← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1599/1989dismissed

Shiv Dei Enterprises And ORS. v. Udami And ORS.

2015-02-25Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal15 pages

  

  !"#$ #

 #% & #&'()(*+ ,, -(.#&(* / ()&)%*0%* -&

//&11%* ) 2) 0%3(%*0 -& ) &)/*0&* ) +



     

    

  





!   

"

## $

%%%%          ! "#

$%  &'%(!)* +  # %  )* ,

&'%(!) '

%#%-).-( * !4! '

(



   )   + ,"

#-#    (   0     )  

" ,

#-2    .30     

 & '

4   35*

 *

)  

  *



 *

,



- *    *

6"7 9"7 

 +,  :



 ;

* !,3

$ <    )   9"



*

 =.

    *    + ,"

#2, 

 +26   1

&+'

>    /  /   @ / 



   -/- '- +01 23  *   *

 * *    2 , #2+ >    )   " ,+ #26    (   0   /  

  ,,1    234 *  ,# , #-+ &6'

   

* * .  *      

- ).

 / C < 

#"+ !  7 7$ *   A >    +, ,- #2+  1 !0

A C$ <   . 

 1 

 .    / 8    



 &"'

   





.     */ *

 *  *    



 6;"

*.

#-"



 ./    6"7 9"7  

 *  AD/ /    



 &9'

(

   *

.  

1     

-  B   *

 A*  /  * 

 E*

 +26  *

D  *   / B  * * 



* B        ?  

 .) 

/ *   F   /





 1  * &2'

F . 

    * 1

3

                  

                     !

      

     "#  # $      

   $%&    ' 

   

 ( '   $%)           *

          

  ( '   $%#    

  +    

   , -   .

&-'

?      <  





  93 93?

) /   

) /

 

 * 

>



93   /

/  * 1



 93?

  1/ 

 

8 *

 * * 



 +, :



 ;

*



: * 

D

 +, :



 +;2 +;9



 /   .

 

   

  8 *

:  1  

: 1  

G *

  *



 )  

" ,

#-2 &#'

4

   )   -/-     +5 + ,

#-2 (3   0   :      . C1  ?       ** )  + ,"

#-# C1  

  

  



,'

(

   

*

 * 

< *   / .    

"

##

/ / 

/ .

 *

  < /  *  .1

 



;  

'

(

/     * 1

.  D  13

/         (  &  '  

      +           0   1   +   +    /       2 

 #+#(  /      3  4 3  5 6  &(' 

 + +  +/     5#

   '    %       '

 35*

 @3

   * 9"



*

   3   /  /  + ,"

#2,  

    

    /

F    *  B  



 6;"

*.

#-" 

*  . / D  6"7 9"7



 *     D  <      

 *

,



- * ? 0

A C   *



<    /    /

1 * 

  ,,1    234 ,# , #-+ (    *   / . )     *   /  *

+'

?   1

 (@3

. 2   /

#2232- 78 '  

#2- -

#-

   * !=8 (@ ;+$  

,# #2"

  A >>    1

  :* (* @   (@3 

*     =8 ( ;

8





*

 * *  69-,,;3  * 

 1  (@3+    8  



?

  

*3(

 1   (@36    <       1 



 *   

 .  ( (/ (* @   (@3"

 8   !=8 (@";

$



<  



 *  

#-,



 * / 

*3(@39    

  / =  <    * ./ 1  F  */ >) !(@32$

@  *  !(@3-$ ?   !(@3#$    /

/   

=   /  

1 

. *   *

  / (

   

 *

 * <) 

/

#2-

#-

 /     ./ 1 *   * <   * *

 B   

(@3 , (@3



(   6'

 (  :*    C A**  

  =8 (@6; >        1 *   1 /    "'

<  1/ 1/   

1

 /    * C1    /

    

  -/-  '-   +01    23  *   =8 3



 +2"

 1

  (   0   1

 " ,+ #26

 

 5*

      + ,"

#2, > 

) *   5*

 *

 * 

<  

  *   C1    /

)   

. / 2    /

#- 3-+ =8 (;

 (* <)  1

:

 +,2;2 +,2;9 1 



   

   

 *    9'

C1   

1  / 



   AD/ C1    ./ 

 2'

>    * .     

-'

 

 "

   * .

     

-  C    

1  

*       /  .

* / 

 F  .*       * 

+ ,- #2+

 D 

 D   > . /   

. * *  / *  *

D    /  

* *

D B    

   35*



B       *  * 

 

  1 

/

**

 *  

#'

C   .*     /    . 

  1   *

D   * 

* D   *  

  B    *       



  /  *

   

  *   & ,'

       

  /   

  

    )  C1   + ,"

#26 !=8 3 $  

   ,,1    234   ,# , #-+ !=8 3+$ <      

  

   / B */ .*     



  B  

, C1  1 (* <)  1

7

 +,+;2 +,2;9   0 *.   

   * *  '

C    .*           +, ,- #2+ !  

- $ . /  

1    

 )   *  

 @    1 

)  

*

35*

 * 

   ,



- * B         

+ 

 ) C1   " ,+ #26 >   ) 

+  )

 3

9/ :

;+ *

 <,   (    

  

         '  1    

) (  ) 25' =   :

 %      "0 4          '       9/ :

;+ *

 <,   (    

  

               )   )   ( +      ' .

& '

F     

  .*   1

D

  

    

     /

  *

 *  /     C  

=8 (3

.*    

/ 

1 / 

0 *. 1

(* <) 

7

 +,2;2 +,2;9  

 

    /  1

   .

      



* 

/   

   * D/       & +'

> 1 

    </  

*   .    =      /   

 )   " ,+ #26 =8 3  C1   *

  ,,1  

   5     ,# , #-+ !=8 3+$ AD/ D

1   & 6'

G

  . 1 

  <   / 

   

    

  



/  /  . 

        +, ,- #2+



 "

* /   .   

1  

=8 3 3+

  

   

* / ;

 

*  

/ * B D

  . 1   & "'

G

 + 

 1

D 

 / . 8  <     

-    

1     

     /  D

 +

 1   <   / 

* .   

 

& 9'

<  C A**      3

1 1*

    C A**  

  *

 

& 2'

/  D 1 1  E



 

 & -'

> 1 1  .  . 

/ . * 

*   

  . 1  4./ " , "

 ! &0  ! #