High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/15873/2018dismissed

Vijay Kumar Sharma v. Bharat Somastamb & ORS

2018-11-29Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal16 pages

!"

#$ "%&'&#()

*

'

+,,

, '

) -.

, ,/

!!!!!!!

,/

1 2

# $%& ' '

# ( )'

'*+ ,-$&.,/# 0# , '# 1 2 # 134 ,56(7+ '

# '( ) '*+ 8 9 &.. '

' # # # &.,&&.,/ ( : ;$+ # 4 # ' 2 # 2

# ;

) # #2

##

&.,5

2

2 #8#8 '# 2 8 #

< 8# = 2## # ### "

8 2 # #

2 " ' >?4;

5,;

@;%,%&0 &.,7 # #

8 3"

2

? ' >?4;

5,;

A;--%/

&.,7 # # ># 8 2 # #2

# ## 8B3 8 2

?2

## # # 8B3

#2 2 # 8 # B3 #

B3 ## 8

#B3 "

## B3 # # # B3 # B3 8 # B3 # 4 - ..

...C; ># 8 # 4 ,.

..

...C; 8 3

#

2 ## B3 ?2### # D

&.,5 # #2

## >,2## #

2# # # 2 = 2 # # "

# 2##2 "

# #

#

8 #8 C ## '

# "

8

#8 8 "

# # <2 ?2

< # B32 "

B3 2 2

8 2 ## "

8

# #C #

##

8 *

#2 # # ,56 (7+ '2 # < 2 # # ##2 ;

)' # ##<

< # ,56 (7+ '

' 1 #

# ' # 8 ' # 2 2 : ? ##2>2

,&5&.,/ # #* E 8 9 # &..'

'

# # 0 3 #

' ## # 2 @ '

F3 ' <

8 # # ,-. ' 89 3 ;

),-.'9 (,+ '

# # ## 2 # ;(&+

89 ;

(+ # 2

G (+# G (+ #

282#

(&+"

'

0# 2 #89 ;

(,+ 2 < *

# 89

#

,-.'

' >2 ' 2### <2 ,56(7+ '

' 2 &.&(,+ '

' 2 2 '

: H = > # # : 2 # : 2 < ? '

F33 I3 # 2 3 I '

F I' # I ? '

F3 I' 4< 3 I"

2 ,56&.&'

F33F # ##2 I,56#2&%"

#$$&%"1-'

5#6"1 !# &(7"'!&8 !"

%#8(&9 :2"

% '"

(,+ #

2 9# 2 ' ## 2 # 2# 2 < '

F333 (&+> # ####<

2 2 2 2 (7+ 2 ,-. ; &.&#'!5#(";"(!

#$ &''<"

#$ 51#%"''

;

(,+ # 2 89 2 ,-& 8 J ##2 # : K < # # 8 2 ## ;

(+2 # #:# # '

G

(+2 # '

# # 2 ( + : &.. (&+3< ;(,+ 8 8 2 # #:# # ' #### # ## 2: (7+3 ;(,+ #

##

## 2

' #: 2

2 2

I '98 ,-.( '

F3+ I #I I# I

I I #

282# '

F # :# # 2 # 4 &.& '

2 I I2 = (2 + 2

< # I 2 I"

' 8 < '# (7+ #

## ## 2 #: 2

'

F33 #2 # 2 # H9# =88 #( ,5$+ ##I134I3 #

* 2 2 # < ##

8

( ,5/(,+ 3

!"!

#$!%&'( !

) # & * + ' #2 < I7.,(+A ;

134# # # C #

# # ## G 7.& (+ A 2 #C # ## 9# 134 # # I <2 2 ##2 I$-'<# < 134 ,5$ ' #9# 3 #9# #

#

< ,5$(,+ #

:

"

,5$ ' ;

# 9# "

#2 ,5$(,+ ' # # I

##I /&3 < ### 134 # 1348 <# 134# 8

134 # 2## 2 134 < = ($#1; !&#(= /7 "

## # : I I ,5$(,+ ' : $,(,+ (+!(+2 :

2 2

I # #I

I # I"

: ,5$(,+ ' <# :

I #I I #I"

;<# 2 I I ,5$(,+#8

$,(,+(+! (+ '

# #

# 9# 2 # # 3 2 #

# -$ # #

# 8#2 D2 8 8 2 2 #

' # 2 1 : #

$,(,+(+ '

#2 2 #G 55 ' 8

2 2 2

G -, ' 2 8 G ,6. ' 2 2 ##

C 9 C 2 #9 ,./A # 134

# 134 ## 3 134

2 # #2 # ##

# #

# I #I $7% ' "

,.%3# # &( '!

+!

+ , ' #

#

( ''&6/;6% &.+

I&.>

## 32# # # 9

2

# 2

# # # # = #

# "

# ' # # # # # # ##

# # #

B:

#

? # 2 2#I ,,, ' 2 # #

# # 134 ,5/ ' "

# # 2 I I < # ,5/ '

< ,5$ '

# # # # ,/7 ' 8 # # ## # 134 2 #

# 9# ,,$ 3 # # 2 # # # # '2 # # # #134 ,5$2 8 "

2 2 134 ,5$ '2##

#&, ' # ,,5 #

2 < # #

,5$ ' #

134 ## 9# 2 # < < 2

# 2 D ## # ## 3 2## <# # ## ## # ,&.6 2 2 # < 2##

3 "

# < (+ #C # (+' # (+## (+'

(+ ' 2 # #C# # : # 7 = # 2 #:# #I ?=# ' #

,56 (7+ '

' (&2 /<; 1 (> #!?"1'

/ &@ 55 (> (#!?"1A &.,7($+4'4('

#+5%62

;

I,, "

(7+ '

'

' #"

' 8 J(&..%+5 ''66%K:

< # : ,56(7+ # 2 : # # ,56(7+ '

' < #

# 0C

,56(7+ #

2 # "

# # # "

# #

#

2##

# # 2 2 2

(7+ '

' # #

# : 2 < 2

A # : #

#02

2

I 3 ' ,56(7+ '

'# # A 89 2

3 2 2 # ## 2 2 # # 2

2 #< ; 2##### # ## ## 3 134 ,56(7+ '

' @ '

' 2 # ? 2

# #

#2 < 3 ## 134 ,56(7+ '

'

4 ## # # 3 # #

2 0 &.,7 # 8 # 2 ' # #2## 2 # &..

'

' 2 ##2 2 # ,56 '#8 9 # "

#

#2 # #

,56 ' # 89 8 D # # ##

' 2 ,-$&.,/ ( : ;&+&.,&&.,/( : ;$+

# ### 2

' > > : ##

,/

#7";:"1

*0

-.!.!

)$!/ (0 !) !'

1!)02 -.!.!

!$ 3!

1!)02