← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3346/1998allowed

Roshni Devi And ORS. v. Haryana State Through Chief Secy. And ORS.

2024-08-22Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj12 pages

  

  

 

 

 !""#$!%&&' (

)*+,- +./0/,1' ( #

    

  34"-5-    

    

"         

    

         

  6666  



          !  " #$$$$$$%7  "!/ !

           &'" ( #$)  $* $+ # #,,)   --  .

.     

 

"!/!

 

           !   !       ! /!  ! -    

 !0  8  9

   0  

 0 1$ $+ $+ #,,)   - ( ( (        2

"0    ( ( 7+:27;++*

 0  0 /!         .  <      0  ( ;7  !



 /! "!/!   =   072

"  !!      1   !!    <            

       2    

    

     2  0  !   !  !!  ?       0 1 >0 !

!-  "!            ! =    



0+/! ! 

!      0 !   0        0( ;! 0 0       !       ( ;      !   0   0               "! /!   - (       >  " 

.    

 (   !  1  

  >0 !- !

!  =        &'"( #$)$* $+ # #,,)   -- -+:,;;);$@7    '> 

   > >                 0 ? 0    7-                    "! / !

  ! !

!  <   



!      !        "! /

  = =! 0 0 ( # @   -  <

   0 < A  0     

$ 



 

    

   

 



! 

!

 !

  





 # 

$ % %&5  '#()*

+ 

 !  !



,   

 

'(

 !



! 1

1! 

 &

 





 



 #  ,

+  $%&5'#() )*

  

   

 

!!



+  $ %&5'#()*

!





!

$%&5'#() *

 

 !

!

 



1! 

 

  

 

!

 !

+ +  $%&5'#()*

 ""



!!

 -

$% %&5  '#()*



 !!

!

+  .   / - $

* 0( )54

&2

&1

+ !

!

2

1!  

 

  !

 $





 

""



 



 

$ 





!

&

+ +  / - $ 

*  0( '())()

&2



1!

* 

!

  

 

$  



""   - 

!

       



 

+  $% %&5  '#()*

 !  

1!





 

 





 #  

!





,

+  $%&5'

'#()*  



 !!

 

 "

! 

 

 

6 



 1

 

  



  !

 

  7 

 

   





 

.

. 

!

 

 



!

 

  !

 



8 3#$ $;

+$+; -   !      0!&'"

" ( #$) $* $+ #,,)



     

'!   -  - 7-  

0 > >  0      ' 0    

0      !

'

   0  00      <     0

'?   $:

$) +$$;

 > >      ?        0 0?    !!0          -                      !         ?    !   0 0 

   !   0  ?         <   

    0      0         ?0   0     "

/

 7 0( ( #   0 0  0   -            0 ! 0 7-   )%  *

   

    !"#!$ %!&   )



 ' '

% ' ( <  A ! 

0    :    

  







"     

  

 

   !



 

  ,

 





  







 !



!  #

 



""

 



  ;  !!  

  

 





 !!





 



 ! ! 

  $ !!









!



3



 

3 

 A

 

 



 !



 !! 

 



 

2





 !

!    "







 !!   

 



"

 !

  

   

  



 



 

 





 





!

 !! 

!" 

  

  

 

 

 

   <

"

  

   





    

 

  



 

 ! 

 

; , ,

= =,  > ?

@

D

B<

 

  

  

5 



    

 



 





 



!

    

 

  "

  

3 

    

 



  

   











"







  B

+

.!

 

1

 

  

.

2

!  

 



 !

 



!

 

) ))

 

""

""

:



!

, 

! 

  $ 





"" 

"



 !



""

  !

 



:





!



 

!!





"" 



!





 

 

 

""

""   

.

.! 2

 "

  



""

  $  !

  



 5

  



:

 

 

!

   



  



   



 

   

  





       



 ;5

   

 

   3

 

 

6



 

  

 



 



 

  

  

 

 



  !   

 

 8

 "!   !B0-!> ! )-! .!

/  %  *

!  )  

  %     +0  

 A 

)

3











  

 

"

!

! 

 





 

 



"

!  

 !



"

 "

 

!

 7 

"

3 

 



 7     

! !

 

2





  

 







 

3 

 !

 

  

 





  



 7    

    

!

" 

. 



!     

   "







 "







3   !



  "

  

     

"

3 

 !

 

  

#

+

 "  B !

 ;

  

 

 

% 4

4

  

    " 

! 

""

 

) )

   !

 !

 "

  



! 

  ! 

 )

 2



 *

.! 2

  

 



"

 "

 

! !



 

2





  

 

  



 

!



 "

 

!

 7      



7   





 7 

 

 

 !



 



 

! 

 







B  

B   ! 

 )

 *

2  !

"

"

!

  

     !

!

"3!

 

  !

   

"

!

 7    

  

 

! 

  



!  

   !

 "

!

;

;



 

!



  

"

!

 7    

; 3 

! ;

 



!

  

   

!

 

!!

  



  



 

!

 



  (  

"" 



  

) )@

, 2

.!

2

 

 

 7 











 !

 "

 



  )

*

2



 



 "

! 

 

2



 

 "



"

!  !





""

"

!

 7 



!

1

!

 7 

 

 

 !



!

 " 



 



! 

  5  !

 

 !

<"



 "







 )

*  

 

 

"

"

!

 7 

 





 

 

     

 2

  

- - 

#

 "



 

 

"

!  !

!

 "  

 )

*

2





!

!

 





!!

  









 "



 



!



2



 

 "

  





 

  

!



 



 



 



 



   

""  

 "



 

     



 

"

!

 7  

     

 

  

 

  

  !

 

   



   

  

  "





 

  !

 







"





    

 "5

 

 ! 

 )

*

 

!  

 



 1

 



   " 

 2

 

#

+8



 .

. - >              ?      !    0   - 0A  0  ! '

'     

   ! 0        0     0  '

'      

    

   %0  0   <      0!   ! !! <       

 0   ( 0     

      - 

<     ?   0 !  -

      !

 

   ?      <    ?   !

  ?  0 0        !!     7-  <          A     0   0  - <   ?

  !

!             0  

0 < - 0!          !         0 !         0 



 %

%    C  - !    0!   %!

!   '

'       !   0               0  !!    "

/     ?  

      <  7 - !"

" #$$$$$$%7   E *D!

!!   C <  

  0  0           ! 0 !    !!  

     !           !    0         0 0       ( #        !              

   !  89    89     

 

     

 "

# A

 !(



F ($

A



F ($