

* +  

 

 "

'

  ; %& #0 %#&1  

      &% #0 %#&1  

   "'

+

(  

  '    7  

 (

 



'

8

 3   



    8      ( + 

    

  8

 " 8

   ?



  (   8  "

 

 8   

7  



 8 ( 

; 

  8   8 

8  

8 "

+

  "

8

'  





(  8 8

  8  (

 8 '

   

 8  

( 

   8 !  ( 



(   8

7 8  "

    

 "'  

 8

8 8    4

! ( " 

+ 1##  8 8

 8  "  "  "

8 + 1##45

!   (    '

8 "'

(  



<

; '  ( "

" 8 ,

 

 " " (    '



  "

8

 8  " 

 "'   4 

"    *

 ;

  (  "  )*+

  

 

  (   



;

  /A *
2

 )*+

"  ;



" ' 

 



 

 + 



 

  

  ( "

&% #0 %#&1 







 " 

 



    * ?



   '   "

  %#1 2
2  ""  * ?



  

2   "



  /#% *
2 #$ &% %#&1

 

'

 @ " "

     2"

7&

7% +    

7/ "8 
 
7     8 , + " + 


7- : 2 :

 
70

(   "

  ; 2 :  + 

71   ;"

8 
71    +  28    
71 C '

"D :2 ( 
7$

 
7.

2 * 
7&# * +   *

 ;
7&&

 
7&% * "  ""  '

 * +  
7&/

  ( 

7&A   , ;   *

6 "

   "'

  
"

  ""  "

(  







8  



  /&/

8 2
2







 

   

 (   ( "$

 

!!-#

("$



) !

::"

:-4

;:)

* ,"$<3

$

$"<3

'8' =>  

 "    '

'

(    *

  4




 "

'

"  ; "



 

 "

(  "

8 ?



7    ' 

 


7A 

:  ( " (  

   "



 

7A  (8

 "

 8

?

 8

 8

8 ,


    



  ,
    -50 "

8 "

   8 8

8  8  +

 &# ## "

( 

 "  ( 



 

  8  

  8(  

  * +   *

 ;   

+    

=   " =@
7&#4)

=@
7&#4

'  

( " "   $/0#11/%/#

.A&10.A%-%

+ "    .1$&%5/$/0#   

=@
7&A43

 

  0-53

   

  +   &% #0 %#&1 @  ( " 

" , $/0#11/%/# ( &. #- /0   %& A% &&  

    &/1  .



 %& A% &&   &% 0 %#&1 (

7A 

  
7A 





 "

 

  

=  

     &% #0 %#&1

(   8 (  (  

 

 "$

 

$

*)?

)#

#

$

4?

@"

!

4"

# "$

*4 # $

!#

*  

   C=@
7&#4<D ( "  =@ ;4%

=@ ;4/   "" =@
7&#4

 

 ,

(

 "" =@
7&#4, +     ;   

  

+   (

 

7% 

B 8

 " 

7 " ; =@ ;4/    * +   '

     

 

8  

5@ "  

+'







 

 , & ,
 

 

 

=@ ;4A

 "" =@
7&#42



  "' , :+ #0) &//A '

 

  4




    

 =@
7&#4<

'

"" =@
7&#46 =@
7&#4 =@
7&#4

=@
7&#4, =@
7&#4;

=@
7&#4F   "'

7A  "   8 





( "'   

   "'  



 

:(
71    ;"

8    ;"

8   ( "'  ' %#&#

("

  "'  ;"

8 

 '

"' 

  

 "'

  '

(  
7& "



7  "'

70

(   "

 (  "" 3 



&    ""

@ "    '

"





*    ""        &%4&/ 0 %#&1

 ""

 

 1%  

 / ' "

 '

(    

 
7A    

  ?

 

  

 '

    



  "   "  



 ""   8

6   

  
7$

  

 

 !"

 6

3  

(    " , .A&105.A%-%

 "    && #0 %#&0

'

2) 

=@
7$4 '

= *

 

=@
7$43

    "

=@
7$42 2 

  0-3 

! <

8



=@
7$4

;  " 

  " ,
7A    .1$&%5/$/0#

*   
7&A   , ;   *

6     

, 

 ( " "  

*

 " , $/0#11/%/# @ 
7A 

  (  "   ?



! " " 8   '


7A 

    " ""  "

 '

 

:  

 3 " " 
 

       !" #

"$%&' ( ""  # 

)  * +  

,,  -$.

!" 

/0      

  '

"





  '

( 8

 "  : 






7A  

 "

 '

  8 

 
"

  

: <



 

(



   &0 #0 %#&1 "

 


7A 

(

 

,     

  , + " '

   

 8

 8 6       

 

 '

 

  

"'


7A

  '5( (   8

  



7A  (8

 " (  (8



?

 8

 8

8 ,
 ! ( -50    8

8

8  8  +     

  0-3 * =  (   &% #0 %#&1 @  ( "    .1$&%5/$/0#

" , $/0#11/%/# ( &. #- /0   %& A% &&  

+ "    .1$&%5/$/0#   

=@
7&A43  =@
7&#4<

'

"" =@
7&#46 =@
7&#4 =@
7&#4

=@
7&#4, =@
7&#4;

=@
7&#4F   "'

7A  "   " 





  '

 

:     

    "  "



  *0    - 

'  

1 "  ( 

  " 



 

5 & !  "   

  (  

"'

G"

G

 '

 H

% !

      '

'





' '



@

 ' @

'H / !  "  

 

'H A !'

 @ '

 ' @  H

- !

  "





   



(

 '







" '"

3 $"

- 

$ 4

 1 

, %0

%1

5 %0 *

"        

1 *0  - 

'     5  6  "  



  "    

7

 "  (  

?

 "

* (      

5 & !  "   

  (  

"'

G"

G '

 H

% !

      '

'



 ' '



@

 ' @

'H / !  "  

 

'H

6 A !'

 @ '

 ' @  H

- !

  "





   



(

 '







%1 7

  %1  ( " '

 



 

 (

"

 '

  

 ""

*  

    

 8 ( '

 



"" 

7

"

  %1  "

 '

 "   *

  "  

  %1 * =   ' (

 "    '

(  

  (

"

 '

 ""

    

 8 ( '

 



"" 

(

"

  %1 * =  "

 '

 "   *

, %$ %.

/#  

5 %$ * '

""  

    (   '

  -" ".- 

7 $ 

4

, %.



"  %1

  "  '

 4 , 1,"

"2" !

..  7  8  -  95   (5

9    G  G ( 

?

    H   "      

8(



"

   '

  *"

  '       '



  *"



 '

G* (  

8    "'

 G  '

8H 8  ' 

*  '



8    "

8( 

 8  

""    '

  (

 G( *  G  (

"  '

   '

8  "

 >   

 "   

16,

 +- 

$ 

/# !   "  

 

""

  



.3 $!

- 

'  ( "

9&# * 

  '



  "  ( 

  



 (

"  

 " 

  '

"  

;    " 



  (   '  

 ( '

   

    " >

* ' "
:- 

  4

) &  " @ "

(

    



 

 " "

 

   @

' ( 

   ( "

'



 "   8



"   "   @

 

'

@

 " 



 

      " 





?

 *

%CD " 

5 ! "

'

 





 )

 (  @ 5   '

7 &# 7 



 

7 &#



 

 ( 

" 



" @ 

8 

'

 :



"  @ "

  " 8


7 &  "

 * 

 (

 '

@

 " 

   

   " 



 * ( (5

 

 "    "   

   8  8

   7

  

7

 '

(

  

 " : 

 



?

 :   (  ?

 



" @ 

( @   *  !"- #

"$%

  & "  '

( 

 

( 



  "" "

*

, /

A  

5 / =@ '



  

 + "  "  

"

  " '

?

:



   " 

 

:

 +'

  '

 ""



 '

'

 "   " 

  (

   "



=   (

 

 + "

'

 (  

 "" "

 8  "

 "

 + " ( 

7 

( 





  :

(



 



 + " (

?

   7  

 + "  '

(

 '

?

 

 * -$.#2"- 

/0          " @ "

 

'

"





! ' ( 

(   %1 * =  "  @     "   





"     '

       @



  (



*

, &A &-

&0  

5 9&A * ' 

# :"&

  (    '



9%& '

( 8

 ('





 

  

 '

; '

 (  '



(    >

&- !

 "

B ' "
: 

 & 

, ( 

* ( ( 

   "    "   

   8  8

   7

  

 >

&0 68( '"

  $"

 

$ &

,  



9%A *

"    

 *0  

' & 

1

&-/ "  



  "     7

 "  (  

?

 " * (      

 C22  &$-D

9CD  "   

  (  

"'

G"

G '

 H

CD       '

'



 ' '

 @

 ' @

'H

CD  "  

 

'H

CD !'

 @ '

 ' @  H

CD !

  "





   



(

 '

  

 >

& %- 7

  %1  ( " '

 



 

 (

"

 '

  

 ""

*  

    

 8 ( '

 



""  7

"

  %1  "

 '

 "   *    (    8    ) '  "  ' "" #- 

)  * +  

,, " @ "  &#0 * =  &$1% (  (



'



  "

 

:   

 @

( 

 '

   '

( ( '

 

2 



  

*

, &%

&A  

5 9&% !   '

 '

 

       
7 A (   I  

  

:   



 I  !   I 
7

    

             *



  I  

&A ;

    '

7 && &%

&0 (

 

 
7 &&

&0 '

( '

"



  !  (    &#0 * =  &$1%

  *     @

( 

 '

   '

( ( '

  >

*   

 '

' (
7A    8

 

 8 ?



  ( @  ( " 

" , $/0#11/%/# ( &. #- /0   %& A% &&   

 

(

      8   (

  

'



 

C=@
7&#4<D

'

"" =@
7&#46 =@
7&#4 =@
7&#4 =@
7&#4, =@
7&#4;

=@
7&#4F

 +

'

 

    C=@
7&#4<D ( "  C=@ ;4%

=@ ;4/D   ,

(

 "" =@
(&#4, +     ; 

 =@ ;4A 



 "" =@
7&#42

"' , :+ #0) &//A  '

 

  4






    

!   

 

6( (  " "    8   

 "+ 45

 

0 & 
;/  

 ,  '



    

"

* <0 "5& 


7&

7% '



, %

/ ( 8 

'

 

! *

(

:(   ! *   
7& "

     '

'

 8 


7& "



:(     '





7& "



   '

'

  '

  8

 *    (   ?

  8 @ "

!      8    (

  =@
7&#4<

'

"" =@
7&#46 =@
7&#4 =@
7&#4 =@
7&#4, =@
7&#4;

=@
7&#4F (    (

( (
7A    8

 

 " 



     (  " '5(
7A 

7

 '





    (

"

 '

  ""

 C=@
7&#46 =@
7&#4 =@
7&#4 =@
7&#4, =@
7&#4;

=@
7&#4FD 

 =@
7&#4< (

" '

 "

 '

 "  

 " 

 "

 "  '

 

*





  "  8 '5(
7A    

6  

 



*  


7A    8 

    @ " 



: (    8 





  

  "   '

   ;"

8  (

 

71   ;"

8   ( "'

 ' %#&#

:

("

  "'  ;"

8 

! ( "'   

"

 (

 

7& '



  '

 8 "'

(  

 "  8 
7& "

  

" (   *

 ; &/ #0 %#&1

=@
7&4

:  


7& "



"  " "

<0 "5 

 

"


7&    8 "

7 

:



  8 

 "  #$ #% %#%& 

 "" 



 " " 





(


  

 

2 &' &' 


  "A?$#3"

2

#* C"$<+4 # $ % #+

* /) % #+