High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3875/1999dismissed

Vijay Kumar v. Commissioner Of Income Tax Patiala

2017-07-07Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Arun Monga11 pages

Gurbax Singh 2017.08.16 10:44

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT

CHANDIGARH CWP No. 3875 of 1999 Date of decision: 07.07.2017 Shri Vijay Kumar Jain, Development Officer, 2 Ranbir Marg, Patiala ......Petitioner Vs.

Commissioner of Income Tax, Patiala, C/o Income Tax Office, Patiala .....Respondent CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY KUMAR MITTAL HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL Present: Mr. Divya Suri, Advocate for the petitioner. Mr. Z.S.Klar, Senior Standing Counsel for the revenue. Ajay Kumar Mittal,J.

! " $ %& '( () *" ++ ,"#! " $ -. "/0 # !" ) " 1 ' ## ,"# ! - )0 ) 2,- 03 ( ) # ' ,"#! ))')-.')/04 ' # " " " *"50 671 *# *"# -

. 67** /0 ' "1 #

%& ) ) 5

%& ("

%& "#(") ' ' " ) ' 8 )) " "# #8 ") 1) 67**

)) ) (

( " )1 " "1 1)1 #'" 91)# :

" ; ," , < +=( )"#!#( # 1 ))( # & &$ # ( # ' 1 #8

% >#

") "#"" !" " "1 '

) "1" ))(" "1 ' "# ( " (" ( ) ' ## ,"# ! - )0 2,- 03 (

1 " ) " 1 " # # ! # "1 ' "# ! # ""

) ( *" ++ "( "#! #

) ) ' ') " # (" > ")) ""

) )' #' ')( ! ##"" #,## 67** ( " '?1# , 4"

- 0 " ')##1) #

)! ( " " "!' )) ('' #") ')1 '8 # ! "#"' !,)) "#(# 1)')"() '

) ' # ") )'1) '( () "'9)=

- 0 $,@ -9)0") #8 ") )# ))

))#1"() ' ) '

# " ) ") "# #()! ") ') "" "# !(' " "# 5A ) "# ))1 (' (" ( (1 # ( "" " ) )1 ) " " 5A ) #(' " ( ) 1' ' (")") ' # #8 ") ) ! 1 ) '

" 1 ) ) ") ' ,"#!##)" #)) "50 67** ($5 " ") " "# # ! ') "# ' !

((5 " " )) ))#(

))' ' " " " ( # ')

%& ("") # $ %&') "# "" ( ( (" ) ' ))( *" ++ " "" "#()!" "#("( ' 5A # ' )) ' ') " ' ( () 1 *" ++& " "" )

" ! $ %& '

" "" " ( 67** # ( ) )) " ') *" ++ -0 " ") '8 67**"# ) #8 #( % + B" " )1 !" " " (# #

%&("(! "" "( "# ')" # ) ( ( # ' ) ') '## ,"#!)(' ) 8' ## "1 !') "1 ' "" ' "#)" - 0 ,@$ "

67** ' '# "#())# 1)')"() ' ) ' # ( )# " (" ) =(1 "

" 9)= "

! ("("" ' # "# !(# "1!) #) ) #) )(# ) ')'"1 *"#1 ) ' ' , " ""# " "# ! ') ( ' (8 "# "' " *"( ) ' !"# " ) 1 " ++ " ( ' ))( " ! # () 1

" )) ( )( ( + # " ( 1 *" ++ "# " ,- 0 ( ' '"8 ' " )" 67** )#

(""

1 ) ")

#( $

# ) ) ") *" 4"- 0 " ("("1 5

" 9 , !" (

$ " ' *' *" *" 5 4" - 0 "

9 " )1 #) ))( # ') ' ( )) ) )# ! "1 ' '1 ") 67** C& * 9"!"# D ! # ')

, " $ & &&&& @

5 $

&&& &&& &5 &&&& ,%

++ ( ( @

+$+ @

55 @+ $+ &&& &&& 5& &&&& , % ++ ( ( @

5$ @+ + $ + &&& &&& & &&&& ,%

++ ( ( @

@ @+5 $ @+ 5 @

+ @+ 5$+

&&& &&& & &&&& ,%

++ ( ( @ $ @ @

$ &&& &&& +& &&&& ,%

++ ( ( @ @+ 5 @

&&& &&& &$ &&&& ,%

++ ( ( ( " #8# #') (5 # " "

, () ' 1 " )1 1 67** *"# .! / 67** # C& ., ) " ! "# # ! ) '

B" "# " ## "" 1

" )) ' #

")/ *" 67** C&

C . *'>" 1 *"# ( #8 *#' ' ' 9"#' ") "" "(1 *" " ! ( " " ! "# " !"#1 )( # ' "#') *"#'

") )) ' " #)C& -0 ( ! ') ,"# ! " $ -+ $ 0& , ," ")' "# # & 1 " "# ,, ," ")' "# # "

"# ,,, , " ( ! ") "#&! ')))1 &

1" "# ")-0 "

"# ")-0E ,7 , " ( ! "# ) ')))1 " ! 7 ! ") ! ) #' " F" "

*" ,"#&! "& - 0 ," ")' "#

# & 1 "

"# -G0 , " ") ' "# # " "#/ *"5 67** C&

5 - 0 ! # "

") " )) ' ##')' ") "" "(1 *"# " "" ##'"' ") ") ! #') " #( )) ) )# !C ( #) ") ") ' ) ' )) ' #

")(1# ))"" " ! "# " ! "# (" " ") ( ))' # 1'11 ## " " '" ( - 0 ") )) # '

( ' # " "# ) ( )) " " ") -0!!!!!!!!HHHHHHHHHHHHH/ ) '1 1 ( .! /

## !) ' B" "#" # # "" 1

" )) ' # ") *" 67** (#8 *#'

'' 9"#' ")

"" "(1 *" " ! ( "

"!"# "!"#1 )( # ' " # ') *"#' ")))' " *" 5 67** 1 ( !

# ") *" )) # # ') "" " ( *"# " "

1 " " # ") # & &$' 1 )" 5 "# ())1)')"() '

) ' #' " '9)=

! " -0 " !(# "1!)

#) ) #) ) ( # ) ') ' "1 "# 1 ) ' ' 5 :" ")' " " # *" 5 - 0 4"

5 - 0 " ' " "# " ) "## !((8 "#"' :'!') 67** (

%& ') ' )"& " # & &$G $ %&))( *" ++ """ ,- 0"(" '))( (( (

5 ,"( #()! ( ' ")") ' 8 # (" ( '>" # ) ' )) =(1 (1 ! " 1') ) ( *" ++ " '# ") 8 ' # , ") ' "" )) ) ' ( ) )) ) 8 # , ( "# )" "#("!( '")") ))( *" ++& " ") '))( ' '4"! ( )

") " ( " *" ++& -0 " ( ' 4 !"-0') ' "1'') .)/ . ' / '1 ") ")#' $ %& # *" ++ "()

1) ' 67** ' )"") ' & " ' (" (( ( ' '") # $ %&"' )

; ") '') 1( 8 ' ) # # '

# !"#$!" % & ' () 8 % *( ') *(