Shri Pal And ANR v. State Of Haryana And Others
!"#$%&'$($')$!*% + ,
!"#$%&-'*%* %.$!*% / , +
!"#$%& -0*1!$!*% + / , / 2$&2$'*-$'1&3)$*'4 005 !"#$%&
00 $0163%-'*%* %.$#$%&*44 005 !"#$%&1%!'$1(*%(7341%6
8 9:; < ;< ;;
: **** !
"# $ % <1%!$$- * !"307
'16$' &'(
) * + + ! ,,-.,,/ 01
!* ! 2 1 ', ', ,3'4 & 5 '-( '4 ', ,3'4 & 5 '/(
+ 6 , 7!1 8 '4 3, ,3'9 '4 3:
,3'4& 5 ', ':
! ( ) #! 1 ;
% 000&
000( >
! 4?3@'A33 * :'
'44- :'
3:
'44: = *1 ;=
! ! 1
* = = 1 * ! + * B'9C
1.&( &,(
) * 11 &
000( *1 + ! D11$=
- 2 - '49:'44,! *#1 *
0 ! / :
'44-=1 ! '9 :
'44-1 *#@!1 !
@= * * ! :'
'44- != !+ 1 * 1= =1 1 !
1 ;1= < &
000 !1 1 ! ( 6 ' * * :'
'
'44- E> F ! ,??3@:,33* 6 ,*1 * '
, '44- E> F ! /?3@4A3 &< (
000 1 ! 4?3@'A33 = *! !11 < = &:(
= = *#1 < G$ . * +
+7! =#*@1*1 != 1 ! 1 < 6 9'' '44- &1 G$ ( <6 ,?AA'44-&= ( < 6 '?3'' '449 & 1 ( ! !
!= =
+ !!. *!*! *#1 * *! @ 1 < .< @00 *! ! * = =+ 1 #1 ! !
- 3 - &A(
0 ! 7 ! !
= *# * = < %@00 = 81 * = <6 -3'? ,3'4 <6 '-3'-,3'4* * '9 ,3'4!
#1 &?(
)
* 7! = 1 ', ', ,3'4 '4 ', ,3'4 & 5 '- '/ ! ( * 6 , 15=1 1 * *1 =
5=
=!! + 1!=+
1 1 * #1!!1
000 < =
1 * ! = !+
*%&$%&3*%(*4&2$-$&3&3*%$' &-(
"! ! ! = 1 ! / :
'44- '9 :
'44- *#@!1.!
. @= ** ! :'
'
'44-!= !+ 1 !
000
* * ! *#1 < &
000( !2 1=5!+1 1 *! * 1 ! 1 = *
0 > .< = =1
! 1 * *1 = + ! 'A'- ! +7!1 !
- 4 - &/(
0 1 = = ***#1 G$ .*
+7! *11 * *1 + < 6 9'''44- <6 ,?AA'44- <6 '?3'''449!
*+ 1 < .< @00 * ! +
* + 1 = ! ! =5 *! = != H ! + ! 1> 1 * * ! !!1 *
000 1+ ! *! 1 1 * * !
*#1 <
+ 1 !!1 1 ! +
$(-*%!$%&(.* %&$' &9(
+ + 6 , : ?* + ! =6 ' 1!=3'
3, '44- * = !! * @*1 *# = 3A 3, '44, :'
'44- 1 = = 1 !+
!.71 @5
!= !! 1 = =@ ! !
. @*1*# ! =! 1 != + +7!
- 5 - &4(
0 1 * +1 ! 1 + !
= ! ' *! =1=. 1=> < %@00 &
000(
1
!! ! 2 ! !+ <
+1 = / !
*# +!= = ! 2 ! + .% @$ *# = +=
7 1= *!!! <
* !+ 1+ * = !* =
= &'3(
* *1!!!7! ! = !6 ,* 5 1! * * 1 1 = :3 ''
,3,,+ &''(
! 7 1=* # ''
3:
,3,- %106(3( &',(
) * + + * *#= * * 11 *1 + ! D11 $=* 1 % @$ > )! 1 ! 7! 1 + 11 !
&< (
@000 1 +1 < 1 ! =
- 6 - ! +
+1 1 > % @$ 1 ! !
! '
@!#1@1 @*1 !=
1
& ( &':(
0 ' !! = #1', ', ,3'4* 11 *1 3A 3, '44, * 1 * :'
'44- % @$ > @ !
,??3@:,33 ) !1! /!
!! !!! * +!= +
1+ =. != < %@00 &
@000( !+
!= '
, !! +1 + ! 3'
3, '44- @*1 ! = 3A 3, '44, :'
'44-+1!#+ != &'A(
) ! =
!@+# !=
!
= = 6 '* 1 !
@000<
2 !! 2 ! !+ <
&'?(
0 6 , !! = 1 #1 '4 ', ,3'4 ! * 11 @*1 > $= * 3'
3, '49A "+ * 3'
'3 '44,! =*! !
- 7 - +!#*1
)!= !11 ! ,/ 3?
'44:! ! ! ''
3?
'44A 6 , ! 1 8 !
@*1 ! :'
3:
'44: * ! 0
!!1 !! 5@1 1 > = 3'
3, '44- :'
3:
'44: '44: ! * ! + + ! = . != < 1 !! * 1 11= >
@000<
>
''
3?
'44A ! ! @*1 * * 1
@000
2 2 ! * *#11 +
@000
! +1
@000 &'-(
) ! 1 !!
&!
( !
+ * @*1< *!+ ! ! *! * *#1 1 < .< @00*! +
* ** @ 1
&
(!+ 1* 1 1 @*1
@0=
*= =
= =@
+1
@000< ! = 1 !
)
1=
! @*1 * * 1
@000
* !+ ! .!! ! ***#11 + !
! 1= 1
@000
- 8 -
@0 =
! @!
=@ *# * !# 2 2 ! *
@000
! =+E F< = + =
&'/(
) ! +1! *! =5
&
( 0! 6 '
8
/@
!# !! !!* *# < + ! + !1 !1 ! = = ! ) = !@+# *1= + 11 !
@000 < 0 ! 6 , !@+#
! '4 ', ,3'4 * 11= @*1> <
0 + !!=
= ! + * E1 F
@000< ''
3?
'44A! !
+ '44- !
&'9(
1 ! 1 @*1 != * ! G @5 !
+ != !! + 1 !=@ ! + @*1*#@!1
!! * ! ! 5 @*1 11= = !
6 '8
* 1 * ! = :'
'44- ,8
1*@ 1 % @$
- 9 - = :'
3:
'44:
) ! != @*1 &'4(
== 1! ! 6 , != !!"+ *11! ! !! ,/ 3?
'44: ! @ > :'
3:
'44:
* ! +
) 81 ! 5
+
! ! + ! + !
@5 +
= 1 +* !! 5!
#1 &,3(
0 *11 !
= * = !!1 =
&,'(
* ! ! + *1= @1 6 , +*# 1
!
1@5 +
! !!!*
* =! !! &,,(
* =! +
*! #+!= =* !!+ &,:(
1 ! !!1 / , <1%!$$- * !"30
!"$
1. Whether speaking/reasoned?
:
Yes/No
2. Whether reportable?
:
Yes/No