High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/350/1992allowed

Har Narain v. Satbir Etc.

2023-09-01Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja5 pages

2023:PHHC:115993 1

!"# #$%&%'(

!" # " ( )* + $ % &# '

("') (

* +,#&#

("') (

-./$)#0 1. ("') ( 1*(""

.0 2222 + , *

*0 30 ( )#

, # ! " + ",/ "")" "

45" 4 6

"!0 ! 38 3#!0 )'0 "/, 3

/ + ) " # )

3"/" :

/0! " # # ; )'0 "/, 3 3 #"3 " , # ")0 ( #3'( ) ,",+ ) 3) " *

() /,#/

! ' " ,# / , #' " 3 # #'/

4<( "

" 3,

" 3

/ " " 0" # ", )" # #0! " / ,#" / , )!

2023:PHHC:115993 2 < :( 3) "3# !/

" 3 3" !0 " # " =) 1

( "0 " "" ' ) ') "" "

56(3# 1

) <3 >'!0 #./$)#0

4<3 # )# " # ( #3; , /

?# 7 '" + ",/ " ") " "

45( "/" " !0

,,'" # ( 3 "(#3'( #/3 "/"'"+ ",/ " ")" 4 6

6 :/ ,, # / " + ",/ " ")( " )

!/ # ,# ') )", 3 " ,

# ) #3'( # ') " 3 " !0 # 7 '" " "

" 7@$ 4

56 " # /

3 /"" !)> # 7

) #"+ ") !0)", " !0 ./ $)#0 # 3 ! " ) -* #$ +!

,7//A", )

#3'( # " ') 3 "( # "

# 0 !/ #0" (/ #0,", " " !0

3/ "!0 0 )# 3 ' '" )" ' # " "

3#'/ ) 5 # ##"( ") !/

# 3 # 0; "

2023:PHHC:115993 3

# ( !) + ) ( " # )

; #/3 / !

!/ # ' )" ' ( ./ $)#0 # ! )"" ! : "" ( * + ,# &#

"') ( # " !#

./ $)#0 # ,# !, # (#3'( ) >,/ "/ !#

",)" (#3'()" )", "" 5

#!! ,# # ) #7 4 : #' #" " ) # " #' ,

# ,# #!>: " !

) # !//"!#

# + ",/ " ") " !0 # 7 ! 3 #3 )) ' ", # ! )"" ," 0 ; #', ! "" !0

' "/

0( ') )",; 03 ",

3# '" " " " " B 0

56( " !0 # 7

) ( C ."( ') 3 " ?# / 3

/" !0 7

) '" "" "5 #B 0(

56(#3'( #7 '"" "

# /!

" 7@$ 4

56 "

3,"%

"#$%$ & " ' " ! " " () " #$%* +!, -). " " (% "#$%*+!,-/. !

2023:PHHC:115993 4

' ' #)0 1 & +2 . 3 ! ! " #$%/" ' ' 4 C , ') )",!0 #./$)#0 ,

; 0 ; # ' #/?# ,", " !0

' ./ $)#0 # ! #" )" #0" (/ #0 " #! "" '" 0 >, ' ) ') " " ,

# ! '" )"=) 1

/! E' #""

# /!(

" !0 # 7 ( 3# )" ) ,", " 0 !0

) #') "" ", #," !0 ! 3 # "" !'"" !

#' ! !

# )" # " ; 6 /! () /!<'"' " ""B 0

4<(#3'(

# / ,", # /, " # ! #" )" '( # # 6 ; 0 3 )""

3)#," #/ ( 3 # ) 0 ) ' # !) 0 "#',!"!0 #)/ 7 + ") " # ( #3,

! 3 / '))! ') '")

:/ !

" !

) # !//"!#

" 9" " + ) #!)

2023:PHHC:115993 5 3 " ! / !

)

) / #/

! 0#', # "

# #" " 9" " / " ; ( / + ) ) 3 / !

, " 9" " ' #!) 3#)#0 )#"! , )'0 #', "') )",,

:0)( # !, ",# ,, !" 0 /

:'3 #") /"#!'( ",

7 ," " 0 ; !0

=) "

,7 () <(!,, #)"'" ?# #

3" " # + ",/ " ") "!0 ! 3 "=) "

() < #!0, ,") /

(#3'( # #

! ! )0 )",,

))")3 # 3

$", ) ( 0(#

""" + @# #>,9" % F9 @# # % F9