High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1852/1989disposed of

(O&M) Shiv Singh And ORS. v. Gurbachan Singh And ORS.

2015-02-18Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal12 pages

!"#$!$%&'' (#)#%*( +(!,- ..!//0%+- 1!,-2- 2,30"(0%#%*(40"(0%#%*( +(!,- !-.%$!%+-

,!-!%+& ,1#-(0/**0,50/$)"0+! ,+(!0..!//0%+- ,2,-(!,#%*($)"0+! ,+(!,!-.%$!%+

%!,+(!,!60#%#%*,!-.%$!%+- !"#"$%#&!'

,+(!,!0-%-6!%+#%!$#%+(!0../#"0+#%+(!-06! #- 0//5!$ -237!"+ + 0// 72-+ !8"!.+#%- 23-+0%+#0/ 92!-+#%- /05 0- ,62/0+!$ #% 0,0 +(! 0../#"0+#% 0,! +0:!% % ,!",$ -+0%$-$#-.-!$

!('#%!)() !!%$0%+- + ; 0,! #% 0..!0/ 0*0#%-+ +(! 72$*6!%+ 0%$ $!",!! $0+!$ '<'; .0--!$ 3= $$#+#%0/ #-+,#"+2$*!0/0%$(0,

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

%$0%+- + ; (0$!8"(0%*!$+(#-/0%$5#+( 06#%*( 0+(!,+(!./0#%+# % +(! -0#$ !8"(0%*! < :0%0/- A 60,/0- /0%$ 50- -+0+!$/= !8"(0%*!$3=$!!%$0%+- +;5#+(:0%0/-/0%$E0+!, %0,!-0#$ 06#%*($#!$0%$./0#%+#-2""!!$!$+(!!-+0+!

06 #%*( /0#%+# "/0#6!$ (#- 5%!,-(#. 0%$ .--!--#% )!, +(! -2#+ /0%$ 6+ 0660 B02, 0+!, (!, $!0+( -2""!!$!$ 3= $!!%$0%+- D + < 0- (!, /!*0/ ,!.,!-!%+0+#)!- !!%$0%+-

0%$ 0,! +(! ,#*#%0/ 5%!,- 0%$ $!!%$0%+- ' + ;

(0)!3!!%#6./!0$!$0-$!!%$0%+-0-+(!#,%06!-0..!0,!$#% +(! ,!)!%2! ,!",$ #%"! +(! ,#*(+ +(! ./0#%+# 50- %+ 0":%5/!$*!$ 3= +(! $!!%$0%+- +(!,!,! +(! -2#+ "06! + 3! #%-+#+2+!$ D !!%$0%+- +; 0..!//0%+- 0$6#++!$+(!"/0#6 +(!./0#%+#0%$+(!=./!0$!$%37!"+#%0*0#%-+$!",!+0/+(! -2#++(!,$!!%$0%+-"%+!-+!$+(!"/0#6 % +(! 30-#- ./!0$#%*- +(! .0,+#!- //5#%* #--2!-5!,!,06!$&C

! " ! # $ " "" % & !

'('#

) ""% ) !

()

) +, !

-" !

/ ,& ((

0," ,1

+ )*(2 3( !

(

)) )* 0 ,

$ ( " 0 ,

*) 4))&)* #

(&#& # )' 0 , 0 ,

! 4 - 5

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

)!, :0%0/- D 60,/0- /0%$ %/= 0%$ +(0+ + -237!"++#%0/.0,+#+#%3!+5!!%+(!"C-(0,!,-+(!,#--2!-5!,! %+"%-#$!,!$,!/!)0%+#%+(!"%+!8+,!0/"%+,)!,-=3!+5!!% +(!./0#%+#0%$$!!%$0%+- +;0%$+(!+,#0/2,+$!",!!$ +(! -2#+ .0,+/= 0%$ $!"/0,!$ +(! ./0#%+# + 3! 7#%+ 5%!, + +(! !8+!%+:0%0/-D60,/0-/0%$-237!"++0$72-+6!%+0++(! +#6!#%0/.0,+#+#%3!+5!!%+(!"C-(0,!

/0#%+# (0)#%* $#--0+#-#!$ 5#+( +(! 72$*6!%+ 0%$ $!",!! +,#0/ 2,+ #/!$ 0..!0/ 3!,! +(! $$/ #-+,#"+ 2$*! 0/0%$(0, 0"(0% B02, 0/- #/!$ 0..!0/ 0*0#%-+ +(! -0#$ 72$*6!%+0%$$!",!! % +(! ,#*#%0/ -2#+ 0,0 ' +(! ./0#%+ ,!0$- 0- 2%$!,&C

3 6

!! " , ,, , 2, 6

" !#% (" ,1 + )*(2 3( 0 7

,,, ! ,

++(!0*!%$+(!0..!0/0%0../#"0+#%50-6)!$ 3= +(! ./0#%+#C0..!//0%+ 2%$!, ,$!, A 2/! < , 06!%$6!%++(!./0#%+ '

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

3176 & &) ! ! ,

! 8'139," % 3'8#19& 3(8(1#9&8)19+ 8(19 819 3#2 3 , " )3*' , *(((6 % 3' 3( 0 !

% 3#2 3& & &) 6 &0 +, ! ! $ 8 139

8#1 9 8*1 *9 % 8#1 9 8*1*9 % #8'1 9&831)9 333819&831'9 )831'9& 8*19 81'9

, 0 0,$

5 ,$!, $0+!$ ;' % +(! ,!",$ /5!, ..!//0+!2,+*#)!-+(!//5#%*,!0$#%*-&C :;

<4< 7 #

" , 0 " = ( - # ; ; " " ; ! > !" ," )3 7 !" " 0

+ 74<2 )5 ;

!,2-0/+(!0,!-0#$,$!,$!-%+-(55(!+(!, %+#"! +(#- 0../#"0+#% 50- *#)!% + +(! 0..!//0%+- %/= $!!%$0%+G,!-.%$!%+ < 50- "%+!-+#%* +(! 0..!0/ 0+ +(0+ +#6!

D %;'' +(!/5!,..!//0+!2,+0//5!$+(! 06!%$6!%++(!./0#%+3=.0--#%*//5#%*,$!,&C : < -$$ 7 <4< 7 # " -, 0 0 <4< 0?, " " 2 " , " ! , 1 )

? , , !0

7" , $ , 7 ? " 0 ,

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

+(0+ /5!, ..!//0+! 2,+ $#$ %+ #%)#+! 0%= 37!"+#% ,6 +(! 0..!//0%+- < (! /5!, ..!//0+! 2,+ #% 0,0 D +(! 72$*6!%+ +: %+#"! 0)!,6!%+- 60$! #% 0,0 'C +(! ./0#%+ 5(#"( 50- 06!%$!$ $2,#%* .!%$!%"= +(! 0..!0/ 0,0 D +(! 72$*6!%+.0--!$3=/5!,..!//0+!2,+#-0/-,!.,$2"!$0- 2%$!,&C 6 0 , ! ,

, 0 " 317 " ! , & ) ! -" ! +, ! " !'%13" , / )3*'

, *3((( , +, ! .

& ) +, ! -" ! ! " , , " "" % $

3'13(& 2 $

3#2 3 0 !

6 ! $ , 31 70 "

+, !5 #%"!+(!%/=92!-+#%+(0+-2,)#)!$,"%-#$!,0+#% 3!,!+(!/5!,..!//0+!2,+50-5(!+(!,+(!-0#$"%+!%+#% +(!./0#%+##%+(!06!%$!$./0#%+50-5!//2%$!$,%+(! "%+,)!,-=50-"%#%!$++(!./0#%+#0-5!//0-$!!%$0%+- + ; (!,!,! +(!, "C-(0,!,- 5!,! %+ 0+ 0// 0!"+!$ 3= +(! -0#$ "2,-! 0$.+!$ 3= +(! /5!, ..!//0+! 2,+ )!% %%!

0..!0,!$ !8"!.+ ,!-.%$!%+

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

%+0%$$!",!!+(!+,#0/2,+)#$! 72$*6!%+0%$$!",!!$0+!$'<'; ' E!0,%!$ "2%-!/ , +(! 0..!//0%+ (0- ,62/0+!$ //5#%*-23-+0%+#0/92!-+#%-/05&C .

!5 ..9 @ 7; , " "

! ! , ...9 " " ! , 0 , 0 $ 0

0 ,"" ,"

.A9 @ 7 ; 0 " " ,

A9 ? !" ,

0 @ 7 ; 0 5 26 0%$ -23-+0%"! 0,!-0#$ ,62/0+#% 92!-+#% #- 5(!+(!, 06!%$6!%+ "2/$ (0)! 3!!% 0//5!$ 3= /!0,%!$..!//0+!2,+5#+(2+%+#"!++(!0..!//0%+-G$!!%$0%+-

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

50,!-0#$92!-+#%- +0,!0%-5!,!$ "//!"+#)!/= + (!/$ +(0+ +(2*( +(!,! 50- % /!*0/ #6.!$#6!%+ #% +(! 50= /5!, ..!//0+! 2,+ #% 0//5#%* +(! 06!%$6!%+ ./0#%+0++(!0..!//0+!-+0*!32++(!-06!-(2/$(0)!3!!%$%! 0+!, #--2#%* %+#"! 0%$ #%)#+#%* 37!"+#%- +(! 0..!

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

1 #- 0/- $!"#$!$ #% 0#,60+#)! + -0= +(0+ +(! 72$*6!%+ 0%$ $!",!! .0--!$ 3= +(! /5!, ..!//0+! 2,+ 3!#%* 0*0#%-+ +(! .,#%"#./!-%0+2,0/72-+#"!#-%+/!*0//=-2-+0#%03/!#%+(!!=!- /05 ; #%"!/5!,..!//0+!2,+(0-%+$!"#$!$+(!"0-! %6!,#+-0%$6!,!/=-23-+#+2+!$ 0,0'C+(!06!%$!$./0#%+ 0- ,!/#! "/02-! , +(! ./0#%+# +(!,!,! #+ 52/$ 3! 72-+ 0%$ !8.!$#!%++,!60%$+(!"0-!++(!/5!,..!//0+!2,+5#+(0 $#,!"+#% + ,!)#-#+ +(! $!"#-#% % +(! 0../#"0+#% 2%$!, ,$!, A

2/! < #! 06!%$6!%+ +(! ./0#%+ 0%$ $!"#$! +(! -06! 0,!-( 0+!, #--2#%* %+#"! + 0//"%"!,%!$ 0%$ +(!,!0+!, $!"#$!

+(!0..!0/%6!,#+-3=*#)#%*,!0-%03/!..,+2%#+=(!0,#%*+ 3+(-#$!- D

!-2/+0%+/= #6.2*%!$ 72$*6!%+ 0%$ $!",!! $0+!$ '<'; .0--!$3=$$#+#%0/#-+,#"+2$*!0/0%$(0,#--!+ 0-#$!0-!#-,!60%$!$30":+/5!,..!//0+!2,+,$!"#-#% %6!,#+-0+!,#--2#%*%+#"!+(!0../#"0+#%2%$!,,$!,A 2/! < +0//+(!0!"+!$.0,+#!- 0,+#!-0,!$#,!"+!$+0..!0, 3!,!+(!/5!,..!//0+!2,+%'';' *+ ,-. !(&##&!' -0"(#%