Vijay Pal Singh v. State Of Haryana
!"#"$% &"'
( )*"$+, - " "$ . & .#/# * .( $ - #0$1 $
.
2% $34) ./# "! *5 )"
. # $ % .*** ,/617!
. , 0 " "$ . . 7 $8/2 .*, .
$6 6 .( $ 999
# "# 4 "$+ : $ /0 . , ."$+ ,./+, &"1
$ . $!"$+1/ 7"10 $1 2"! .
( ."$ , 0 " "$/$1 .* ! "$ . "# .+.
. +/) . 4 ") , 0 " "$ . "$ !
# ;<6 1 1 . +"# . 1/$1 .* ! "$# =;=>=<?*! )"! * "$ , /8 ) $6 ,#") $1"# ."! , 1 @ .$ 1!/$# )!$ $1# , , 0 " "$ .A #"20)"!
"$ , "$# # $ , .. # ! !!/# 1*"
26 .2A,2$ ,"# .. # $ 6 > # ."0# B!$ "$"$+
4) # !,C .
1) (1.!,)."1
2+ B ) >
4) #C 1"
. $ !, #, 7"$+ )A "+, :+? +.2# $1<# ."0#B!$ "$"$+
4) # !,C D) 2 ?)0.
D) 2
4) # ?2+4 ."$+ !, 4./ .(= 6 E $= B )<
4) #C , 7"$+ )A "+, >
+.2#A . . !7 . 1 $1A,2 1 1"#!)#/. 2 $ , 7"$+0/.!, # 1 ,
. 2 $ "$ 1!$ .
.2 , 0 " "$ .6A, . /0$* ! "$; , *! A 11 1 $1 , 0 " "$ . .. # 1$ $1$"$ ..+ "$#/
. 11"#!)#/.
FG 2 $ ,"#"$7)7 2 $ "$ , 0. # $ !
# @ .$ 1 !/$# ) !$ $1# ,
.
.2 ,
. 2 $ "$ 1 1"#!)#/. # 2 $ #6 , . "# $ , . 2 ."
) !$$ ! , 0 " "$ .A" , , !22"##"$ ,
$! , )) $, 4 $ 0. # $ 16 !, .+ # , 7 4 $ .
2 16 , . . 0.# !/ "$ A" $ ## #6 $$ , 2 , 7 4 $ H 2"$ 1 $1 "$ , 0. 7 ")"$+ $1 2"! !$1" "$#6 ."
) A/)1 : !$#"1 .
4) "2 !$!)/1 6 , .
. 6$/# /)0/.0# A/)14 # .7 14(: 0"$+ , 0 " "$ . 4 ,"$14 .# ?
$ , , ., $16) .$ 1* /$# )!$ $1# , $ 1/4 , 0 " "$ ., #4 $"20)"!
1"$ , "$# # 6#) )($ , #"# 1"#!)#/. # 2 $ 6( "$7" A , !22 .!"
)I/ $ " ( !$ .
$1. !7 . 1 .2! !!/# 1*"
264 ./$1 .* ! "$; *! A/)14 .
! 16 , .
. 6 , 0 " "$ ."#$ $ " ) 1 4 . ) # 1$. +/) .4 ") > , 7 !$#"1 . 1 , #/42"##"$# ) .$ 1!/$# ) . , . " # ; 12" 1)(6 , "$7)7 2 $ , 0 " "$ ."$ , "$# # "##) )($ , 4 #"# 1"#!)#/. # 2 $ ! !!/# 1*"
2
.2 A,2 $ ,"# .. # $ 6 !22 .!"
) I/ $ " ( !$ .
$1 A # . !7 . 1 $1 A, 2 1 # 2 $ , , , 0/.!, # 1 , # "1 !$ .
.2 , 0 " "$ .6 4 #"1 # 1"#!)#/. 2 $ 4( , 0 " "$ .0/.#/ $ ,"# .. # A 7 .6 . .2 , 1"#!)#/. # 2 $ #6 , . "# $ , . 2 ."
) !$$ ! , 0 " "$ .A" , , !22"##"$ ,
$!
FG < $34) , */0. 2 /. "$J
6 , # , )1 , !$ ##"$ 2 $ 2 1 0)"!
"! .!
$$ 4 : $"$ !!/$ !$7"!
$ !!/# 1 /$1 . , * ! "$ 7" A * ! "$ ?6 7"1 $! ! A, .
#"$
! " #$%&'
(% " A #, )1 , 2 . !$ ##"$ ! !!/# 1"#$ $/+, "20)"!
$ !!/# 1 H! 0 A, . , . "# , .# "#
! .( 7"1 $! #/# "$ , !, .+ + "$# # "1 !!/# 10 .#$6"$A,"!, 7 $ / )" (6 , !$ ##"$ $4 /# 14( , !/. ##/. " # ) , , !$!)/#"$A,"!," "# "$!)"$ 1 1.
A .2 , , . 7"1 $! "#."+, ) 7 H .
! ,
. 2 $ "$ 1 1 !"#"$3# . 0.1/! 1 #/$1 .%
!"
# "$
% &
' ( # )
$
$
& & & $
' ( # ) *
!"
# %
++
)
&
,)
& #
$ ) ) $
)
-
. &
FG & / $
) &
$
$
$
0 $&
) $
)
,++%
$ *"$+,3# 1 !"#"$ A ))A 1 4( .1"$ $!, ,"# /. "$12* 3 & $
4 5 6 728-8 ' '', ',',) 9,',' 0 . .2 , 1"#!)#/. # 2 $ ! !!/# 1 # A )) # 1"#!)#/. # 2 $ = !$ ##"$4(0 " "$ . , . "#$2 ."
) !$$ ! , 0 " "$ .A" , , !22"##"$ ,
$! ) ,/+,6 . !7 .( "$ , !
# "# !22 .!"
)I/ $ " (6( , 4 ./$1 .* ! "$;A/)1$ 4 .
! 1 "$ 7" A , 0 " "$ . $ , 7"$+ 4 $ .. # 1 .2 , #" 6 , . 4 "$+$. !7 .( .2,"264 #"1 #"$7" A , $)(2 ."
). )" 1 /0$ 4( , * 4 "$+ 1"#!)#/. # 2 $ ! !!/# 1 !$ ##"$ = 1"#!)#/. 4( 0 " "$ . A,") "$ 0)"! !/# 1( $ , !".!/2# $! #6 " !
$ .
#$ 4)( 4 ##/2 1 , , 0 " "$ . "# $ "$7)7 1"$ , !22"##"$ ,
$! 4 #"1 #$ !!/$ ,"#$ 4 "$+"$7)7 1"$ $( , .!
# /$1 . , *! 6<?B, 7"$+4 $ 1"#!, .+ 1"$ !
# C6" !
$4 .
#$ 4)( ##/2 1 , , "#$ )": )( !22" $(
$! /$1 . , *! 6<?A,") $4 "). 7 .6 "$7 # "+ "$"#!20) 6!, )) $, #4 $0. # $ 1 $1!, .+ #, 7 4 $ .
2 1 $1 , 0 " "$ ."#4 ,"$14 .##"$! 6 $1 ."
, !
# "#)": )( : "2 5" ,/ !22 $ "$+$ , 2 ." # , !
# 6 2 ,
F?G 7" A , $/# /)0/.0# A/)14 # .7 14(: 0"$+ , 0 " "$ . 4 ,"$14 .#!!.1"$+)(6 , 0 " "$ .. +/) .4 ")"#) $1 , 0 " "$ ."#.1 . 1 4 . ) # 1$. +/) .4 ")1/."$+ , 0 $1 $!( , ."
)6#/4' ! ,"# /.$"#,"$+4 ")=#/. (4$1# , # "#
! "$ , ) .$ 1 =."
/. =/ ( +"# .
6!$! .$ 160.7"1 1, "#$ . I/". 1"$ $( , .!
# , 0 " "$ .#, )) )# 4"1 4( , !$1" "$#!$ "$ 1"$* ! "$;BC . A 7 .6$ ,"$+# , . "$ 47 #, ))4 !$# ./ 1 $ H0. ##"$ 0"$"$$ , 2 ." # , !
# 1) ## 2 $ "$6"$!
# , 0 " "$ ."#"$7)7 1"$ $( , .!
# /$1 . , *6! 6<?A,") $. +/) .4 ")"$ , "$# # 6 , 0.# !/ "$ A/)1 4 )"4 . ( 27 $ 00)"!
"$ . $! )) "$ 4 ")+.
$ 1 , 0 " "$ ."$ , "$# # " "$ ))A 1"$ ,
. 2 $ "$ 1 .2# ! "#"$#"#% 120 :#& 6
* : ; :
$ ; :