M/S Jai Bala Ji Construction Company v. Union Of India And Another
!"#" $% & &
! '% ()'&*
* *
"# $ %
% &' ( ))
&' ( '( ) &) ***** * *
&+, -.
'/0
+ ,&
-
'( ) &' ( & ,
. / &
0%
- 1
( - 0(&
- & 0%
%2 3 / , 4 '2#5#6 '
"$!
#
7 /
) ++5 '0
'&+885
9 ':&
4 , '0
/ 0
% - ( 0- 5 ; 0 - #!
- ( '2#+<
0 '2#.
(
0 & 53' 53+ & ( (
, 0- &
0
0 &2 =2 >&- - 0 0 /
" =53+
! " #$
%
&!
? ; 0
-4& -4 0 #
0 +3@5.@+?( '2#1
0
&
0 +@@8.@+6
&- -
(0 - ( ( ) +.7 ' -
-0 <:0 )
-
( ,
0 & , ( %
0 , ,
6 <0 -
2 &
0 0
,
0
) '0 <
0 0% 0
0 - ,
- # 0 0
- , =2 > ( 51
!
- ) A
'&- 0
0 B
,
C51& 0 0 -
, , =2 >0 -
=2 > , 0 0 '0 0 , ) ++ '<
0 ( - & (0 - - -
=2 > ,
/ & ) '0 0 < 0 ( & / 0
0
0 &0& ) '0 , 8 & ,0
0 - , 2
0- 2 0 ) '0
/ 0
4 ,#
(< -( 0% '0 ,
=2 > , '0 0 , <
C51- 0 C+@ B
,
& 0
5.+( +@ <0 D & - 0 &
-
5.+( &
, &- -
0 0 ,# 0
, 2 ,& 0 0 , ++ I have heard learned counsels for the parties. +.
, ( "#
!
" "# " "$% "
# &'
"#" "( " ' ( )* (
) +
"
(
)* " "
(
) ( ), () -
" . "
( )- (
)/
0
(
)1
2 ( )1
0 " % 3
" & ( )1
45 /-6 " .&
3
1 1
3
" & ( )1
0
7 " 8 . "
(
)1
" # "
(
)1
0 0 9
" % "
( ) /
& ( )1
"
# 3 1(: :) - / 9 3 " 9
" 8;(;)&
2 ( ) :
<
& 3 '
& 0
" (/ - =>) "
0
?% 9 (/ - =>>
) 0 (
) ?%9 (/ - =>>
) & )"
( 0
(/ - =>> >) % 2 & *!+
, ''- .- / '$ -(-
0
" @+ @+
" 9
"
" .(7)%& %&
(8)$;?$( )?8( )( )8888=-(8)8.8.-&# ( )# ( )
# ( ) :
@ "
"
" ( ) : "
" 9
9 ( )
"
9 9
- " & 0!
#" .
"( 0!(
A A " #$& "
" "
%
& 0! (3
7
= & B
& 0* ( 11"
"# .
" $
11' .' - "# " !
2 "# .
" "'
" .$ "##( 0* (
<= ( B ") - 3 :- @ C
4 - @
@ + &3 #
@ + & 22 22 22> +1 '
-
- , 2 0 0
( ( =2 > ,& 0 -
0
+3 ; - 2 -4 #
0 D & ( .@+7<0 0 -
0 0 0 0 +7 & - 0
, -4 -
=2 > ,
+5 / ( -
, -
- 0 <:0 ) 3 4 ' & "
- 561%
07'!
20& -
- ,
-
0- - , #
& ) ++ '&-
-
- 0
-
=2 > , / 2 0 40 0 0 ) ++ '0 ) ++ '&
,
2
0 - 0 / & 2 0 <-(& -
=2 > , , (
0 0
& -
0- %
-
=2 > , 0 2 0 (
0
) ++ '
+? ! & <:0 ) 7###" '
&"# & &
27' !
89&
- 0( -
2 , 0 , ) ++ '/ (
% ,
"# 3
:
;;#- "
& 7
:
=
&
:= (#-) :
-$
# $&
&
8
= (?)= (8) = (#):", "
7 " & 9- $$
; = (#-)
-
&= (#-) :
;;#-
& 83 7
8
= (#-) :
;;#-
'
(
) -
, ":"
#
& ( )
- , ":"
&!
!
3
! 7
8 =4 " '
* - - -
" - ;;#
: - %;;8 '
;&3
:" , " - D
E&3
7
&!
!!
" '
( ) =7 " :* @ "&F &&G : #! '
?&H& - &1
D5
I &I 3
" .( )
D63/"&:/+F F %( ) 7
!
= =
'
( )!&
1 &11' !
- =4 "
=4 " '
( )
= 4 " 0
( )& , "
&3 , "
=
& +6
( -
&
- ) ) ( ) , &$ ) ,! & <C18@& ')#)) &
&C- , & $ )') C , & % 0& 0
C86??8?8311& E
"
( , F,
& ) '0
% 0- &0%
( ,) +. '
/ +8 0 '0 & 0
2 0 '0 ( .@ G
0
'0 - G ) '0 '& .+ ; '0
D ,
0 ) .8#' ' .. 'D
,- 0 ) ) ( ) , &$ ) ,! & & +* *
. B , "HC B "HC