Gurbax Singh And Another v. State Of Punjab And Another










 

 

















































 !
"
#!$%&%'
(
) ) *+,
%'-.
'#
' .!




































! % %'!&






























/     !
"
*'0+
'#
' .!


























































!&1'#!' & (
 23
 
 
 4
3

!&!' ( -!&.
!56
#7$ !6
"
.!
1! % %'!& *7
4.*'6
6
*'0+ !!18
956
#7$ !6
"
!&1'#!'
















:::::::

 4
36

;

3< .*-.
.!
1!&!'
1! % %'
"%5!#
*'#!
!$ %'
=>
 
.!

1! % %'!&
&!!8
&! %'-
&%#!
"
.!%
$'7%$ %'
'#
&!' !'$%'-
+9
.!
*#%$%5 -%&  !
&
5&&6
3*#.%'
;"
&. 6
.!
%5
* <
*'#!
!$ %'&
=>6


!#
?% .
!$ %'

'
.!
-*'#
.
.!
#%&1* !
"@
?.%$.
.! %@1*-'!#
$'7%$ %'
'#
&!' '$%'-
%-%' !#
& #
@%$+59
!&57!# .!
$&!
"
.!
1&!$* %'
!@' !#
"@

$@15%'
"%5!#
+9 *8.?%'#!
4*
;!&1'#!'
<
&
1!
?.%$.
.!
.*&+'#.*1%'#!15
%'-.6
.! " .!%'5?
*+,
%'-.
;1! % %'!
 <6
.!
@ .!%'5?*0%
4*
'#
&%& ! %'5?
*1!!
4*
;1! % %'!
<
.#
#!@'#!#
#?9
"@
.!
'#
.!
1!' & 55!- %'&
?% .
!-#

.!
"!&%#
$$*&!#
1!&'&
.7%'-
-%7%'-
+! %'-&
'# .! &

.!
$@15%'' 6
"
*&*1%'-
.!


 
'#
.?%'-
.!
*
" @ %@'%5
.@!
?!!
5&
@#!

" !
!-%& !%'-
'

*'#!
!$ %'&
= 6
=> 6
=
'#
) 
 
.!
15%$!
%'7!& %- !#
.!
@ !
'#
"%5!#

!1
*'#! !$ %'&

 
'
.!

+&%&
?.!!"
.!
%5
*
"@!#
$.-!&
-%'&
.! "!&%#
$$*&!#
1!&'&

'
.!
%5
?.%$.
!'&*!#
.!
1! % %'!&
?!!
.!5#
-*%5 9
" .7%'-
$@@% !#
""!'$!&
*'#!
!$ %'&
=>6

!#
?% .
!$ %'
=  
'#
.*-.
#!
"
.!
%5
*
# !





A
.!9
?!!
&!' !'$!#
 *'#!-
%-*&
%@1%&'@!'
"
.!!
9!&

.!
1! % %'!&
11!5!#
-%'&
.!

B

C "!&%#
0*#-@!'
'#
&!' !'$%'-
#!
+!"!
.!
!&&%'&
*

3*#.%' ?!7!6
?.%5!
.!
11!5
?&
1!'#%'-
.!
1! % %'!&
'#
.!
$@15%''
!' !!# %' 
'
@%$+5!
&! 5!@!'
'#
'
.!
+&%&
.!!"6
.*-.
.!
%'& '
1! % %'
.!9 &!!8
D*&.%'-
"
.!%
$'7%$ %' 3!'!#
  !
$*'&!5
11&!&
.!
!5%!"
19!#
"
+9
.!
1! % %'!&
' .!
-*'#
.
.!9
& '#
$'7%$ !#
"
""!'$!&
*'#!
!$ %'&
=>6
 !#
?% .
!$ %'

'#
.!!"!
#!&!7!
'
5!'%!'$9
3!'!#
$*'&!5
"
.!
$@15%''
.&
'
+0!$ %'

.!
$$!1 '$!
" .!
1! % %'!&2
19! '

   
; <
 '5%'!

> =
.!
*1!@!
*
.&
.!5#
&
"55?&(




11!&

*&
.
$%@%'5
1$!!#%'-&
%'757%'-
''.!%'*&
""!'$!& 
?.!!
.!
""!'$!&
!
1!#@%'' 59
"

1%7 !
' *!6
$'
+!
''*55!# %!&1!$ %7!
"
.!
"$
.
%5
.&
5!#9
+!!'
$'$5*#!#

11!5
& '#&
#%&@%&&!# -%'&
$'7%$ %'
'#%'-
*
1*'%&.@!'
%&
'
.!
&5!
"@
"
#!5%7!%'-
0*& %$! $%! 5
@! .#
"
1159%'-
5?&
!7!'59
%&
5?9&
&*+0!$

5?"*5
!,$!1 %'&

-!& ?% .*
&9%'-6
.
.!
$&!&
?.!!
$@1@%&!
%&
& *$8
1&
$'7%$ %'6
.!
%-. *
*-.

!,!$%&!
&*$.
#%&$! %'
?% .
!$ % *#!6
8!!1%'-
%'
7%!?
.! $%$*@& '$!&
&**'#%'-
.!
%'$%#!' 6
.!
"&.%'
%'
?.%$.
.!
$@1@%&!
.&
+!!' %7!#
 6
'#
?% .
#*!
!-#

.!
' *!
'#
&!%*&'!&&
"
.!
""!'$!6
+!&%#!&
.! $'#*$
"
.!
$$*&!#6
+!"!
'#
" !
.!
%'$%#!'$!
.!
*$.& '!
"
!,!$%&%'- .!
!, #%'9
1?!
*'#!
!$ %'
=>
 
?*5#
+!

&!$*!
.!
!'#&
"

0*& %$!
.!!
$'
+!
'
.#
'#
"&
5%'!
$'& %$ %'-
.!
1?!
"
.!
%-.
*
 #
&*+& ' %5
0*& %$!

!& %$ %7!
$'& *$ %'
"
%'.!!'
1?!&
*'#!
!$ %'
=>  
@9
5!#

%-%#

&1!$%*&
0*& %$!6
?.%$.
%'
.!
-%7!'
"$ &
'# $%$*@& '$!&
"

$&!6
@9
 .!
5!#

-7!
%'0*& %$!
'
.!
 .!
.'#6
%'
$&!& ?.!!
.!%'*&
""!'$!&
.7!
+!!'
17!#
-%'&
1!1!  &6
'
&*$.
+!'!"%
*-. 
+!
!, !'#!#6
&
$* %*&59
+&!7!#
+9
.%&
*
%'
%'#!
%'-.
7
  !
"

*'0+
'#
3,@%
9'
;*1<

=
'
 .!
?#&6
-7!

&!%*&
""!'$!&

""!'$!&
?.%$.
%'757!
@5 *1% *#!

.7!

.@"*5
!""!$
'
.!
&$%5
'#
@5
"+%$
"
.!
&$%! 9
 %'757!
@ !&
$'$!'%'-
1*+5%$
15%$96
$''
+!
$'& *!#
+! ?%,
?
%'#%7%#*5& 
-*1&
'596
"
&*$.
""!'$!&
.7!
.!
1 !' %5

%@1$
.!
&$%! 9

5-! ""$%'-
+@%'+5!
""!'$!&
.*-.
D*&.%'-
1$!&&
?*5#
'
'59
&!'#

?'- &%-'5

.!
$@@*'% 9
+*
@9
5&
$$#
'
*'#*!
+!'!"%

*'&$*1*5*& .+% *5

1"!&&%'5
""!'#!&6
?.
$'
&!$*!

F&! 5!@!' G
.*-.
#*!&&6 .! &6
&$%5
+9$ &6
+%+!&

 .!
#*+%*&
@!'&

%&
?!55
&%#
.
E5!
'
-*%5 9 @'
!&$1!6
%"
%
$'
+!
7%#!#H

!#%'-
"
.!
"!
!, $
"@
.!
0*#-@!'
"
.!
*1!@!
*
%'

@-152&
$&!
;&*1<
5!7!&
'
@''!
"
#*+
.

&!7!
.!
!'#&
"
0*& %$!
.! *1!@!
*
.&
1!@% !#
.!
%-.
* &

!,!$%&!
.!%
1?!&
*'#!
!$ %' =>
 

&!
&%#!
$'7%$ %'&
?.%$.
!
"
""!'$!&
?.%$.
!
'
.!%'*&
 ?.!!
.!
""!'$!&
!
1!#@%'' 59
"

1%7 !
' *!

B

C '
.!
$&!
%'
.'#6
.!
#%&1* !
+! ?!!'
.!
1! % %'!&
'#
.! $@15%''
&!
"@

@ %@'%5
#%&1* !
'#
?&
.*&
1%@%59
1%7 !
%'
' *! .!
%@1*-'!#
$'7%$ %'&
5&
#
'
%'757!
'9
.!%'*&
""!'$! &
#%!$ !#
+9
.%&
*
'
> = 6

!1
# !#

 ) 
+9
.!

*#%$%5
-%&  !
&
5&&6
3*#.%'
;"
&. 6
.!
*#%$%5
-%&  !<
.&
+!!' !$!%7!#
&
1!
?.%$.
.!
1 %!&
.#
-
!$#!#
.!%
&  !@!' &
+!"!
.!
%5 *
%'
!@&
"
.!
$@1@%&!
%7!#

+! ?!!'
.!@
'#
.
%'
.!
1%'%'
"
.! *#%$%5
-%&  !
.!
&@!
?&
-!'*%'!6
75*' 9
'#
?% .*
'9
$!$%' .!!
%&
9!
' .!
&1!$
"
.!
@ !

'% %559
.!!
?!!
"*
$$*&!# %!
.!
$@15%'' 2&
.*&+'#.*1%'#!15
%'-.6
.!
@ .!%'5?
*0%
4*
'# .!
1! % %'!&6
?.
!
.!
$@15%'' 2&
" .!%'5?
*+,
%'-.
'#
.!
@%!# &%& !%'5?
*1!!
4*

*%'-
.!
$*&!
"
.!
%5
.*1%'#!15
%'-.
!,1%!#

'" *' !596
*0%
4*
5&
#%!#
#*%'-
.!
1!'#!'$9
"
.!
11!5
"%5!#
+9
*0% 4*
'#
.!
1! % %'!&
-%'&
.!%
$'7%$ %'
+9
.!
%5
* 

.*&6
#*%'-
.! $*&!
"
.!
1$!!#%'-&6
1! % %'!
 6
?.
%&
A
9!
5#6
.&
5&
.%&
?%"!
'#
&' '#
1! % %'!

.&
5&
5&
.!
+ .!
'#
@ .! '
.!
5%-.
"
.!
+7!
#%&$*&&%'
'#
.!
1!$*5%
"$ &
"
.!
1!&!' $&!
&
5&
%'
5%'!
?% .
.!
5?
5%#
#?'
+9
.!
*1!@!
*
%'
@-152&
$&!

;&*1<6

)
# !#
 


!-%& !!#
*'#!
!$ %'&
= 6
=>6

A6
=6

6
) 
'#


5%$!
  %'
%+?56
%& %$
3*#.%'
&
5&
.!
#!& # !#





A
1&&!#
+9
.!
%5
*
$'7%$ %'-
'#
&!' !'$%'-
.!
1! % %'!& *'#!
!$ %'&
=>6

!#
?% .
!$ %'

!
&!
&%#! .!
1!&!'
1! % %'
%&
55?!#
%'
.!
+7!
!@& ) )











































B 4
3C &.@&.!





































  I.! .!
&1!8%'-J!&'!# (







!&



J



 I.! .!
!1 +5!

(



















!&



J