← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/731/1992dismissed

(O&M) Jaswant Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2015-10-14Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan5 pages

   

      

!" #$% &%'()(*+,  #)-#*$(*./&%'%#)%&"$/01./2) 33%44#*$  5%0)1) $#$% #06#*##*&$/%0) %)3*&%*$)

!+  72 !  8 2  0%)%*$+9 !0:($#(*;&<'#$%; 0$/%#33%44#*$ !05(=0#:1*(#;&<'#$%; 00%)3*&%*$  >/%$/%0$/%%30$%0) 4'#4*%-)3#3%0:#6?%#44-%&$)%% $/%@1&.:%*$A

?%0% %00%&$$/%%30$%00*$  >/%$/%0$/%@1&.:%*$)/14&?%0%30$%&(*$/%&(.%)$A 99 99 2 ; 2"

:31.*%&(*$/%30%)%*$0%.14#0)%'*&#33%#4()$/% @1&.:%*$  #*&  &%'0%%  &#$%& 



;  3#))%&  ?6  $/%  4%#0*%& &&($(*#4  ()$0('$  1&.%;  *%3#$;  #

(0:(*.  $/%  @1&.:%*$  #*& &%'0%%&#$%&B  ;3#))%&?6$/%4%#0*%&&&($(*#4%*(01? 1&.%;*%3#$;<(&%-/('/$/%)1($ $/%34#(*$(

-#)&():())%& 0(% 46)$#$%&;$/%34#(*$(

/#& (4%&#)1($ 03%0:#*%*$ (*@1*'$(*#.#(*)$$/%$#$% #06#*#;1?(<()(*#4

('%0 "

#*&$/%0) 00%)$0#(*(*.$/%: 0:$#=(*.3))%))(* $/%)1($ 4#*& (*310)1#*'%$ $/%0&%0 &#$%& B ; 3#))%& ?6 $/%

44%'$0;*%3#$

1

('%  $  )#6  $/#$  $/%  34#(*$(

 '4#(:)  $/#$  /%  /#& 310'/#)%&  $/%  )1($  4#*&  $/01./  0%.()$%0%&  )#4%  &%%&  &#$%&   0::$ :#;%:<#$(#*&(44#%<(&#1./$%0)

#0#%<(&#1./$%0 :$C#/0%<($-#))$#$%&$/#$C#/0%<( -#)#?(.4#*&-*%0/#<(*.:0%$/#*)$#*&#0&#'0%) $/% 4#*&(*&(

%0%*$<(44#.%) &()$0('$*%3#$#*&$/#$$/% 44%'$0;

.0#0(#*;-0*.4631$#3%*#4$6 )$#*&#0&#'0%) 4#*&;#) %*<()#.%&  1*&%0  1*@#?  %'10($6    2#*&)  %*10%  '$  (*  /%0 #?)%*'% /%)1($4#*&-#)*%<%0&%'4#0%&#))10341) $%0$/% &%#$/ C#/0%<(*  BB;/%0$/0%%&#1./$%0);*#:%46;

03$(%<(%$')1''%%&%&$/%0%)$#$% $%0$/%%* 0'%:%*$

#06#*# %(4(*.)*2#*&4&(*.)"'$; ;$/%)1($4#*&-#) &%'4#0%&#)3%0:())(?4%#0%#;<(&%0&%0&#$%&  /%:#$$%0 -%*$(*#33%#4(*$/% 10$ ::())(*%0;:?#4#;#*&$/%0&%0 ?%'#:% (*#4 2#$%0*;*%!(0(*./&% %*&#*$B":#&%# 0%30%)%*$#$(*$$/% 44%'$0;*%3#$;-/.#<%($$/%)/#3%

#33%#4#*&-0*.46#''%3$%&$/%)#:%;<(&%0&%0&#$%&B ;

&%'4#0(*.$/%)1($4#*&#))10341)#0%##*&):%$/%0#0%#

<(44#.%#=/4(-#)&%'4#0%&3%0:())(?4%(*4(%1 $/()4#*&/%)#(& 0&%0   44%'$0  ()  (44%.#4;  <(&;  #.#(*)$  $/%  4#-  #*&  -($/1$ @10()&('$(*

*$/%$/%0/#*&;$/%)$#*& $/%&% %*&#*$)-#)$/#$ $/%&()31$%&#0%#-#)&%'4#0%&)10341)(*$/%/#*& 0(.(*#4-*%0

99 ?6$/% 44%'$0;<(&%0&%0&#$%&B #33%#4/#)?%%*

(4%&#.#(*)$$/%)#(&0&%0#*&)#(&0&%0/#)?%':% (*#4/% @10()&('$(*    $/%  '(<(4  '10$  $  '/#44%*.%  $/%  0&%0  -#)  #4) '/#44%*.%& 0:$/%34%#&(*.); 44-(*.())1%)-%0% 0#:%&+9 D >/%$/%0$/%34#(*$(

()(*3))%))(* $/%4#*&&%$#(4%& (*3#0# $/%34#(*$;#)#44%.%&A 

>/%$/%0  $/%  0&%0  &#$%&  B     $/%  44%'$0;

*%3#$;()(44%.#4#*&<(&;#)#44%.%&A );$-/#$ %

%'$A   >/%$/%0$/% 10$/#)*@10()&('$(*$$06$/%30%)%*$ :#$$%0(*<(%- %'$(* B #06#*# %(4(*.*2#*& 4&(*.)'$; A  , >/%$/%0  $/%  34#(*$(

 /#)  *  4'1)  )$#*&(  $  (4%  $/% 30%)%*$)1($A   >/%$/%0**$('%1 )  -#))%0<%&13*$/% &% %*&#*$) )$-/#$%

%'$A  B %4(% E  $%0  0%'0&(*.  $/%  %<(&%*'%    ?$/  $/%  3#0$(%)  #*& /%#0(*.$/%:*:%0($);$/%)1($-#)&():())%&/%@1&.:%*$-#) 13/%4&?6$/%4%#0*%&&&($(*#4()$0('$1&.%;*%3#$ /()  10$;  <(&%  0&%0  &#$%&    ;  0#:%&  $/%

44-(*.)1?)$#*$(#4F1%)$(*) 4#-+9 D >/%$/%0  $/%  0&%0  &#$%&  B   3#))%&  ?6  $/%

44%'$0;*%3#$;()-($/1$@10()&('$(*A

>/%$/%0(*<(%- $/%144%*'/ $/() 10$(*

9,9   

     

    B  "  2 

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

%%*:#&%(*$/% 34#(*$  $/#$  $/%  )#(&  0&%0  )/14&  ?%  &%'4#0%&  (44%.#4  0  -($/1$ @10()&('$(*%'*&46;( $/%#1$/0($6()':3%$%*$$3#))$/%0&%0 #*&  &%'(&%  $/%  )#:%;  ($  '#*  &%'(&%  ($  0(./$46  #*&  -0*.46  #*& -/%$/%0$/%0&%0()0(./$0-0*.()$?%$%)$%&*46?% 0%$/% ':3%$%*$#1$/0($6*$/()'#)%;($':%)1$$/#$$/%:#$$%0-#) %<%*$#=%*?

;:#(*$#(*%&$/%)#:% 10$/%0#33%#40 0%<()(*-#) (4%&

99 2%#0*%&'1*)%4 0$/%#33%44#*$/#)0% %00%&$$/%144 %*'/#1$/0($6 $/() 10$(*  

      

   B"2

;-/%0%(*($-#)/%4&$/#$ -/%0%$/%0&%0 44%'$0&%'4#0(*.$/%4#*&#))10341)-($/1$ .(<(*.330$1*($6 /%#0(*.$$/%4#*&-*%0;#)%*<()#.%&(*14% B   ;  $/%  '(<(4  )1($  $  '/#44%*.%  $/%  <#4(&($6    )#(&  0&%0  () :#(*$#(*#?4%/%)#(&#1$/0($6()*$#$$0#'$%&(*$/%30%)%*$'#)% (0)$46;*&%'4#0#$(*-#))1./$$$/%%

%'$$/#$$/%0&%0&#$%& B ()(44%.#4#*&*-/('/.01*&;($()(44%.#4$-#)#)(:34% )1($  0  (*@1*'$(*  0  0%)$0#(*(*.  $/%  &% %*&#*$)  0:  $#=(*.

3))%))(*(*310)1#*'%$$/%)#(&0&%0%'*&46;($-#) 1*& ?6?$/$/% 10$)?%4-$/#$$/%0&%0()4%.#4#*&-#)3#))%& # $%0/%#0(*.?$/$/%3#0$(%) /%0&%0 -#)$%)$%& (*#33%#4 ?% 0%(*#*'(#4 ::())(*%0%*'%;$/%'(<(4)1($$'/#44%*.%$/% )#(&0&%0()*$:#(*$#(*#?4% $?%(*.);$/%30%)%*$#33%#4()

1*&  $  ?%  -($/1$  #*6  :%0($  #*&  $/%  )#:%  ()  #''0&(*.46 &():())%& 2 "

 

,  )@=)