High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/747/1992dismissed

State Of Haryana v. Ram Dhari Singal

2023-02-22Mr. Justice B.S. Walia3 pages

!" "#$%$&'(( ! !" )* & &+ &!,") -"!$!$&")% .")%/% 0, )$$&1, 2 -"%3&+"&!

) 0'

&452"6)/%!$#"7 2$ )"%"&!' 6)8)$%, &8/0 ) , , 29++2 9 )* & :::

"%3$!"%").$#"9&&"$%3)"%"&!&5", 2 !,")"%3&+"&!

, 22"&1" 5* !," ! !" )* & $& !," $&%! &! "1/2 ) "#&+33" 2$%!!,";/+10"&! &++"#)""+ !"+

3 %%"+5* !," 2" )&"+ ++2 $%!)$#! /+1"9 &"3 !9 )".")%$&1 !," ;/+10"&! &+ +"#)"" + !"+ <(

< 3 %%"+ 5* !," 2" )&"+ /5 /+1" %!

2 %%9 &"3 !$& $.$2/$!

<< 3")/% 2 !," ;/+10"&! &+ +"#)"" + !"+ <(

< 3 %%"+5*!,"2" )&"+!)$ 2 /)!)"." 2%!, ! $.$2/$!

<< = % $2"+ 5* !," )"%3&+"&! > 32 $&!$

) 3")0 &"&! $&;/&#!$& )"%!) $&$&1!," 33"22 &!%?+"

"&+ &!% )0"

"#!$&1)"#.")* #%! %!2"& 3$3"% "!# )0 !," 32 $&!$

&+ & !," 5 %$% 32" +$&1% !," 3 )!$"%9!," 22=$&1$%%/"%=")" ) 0"+'?

?? "

#$% & &

' ( ) ,")"

!")&!,"5 %$% ".$+"&#"2"+5*!,"3 )!$"%9$%%/" % !=")"+"#$+"+ 1 $&%!!,")"%3&+"&!?32 $&!$

&+$& ./) !," 33"22 &!%?+"

"&+ &!% &+$&.$"=!,")" !,"%/$!= %+$%0$%%"+ , !& 33" 25*!,")"%3&+"&!?32 $&!$

9!,"2" )&"+++2 $%!)$#!/+1"9&"3 !$&3 ) 1) 3, ,$%;/+10"&!# 0"!!," #&#2/%$&!, ! $@$&1 %2")"%3&%$5$2$!*A/ !,"2%% 3$3"%&!," 32 $&!$

&!,"5 %$% +"3 )!0"&! 2"&A/$)*= %&!2"1 25"# /%" 3 )!

)0 !," )"%3&+"&!?32 $&!$

9 !,") %!

= % 2% & +/!* $& !," )" #, +/)$&1!,"3")$+$&A/"%!$&9!,")"

)"9!,"*=")" 2%"A/ 22*2$ 52" !,"2%%%/

")"+5*!," .")&0"&!& ##/&! 2%% 3$3"% )0!," 5."0"&!$&"+)" #, ##)+$&12*9!,"2" )&"+++2$%!)$#!/+1"9&"3 !9=,$2" ,2+$&1!, !!,")"%3&+"&!?32 $&!$

2&"#/2+&!5"3"& 2$B"++"%3$!" &/05") 3")%&%5"$&1)"%3&%$52" ##"3!"+!," 33" 29%"! %$+"!," /+10"&! &++"#)""+ !"+ <(

< 3 %%"+5*!,"2" )&"+!)$ 2 /)! &+ +"#)""+ !," %/$! !," )"%3&+"&!?32 $&!$

=,$2" )"%!) $&$&1 !," 33"22 &!%?+"

"&+ &!% )0)"#.")$&1!,"=,2" !,"2%% !,"3$3"%

)0 !," % 2 )* !," )"%3&+"&!?32 $&!$

9 =,$2"2" .$&1 $! 3"& ! !," 33"22 &!%?+"

"&+ &!%! %%"%%!," 0/&! 2%%!5")"#.")"+ )0 !,")"%3&+"&!?32 $&!$

+/"!,$%&"12$1"&#" C D" )&"+++2 9 )* & 9, % $)2*#&#"+"+!, !$!$% & +0$!!"+3%$!$&!, ! 3 )! )0!,")"%3&+"&!?32 $&!$

!,")"=")"

?? &/05") !,")

$#")%>"032*""%=)E$&1$&!,"% $+)" #,F )" G &+ !, !$&!,"#$)#/0%! &#"%9 $@ !$& 2$ 5$2$!*&!,")"%3&+"&!?32 $&!$

2&" = %&! ;/%!$ $"+ &+ !5"%!!,"2%%#/2+, ." 5""& )"#.")"+

)0!,")"%3&+"&!?32 $&!$

$&3)3)!$&!&"12$1"&#" !!)$5/! 52"! ,$0 !,")3$&!, %5""& )1/"+ < &!,"2$1,! !,"3%$!$&&!"+ 5."9"%3"#$ 22*3 ) 1) 3, %HC9+&! $&+ &*$& $)0$!*=$!,!,";/+10"&!3 %%"+5*!," 2" )&"+$)%!33"22 !" /)!)".")%$&1!,";/+10"&! !,"2" )&"+!)$ 2

/)! % $! $% ="22 %"!!2"+ 2 = !, ! "."& $& 0 !!")% $03%$!$& 3/&$%,0"&! 0&1%! %$0$2 )2* %$!/ !"+ "032*""%9 !,")" # & 5" & +$%#)"3 &#*$&#"9$&!,"$&%! &!# %"9!,"+"3 )!0"&!, %5""&1) &!"+ 2$5")!* ! ! E" /! 3)#""+$&1% 1 $&%! !," )"%3&+"&!?32 $&!$

"#!$&1 )"#.")* !," 2%% $& 3)3)!$& ! !," &"12$1"&#" !," )"%3&+"&!9 & A/"%!$& 2 = 0/#, 2"%% %/5%! &!$ 2 A/"%!$& 2 = )$%"% ) #&%$+") !$& $& !," $&%! &! # %" ##)+$&12*9 $&+$&1 !," 33" 25")"

! 0")$!9!,"% 0"$% (( *( +, - # . /#0 . /#0