← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/514/1992disposed of

Avtar Singh v. M/S Bhagat Traders

2023-10-31Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary4 pages

     

!"#$%& "'

%(()

*+,- "'

.-/010"23 4%#%5#)5)4

6,+7

####*-'-2.+2,: ;;-<<+2,

=-71>1

?@1 A9+8+, B7+.-71

###C<+02,0'':

-1;"2.-2,

D EFDGD  C7-1-2,3:

!"2- '"7 ,9- +;;-<<+2,#

?7#

"19+2 H+< A+,,+I -20"7 .6"/+,- J0,9

?7# ?+2.--;

K# +LL+2I .6"/+,-I '"7 ,97-1;"2.-2,#

M NNNNNM D GG %#

O9+<<-28-

9+1

P--2

Q+.-

PR

,9-

.-'-2.+2,:+;;-<<+2,

,"

,9-

L>.8Q-2,

+2.

.-/7--

.+,-.

5S#%)#%(T(

;+11-.

PR

<-+72-.

>P

U>.8-

V1,

O<+11I

K9+22+I

J9-7-PR

,9-

1>0,

'"7

7-/"6-7R

"'

1#$&IS%W#$$@:

'0<-.

PR

,9-

;<+02,0'':7-1;"2.-2,

J+1

+<<"J-.

J0,9

02,-7-1,

X

%)Y

;-7

+22>QI

+8+021,

J90/9

,9-

+;;-+<

'0<-.

J+1

.01Q011-.

60.-

L>.8Q-2,

.+,-.

%5#5%#%(()

;+11-.

PR

<-+72-.

..0,0"2+<

*01,70/,I

C+,0+<+#

)#

A-'"7-

Q"6028

'"7J+7.

,9-

Q+,,-7I

0,

Q+R

P-

J"7,9J90<-

,"

7-'-7

,"

,9-

"7.-7

.+,-.

5W#54#%(()

;+11-.

,901

/+1-

PR

,901

O">7,

7-1,70/,028

,9-

1/";-

"'

,9- ;7-1-2, 1-/"2.

+;;-+<I J90/9 7-+.1 ,9>13

ZH-+72-.

/">21-<

9+1

7+01-.

,97--

"PL-/,0"21I

2+Q-<R

[0\

,9+,

,9-

;<+02,0'':7-1;"2.-2,

/"><.

2",

/<+0Q

+2R

02,-7-1,

"2

,9-

+Q">2,

/<+0Q-.]

[00\

,9+,

'>,>7-

02,-7-1,

/"><.

2",

P-

+J+7.-.

X

%)Y

+2.

[000\

,9+,

,9-

1>0,

J+1

'0<-.

P-R"2.

<0Q0,+,0"2#

C"02,

!"#[0\

^

[000\

J-7-

2",

,+_-2

P-'"7-

,9-

`071,

;;-<<+,-

O">7,

+2.I

,9-7-'"7-I

V

+Q

2",

;-71>+.-.

,"

;-7Q0,

,9-

;-,0,0"2-7a1

/">21-<

,"

,+_-

,9-1-

;"02,1

'"7

,9-

'071,

,0Q-

1-/"2.

+;;-+<#

B9-1-

+7-

b>-1,0"21

"'

'+/,1I

J90/9

+7-

,"

P-

.-,-7Q02-.

"2

-60.-2/-#

'+7

+1

;"02,

!"#[00\

/"2/-72-.

,9+,

'>,>7-

02,-7-1,

X

%)Y

/"><.

2",

P-

+J+7.-.

102/-

,9-

  

   

  

   !

    #     # 

#$ #        # %  #    &   ! '()*)'++,- .#

/  ! #  

 #

/  !  0 $ ! !     ',1 ! #  ! !% ! #        - 2!  #   #

        #  ! #     "

% # # &  !  

 %  ! # 3 2  4- .#       !  !!0 ! # 

#      #    # 3 2  4   #

!!

 # # &  !  

 %  

   

# "$ # 4-  ! # !!0 ! #   # 6  !# %-78

# 9 :- ;# $%      % # !     ! #  "< ##!!0  #!   - *- = #    #  - >- .#

  ?

   %  #! ! #   

 "

 # # 4 #0  $        # ! 

0  0"

    #  #        0    "# #"6  #      ! - @-   - A- .# 4  !  #0

0  # ! 

0 

 "$ #   # %#  0

#  %  %  !% 

##   !

 

#  #  

BCDBEBDFGH IFJ GBCKLHDB 8,('@9 @ ?44 '>A  "$ 5M"

# ?

4 #   #      # !% ! !      !

 

#

    ! ?

 *' ! # N6" 4 2  '+'O 

##

      BPQRCKRL IFJ BLSET ,(,, ?44 UV ?4 '(,@ " 0%  #% #  WX #  

$  #%# #  &

 ! !  !  " &  ! 

    $  $  ?

 *' ! # N6" 4 2   & # $ #            

##  $     

  % #0% #

     

      ! "   

""    "   "# 

!#    $ %& 

"

'!

" "   ()" !  *$ +!  "& "! ''

" !      "  ,- !  ,''  )" !"   "

.  %  / ! 0''/*$ 1$ +  "

# !    234567 8297 :;<

76=5:6

2> 63?5 & @ABCDE CF G// FC&  ! H!I   G'  /  "   (0 '"   " J# !"  "   J  !

! "! ''

" ! 

!    !

!#"   !  #!   !

!#"  !"&  & #"" 

!-"    . "  

$ %  !

!#"    "

!   !

!#" ! 

"

"   !. 

!$ % J  ! 

!

!  "! ''

" !.  

" ! 

!   ' ! ! . !  !  )" !  $* K  & (+!

     &   !   # /  !

!    !

!#"     ''  !  

! .

"  # /#!

  

L$* D$ %  

!"  CAM& " #!

.  /"



"   !#

!  ''&

 '' !#   ''! " -

! !  #!   !" !  !

  "   & 

 !# ! #  " 

!#   !  !  " '"! "&   "  

  '   "'!!,/ ""

! 0#!,  $ +!  " #  J# !

! 876;523 N2> :< =2=O P23Q RS

2=62>2 & CDDB@CE TUV CWA&   " / ! '.

 &  !

 "   !  ! " X!  '"

!#  !

" 

. ! #  "&

 !!

!"

 

    !" ! !! 

!".&  

"

!"" ! 

!"  ! Y ' ! !! #!$

    

   !

 # ! 

    $

$

$   % # !#

& $!   ! 

   & '# !

 (

  ) %  *

&&$ & *

!

")$ +$"# !'% #

'& , +

 -

,& 

 !

  

   ./ 0  $&*# ! +$"

   "

!

10)) &  )  2345678 956:;

< <

= >?@AB= C!! ) $E   F GEH C!! )

,& F GEH